7 ms·
AI isn't going to kill the software industry
- cryptozeus 2y agoI have to say, it's not every day that you find a well-written article without loads of jargon or clickbait titles full of personal storytelling!
- aboardRat4 2y agoAI is not going to kill software industry, but is there still a software industry? Or, rather, is there any non-software industry left?
- whatshisface 2y agoThere's still a difference between sales and retail, investment and finance, and between software and tech.
- turbojet1321 2y agoThat's like asking "is there a building industry" just because every industry uses buildings. Every (well, most) industries use software; but the production of that software is itself an industry.
- aboardRat4 2y agoIs there a taxi industry? There certainly used to be one in the past, but where I live now, each taxi fleet is owned by what used to be a "software company".
- simonw 2y agoI've been trying to put this effect into words for a while, now I don't have to - this is really clearly stated: "AI tools create a significant productivity boost for developers. Different folks report different gains, but most people who try AI code generation recognize its ability to increase velocity. Many people think that means we’re going to need fewer developers, and our industry is going to slowly circle the drain. This view is based on a misunderstanding of why people pay for software. A business creates software because they think that it will give them some sort of economic advantage. The investment needs to pay for itself with interest. There are many software projects that would help a business, but businesses aren’t going to do them because the return on investment doesn’t make sense. When software development becomes more efficient, the ROI of any given software project increases, which unlocks more projects. [...] Cheaper software means people are going to want more of it. More software means more jobs for increasingly efficient software developers."
- nickfixit 2y agoThis is the way.
- jameslk 2y ago> More software means more jobs for increasingly efficient software developers This assumes software developers will be the ones needed to meet the demand. I think it will be more like technical product managers
- simonw 2y agoI think it will be the software developers that lean more into the kind of skills you see in technical product managers, or maybe vice-versa.
- nicoburns 2y ago> I think it will be more like technical product managers Even with traditional software development you'll be a much more effective software developer with good product management skills in a lot of niches (basically anything that's building a something user-facing)
- QuiDortDine 2y agoBut who will they blame when the solution inevitably fails to live up to the inherently contradictory demands of the different stakeholders?
- swatcoder 2y agoYou're splitting hairs over a title, but effectively talking about the same individuals. Whatever juice there is to squeeze out of generative AI coding, the people who will squeeze the most from it in the near future (10-20 years) are current and incoming software developers. Some may adopt different titles as the role matures, especially if there's a pay differential. This already happened with data engineering, database administration, etc So it's possible that the absolute number of people carrying the title approximately like "software developer" may be fewer in 10 years than it is today, although I personally find that very unlikely. But the people leading and maturing whatever alternate path comes up, for the next generation or so, will more often than not have a professional or academic background in software development regardless. The whole point of the article is that generative AI represents a lever that amplifies the capabilities of people who best know how to apply it. And for software development, that's ultimately going to be software developers.
- 65 2y agoIt's beneficial for executives to say AI will kill the software industry, it's a way to stoke fear in workers and a convenient way to say "with AI you could be x more productive," which makes the expectation that the worker should be however many times more productive than they already are, with or without AI "help". This is an attempt to increase hours worked at the same wages, which is itself an attempt to lower wages.
- andsoitis 2y agoWhile this behavior may exist in pockets, my experience suggests that this is not broadly the general mental model / approach by executives. I think this is a narrative in some peoples heads, but is neither an accurate reflection of the world, nor a healthy way to approach employment.
- 65 2y agoYou're probably right, though I speak from anecdotal experience, as the CTO of my company recently said that developers should be 5X more productive with AI. So what if I'm not 5X more productive with AI? Doesn't matter, because there's more tickets in the sprint that, in his head, I should theoretically be spending the same time working on as "before AI."
- lexandstuff 2y agoSounds like your CTO is dangerously incompetent and isn't actively using the AI tooling they are endorsing.
