7 ms·
A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy
- brc 14y agoThat's probably one of the best articles I've read on the real nature of 'alternative' energy in a while. My rule of thumb is simple : if someone calls it 'Alternative Energy', it means it's an alternate to having a cheap, ready supply of energy. Otherwise, it would just be called 'energy'. Nobody calls Nuclear power alternate energy, even though it's radically different to anything else that came before it in terms of generating power. The percentage of power generated from wind globally, currently, rounded to the nearest decimal place is zero. Trillions of dollars have been spent on windfarms and solar panels around the world, and, as the article notes, it has made zero difference to the overall energy mix. Yet it has affected national economies in real ways - the bankruptcies in Germany, Spain and elsewhere have real costs, as does taking the most basic economic input - energy - and making it more expensive for zero environmental gain at the global level. Despite the countless examples of failures to point to, the boosters insist that it's the right course, when any plain analysis shows the exact opposite. There are plenty of people who hand-wave around the very real problems as outlined in the article, and say things like 'give it time, it will work out'. But you have to be a starry-eyed believer who trusts in state-coerced solutions to gloss over the myriad of problems of trying to jump-start essentially niche technologies into mainstream adoption. It takes real courage to rely on human ingenuity to solve problems and come up with solutions. It's frightening to look at an issue and realise you have no answers at all. But what's worse is to set off on a futile and damaging strategy just to be seen to be doing something, when that thing is ineffective at best, and damaging at worst due to the self-delusion inherent. This holds at the personal, family, business, state, national and global level.
- singingfish 14y agoI disagree. The article reads to me like a partisan anti-renewable energy opinion piece with the facts chosen to fit the author's point of view. A scientific examination of the issue value would evaluate a hypothesis, not state the viewpoint at the outset.
- jws 14y agoIt might also use actual numbers for solar radiation in Bavaria instead of childhood recollections. Bavaria is surprisingly not terrible for solar power. Most of Bavaria gets 2/3 the solar radiation of the best spots in Spain, and is even about 50% of the best spots you'll find (like in Chad, but then you'd have electrical power in Chad instead of Germany.) http://solargis.info/imaps/ http://solargis.info/imaps/ lets you poke around much of the world for your dream solar farm.
- rayiner 14y agoGermany is actually great for solar power, like the American midwest. The reason is that it's not just about average solar radiation, but also about average temperature. Solar cells are much more efficient when it's cold than when it's hot. Excelon recently built a huge solar facility up in Chicago, and it generates something like 80-90% as much power as plants in much sunnier places, because Chicago is so cold for so much of the year.
- ajross 14y agoIndeed. I got as far as the author dismissing solar and wind on the basis of "capacity factor" (average output over peak output), which is completely meaningless. That "peak output" number has no relevance to anything. What matters (all that matters, in the context of the article) is obviously cost (in money, perhaps corrected for things like real estate occupied, etc...) per net power. And it doesn't even get mentioned. Yawn. Still, it's better than the really awful junk Burt Rutan wrote last year.
- martythemaniak 14y agoI found this piece to be depressingly pessimistic and downright whiny. Many people have argued that humanity has become excessively risk-averse and in-ward looking. "It's hard" is no longer a challenge to be overcome, but a reason to sit back and kick the can down the road.
- jbellis 14y agoIf only the laws of physics could be repealed with guts and hard work.
- zxcdw 14y agoIt's not about something not being possible. It's about something not being "commercially profitable". We could abandon all the coal and oil in a decade or two and move completely onto renewable energy sources, it is possibe - it's just nobody gives a damn about it, because it would have a dent in quality of life, especially in western countries. It's our selfishness and greed holding us back, rather than laws of physics.
- sliverstorm 14y agohumanity has become excessively risk-averse Well exemplified by our incredible fear of nuclear power
- Semaphor 14y agonuclear power. In Germany just lately there was another (though as always shortlived) surge of news about how politicians played their games with nuclear waste. Our final storage of nuclear waste is a joke from the past by corrupt politicians. When you can't trust people to think about the (instead of their) future it's hard not to fear nuclear energy.
