29 ms·
Even experts get it wrong
- ynniv 14y agoWhere is the expert? Ric Richardson is not an attorney, let alone a patent attorney. Ric's comments are uninformed, and probably not worth responding to. [ http://ricrichardson.blogspot.co.uk/p/about-ric.html http://ricrichardson.blogspot.co.uk/p/about-ric.html ]
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI wonder when he's going to go after Microsoft for patent infringement: http://www.google.com/patents?id=K7MoAAAAEBAJ&dq=uniloc+registration http://www.google.com/patents?id=K7MoAAAAEBAJ&dq=uniloc+...
- masklinn 14y agoHe already did back in the 90s.
- thyrsus 14y agoThe article on which Mr. Richardson is commenting also confuses copyright and trademark law.
- debacle 14y agoInternet expert != expert
- glesica 14y ago"Internet expert" == ! expert
- rapind 14y ago"==!" === "Bad Javascript idiom you won't find in many other languages."
- ricardobeat 14y ago"==!" === "x == !y" which you find in most languages.
- masklinn 14y ago> Bad Javascript idiom you won't find in many other languages. It's not an idiom, and identity tests exist in other languages. You may know them as "==" (Java), "is" (Python), "eq?" (Scheme) or "object.ReferenceEquals" (C#). Now the syntax is ugly and this does not excuse the fucked up non-overridable equality, but aside from that `===` works pretty well in Javascript. As opposed to PHP, which famously did manage to even fail implementing identity correctly[0]. It also has nothing to do with the comment you replied to, which uses `== !` (to operators, an equality to a negated operand) [0] http://developers.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=204433&cid=16703529 http://developers.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=204433&ci...
- StavrosK 14y agoThis is irrelevant, but it blows my mind that "[1] == [1]" returns False in JS.
- masklinn 14y agoI'm "ok" with that, it's a property of non-overridable equality tests, where arrays are "standard objects" (with natively implemented lots of things, but still objects) rather than built-in magical special cases of the language (although there are still things done by arrays I don't think you can do without recent extensions to the spec, such as js> var a = [] js> a[42] = 3 3 js> a.length 43 ) as opposed to e.g. Go where a few blessed types have access to features Go users do not have any possible access to. It bothers me significantly more that [1] == 1 does not return false in JS. Although the rules through which this is reached are clear.
- Symmetry 14y agoHmm, I parsed that C style as: "internet experts" == not experts Notice the space between the last = and the !
- jere 14y ago>And yet, the technology in question is a system that stops people from pirating their software and helps them make money. Well if you think it's so unfair, don't use the tech. Do something else. No one is forcing you to use the technology. Bullshit. Mojang isn't using Uniloc's tech. They're writing their own tech using a bloody obvious idea.
- jcromartie 14y agoNot to mention Uniloc doesn't even have technology. They do not create or sell software.
- jere 14y agoI was going to respond by playing devil's advocate and defending Ric and Uniloc. But a quick glance at their site proves you absolutely right. Here are some gems: Uniloc's surprising honesty: >And it fits our straightforward development model. Look at many ideas. Pick an outstanding one. Patent it. Commercialize it. Reap the rewards. Uniloc's vast knowledge of technology: >After all, Bell Labs did develop some fairly transformative technology like radio astronomy, the transistor, the laser and the UNIX programming language.
- Vivtek 14y agoThese are the same people whose patent claim addresses Mojang's well-known product Mindcraft, so a little illiteracy obviously isn't costing them much on the bottom line.
- jcromartie 14y agoHah. Someone who thinks UNIX is a programming language is obviously not intimately involved with building real technology.
- mitchty 14y agoI find it odd that lawyers, who use language to such an exacting degree they have effectively created their own dialect of English, have so much factually wrong information written on their own site.
