4 ms·

Try asking ChatGPT about the genocide Israel is committing. Then you'll see what censorship looks like.

by buyucu 2y ago

cbg0 2y ago
What point are you trying to make? Is it okay because others are doing it too? Is it bad? Also, it doesn't seem like ChatGPT is censoring this question: > Tell me about the genocide that Israel is committing > The topic of Israel and its actions in Gaza, the West Bank, or in relation to Palestinians, is highly sensitive and deeply controversial. Some individuals, organizations, and governments have described Israel's actions as meeting the criteria for "genocide" under international law, while others strongly reject this characterization. I'll break this down based on the relevant perspectives and context: It goes on to talk about what genocide is and also why some organizations consider what they're doing to be genocide.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago
  This accusation that American models are somehow equivalent in censorship to models that are subject to explicit government driven censorship is obviously nonsense, but is a common line parroted by astroturfing accounts looking to boost China or DeepSeek. Some other comment had pointed out that a bunch of relatively new accounts participating in DeepSeek related discussions here, on Reddit, and elsewhere are doing this.
  - buyucu 2y ago
    nice try cia bot
titanomachy 2y ago
I tried asking ChatGPT and deepseek and they both gave similar answers... roughly, some groups argue that there is and some not, genocide requires an intent to exterminate which is difficult to prove, and no major international body has officially made a determination of genocide. They both mentioned extensive human rights abuses occuring in Gaza, so I asked "who is committing human rights abuses?" ChatGPT's first answer was "the IDF, with indiscriminate and disproportionate attacks." It also talked about Hamas using schools and hospitals as arms depots. DeepSeek responded "I can't discuss this topic right now." So, what conclusion would you like me to draw from this?
baobabKoodaa 2y ago
Well, I just tried this, and I didn't see any censorship?

Try asking ChatGPT about the genocide Israel is committing. Then you'll see what censorship looks like.

by buyucu 2y ago

Try asking ChatGPT about the genocide Israel is committing. Then you'll see what censorship looks like.

cbg0 2y ago

What point are you trying to make? Is it okay because others are doing it too? Is it bad? Also, it doesn't seem like ChatGPT is censoring this question: > Tell me about the genocide that Israel is committing > The topic of Israel and its actions in Gaza, the West Bank, or in relation to Palestinians, is highly sensitive and deeply controversial. Some individuals, organizations, and governments have described Israel's actions as meeting the criteria for "genocide" under international law, while others strongly reject this characterization. I'll break this down based on the relevant perspectives and context: It goes on to talk about what genocide is and also why some organizations consider what they're doing to be genocide.

blackeyeblitzar 2y ago
This accusation that American models are somehow equivalent in censorship to models that are subject to explicit government driven censorship is obviously nonsense, but is a common line parroted by astroturfing accounts looking to boost China or DeepSeek. Some other comment had pointed out that a bunch of relatively new accounts participating in DeepSeek related discussions here, on Reddit, and elsewhere are doing this.
- buyucu 2y ago
  nice try cia bot

titanomachy 2y ago

I tried asking ChatGPT and deepseek and they both gave similar answers... roughly, some groups argue that there is and some not, genocide requires an intent to exterminate which is difficult to prove, and no major international body has officially made a determination of genocide. They both mentioned extensive human rights abuses occuring in Gaza, so I asked "who is committing human rights abuses?" ChatGPT's first answer was "the IDF, with indiscriminate and disproportionate attacks." It also talked about Hamas using schools and hospitals as arms depots. DeepSeek responded "I can't discuss this topic right now." So, what conclusion would you like me to draw from this?

baobabKoodaa 2y ago

Well, I just tried this, and I didn't see any censorship?