- tivert 2y ago> While this behavior may exist in pockets, my experience suggests that this is not broadly the general mental model / approach by executives. I think this is a narrative in some peoples heads, but is neither an accurate reflection of the world, nor a healthy way to approach employment. But it may be consistent with worker's experience with the effects of executives' actual decisions, and a better fit than the executives' actual mental model.
- Kerrick 2y ago“Crack the books”—can anybody recommend good books for this shared future of ours? I’m tired of trying to piece it together from blog posts, READMEs, and short video tutorials.
- simonw 2y agoI haven't read these all the way through myself but I've seen enough of them that I'm confident suggesting them: - Prompt Engineering for LLMs by John Berryman and Albert Ziegler: https://www.amazon.com/Prompt-Engineering-LLMs-Model-Based-Applications/dp/1098156153 https://www.amazon.com/Prompt-Engineering-LLMs-Model-Based-A... - AI Engineering by Chip Huyen, which I recommend based on the strength of this extract about "agents": https://huyenchip.com/2025/01/07/agents.html https://huyenchip.com/2025/01/07/agents.html
- airstrike 2y agoI like hands-on learning more than I like textbooks, so in case that matches your requirements, maybe try training your own GPT to have a sense for how it works. I wrote a Rust version of the famous https://github.com/karpathy/nanoGPT https://github.com/karpathy/nanoGPT (which is in Python) so that I could learn how it's built. I wrote it in Rust because I wanted to improve my skills in that language, be forced to write code instead of just reading the existing implementation so that I would truly learn, and test the quality of the nascent Rust AI/ML ecosystem, but you could pick your own language
- brainbag 2y agoWould you say more about your experience writing it in Rust? It worked well, what didn't, anywhere you found that you struggled unexpectedly or that was easier than you expected?
- airstrike 2y agoHey, thanks for asking. I'm the furthest from an authority in this so I encourage you to take everything I say with a grain of salt. I was using the burn[0] crate which is pretty new but in active development and chock-full of features already. It comes with a lot of what you need out of the box including a TUI visualizer for the training and validation steps. The fact that it's so full of features is a blessing and a curse. The code is very modular so you can use the pieces you want the way you want to use them, which is good, but the "flavor" of Rust in which is written felt like a burden compared to the way I'm used to writing Rust (which, for context, is 99% using the glorious iced[1] GUI library). I can't fault burn entirely for this, after all they are free to make their own design choices and I was a beginner trying to do this in less than a week. I also think they are trying to solve for getting a practitioner to just get up and going right away, whereas I was trying to build a modular configuration on top of the crate instead of a one-and-done type script. But there were countless generic types, several traits to define and implement in order to make some generic parameter fit those bounds, and the crate has more proc_macro derives than I'd like (my target number is 0) such as `#[derive(Module, Config, new)]` because they obfuscate the code that I actually have to write and don't teach me anything. TL;DR the crate felt super powerful but also very foreign. It didn't quite click to the point where I thought it was intuitive or I felt very fluent with it. But then again, I spent like 5 days with it. One other minor annoying thing was that I couldn't download exactly what I wanted out of HuggingFace directly. I ended up having to use `HuggingfaceDatasetLoader::new("carlosejimenez/wikitext__wikitext-2-raw-v1")` instead of `HuggingfaceDatasetLoader::new("Salesforce/wikitext")` because the latter would get an auth error, but this may also be my ignorance about how HF is supposed to work... Eventually, I got the whole thing to work quite neatly and was able to tweak hyperparameters and get my model to increasingly better perplexity. With more tweaks, a better tokenizer, possibly better data source, and an NVIDIA GPU rather than Apple Silicon, I could have squeezed even more out of it. My original goal was to try to slap an iced GUI on the project so that I could tweak the hyperparameters there, compare models, plot the training and inference, etc. with a GUI instead of code. Sort of a no-code approach to training models. I think it's an area worth exploring more, but I have a main quest I need to finish first so I just wrote down my findings in an unpublished "paper" and tabled it for now. ________ [0]: https://github.com/tracel-ai/burn https://github.com/tracel-ai/burn [1]: https://github.com/iced-rs/iced https://github.com/iced-rs/iced
- 9rx 2y agoWhat we are currently calling AI is just a fancy programming language/REPL/compiler anyway, so obviously software developers aren't going away any time soon. You fundamentally must be a software developer to use these tools. Elevator operators never went away either. In fact, there have never been more elevator operators in human history! Not a good career choice, though. That is what these warnings, realistic or not, are actually calling attention to.