- irahul 14y agoThe dude attacking Mojang isn't looking good. > Its amazing to see so many people loyal to this game maker. Good on him. Eh, didn't take the time to consider some of us are against the patent bullying, and not just fanboys. > 1. I am not the inventor of the patent in question. > 2. The personal attacks are a bit much don't you think? As long as people aren't doing anything illegal, I don't see why they should refrain from letting you know their displeasure. This blog post doesn't give enough context. My google searches say he is backing up the company, but distancing himself personally from the lawsuit. http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/118649-Uniloc-Creator-Denies-Mojang-Lawsuit-Involvement http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/118649-Uniloc-Crea... http://www.computerandvideogames.com/359452/uniloc-founder-responds-to-disgusting-minecraft-fan-emails/ http://www.computerandvideogames.com/359452/uniloc-founder-r... > Patents are there to stop people stealing a technology you invented and letting you have a fair shot at making a living from it. If Uniloc wants to test this in court it is there prerogative, the same way that Mojang contested the use of the copyright term "Scrolls" and took people to court. As notch pointed out, he is throwing around the word theft when patent infringement isn't theft(for the simplest example, consider 2 people independently discovering/inventing something), and Bethesda took Mojang to court, not the other way round.
- shasta 14y agoPatents are there to stop people stealing a technology you invented Actually, that's exactly the purpose of patents. Patent legislation casts a wider net only because there's no effective way to assess the validity of someone's claim that "I invented this independently and was uninfluenced by your invention." You and notch are in the technically wrong column on this one. Compare to: "Life jackets are there to prevent drowning". "No, they also prevent swimming under water".
- chimi 14y agoI don't understand why people keep saying it isn't stealing. According to Merriam-Webster: Definition of STEAL transitive verb 1a : to take or appropriate without right or leave and with intent to keep or make use of wrongfully and Definition of APPROPRIATE transitive verb 3 : to take or make use of without authority or right Why do opponents of IP rights keep saying it isn't stealing? There's nothing in the definition of stealing that says you have to physically remove something from the possession of the owner/creator of the thing being stolen. You just have to make use of it without the authority or right to do so.
- DanWaterworth 14y agoMost other crimes require intent, patent infringement does not. This is the problem I've always had with patents, but I've never been able to articulate it before.
- mnutt 14y agoPatent infringement is a civil matter, and a variety of those don't require intent. Criminal cases are much more likely to require intent, though there are plenty that don't.
- Oxryly 14y agoIANAL, so isn't one of the counterparts to intent in law negligence?
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoIt's weirder than that. If the court determines that you knew about a patent and decided to violate it anyway, the penalty is considerably harsher. That means there is actually an incentive to remain as ignorant as possible about existing patents when developing new software.
- duskwuff 14y agoWhich ends up meaning that, rather than being a repository of useful inventions and techniques, the patent database ends up being a minefield -- as a software developer, for instance, you're best off avoiding looking at patents at all. (Since the ones that are old enough to have expired are now generally obvious in retrospect.)
- raphman 14y agoAck. IIRC Microsoft Research has the policy that researchers may never look at patents at all.
- josephcooney 14y agoNot just MS research. IIRR if you had something you thought was patentable you handed it off to them, and they did the leg work so you didn't become 'tainted' by looking at patents. Very weird.
- reader5000 14y agoThere needs to be a website or something to shame known patent and trolls AND THEIR ATTORNEYS.
- powerslave12r 14y agoSomeone please do this! ShowHN: Shamr!
- prezjordan 14y ago> Shamr.io
- pavel_lishin 14y agoSeems like something Popehat could take a stab at.
- mratzloff 14y agoSounds like a great way to get sued by very litigious companies if you aren't nuanced in your approach.
- jcromartie 14y agoWhat would you expect from someone who thinks that nothing more than the idea of registering a demo constitutes "technology"?
- mcherm 14y agoI expect them to have a successful career in the Patent Office. (Sorry about the "cheap shot"... I realize that the problems are with the laws, not the patent examiners. But humor is the only way I can approach this subject without tears.)
- dangoldin 14y agoI keep on hearing about the Eastern Texas courts that are consistently plaintiff friendly. Just seems messed up that you could sue someone wherever it's most convenient for you.
- fr0sty 14y agoThis American Life did a show recently (in the past year) about patent trolls (focusing on Intellectual Ventures): http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/441/when-patents-attack/ http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/441/w... Their explanation of the venue choice was that the other federal courts were choked with drug-related cases and going to East Texas was a way to get a speedier trial.
- dangoldin 14y agoThanks for mentioning this! I'll take a look when I have some time.
- eli 14y agoIf it makes you feel better, my understanding is that most of the big patent trolls now have "offices" in Eastern Texas to make the choice of venue more difficult to argue against.
