4 ms·
Could self-driving buses bring vehicle autonomy home?
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoHow about we just make the job of driving a bus suck less by making it pay more and giving drivers more leeway to handle problems on their busses, and more support from law enforcement for same, to address the shortage of workers? Then we don't need robo-busses and we can just use the non-robo busses we already have and perhaps even buy more of them, and setup more routes? The issues with busses are lack of coverage by the network and the shortage of drivers because it's an awful job that pays shit wages, both of which are down in large part due to lack of funding and the political will to allocate it. We don't need a computer to solve these issues.
- daseiner1 2y agoThe problem with buses is that nobody wants to be on a bus with the people who are regularly on buses.
- taurknaut 2y agoReally? I take the bus all the time. It's just normal people. Unless this is an obscure reference about drug use in your neighborhood or something that's completely going over my head.
- daseiner1 2y agoTo be clear, the majority of bus takers in my experience (several large cities on the West Coast of the US) are perfectly nice people. But often enough as to be a nuisance there are individuals who are: severely mentally ill, openly using drugs or intoxicated, blasting music on their phones, hostile or aggressive, lecherous and intimidating towards female passengers.
- nradov 2y agoThis varies widely by area. In the SF Bay Area due to public policy failures in housing, mental health, and substance abuse, some of the main bus routes have turned into rolling homeless shelters. You don't always see that but it's pretty obvious on certain routes at certain times. This makes some normal people uncomfortable — particularly women traveling alone. Regardless of whether that reaction is rational or not, it's another factor that discourages normal people from riding the bus and causes them to vote against public transit funding.
- whimsicalism 2y agowhat public policy would you suggest?
- whimsicalism 2y agothere is pretty often someone crazy on the buses i take, both in SF and DC where i grew up. generally i dont feel unsafe but i also dont enjoy being in an enclosed space with someone losing their mind
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoAnd who exactly are you picturing would be riding a robo bus then? Or is this going to be an expensive bus for tech workers so they needn't rub elbows with the poors?
- daseiner1 2y agoCounterintuitively, I would be likelier to take the bus if it were more expensive. My original comment is not about “the poors” and I am not a tech worker nor do I make “the big bucks”. Lower the pitchforks, please.
- cozzyd 2y agomaybe in some places, but usually the problems with buses are insufficient headways and lack of traffic priority.
- seabass-labrax 2y agoThe bus stops themselves are also a large consideration. Depending on the local climate one really needs a rain/wind shelter to make waiting comfortable enough, and it is obviously beneficial to have bins, seats and electronic departure boards. A very enlightened transport network would provide free Wi-Fi, but that might be asking for just a bit too much! All in all, I feel that the 'waiting' phase of catching a bus is often neglected, yet vitally important to the total experience.
- cozzyd 2y agoThe best way to improve the waiting component is to make it shorter, but indeed, most stops should have shelters (and they do, at least most of the ones I use in my city...) Wi-Fi might have made sense years ago, but there is good cell service everywhere.
- nytesky 2y agoBus drivers should be in their own cab. That would help a lot.
- seabass-labrax 2y agoYou could say they already are, at least with regard to recent vehicles for the European market: https://www.powerprogress.com/news/mercedesbenz-delivers-citaro-hybrid-buses-to-transport-firm-in-rome/8012818.article https://www.powerprogress.com/news/mercedesbenz-delivers-cit... The driver's area is entirely separated by an internal door, with an optional hole in the glass for operators which take cash. These separating doors became most widely fitted after the COVID-19 outbreak (for the drivers' safety), but they were already in use in many European cities years before that.
- triceratops 2y agoIf you increase wages you make buses either a) more expensive - less incentive for car drivers to switch (and you're hurting low-income passengers) or b) more loss-making - easier for car drivers to lobby politicians to kill them off. Bus fare is already pretty expensive when you consider the quality of service, speed, and convenience outside major metro areas. > due to lack of funding If there's a lack of funding, and there's tech that will make buses cheaper, it's a no-brainer to adopt it. > the political will to allocate it Willpower and political capital are limited resources. Why squander them when there are alternatives?
