5 ms·
IOC long shot Watanabe hopes 'crazy' Olympic idea sparks debate
- hakfoo 2y agoThe Olympics are choking themselves to death right now. I can recall sitting on the sidewalk watching the torch relay for Los Angeles 1984, but today the Olympics is just eighteen months of irritating ads followed by three weeks of media clucking. Fewer and fewer cities want to splash hundreds of millions on building stadiums that go to rust in a few years, and the ones still willing to do so are often just using it as a sports-washing vehicle for mediocre records on other factors. It's not a good look when voters overwhelmingly cheer the withdrawl of your city's bid! Once you find a venue, you're not really playing for the host city, you're playing for the cameras. Schedule the events based on when it's prime time in rich ad markets, not when it makes most sense for the sports, or even when it would maximize the exposure for the sports that most people ONLY see once every four years. Ooh, look, the Dream Team. Big whoop. They run 40 NBA games a year on local TV, show me judo or hammer-throwing or synchronized swimming. And despite all that, they seem to have no concern about the TV product they made such efforts to prostate themselves for. Does anyone at NBC get concerned that people intentionally look for VPNs to access the CBC and BBC streams because they've made such a mess of tape delays, schmaltzy human-interest stories, and laser-focusing on American athletes? Of course, the sphere around the events is a complete branded marketing festival. The thing that still sticks with me was an article about the London 2012 games that said they had people going around putting tape over the logos on the toilets because they weren't an official paying sponsor. That level of petty goes well beyond business school. They're over-the-top with their trademarks too, especially for a nominally well-intentioned non-profit. Nobody is going to starve if the gyro place on the corner is a little too loose with adjectives referring to a specific holy mountain. The Olympics used to be a noble idea: we can have international competition in a benign venue, in the spirit of celebrating peaceful achievement. Maybe a much smaller take on it would go back to those roots. Smaller events wouldn't disrupt or bankrupt host cities, so we'd see real interest in hosting again, and they'd be less tempting to turn into a TV Event and marketing freakshow at the expense of all else. Maybe his idea of "let's do five cities at once" is a way to get there, although I worry it's more the business equivalent of "we couldn't scale single-threaded CPUs past 4-5GHz, so the only way to go bigger was to add more cores."
- mathieuh 2y agoIt's the same with football. FIFA is so ridiculously corrupt it's actually jarring. Hosting World Cups in Qatar and now Saudi Arabia, running players into the ground by continuously adding more fixtures to the season, awash with gambling money, football clubs owned by nation states. I stopped watching football when the World Cup went to Qatar and I haven't watched any since, it turns my stomach now.
- mikestew 2y agoAnd it’s coming to Seattle in 2026. I would be more excited about it, except for the reasons you listed (and more). Thankfully we will both be retired by then and can just leave for a month. At least World Cup acts as the kick in the ass to finish that light rail to Redmond.
- PaulHoule 2y agoWhen they had the Olympics in London I heard tourism actually decreased because everyone was afraid of the crowds. [1] I'm thinking about going to the next Olympics in LA because I want to go back to LA and because LA has always been sane about it: the 1984 Olympics made money because they didn't build an Olympic village -- and they could talk terms to the IOC because no city wanted to host it after Munich. [1] I remember standing in front of the New Yorker hotel across from Madison Square Garden and some Londoners were complaining that NYC wasn't crowded enough. Crowds in London are intimidating under normal conditions.
- dfxm12 2y agoFWIW, flights and hotels were unreasonably expensive, even for London. I was sort of relieved after I went through the ticket lottery and didn't get anything I had wanted. It was disheartening to later watch and see a bunch of empty seats on TV though! https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2012/jul/29/london-2012-empty-seats-trap https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2012/jul/29/london-2012-em...
- ethbr1 2y ago
- fourseventy 2y agoI think a better solution is to have the olympics rotate between 3 or 4 cities. That way they can re-use all the stadiums and infrastructure.
- madcaptenor 2y agoThis gets suggested over and over again. Sometimes people say it should be in one city. The romantics suggest Athens (because the Greeks invented the thing) but the practical suggestion is Los Angeles.
- Jeremy1026 2y agoReusing stadiums every 3-4 olympics wouldn't be super helpful. That is 12-16 years between hosting again. You'd realistically only get 2 games out of your locations before you'd be rebuilding it. Which admittedly is 2x as many times as you get out of most games, but its not a particularly big drop in the bucket in the grand scheme.