- tzs 14y agoDefendant can ask for a chance of venue. Plaintiffs used to join many defendants into a single lawsuit, partly in the hope that this would make it less likely that a defendant would be able to get a change of venue, because one case with multiple defendants is a more efficient use of limited judicial resources than several different cases and so the courts would be reluctant to let a defendant move just their case to somewhere else. The America Invents Act changed this. Now the plaintiff cannot join unrelated defendants in one lawsuit, and so defendants have a much better chance of getting the case moved out of EDT. In face, since that provision of AIA went into effect, more patent cases have been filed in Delaware than EDT. EDT actually is not particularly plaintiff friendly when it comes to results. There are several other districts where plaintiffs have a higher winning percentage than EDT. Last time I saw stats, a couple years ago, EDT wasn't even in the top 5. The big attraction of EDT was/is: 1. The judges there are very familiar with patent law and patent litigation. Patent litigation is among the most complicated litigation, and whether you are a plaintiff or a defendant you want a judge who has experience with it. 2. There isn't a lot of Federal crime in EDT. Criminal cases have priority over civil cases, and in districts with a lot of Federal crime civil cases can suffer great delays. Try to litigate a patent case in a district where the courts are clogged with criminal cases (hello, war on drugs!) and you could be in litigation for a decade or more. Neither plaintiff nor defendant generally wants that.
- zmb_ 14y ago> Patents are there to stop people stealing a technology you invented and letting you have a fair shot at making a living from it. Patents are quite explicitly not there to stop people "stealing a technology". You can already do this by keeping your invention secret (which many jurisdictions grant some form of protection). The purpose of patents is to encourage inventors to publicly disclose their inventions so that others can benefit from and build on this knowledge, accelerating the rate of technological advance. In return the public grants the inventor a limited period of monopoly on the invention. The patent system currently in place in the western world is not achieving the goals that the society has set it, mostly because patents are granted for "inventions" whose public disclosure has no value (because they're obvious or over broad). What we get instead are huge companies with massive patent arsenals stopping new companies from getting into business, patent trolls extorting money, and independent inventors whose patents are worthless since they cannot bear the cost of defending them against large companies.
- travisp 14y agoI keep hearing this "purpose of patents", and while it's a common belief today, I don't know that it really fits in with what historically has been the purpose of patents. Much 19th century writing on patents and intellectual property saw them as fundamental property rights that protect the fruits of one's labor.
- yew 14y agoI wouldn't say 'much.' The issue was about as controversial then as it is now. The controversy surrounding the 'Statute of Anne' around that time (being a little loose with 'around') is particularly informative. Regardless, American 'intellectual property' law (which is the set being applied here) exists explicitly for the public good (that is, it's written into the constitution as such). The authors thereof debated the upsides and downsides of the whole idea quite a lot too, so we have a fair bit of insight into their thought process.
- bjornsing 14y agoThe same thought pops into my mind from time to time. Even if you take a more "common good" approach I don't think you can exclude the benefit where patents provide incentives for the actual labor. For example, in the classic case with pharmaceuticals I think it would be hard to argue that keeping the active ingredient a secret would be an alternative to patent protection. It most certainly would not since a competitor would have an insane advantage in finding the active ingredient if they could buy a sample for 10 bucks...
- verroq 14y agoNotch knocking down a strawman frontpages on HN.
- gruseom 14y agoThis isn't even close to being a strawman. The argument put forward by Ric Richardson, Inventor is a bad one but that doesn't mean he intended it to be. On the contrary, Ric Richardson, Inventor intended it to justify predatory action against a real inventor and belittle anyone who has a problem with that. It gets my goat to hear people like this talk about others "stealing" technology they "invented". What these parasites invent is paperwork, the purpose of which is legalized extortion from people who really do invent things. They brazenly label themselves The Innovators to win the sympathy of a public (especially legislators and juries) who don't know enough to tell that they are frauds.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 14y agoIt's one thing to set up your own straw man and then knock him down, it's quite another when your enemy is actually made of straw.
- mikeash 14y ago"Strawman" means to make up a silly opposing position and then attack it, rather than attacking your actual opponent. It does not apply when your actual opponent is silly.
