3 ms·
I don't think Chesterton has much to say about DHS, which is relatively new.
by tptacek 2y ago
I don't think Chesterton has much to say about DHS, which is relatively new.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Lutger 2y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago…who are you quoting or paraphrasing? Parables aren’t an argument on their own.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoThis is the original text written by Chesterton that describes the concept people refer to as "Chesterton's Fence" but with the word fence replaced with "department of homeland security".
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThanks.
- Lutger 2y ago> I don't think Chesterton has much to say about DHS, which is relatively new. I'm responding to this statement. I thought it was pretty clear that the quote is still applicable, especially if you can read it applied to DHS. The comment I replied to was a response to a comment with the original quote. Its called Chesterton's Fence. Chestertons Fence is a device or principle. It is not actually about a fence. As such, it still applies to, or pretends to apply to cases in the future, of which Chesterton could not be aware. I assumed this demonstration was clear enough, but apparently I did something wrong here. Anybody care to explain why I have been flagged?
- sneak 2y ago…and entirely a kneejerk reaction to 9/11, enabling a massive public-private wealth transfer graft under the false pretense of national security.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> a massive public-private wealth transfer I’ll say this as someone who’s moderately wealthy: this administration is a massive wealth transfer to those with either capital or connections to it. Taking apart these committees means less-regulated telecoms, infrastructure and financial services. If you’re in those spaces, this is great for you. The size of each of those industries entirely dwarfs the military-industrial bogeyman, which is largely just being transferred from one set of owners (Boeing, Lockheed, et cetera) to another (Musk, Bezos, Lucky, et cetera)
- sneak 2y agoSure, but DHS long predates this admin. The list of giants suckling at the public teat is huge (Rapiscan, anyone?) and spans many different administrations. One possible upside of the current situation is that the very obvious corporate ownership of the federal government is dropping the “emperor has clothes” pretense. We are ever closer to simply paying taxes to Buy-N-Large. If people don’t like it, at least now they can have a practical conversation about it (Luigi notwithstanding). It’s sort of like when Snowden showed us how fucked we were/are.
- nradov 2y agoThe 9/11 terrorist attacks might have been the triggering event but bringing a bunch of related federal departments and agencies under a single umbrella in DHS was probably a net positive. The previous structure was tremendously inefficient with a lot of duplication of effort and time wasted on interdepartmental coordination. Obviously graft should be addressed but it's unlikely the total graft was any lower before 2002.
- _djo_ 2y agoHowever, DHS was almost entirely formed from existing departments and agencies that were merely rehoused under a new structure, so Chesterton's Fence definitely applies to all of those. Even CISA, which is one of the newest elements, is now almost a decade old with a lot of accumulated expertise and experience.
- sympil 2y agoThe newness of DHS has nothing to do with whether or not Chesterton’s Fence applies.
- sanderjd 2y agoDoes the metaphor actually include the age of the fence? I always thought the idea is just to understand why the fence is there before removing it, regardless of its age. In theory, it should be easier to understand the reasoning behind the existence of newer fences, but the idea is still to do that step first... I mean, clearly some people just reject this entire idea as creating too much friction, and I can often see their point!, but I think we can at least avoid saying "it's a good concept, but it just doesn't apply in this case", and be honest about just rejecting the concept.
- addicted 2y agoYou seem to have Chesterton’s fence completely backwards. Chesterton’s fence can never be an argument against creating something new. The whole point of it is that if you come across a fence then that was the result of a conscious human decision and subsequent effort, which strongly implies there was a reason it was created, and until you understand what that reason was, you’re taking a risk by destroying the fence. But if there is “nothing” and you’re creating something new, Chesterton’s fence doesn’t apply because the lack of existence of anything was not the result of intentional human design and effort, therefore there’s no evidence that the lack of existence of something “had a reason for it”.
- tptacek 2y agoRead The Drift From Domesticity, where this whole "fence" thing comes from. It's an appeal to (small-c) conservatism, to respect and understand traditions and norms. It is not a logical rule about it being improper to alter absolutely anything without a clear understanding of its origins. You can disagree with me about its applicability to the newest cabinet branch, but our disagreement isn't rooted in me not knowing the metaphor.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoThere is no creation without destruction, so yes Chesterton's fence almost certainly applies to an act of creation. In other words, there is no "nothing". We will always be playing in a sandbox someone else played in before us.