- Aperocky 2y ago> there have never been more elevator operators in human history Press X to doubt
- 9rx 2y agoWhen was there more? We keep building more and more buildings with elevators in places where there are more and more people. With defined elevator attendants being almost unheard of nowadays, leaving elevator users to be operator in nearly every case, anything else is mathematically unlikely. Software developers aren't going anywhere, but, like the elevator operator, everyone might become a software developer. At least that is the theory the grifters are grifting on. They aren't literally saying software developers are going away. That couldn't work given that you become, if you weren't already, a software developer when you use these tools.
- herval 2y agoThat’s very easily googled: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Number-of-Elevator-Operators-1870-1990-22_fig3_321640625 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Number-of-Elevator-Opera... There were more elevator operators before elevators became easily operated by the passengers - as expected
- 9rx 2y agoThat indicates that there are effectively no elevator operators today, which is clearly false. Elevator manufacturers put a lot of effort into incorporating an array of buttons for the operator to push for good reason – and push them the operator does. I witness it every time I enter an elevator. Are you confusing operating an elevator with operating an elevator professionally? We were never talking about the later, and even called attention to how it is not a good career choice today to really drive home that idea.
- simonw 2y agoWhile I found myself in furious agreement with the section titled "Jevons Paradox", I'm less convinced by this argument from the "Comparative Advantage" section: "While AI is powerful, it’s also computationally expensive. Unless someone decides to rewrite the laws of physics, there will always be a limit on how much artificial intelligence humanity can bring to bear." The cost for running a prompt through the best-available model has collapsed over the past couple of years. GPT-4o is about 100x times less expensive than GPT-3 was, and massively more capable. DeepSeek v3 and R1 are priced at a fraction of OpenAI's current prices for GPT-4 and o1 model and appear to be highly competitive with them. I don't think we've hit the end of that trend yet - my intuition is that there's a lot more performance gains still to be had. I don't think LLM systems will be competitive with everything that humans can do for a long time, if ever. But for the things they CAN do the cost is rapidly dropping to almost nothing.
- thfuran 2y agoA human brain runs on about 20 W, and I see no reason to believe that that is the absolute limit of efficiency. It's probably quite efficient as far as mammalian meat goes, but evolution can only optimize somewhat locally.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoIndeed, the laws of physics don't put any limits on artificial intelligence that don't also apply to natural intelligence. It's a strange place to look for a comparative advantage argument.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TheDudeMan 2y ago> I don't think LLM systems will be competitive with everything that humans can do for a long time It's looking like about 3 years. That will be another ~100x cost reduction, $100s more billions in infra, new training algorithms, new capabilities.
- iterateoften 2y agoWorking with nontechnical people make prompts is interesting. I’m seeing a lot of frustration with people dealing with markdown. Even though it’s free form and not really like code at all the hashes, dashes etc throw them off Also seeing a lot of people having a hard time expressing their desired behavior in a concrete way. It reminds me in 3rd grade when we had to write recipes and then the teacher had a classmate maliciously comply to only what was written. Overall I think tools will improve and barriers will continue to disappear but for the time being still has big demand for people to convert abstract intention to concrete machine usable format. It’s just how those ideas are expressed get more flexible with llms
- elzbardico 2y agoYeah, I always suspected this. Increased software productivity facilitated by IA would lead to even more and more complex software. But are we the software workers going to see the results of our increased productivity in our paychecks or are we now on the same boat as the other proletarians that haven't seen their salaries increase in proportion to the increases on their productivities facilitated by automation since the 70s. Are we going to enter history as the last profession to resist feudalization, the last one who gave a lower class person some chance of upward mobility only to finally be conquered by the power of the ultra-rich?