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> more loss-making - easier for car drivers to lobby politicians to kill them off. This logic only holds if you assume public services must make money and this is not a universal rule. Tons of public services hemorrhage money. It's called "spending money to get things" and we as a society have been doing it for basically as long as money has existed. > If there's a lack of funding, and there's a tech that will make buses cheaper, it's a no-brainer to adopt it. A regular car retrofitted to operate "autonomously" costs upwards of 100k by a quick google, and we're not talking a Mercedes here, we're talking a bog standard crossover. Busses cost near 6 times what that "autonomous" car costs for a boring one that a person drives, how much do you think a robo one will cost? Also worth noting, the prototype pictured in the article looks to move WAY fewer people than a standard city bus.
- triceratops 2y ago> if you assume public services must make money and this is not a universal rule I don't assume that. But I'm not the electorate. > Tons of public services hemorrhage money And that makes them easy targets for cuts. I personally prefer having public services stick around to serve people. That means stiffening them against political attacks as much as possible, and taking easy wins if they're available. > how much do you think a robo one will cost? So now we're arguing the actual cost-benefit of the technology. That's a much better way to approach it than reflexively dismissing it.
- 2y ago
- constantcrying 2y ago>We don't need a computer to solve these issues. Awful jobs that pay bad wages seem exactly what we want to solve with machines.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoSure, except the machines some ten years in and who knows how many (tr)(b)illions of dollars still don't work.
- gedy 2y ago[flagged]
- senda 2y agothose startups are really searching for meaning
- Loughla 2y agoYeah, it seems like self-driving isn't the cost saver here. It seems like route planning and optimization is a much better place to spend money.
- gedy 2y agoYeah, I mean using this tech for a fleet of self driving, point-to-point taxis as public transit makes sense to me. A bus on the usual fixed routes? Not really.
- stego-tech 2y agoBecause point-to-point self-driving taxis are a fool’s errand. They don’t alleviate congestion, they don’t improve traffic flow, they don’t improve urban planning. They’re a direct replacement for individual cars, but now rent-forever as opposed to owning or leasing ourselves. The whole concept is just to remove another strata of ownership and funnel more money to Capital and away from Governments, which I guess is the whole point if you genuinely don’t like governments for some reason. The healthier option for the masses is expanding mass transit networks, not luxe taxis. Light rail is infinitely more efficient and safer than individual vehicles, be they owner-operated or self-driving. It moves more people, further, faster, and cheaper than any potential self-driving automobile. When you include the whole of networks - ferries, bus routes, commuter rail - they’re the single most effective solution to everything self-driving car proponents claim their products can do, if only they had another round of funding. I’m not saying we should stop investing in the technology, mind. I just think it’s a better use of our limited resources to invest in improving, expanding, and modernizing mass transit than to build armies of privately-owned taxis, self-driving or otherwise.
- taneq 2y ago[flagged]
- triceratops 2y agoMuch more expensive to build, will face more political opposition, will take years to complete.
- whimsicalism 2y agoyes, we are building california high speed rail and spending billions on it. focus on that while we get actually solving the problem done in peace
- stego-tech 2y agoI still have to facepalm at the sheer lengths we’ll go through to avoid building rail or better transit. Yes, let’s have hundreds of startups squandering billions of dollars in investment to replace the lowly bus driver. That’s way better than spending that money in, say, light rail and trolley car systems, expanding existing subway networks, completing desperately needed infrastructure projects, or modernizing and automating existing rail service. Putting the soap box aside for just a moment however, I could see this being feasible for static bus routes, assuming your city maintains the roads and signals along that route so the ML algorithms piloting the multi-ton death machine on open roads isn’t distracted by a new pot hole or missing road stripe. Since no city in America actually does this though, these things seem about as reliable as the “self-driving” Teslas under Vegas. Then you throw in the need to retrain the algorithm every time the route changes, and the millions in expenses that’ll cost versus the few thousand it takes to retrain a human driver on a new route… Yeah, nevermind, breaking out the soap box again. Stop trying to short-change infrastructure investments and just invest in the infrastructure already. It won’t make some SV VC fund richer, sure, but it’ll at least go towards something useful and necessary for the city’s occupants.