- ClHans 14y agoI'm wary of anyone who uses terms like "state-coerced" - it suggests that the author has bought into an ideology that is decidedly not reality-based. Too often, phrases like that run in packs with ideas like "taxation is theft" (it isn't, of course).
- rayiner 14y ago> The percentage of power generated from wind globally, currently, rounded to the nearest decimal place is zero. This is just not true. I'm not sure what it is globally, but in the US it's several percent (which is not zero percent under any rounding I'm aware of). More to the point, it produces more than 10% of the electricity in five U.S. states. It's also the fastest-growing energy source in the world, even faster than natural gas. > Trillions of dollars have been spent on windfarms and solar panels around the world, and, as the article notes, it has made zero difference to the overall energy mix. Nowhere near "trillions of dollars" have been spent on wind farms. You're just making things up. > Yet it has affected national economies in real ways - the bankruptcies in Germany, Spain and elsewhere have real costs, as does taking the most basic economic input - energy - and making it more expensive for zero environmental gain at the global level. The bankruptcies in Germany, Spain, etc, are the fault of alternative energy? > Despite the countless examples of failures to point to, the boosters insist that it's the right course, when any plain analysis shows the exact opposite. The analysis of the "skeptics" almost always leaves out the vast externalized costs of traditional energy sources. E.g. if hundreds of billions of dollars of externalized costs from coal were factored into the price of coal, coal power would be more expensive than wind power: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-cooper/harvard-study-coal-costs-_b_831755.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-cooper/harvard-study-coal.... > But you have to be a starry-eyed believer who trusts in state-coerced solutions There is nothing starry-eyed about the economists who point out that the free market naturally underproduces fundamental R&D. Pick up an Economics 101 book sometime.
- brc 14y ago- Globally wind power produced < 0.5% of energy last year. Most people forget, or don't realise, that the current obsession with alternative energy is limited to parts of Western Europe and parts of the USA. It has virtually no traction elsewhere in the world. - You're right, I should have written billions instead of trillions, though I'd be surprised if it hasn't reached a trillion by now. It's still an insane amount of money. - Bankruptcies in Germany and Spain by solar companies are very much the cause of bad policies - by pumping up a sector with unsustainable subsidies, then being forced to remove subsidies precisely because they are unsustainable. This creates a bubble into which resources rush, which then bursts and creates a lot of problems. This is the fundamental problem, of trying to coerce a particular set of technologies into place when they aren't suitable for it. The correct response is to admit there is no current technical solution to affordable energy without burning stuff. There is a noisy subset of people who don't agree with this position, and that's fair enough. History has always proven that major advances come from unexpected areas, and tend to render prior technologies obselete almost overnight.
- anovikov 14y agoIn the countries that actively pursue renewables, they take a good share of the energy mix. Germany went from 6% of renewable electricity (nearly all hydropower) in 1990 to 21% in 2011 and about 24% now, and from 3% of overall energy mix (including heating, fuels, etc., not just electricity) in 1990 to 12% now. And current rates of adoption is at least 2% per year for electricity and 1% for overall mix. That's a big deal. Most renewables have already worked themselves out to be competitive.
- pserwylo 14y agoI started reading it and admiring their attention to detail with the first two charts. Extremely clear and informative: http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergytechfig3-1340889659713.jpg http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergytechfig3-134088965... Then it went down hill fast, culminating in stuff like this: http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergyFigIcon3-1340126783409.jpg http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergyFigIcon3-134012678... and http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergyFigIcon5-1340201830000.jpg http://spectrum.ieee.org/img/07OLAltEnergyFigIcon5-134020183... Edit: spelling.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm not sure what to make of that last chart... it's showing wind power increasing from 0.09% to 2.91% in only 20 years (which is the blink of an eye in an industry that moves as glacially slow as electricity production--Chicago just this year shut down a couple of coal plants that were over a century old). If the trend holds up then in another 20 years alms tall our electricity will be produced by wind!
- mc32 14y agoI think his point about that is that promises of renewables replacing traditional sources in ten and twenty year time-frames (such as the proponents he cites) is wildly optimistic. I think the time frames to adoption and ramp-up to significant share are his main points of contention, via a vis boosters of renewables as solution to our energy problems.