- wsintra2022 2y agoSeems that way. I’ve also been thinking this lately. As the bootcamp grads of the last ten years know, getting that 6 figure salary was a blessing, prices rising faster and faster, well that takes the shine off it.
- Terr_ 2y agoAlso all the jobs for replacing unreliable/insecure systems where LLM output is being given wayyy too much trust and system authority.
- agentultra 2y agoI haven’t seen a study yet that suggests AI tools enhance productivity of developers. I wouldn’t take it as a given. The study I have seen was from a company selling AI developer tools whose researchers were employed by said company. Not exactly and independent and bias-free study. Personally they don’t work for me. It’s not AI that is going to take out jobs. It’s the capital class that will do that. That’s what is changing the industry. I suspect this will be the year we start to hear stories of folks getting let go for not using LLM codegen.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dboreham 2y agoI feel anecdotally that Stack Overflow significantly increased my productivity. By induction therefore so should an LLM.
- ClimaxGravely 2y agoInteresting I found SO to not be that helpful even during the golden years. I should not that I tend to work in codebases that have little to no public information though so that might be the differentiator. Presumably an LLM would be less useful due to that but I'm looking forward to trying again in the future.
- cryptos 2y agoFrom my experience AI tools can help a lot to write some parts of your code. You could for example generate a parameterized test from several similar tests. Doing the same by hand might take half an hour, where it would only a take a minute to feed the right things to the AI tool and let it generate the code.
- senordevnyc 2y agoThis one? https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4945566 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4945566 So it's more accurate to say you have seen a study, you just don't believe it.
- carbocation 2y agoI remember when Hinton said that that we should "stop training radiologists now" in 2016[1]. Meanwhile, radiologists are in high demand and are getting paid better than ever. I believe the same will be true for programmers in the future. Sure, some of the boilerplate will be handled for you, just like segmentation is for radiologists. That's great for everyone. 1 = https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HMPRXstSvQ&t=30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HMPRXstSvQ&t=30s
- TheDudeMan 2y agoDid the radiologists suddenly get better than the AI at reading images? Or is the system simply unchangeable?
- carbocation 2y agoA few responses: - Since when have the radiologists ever been worse than AI at reading images? - AI is doing mechanical tasks for the radiologists, so it stands to reason that this makes radiologist more efficient. - The radiologist is a liability sponge, so if at all possible it of course makes sense to augment the radiologist with AI rather than to try to do away with them. (This roughly gets at your point about the system being unchangeable.)
- aiiizzz 2y ago> Since when have the radiologists ever been worse than AI at reading images? Since 2 years~ish?
- carbocation 2y agoFor segmentation? Sure. For their role as a clinical consultant? Not yet.
- avidphantasm 2y agoThe notion of no longer training radiologists because computer vision algorithms and deep learning are good at detecting cancers in imagery strikes me troublingly naïve. Who fucking trained the AIs? Will the AIs magically be able to detect yet to be discovered maladies?
- QuiDortDine 2y ago> Software development has always been a career where you are either learning new things or stagnating. AI doesn’t change the need to keep learning and evolving. Keep in mind, there are still COBOL developers. If you want to stagnate, there's a market for that.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoLegacy markets are niche, and often shrinking.
- bmenrigh 2y agoChatGPT and similar tools have made getting started programming way more accessible. My girlfriend just learned to program starting a few months ago and I’m constantly impressed what she’s able to do with the help of AI tools.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoAI is going to make building software way cheaper and more profitable, but that's actually bad news for a lot of developers out there. Think about how many people are only employed because they know the basics of React or Django or whatever. They can copy-paste code and tweak existing patterns, but that's exactly what AI is getting really good at. The developers who are actually going to thrive are the ones who can architect complex systems and solve gnarly technical problems. That stuff is getting more valuable, not less. But a lot of folks have built careers on pretty basic skills. They've gotten by because there just aren't many humans who can do even simple technical work. That advantage is disappearing fast.
