3 ms·
I was not informed of the exact analysis by which it was decided that they were infringing. I do know that the technique was sufficiently non-obvious that at t
by btilly 14y ago
I was not informed of the exact analysis by which it was decided that they were infringing.
I do know that the technique was sufficiently non-obvious that at the time the various single sign-on solutions that were being pushed (eg Microsoft's Hailstorm) relied on having a single central authentication mechanism rather than having a method for allowing for multiple authentication providers.
In short while I don't personally think that a patent should have been offered for that, I do think that it is a much stronger patent than many other software patents. If I had my life to do over, though, I'd have more strongly objected to that patent than I did at the time. (It came very, very close to being sucked up by some patent trolls and used to sue everyone. Luckily the left hand did not know what the right hand was doing, and while one person was getting it evaluated, another one sold it into a defensive patent pool. Whew.)
The patent was taken out because it was something that they thought was patentable, and they wanted to have patents to their name. It was used in a product that allowed us to deep link to a partner, and have people arrive already logged in from our link.
Unfortunately the time it takes to get patents is so long that long before the patent was awarded, that product was discontinued and both authors had moved on to other employers. Indeed this was true by the time that the patent office came back with its first review.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoThanks for your insight.