- rayiner 14y agoIt seems like a very "neener-neener" argument to me. Okay, so what, proponents of wind and solar a decade ago were overly optimistic about how quickly such technologies would take over. NASA scientists also thought we'd be going to Mars by 2025. What does that prove? At the end of the day, the installed capacity of wind power has tripled in just the last several years. The price of solar panels has fallen through the floor. A number of U.S. states are seeing immediate local benefits from supplying > 10% of their electricity through wind power. I'm not quite sure why "% of global electricity consumption" is the only salient metric. Even if Texas's gas guzzling keeps the overall % low, Iowa still has cleaner air by supplying 14% of its electricity needs through wind power.
- ktizo 14y agoSolar with storage will become ubiquitous when the price point on the storage becomes low enough. The panels themselves are right on the edge of mainstream viability right now, and the technologies involved are getting cheaper and more efficient all the time and unlike most other energy production methods, can be successfully integrated into existing urban architecture.
- ars 14y agoThe panels have been "right on the edge of mainstream viability" for 20-30 years now. What's different this time?
- ktizo 14y agothis - http://rwer.wordpress.com/2012/03/12/energy-prices-two-trends-2-graphs/ http://rwer.wordpress.com/2012/03/12/energy-prices-two-trend...
- ars 14y agoIt's hard to take those graphs seriously when they are not logarithmic, but I see your point. Also, comparing to oil is terrible - they should compare to electricity instead which has hardly changed in price. And if the price is really falling so well, why are we pushing things? Let the price keep falling and people will naturally switch, with no need to subsidies. Speaking of - does that price take into account subsidies?
- acslater00 14y agoThe future of energy is natural gas. End of story. Alternative natural gas production -- "fracking" generally -- has been researched, prototyped, implemented, and grown over the past 15-20 years to the point where one can reasonably envision a future where natural gas displaces coal and crude oil to become the most important energy sources in the world. It emits way less carbon than coal or oil, it is everywhere, it can be liquified relatively cheaply and transported around the world by super tanker, people are less afraid of it than nuclear power, and the technology to actually use it has been around forever. Electricity...home heating...hydrogen fuel cells...all easy with natural gas. As a general rule, when The Economist publishes a 14-page spread about something, it's pretty much hit the mainstream. They did that 2 weeks ago. http://www.economist.com/node/21558432 http://www.economist.com/node/21558432
- btipling 14y agoHow much natural gas is there, and how long will it last?
- guscost 14y agoThe near future of American energy is natural gas. Are you telling me that somebody knows what's going to happen after that?
- acslater00 14y agoFair enough.
- ktizo 14y agoThere are maybe 60 years worth of proven reserves if we don't increase demand, at least according to BP in 2009. If that is end of story for the future of energy, then it is a fairly bleak story.
- brc 14y agoAll mineral reserves are basically 20-60 years into the future. That's because there is no incentive for a company to go out and find more reserves than it needs. I'm not arguing against you, but using company reserves to predict the future is like using the length of a current employment contract to work out the future of your own employment. If you have a contract for 2 years worth of work, you're not necessarily going to be unemployed in 2 years. There's just no need for you to arrange more work just yet. The same principle is at work with company hydrocarbon reserves. The other curve-ball is changing technology. Many fields that are producing now were considered uneconomic in the past, but improvements in technology change that. All in all, they are a very poor way of judging how much 'stuff' is in the ground. Which is why people, when looking at proven reserves 10, 20, 50 years ago would have concluded that things would have run out by now.
- ajcarpy2005 14y agoThere can be no denying that solar panels and other alternative energy sources _are_ an extremely good long-term investment for those who own homes or brick and mortar companies. Don't let any amount of "skepticism" fool you into thinking it is not a good investment.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoI won't inconvenience you with the facts, then
- ajcarpy2005 14y agoapprox. 8 year payoff (to break even with what you would have paid for utility bills) with around a 30 year lifespan at least...4x ROI. How is that a bad investment??