- 65 2y agoThe barrier to entry will be raised, though isn't that always happening in software, regardless of if it's AI or not? Companies used to hire HTML email developers, for example. There are many HTML email builders out there that do the job for a marketing person. Better tooling, if it's AI tooling or a framework, continuously changes the job requirements. Even your average React developer still has to deal with plenty of other things people in the past didn't have to think about. E.g. dependency management, responsive screen sizes for all screen widths, native apps, state management, etc.
- rahimnathwani 2y ago"Better tooling, if it's AI tooling or a framework, continuously changes the job requirements." This might be true if you work at a tech company, but it's not universally true. There are many people who are gainfully employed as software developers, based solely on technical knowledge they acquired years ago.
- senordevnyc 2y agoIronically though, if you do need to build raw HTML emails in 2025, it's still a huge PITA due to the horrible support for HTML / CSS across many email clients, and a dearth of good resources and information out there.
- G_o_D 2y agoFor coders/devs --> AI is useful only to novice coders ai give them a basuc core/template code to start with that they can modify But actual coders who work in companies on projects thay have to follow different styles/languages/algorithm for coding practices, ai cant conform to that , if you are working on legacy codes or refactoring you need to maintain the style and format the code already is in, ai cant give you exact, you cant say ai these is my million line, code scattered on thousand files, analyse and add these feature while maintaining sanctity of current code practice Ai will just introduce new bugs and you will waste more time in finding and solving AI gives productivity boost only if you are starting from scratch, it can give you core code / boilerplate to rapidly start with adding features
- jaredsohn 2y agoDisagree. AI can increase productivity a bunch of ways in this scenario: 1. "Help me understand what this code does." Both via text and by building diagrams. 2. "Help me understand how to solve this problem or how this tech works." 3. Normal code-completion type things 4. Helping build scripts that you can use to apply changes. Also, in general you can ask the AI to maintain the existing style.
- paradite 2y agoI think the two different sides of the view is really just a matter of perspective and definition. Do you view the next evolution of software engineering with AI as still software engineering? Or do you think it's something else that replaces software engineering. Something akin to the Ship of Theseus. I belong to the replacement camp, but I don't think the underlying thinking differs much. Just a matter of how you look at it. My personal take: https://github.com/paradite/ai-replace-swe https://github.com/paradite/ai-replace-swe
- cynicalpeace 2y agoThere's also the effect that reviewing AI generated code is a lot less fun than writing your own code. It becomes more of an admin task, and less of a creative one, thereby attracting less motivated developers.
- jumploops 2y ago> Cheaper software means people are going to want more of it. This is the key insight. Most software today is built for the common user (individual, business, etc.). With the cost of writing curly braces and semi-colons dropping drastically, we’ll actually see an increase in the number of programmers worldwide. This will come at some cost; your average Wordpress agency will need to evolve or get eaten, similarly so if you primarily build CRUD apps. As more software is written, the upper bound should also go higher. Great engineers will be greater, both in capability and compensation. LLMs are the new compiler, and the world of software is going to get a lot more bespoke.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThis cannot be true forever or for everything. I don't want cheaper software controls in my car. I want physical buttons. I don't want unpredictable and worse-than-human self driving at any price, not even if you paid me. (That my kids are beta tester pedestrians for the neighborhood Teslas is at regulatory failure IMO.)
- randcraw 2y ago> LLMs are the new compiler, and the world of software is going to get a lot more bespoke. This is true only if your data sources and sinks are accessible, well documented, and their governing app is cooperative, such that your LLM coding tool can get access to it. For instance, if you want to add a custom filter email plugin, your email app has to provide a plugin API and document it, thereby enabling a LLM-based development tool to seek and find all the necessary hooks for you. But is doing that in the interest of the email app's vendor? If not, no amount of AI will be able to add value to that app, ever.
