4 ms·
So, the piece here wants to frame this as an ideological issue, but the kernel of it seems to be: * the Times employed Krugman to generate content, originally
by tptacek 2y ago
So, the piece here wants to frame this as an ideological issue, but the kernel of it seems to be:
* the Times employed Krugman to generate content, originally on terms that included a Times-branded blog where he could write with minimal editorial oversight.
* The Times consolidated their opinion content and eliminated the blog, leaving Krugman only venues with extensive editorial oversight, notably including how often he wrote about specific subjects (that is: with an editorial calendar).
* He started a Substack; the Times freaked out; he ended up leaving.
This feels like a lot of Substacker stories. He will probably have a bigger and more lucrative audience on Substack, and the Times probably won't suffer much from his departure.
From my own vantage point, the less the Times can index on punditry, the better. I don't pretend this change is strategic for them, but I think it'll probably work out to their benefit so long as they don't immediately go hire another economist.
- sho_hn 2y ago> The Times consolidated their opinion content and eliminated the blog From my reading of the article, you're conflating two seperate events, perhaps due to knowledge of additional facts it doesn't contain, or conjecture, or misreading - it isn't clear. The blog was shuttered, yes, but on his opinion column he just mentions an increase in editorial oversight and getting notes. You call this "consolidating their opinion content" - can you share details? Otherwise it sounds mostly like an euphemism for "they adopted a stronger (guide)line", which is what the piece seems to bemoan.
- tptacek 2y agoThe Times shuttered dozens of blogs (all of them, I think?). It was kind of a big deal at the time.
- jonstewart 2y agoKrugman says here though that the heavier editing of his opinion columns only started a ~year ago, which was 6 years after the blog ended. So presumably those six years were fine enough. I overall agree with you on punditry and I didn’t much read Krugman; I don’t much read any of their opinion columnists. But a point to Krugman in that he can write about actual facts whereas Ross, Bret, and David can only write about vibes.
- jonjojojon 2y agoYes, but he is complaining about the change in policy on his Opinion articles.
- jaredklewis 2y agoWhat's wrong with economists? Not a huge Krugman fan, but I feel economists bring important insights from data that tend to escape regular journalists. If Krugman wore his economist hat more and stayed away from general political punditry, I would probably like him more. The writing of Emily Oster is a great example of what economists can bring to analysis of current events. I wish we could clone her.
- unyttigfjelltol 2y ago[flagged]
- fn-mote 2y agoWe come to HN to read real opinions of real people. Props for saying your post came from AI, but I don’t think AI can add to legitimate dialogue.
- unyttigfjelltol 2y ago[flagged]
- ThrowawayR2 2y agoThe HN moderation team has said that machine generated submissions and posts are not welcome here, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33950747 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33950747.
- unyttigfjelltol 2y agoDoes it make you feel better that the AI and I engaged in an iterative process to identfy what, precisely, in Krugman's long career was so irritating? The AI couldn't figure it out at first. The link you shared says bots are banned. I am not a bot. No one down voted me because they misunderstood I was a bot. The link also says single-purpose users are not in the HN spirit either. I recognize many people here use throwaways for legitimate privacy reasons, but ... c'mon, telling me bots can't post here is not in the spirit of that tradition.
- bjourne 2y agoBut "the piece here" is from the horse's mouth so if he wants to frame it like an ideological issue, maybe it is? He claims to have been pressured to tone down his articles to avoid offending people. Not much of a debate if anything that could possibly offend someone is not allowed to be expressed.
- patriot_games 2y agoThis editorial oversight is not evenly spread over the opinion pages. Bret Stephen’s isn’t edited.