- ninalanyon 2y agoAn alternative is to just drop the whole thing.
- EndsOfnversion 2y agoWhy not just host it in the same place every time? Greece would be the obvious choice. Think of all the money and co2 You could save. But oh wait - that would make it much harder for IOC members to extract bribes… so it’ll never happen.
- lastofthemojito 2y agoIt feels like we've been tip-toeing in the direction of multi-host Olympics. For the Paris Olympics, the surfing was on the other side of the world in Tahiti (French Polynesia). The LA Olympics bid decided they didn't want to build any new facilities, and most events will be at existing facilities around LA, but softball and canoeing events will be in Oklahoma due to better facilities that exist there: https://la28.org/en/games-plan/venues.html https://la28.org/en/games-plan/venues.html Doesn't seem like much more of a stretch to have a USA-hosted Olympics with events around the country. The big downside of course being less interaction between athletes from various sports, but I think at this point, where you've got over 10,000 athletes, you could still probably split that into several cities and have big, joyous celebrations in each.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>It feels like we've been tip-toeing in the direction of multi-host Olympics. I wish they would just pick one place to hold their shenanigans and stay there. Yes, I hated the bullshit that occured behind the scenes in 2020 Tokyo and hope one of the most cancerous and corrupt organizations ever never shits up Japan again. My sympathies to any athletes who sincerely just want to play and compete, but the event itself is trash.
- dfxm12 2y agoEvery Olympic sport has an annual championship in different cities at different times in Olympic off years. Having everyone together in one place at one time is what makes the Olympics special. Special for the athletes, live spectators & host city alike. The more the Olympics are spread out physically, the less special it is for the most people. On the other hand, I know this is a little naive since most of the money revolves around TV rights. Also, as a TV spectator, 24 hour live coverage (like the Watanabe is suggesting in the article) of the Olympics sounds pretty cool. I wonder if the TV networks would like this. It probably solves a lot of the logistical issues host cities have been having as well. This also avoids the worst outcome of coming to a point where only a few host cities, like LA and Paris, can reasonably meet all the IOC's demands games after games.
- 2y ago
- arkh 2y agoBetter: let's go back to basics. One city: Athens. After the first year it suddenly becomes a lot less expensive to maintain the infrastructure. Especially if all participating nations are asked a sum depending on their GDP. And all participants naked before the gods as it was done originally.
- emchammer 2y agoSo they cannot wear a flag emblem, unless it's tattooed on them maybe.
- HelloMcFly 2y ago> One city: Athens In spirit, it's a neat idea. In practice, it would mean that for much of Asia and the entirety of the Americas the events are never aired at an ideal time. Shifting the geography allows for the prime viewing experience to shift with it. That's part of what I love about Watanabe's idea: everyone always gets a prime viewing experience of at least some of the sports.
- lupusreal 2y agoThe broadcast signals could in principle be recorded onto some manner of magnetic tape, then read back off that tape and rebroadcast a few hours later at whichever time is ideal for different parts of the world.
- Jeremy1026 2y agoI really don't hate that at all. 24 hours of live sports sounds fantastic, especially when the games are being held on the other side of the world so you either watch 12 hours delayed or are up at 2am to catch it live. You'd still have some events that you'd have to watch at odd hours, but you'd have the option of watching something else live. Also lessening the burden of host cities to build up infrastructure to host the world for a month only to be left with unused/underused facilities left to rot is a win.
- haunter 2y agoEuros 2020 did that and everyone hated it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Euro_2020 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Euro_2020 2030 FIFA World Cup will be in 3 contentes and 6 countries. Madness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2030_FIFA_World_Cup https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2030_FIFA_World_Cup
- wink 2y agoNot sure the comparison exactly tracks, because the teams need to be traveling. Unless I misunderstood something, unless you'd be competing in two wildly different disciplines you'd be in one place. Unless they separate like 100m and 800m running :P And for fans traveling along? Well...
- chollida1 2y agoTo be fair the FIFA world cup has usually been split among many cities. Putting it in different countries changes almost nothing. Brazil hosted it all over their country so it completely irrelevant if those cities were in brazil or an adjoining country due to the size of brazil and how hard it is to travel to some of their FIFA sites.
- throw7 2y agoThe problem is the coverage. I stopped watching a long time ago. The hosts are terrible. The social backstories are insufferable. It's impossible to watch your favorite <insert sport>... I'd tune in to a live streamed event, but I'm sure they'd screw it up somehow.