- _dark_matter_ 2y agoI have light rail literally a 5 minute walk from my house in an inner ring suburb, and I never use it. It was built to go downtown 100 years ago, and I never go downtown for anything. It's completely stuck, has to still cross over streets and follow traffic patterns, and then only runs every half an hour l. Instead I just drive. Yes I hate it too. So light rail or trolleys is the same but worse and more expensive (plus they also still have drivers). For this to get used, it needs to: - not be beholden to traffic or congestion. Like a subway or the L? Or dedicated lanes for busses could work and may be drastically cheaper - needs to be able to service lots of destinations and changing needs. Subways do this by building new lines and stations (again, $$$) -needs to be relatively clean and safe. This is an actual concern people have that has to be addressed.
- jamil7 2y ago> Or dedicated lanes for busses could work and may be drastically cheaper This is discussed a bit in urban planning circles, one of the reasons trams or light rail is preferred is political, it's much harder for some austerity government to come into power in a city and remove tramlines than remove bus and bike lanes.
- colechristensen 2y agoSelf-driving vehicles are too stupid to drive in the snow. They can't handle variable traction (down to approximately 0 traction on black ice), they can't handle when road markings are entirely obscured by snow pack, they can't handle the general intelligence required to negotiate with humans in the same situation.
- Kirby64 2y agoNeither can most humans, if we’re being honest. Also, low traction situations are exactly the kind of thing that a computer is ideal at solving. Traction control in EVs is so, so much better than on gas cars purely because the ability to modulate force applied to maintain traction is far faster.
- cozzyd 2y agobus drivers are not "most humans" The maneuvers I see them do regularly are unlikely to be done by any current self-driving technology on a congested city street. With dedicated lanes or with no congestion, I can imagine them doing fine.
- kevlened 2y ago"Can't" is not "won't" When it comes to negotiating with humans, I've already seen Waymos flash their lights at bicyclists and pedestrians to cross. For other maneuvers, I've been in one that backed out of the crosswalk when it realized it crossed too far. It's difficult to define what they "can't" do, even in the medium term.
- cozzyd 2y agoI wonder how well they can identify if someone is waiting for the bus or not.
- antithesis-nl 2y agoWell, self-driving buses are definitely more likely to happen than self-driving general-purpose vehicles (due to buses already having predefined routes and often dedicated infrastructure), but which problem are we trying to solve here, exactly? "Bus driver" is not exactly a high-paying job, yet one that is important for social cohesion: passenger safety and informal surveillance of roads and neighborhoods sure are crucial! When it comes to anything 'self-driving', the main goal should be to reduce road traffic and neighborhood pollution-by-parking-spaces. This does nothing for either purpose.
- whimsicalism 2y ago"informal surveillance of roads" - doubt
- antithesis-nl 2y agoReally? "There's a blown-down tree here"... "Someone ran into this lamp post"... "This traffic sign has been vandalized"... "There's someone parked on the grass"... That's all without value?
- whimsicalism 2y agoi just do not think bus drivers where i live are doing that except maybe for the tree - you live in the US?
- antithesis-nl 2y agoNope. Does my HN user name give any hints? Over here, bus drivers (and taxi drivers, ironically, despite being not exactly being law-abiding-as-a-class) account for, like, two thirds of all non-urgent-law-enforcement calls.
- xnx 2y agoIf you think surveillance is valuable, you should love 360 video recorded by self-driving vehicles which travel all streets in a city, not just fixed routes.
- triceratops 2y agoI'm very disappointed in the comments here. They amount to Urbanists: we should make mass transit more affordable and convenient, and people will use it more. Industry: Ok we have tech that can reduce the cost of operating buses by 50% and let them operate round the clock. Urbanists: No no not like that. I didn't hear the words "trains" or "light rail" anywhere. I personally think we should celebrate any improvements in the cost and availability of public transit. And that includes buses.
- xnx 2y ago> Urbanists: No no not like that. I didn't hear the words "trains" or "light rail" anywhere. "Train brain"
- kkfx 2y agoThere is no urban future, despite those who dream smart cities. The reason why it that dense urban areas can't evolve and consume MUCH MORE in the modern world than sparse areas even if most deny it and do not even try to compute the raw materials and energy an urban vs sparse area consume. The future could be or a mass genocide to lower quickly earth population or an "urbanized" world of single family homes and sheds. That's why all who knows push "urban air mobility" which can't be in dense areas and can't be "collective" as well, because it's a way to reduce the need of infrastructure again and again. We need a cluster world, not a mainframe one.
- whimsicalism 2y agohi folks - somewhat related: where can I find a forum like HN where people actually like tech?