- senordevnyc 2y agoI think the API in that case is just going to be the browser.
- parpfish 2y agoi agree that the industry wont be killed, but I do have some worries about what the future will look like. - If we keep making AI-assistance tools that make mid- and senior-level ICs more and more efficient, where does that leave entry-level junior positions? It's already tough enough for juniors to get a foot in the door, but will it get even harder as we continue to make the established older devs more and more efficient? - The current crop of AI-assistance tools are being tailored to meet the needs of mid- and senior-level ICs that learned programming in a pre-AI world. But incoming junior devs are "AI native" and may approach software development in a very different way. - I would wager that there will be substantial workplace/generational divides between devs that learned programming before using AI assistance later vs "AI native" devs that had AI assistance the whole time. I have no idea what these new ways of working will be, but I'm curious to see how it plays out.
- vagab0nd 2y agoIf Thing B is better and cheaper than Thing A, people are going to use Thing B until it runs out. Consequently, people are going to make more Thing B. In the short term some jobs are safe only because we don't have enough Thing B, temporarily. But that's not the reason to claim "we are safe don't worry!".
- lexandstuff 2y agoI don't know what the future holds, but developing software in the present is amazing. I've always loved writing software, but I love writing software with AI even more. All the boring stuff, like converting data from one format to another, is a prompt away. All the annoying scripts you know how to write, but cbf, like conditionally editing files across directories, is a prompt away. Plus, I feel secure with my AI buddy. It's like having a helpful lead who's always up to help me debug, give me a second opinion, or show me what I'm missing. I feel like I can work in any language I want, and learning new things is so much easier with an AI tutor.
- mmaunder 2y agoThere’s a silent majority not using AI, in many cases actually building complex AI tools and models with many moving parts, with nothing to gain from saying that they’re not using AI. And the grifters have everything to gain by pouncing on anyone commenting that they’re not using AI.
- 1shooner 2y ago"Cheaper software means people are going to want more of it. More software means more jobs for increasingly efficient software developers. Economists call this Jevons Paradox." If we accept there will be increased demand for software, it's a big jump from that to concluding the efficiency of AI will be outpaced by the demand for software, specifically along the dimension of required developers. Software isn't wheat or fuel, it can be reused and resold.
- nialv7 2y agoI am quite tired of seeing titles like this. No, you _don't know_. Vast majority of definitive statements like this is going to be meaningless. The whole point about this is that it's an uncertainty, the impact of AI on our society is unpredictable, you could be right, but you could be wrong too. And merely assigning a probability to this is going to be very non-trivial. I just can't understand where people find the kind of confidence to say AI is (or is not) going to <insert your scenario here>.
- bufferoverflow 2y ago"When software development becomes more efficient, the ROI of any given software project increases, which unlocks more projects." - this is just wrong. It assumes every company hiring software developers has infinite scope. In reality most companies hire programmers to create something and then scale down and maintain it. (Obviously, there are companies with nearly unlimited scope, but those are usually huge companies). When some AI can perform the work at 100X the rate of an average developer, you will run out of requirements pretty quickly. You will need 1/100th of developers to oversee the process.
- kvirani 2y agoI agree and like this article, but something about calling those that believe otherwise Grifters feels a bit too harsh and polarizing to me. I know some who do believe AI will cause immense software role displacement, and wouldn't label them this way.
- FloorEgg 2y agoThank you for this article, I really needed a positivity boost today. It's a great reminder to not only consider what wonderful things could happen in the future, but also to want them and work towards them. Clarifying a positive future like this helps others consider it, want it, and make it happen. I understand the case being made is more of a prediction than a wish, but it's also a vision. I believe clarifying a vision makes it more likely to happen, especially when people gravitate to it. There is plenty of negativity already. Thanks again for the positive outlook.