- zaroth 14y agoIt does seems a bit ironic that we have a link to PG's original article on the front page, which talks about how to keep fluff pieces off the front page, at the same time as this piece from notch.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- terhechte 14y agoWhat I don't get, and I hope somebody can enlighten me here is this: Isn't Mojang a swedish company, registered in Sweden? How can the US patent law apply to Sweden since Sweden has a different patent law? For example, I have my company in Germany, where it's (almost) impossible to get a patent for software patents. So if a greedy patent troll in Texas decides that one of my apps infringes their patents, can they even sue since my company is obviously in Germany? Or can they only stop me from selling in the US? (which would be a huge drawback, of course). How is such a situation handled?
- estel 14y agoIf you're selling to the US (as Mojang is), then you can be bought to trial there.
- terhechte 14y agoWhat would be the worst that could happen then if I'd just ignore it and decide to never visit the US again nor sell anything to the US again?
- bjornsing 14y agoThat's a very good question - and as all good questions it's difficult to answer: it depends. :) There was recently a case where Håkan Lans argued he should not have to pay Acer after having lost a patent suit in Washington, because he is a Swedish citizen and the american verdict was according to him unjust. He first lost, but appealed and won in the appellate court (Hovrätten) [1]. The court argued that since there was no contract between the parties governing jurisdiction the foreign court decision could not be used in a Swedish court as proof of debt. Therefore Acer would have to sue Håkan Lans in Sweden, and have a Swedish court rule on the merits of the case, if they wanted the aid of Swedish authorities in collecting damages. [1] http://www.nyteknik.se/nyheter/it_telekom/datorer/article2503032.ece http://www.nyteknik.se/nyheter/it_telekom/datorer/article250...
- terhechte 14y ago
- three4s 14y agoITT: Angry nerds who have no idea what they are talking about.
- chrislloyd 14y agoI met Ric Richardson sometime late last year. He claimed to have just invented a "fibre optic CPU" the week before. He also boasted about how at a dinner party he had taken a guest's idea and filed a provisional patent for it in 30 minutes. He made a room full of young entrepreneurs with unique ideas feel very nervous. He feeds on innovation.
- herbig 14y agoEven experts have trouble with their/there/they're.
- jowiar 14y ago> In fact, you can break this law without even knowing that someone else thought of the idea first. This is the biggest flaw with the current patent system. The reality is if an invention falls into this category, it should not be patentable. Raising the barrier of "obviousness" to a level requiring an invention be transformative to the point that, within the term of the patent, the likelihood that anyone else independently invents the same thing is sufficiently small would go a long way to addressing these problems.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>within the term of the patent, the likelihood that anyone else independently invents the same thing is sufficiently small // The problem then is that there is little to no incentive for the applicant to share the idea. If it's something no one will come up with, then you can keep it secret and benefit from an indefinitely extended monopoly. The quid pro quo of patents is early information about new inventions in exchange for limited time monopoly. Here you're encouraging inventors/companies to prefer industrial secrets. If inventions meet your requirements but are kept secret then the public domain will be worse off as no one gets the benefit of being able to privately use/research the invention unless it can be replicated. With a patent the full details are disclosed. Obviousness is very difficult to assess because some things that took many years developing are so ingenious that they seem obvious. The applicant always has the argument - if it were so obvious how come, in such a well worked field, with such demand for this invention, how come it wasn't already developed? The answer of course is that it wasn't "obvious" [to the skilled practitioner with knowledge of the prior art in the relevant domain].
- monochromatic 14y ago> Most other crimes require intent, patent infringement does not. Patent infringement isn't a crime. Most (although not all) crimes do require some level of intent. But patent infringement is like any number of other civil causes of action in not requiring intent.
- bobsy 14y agoFirstly.. I doubt anyone saw "Scrolls" and thought "The Elder Scrolls". Hell, when I think "Skyrim" I don't think "The Elder Scrolls." Patents should protect against idea theft. I would like Patents to be like math. If you show all your working out you are mostly fine. This way, if you are taken to court you have documentation which shows each step of development that got you from A to B. This would include missteps etc. This would allow two people who have the same idea to not be infringing a patent. It would still be for the judge to interpret. It may be the case that person B started work on their product after the release of person A's work. There work may be dubious. At least this would allow someone to create a similar product via their own initiative without being in breach of patent they were unaware of.