- brc 14y agoBecause it relies on someone overpaying you for the electricity produced, which is added onto someone elses' bill. In a democracy, that's not sustainable. Sooner or later, someone will get voted in that promises the remove the subsidy. Indeed this is happening all over the world. It also leads to resource misallocation whereby time + money + manpower is spent farming subsidies over other productive activities. If your example is for an unsubsidised installation, then it's a good ROI. Otherwise, it's a bad idea as well as morally questionable. The poorer members of society shouldn't pay more for basic energy to make richer members get excessive returns.
- ghouse 14y agoYou assume specific aspects regarding the regulatory environment for the parent. Are you sure that they're talking about a full-NEM style arrangement like found in California, or is it something akin to Australia (or Wisconsin) where you're credited at avoided cost for exports to the grid? I strongly agree that subsidies distort markets (usually to the detriment of society). However, with energy, emerging technologies are competing with incumbent technologies with a host of direct and indirect subsidies. Regardless, for the parent -- solar isn't always a good investment. You need sunny areas with high electricity prices. While this is found frequently, it is not ubiquitous.
- aannnaa 14y agoClean energy is expensive, takes a long time to build, and introduces more problems, but we have no other choice! We can either suffer the consequences of global warming or try to avoid the worst of it. Sticking with fossil fuels is not a choice unless we can somehow make them out of C02 we remove from the atmosphere for that purpose. All the choices we could make to deal with the global energy crisis are terrible, we have to pick the one that hurts the least. We can hurt the economy and stop burning fossil fuels, or we can take almost certainly catastrophic risks with the only planet we have to live on. People love to blame China, but they are polluting to make goods we then import in many cases and are not responsible for squandering the giant fossil fuel inheritance of the modern age. Of course they may wish to get their share of what remains as long as everyone else is burning it anyway.
- lumberjack 14y ago> we have no other choice! There is another choice: geoengineering.[1] Instead of reducing emissions to slow down global warming we actively remove these pollutants from the enviroment around us. I'm not going to comment on it's efficacy though. As for reality, the problem is that nobody can be precipitous. Those who go with more expensive fuels will immediately put a burden on the local economy and throw themselves out of the competition. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoengineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoengineering
- aannnaa 14y agoThe only thing slightly more horrifying than geoengineering is letting global warming just happen, so I guess you are right. To make what I said more precise, I am looking for a choice that doesn't do dangerous experiments with the earth's climate. Geoengineering does such experiments, but it may be the default choice of inaction we are taking right now.
- brc 14y agoThe problem with your position is that, on current calculations, and assuming the IPCC calculations are correct, all of the current policies with building solar + wind + other alternatives will change the trajectory by a year or two. The big lie is that building endless solar panels and windmills is the solution to the problem, when it patently is not. A large game-changer would be needed, and niche technologies patently are not. Any solar panels or windmills must be backed up by another form of energy, or their intermittent power will be unpredictable and extremely bad for quality of life. So if you have to build a regular power plant to make up for the intermittent nature, then why not just have the one power plant? If you strongly believe that 'we are taking almost certain catastrophic risks' (paraphrasing) then trying to solve the problem with solar + windmills is like throwing buckets of water onto a housefire. It is simply ineffectual except for making people believe they are doing something.
- guscost 14y agoYep, this plainly correct argument has been persistently ignored by everyone on the bandwagon for an embarrassingly long time now, and that is leading, predictably, to some unfortunate situations. Nice to see that the IEEE has at least an ounce of integrity left.
- lancewiggs 14y ago3 immediate flaws: He ignores completely hydro and geothermal power. They help Iceland (100%) and New Zealand (77%) amongst others to near complete sustainability for electricity generation. While mentioned, the cost of co2e emissions from gas is glossed over. Charge the true economic value for emissions and hydrocarbon sources are going to be wildly more expensive. He criticizes China for unfairly subsidizing wind on the one hand (their solar story is amazing btw) then complains China is building too many coal plants shortly thereafter.
- mc32 14y agoHe doesn't ignore them, but the capacity for hydro and geothermal is finite and very geographically specific (there is only so many cubic km of riverflow and only so many geothermal sites). The TWatt output of NZ and IS is negligible, on a global scale, therefore they have little impact. It's great for those countries, but they're not a solution to CN's or IN's energy questions, for example.