- apeace 2y agoThe job of "software engineer" as we know it will end. Before the industrial revolution, shoemakers would make shoes. It was a specialized skill, meaning shoes were very expensive, so most people couldn't afford them. Then factories were invented. Now shoes could be made cheaply and quickly, by machines, so more people could afford them. This meant that far more people could be employed in the shoe industry. But those people were no longer shoemakers. Shoemakers were wiped out overnight. Think of how huge the shoe industry is now. There are jobs ranging from factory worker to marketing manager. But there are zero shoemakers. AI writing software doesn't mean it's the end of the industry. Humanity will benefit greatly, just like we did from getting cheaper shoes. But the software engineers are screwed.
- bamboozled 2y agoBut those people were no longer shoemakers. Shoemakers were wiped out overnight. Have you seen the cost and popularity of "Made in X" handmade boots though? Red Wing, Origin, Red Back. It's absolutely crazy The difference is, all of a sudden we could make a lot of CHEAP shoes and yes I'm sure it wiped out a lot of shoe maker jobs, but there is still a lot of good shoe makers around and there is still a high demand for handmade shoes and boots.
- apeace 2y agoTo add to this: the author is missing a major aspect of the Jevons paradox. They keep referencing "more efficient software developers," but the Jevons paradox isn't only about efficiency. The efficiency creates lower cost, which in turn increases demand. The main cost of software is software engineers. It's a specialized skill, so it's a high-salary job. With AI doing most of the work, salaries will begin to fall. It will no longer make sense to study computer science, or spend years learning to code, for such a low salary. There will no longer be people doing what we call software engineering today. So the author is right, Jevons paradox will take effect. But like I said above, it will replace the current industry with a very different-looking industry.
- squishington 2y agoI really don't see AI generating safe code for automotive embedded systems that is maintainable and MISRA and HIS compliant. And there will need to be software engineers who are trained to debug these systems.
- jsnell 2y agoI don't buy applying comparative advantage in this case, even after reading the more extended article that was linked to. The argument makes the fundamental assumption that the marginal value of one unit of a specific type of work is fixed. Whatever is the most profitable use case for AGI is the one that all the compute and power will be plowed into. But what kind of economic activity actually has a fixed marginal utility, no matter how much of that activity there is? I think it's like, none at all? No matter what you're doing, there's eventually going to be diminishing returns as you do more of it. As the highest value use cases are saturated by AGI, the opportunity cost of doing something else diminishes. And comparative advantage only works because of the opportunity cost.
- monobot12 2y ago> While AI is powerful, it’s also computationally expensive. Unless someone decides to rewrite the laws of physics, there will always be a limit on how much artificial intelligence humanity can bring to bear. This means that we’ll eventually allocate our scarce AI resources towards the things they are best at, which leaves plenty of things for humans to do. Unfortunately, this argument doesn't hold up because of "cheap" models such as Deepseek R1.
- Nevermark 2y agoAI is going to create more work for software developers, in the shorter run. Big efficiency gains motivate the million small steps, planned and muddled through, that it takes to harness the new efficiencies most effectively at scale. Not just somewhere. But in the long run (where “long” these days can be pretty short) how can generations of improving automated software developers, improving in both quality & capacity, not replace lots of software developers. > There’s no shortage of people saying “this time it’s different”, but those people have been around for every other major technological advance and they have yet to be correct. I wouldn’t bet on the doomers. This is not a valid argument. It is logical gibberish. Let’s prep it for Lean: “many people have been wrong before, let’s call those people “Doomers1”. There are people who disagree with me. Let’s call those people “Doomers2”. Clearly, “Doomers1” = “Doomers2”, proof by similarity of set names. “Doomers1” have been wrong about something before, therefore “Doomers2” will certainly be wrong. Lean crashes… —- Question: “What software development task is intrinsically human?” Thought experiment: Could there be alien non-human programmers? Based on silicon instead of carbon, that could ever be better than us? An argument that software developers cannot be replaced by exponentially scaling and improving learning tech, would have to involve some quite special reasoning. It would have to tie humans to fundamental math and computing in a way that shook our understanding of all three.