- ars 14y agoIceland has so much extra hydro and geothermal power that they built an aluminium plant just to use the excess. But that's hardly something that applies to the rest of the world. On a global level hydro and geothermal energy is maxed out, every usage that practical is already being done.
- brc 14y agoNZ and Iceland are tiny. Iceland has a total population of 319,000. NZ has a total population of 4.4m. Both are situated on active volcanic areas. Iceland is a geologically new island formed by the spreading of the mid-atlantic ridge. NZ is basically a giant mountain range sticking out from the bottom of the ocean, in a climate where it rains and snows, a lot. They are interesting cases in using technology to generate power both at low cost and minimal environmental impact, but in no way at all are they models for the rest of the world. An externality can't be costed because there is no way to know the cost. You can only model it. As there is no way to validate the model, you end up with many competing models with no way of knowing which one is correct. As such, you can't give an accurate price.
- india 14y agoThe article notes that the total CO2 emission from India and China is rising and crossing the US. This is true but the per capita emission is still a fraction of that of US[1]. It will be impossible for China and India to compete if they aren't allowed the same per capita emission as the developed world. Per capita the US CO2 emission is huge. [1] http://data.un.org/Data.aspx?q=co2+emissions+per+capita&d=WDI&f=Indicator_Code%3aEN.ATM.CO2E.PC%3bCountry_Code%3aCHN%2cIND%2cUSA%3bTime_Code%3aYR2008&c=1,2&s=Country_Name:asc&p=Time_Code&v=1 http://data.un.org/Data.aspx?q=co2+emissions+per+capita&...
- twelvechairs 14y agoHN is not good with discussing these kind of articles. Far too many armchair experts. At least with the programming articles you get the occasional comment from someone who really knows something. Here its just a lot of noise.
- guscost 14y agoInstead of any sort of useful statement about the article, what's this? A thinly-veiled appeal to authority, simultaneously claiming that I am the weak link in this thread? Yes please...
- twelvechairs 14y agoI don't understand your point. Is there a rule against discussing the discussion? Its not appealing to any authority or claiming anything of the sort you describe - you are putting words in my mouth...
- rorrr 14y agoNo mention of liquid fluoride thorium reactors (LFTR) or algae-produced oil. Lame.
- anusinha 14y agoOr many of the other promising and fascinating technologies currently being developed. Not all of them will work, but a few innovations will go a long way to fixing the energy problem.
- pejoculant 14y agoThis article article is ridiculous. He acts as if alternative energy sources must be cheaper than our current energy sources to be worthwhile. Of course alternative energy sources cost less, if they didn't we wouldn't be having this discussion. There would not be much of a need to worry about co2 emissions. But in fact we do live in a world where co2 emissions are an issue. The author more or less acknowledges this and then simply ignores it. What exactly is he proposing as an alternative? Nothing. If we are to avoid the worst effects of global warming we're going to have to pay a price. Furthermore he then goes on to completely paper over the fact that costs have been dropping significantly. The numbers that he sites for solar prices come from here: http://www.solarbuzz.com/facts-and-figures/retail-price-environment/solar-electricity-prices http://www.solarbuzz.com/facts-and-figures/retail-price-envi... Solar module prices have dropped 50% over the last decade. Working backward from the numbers on solarbuzz that would mean that a residential scale system's price has dropped 25%. And by cherry picking the prices for a residential scale installation (28.9 / 63.1 cents per kwh) he ignores the fact that industrial scale systems are much closer to parity. The price for these systems is half of that 15.15 / 33.3. And these numbers have been declining. While the age of mass scale decentralized solar generation may not be here yet, the age of solar may be here much sooner than the author would like to admit.
- anovikov 14y agoThe article somehow implies that the feed-in tariff is Germany was 0.57 EUR until 2011 when it was cut 29%. In fact, there is a formula for automatic tariff cuts built into the law that introduced them: if i recall it correctly, tariff goes 8% down each year at least, but more if there is over 3.5 GW installed. That way, they descended to the levels that are currently much below retail electricity prices there, 0.17-0.24 EUR depending on the size of installation, with electricity being 0.24-0.29 depending on the region. And yet it is highly profitable to install solar systems there. Retail grid parity in Germany has been achieved.