11 ms·
I'm not sure how well that's going to work when the boss of X is doing gestures that are illegal in Germany.
by pjc50 2y ago
I'm not sure how well that's going to work when the boss of X is doing gestures that are illegal in Germany.
- vanderZwan 2y ago> These EU Codes of Conduct are voluntary commitments and companies face no penalties if they decide to back out of the agreement, as Elon Musk did with X (then known as Twitter) in 2022 when he withdrew the company from the Code of Practice on Disinformation. It's pretty obviously a PR stunt done in bad faith to delay actual legal consequences. I don't understand why this kind of "legal" construct even exists tbh.
- nolok 2y agoContrary to what seems to often be believed, the EU way of doing things is to try to make companies do their own agreement and policing, as to avoid the rigidity of regulation unless we absolutely have to. Another example is how the EU asked the phone manufacturers to agree on a common charger for years on a good will basis, and only had to regulate when samsung said they were going to back out if no regulation was made because apple was not playing ball. So the idea here is "guys, we really don't want to come here and make a law about what is or isn't allowed to be said or what has to be fact checked and everything, we want you to behave like adults and agree together about said rules". I believe in this case, the fact that every company is part of the same country and same bunch of absurdly rich tech companies means it's never going to work at all.
- kragen 2y ago> to try to make companies do their own agreement and policing, as to avoid the rigidity of regulation unless we absolutely have to. This is precisely the censorship policy of the PRC. It ensures that nobody ever knows for sure what speech is permitted, so no speech is completely safe. Platforms compete for users by permitting marginally legal speech and compete for the favor of regulators by censoring it. This system is much more effective at suppressing political dissent than the US system, in which censorship decisions can be challenged in open court.
- dathinab 2y agobut in case of hate speech it is relatively clear in most cases what is and isn't hate speech even through people on both sides love to pretend it isn't
- kragen 2y agoIf people on different sides of political divides are investing a lot of effort in labeling one another's arguments as “hate speech”, which seems to be what you're saying, that sounds like pretty strong evidence that it is not in fact relatively clear what is and isn't hate speech. And, once a book, news article, or political platform has been successfully suppressed, it is of course no longer clear whether or not it was hate speech, because you can't tell what it said; you only know what its political opponents say about it. In particular, right now, there are numerous credible claims of human rights violations by Israeli troops in Gaza, and widespread criticism of those violations is being labeled as anti-Semitic hate speech, correctly in some cases, while defenses of the same violations are being labeled as Islamophobic hate speech, also correctly in some cases. These are among the reasons that hate speech is uncontroversially legal in the US.
- dathinab 2y agoNo that is not at all what I am saying. What I am saying is that it doesn't matter weather people label others as hat speech or not because EU countries don't work by a curt of public opinion and convictions aren't based on this. The regulations are about removing clear cases of hate speech, not about policing gray areas. Like there is absolutely no reason to give someone who says all Jews of Muslims should be killed a platform. Or someone who main talking point is that Hitler didn't succeed in killing all, or people which systematically harass other people. And more or less all of the things social platforms have to police are things _which anyway are already illegal_. It's just that due to the pseudo anonymity of the internet, internationalization, bots, sock puppet accounts and social platform having little reason to cooperate with the police persecuting such things in the traditional way isn't viable. Sure making it viable would be nice, but I have to yet find a practical way which wouldn't be a form of mass surveillance much worse then such regulations. Also both in past and presence there have been more then just a few examples about how not hindering hat speech will reliable kill innocents. There are larger examples like the genocide in Myanmar Facebook contributed to. Or smaller examples like recently a innocent teen being murdered by a mob because of people having been radicalized/riled up by hate speech on social media. Or if you want to go back to the 30th a huge part of why the Nazis gained power was that they could effectively spread hat speech and misinformation about how the Jews where at fault for everything bad (WW1, the depression in the 20th, the terms Germany had to accept at the end of WW1 etc.), or about the so called Stab-in-the-back myth, or about pseud science about how the "grate arian race" gets replaced and all mixed up etc.. The relevant part here is how effective they where able to spread this and make part of the population accept it, not whether they came up with it. (Other huge parts where that politics was too polarized to continue working and the previous conservatives helped him as an external person into power as they hoped to fix their issue of losing ground and unify Germany, in a very twisted way they did succeed, at cost of their own existence).
- michaelt 2y agoOften here in the UK if there's a problem with a particular, the first step in regulation is for the government to talk to the trade body representing the industry and basically say "Regulate yourselves, or be regulated" Then, if they're sensible, the industry creates a code of conduct that addresses the problems that drew the attention of legislators, without being too onerous; all the main players in the industry sign up and follow it; and the government doesn't have to pass legislation. Politicians are happy because the problem goes away, and regulatory burdens on industry don't increase. Industry is happy because they get soft-touch regulation that's under their control. It doesn't always work, of course.
- gadders 2y agoLOL NO: https://nypost.com/2025/01/20/us-news/adl-says-elon-musks-awkward-gesture-at-trump-inauguration-was-not-a-nazi-salute/ https://nypost.com/2025/01/20/us-news/adl-says-elon-musks-aw...
- arcticbull 2y agoIt's going to be really interesting to see how organizations, relying on funding and/or support from the government, will twist themselves to deny what is fairly evident in plain sight hoping to avoid retaliation in general. I'm not sure what Elon was doing/intending to do but the resemblance is uncanny. And he did it twice, just to make sure. The first time, I was like eh, could go either way, he's made unique and enthusiastic gestures in public before before. The second one was more troubling. Certainly the kind of thing that would get you tackled to the floor by German police officers. Even if unintentional, you'd have some time to think about it and some 'splaining to do.
- kzrdude 2y agoElon musk did a sign that shows that he's a Nazi. There's no ambiguity, he did the sign the neo-nazis do and it's instantly recognizable. That's my reading of the situation, with my education and background (I grew up & went to school in Sweden) - I mention the background to say that this is how the sign is interpreted where I come from.
- dathinab 2y agoit's interpreted everywhere that way(1) except if fascists are asked to take responsibility for their action which is when it was somehow just a strange accident (1) through I would say it's interpreted as Nazi idolizing fascists in many situations which isn't quite exactly the same as Nazi but not necessary any better either
- racktash 2y agoEven more revealing are the people offering excuses / brushing this and other things off – they are either naive (or have not been following Musk's comments about the AfD etc.) or knowingly acting in bad-faith. If there is one small positive about these political times, it's that we're finding out who the authoritarian / far-right sympathisers are.
- staticelf 2y ago[flagged]
- exe34 2y agocould you explain what you mean - are you saying that the sign that Elon made, twice, was not a Nazi salute?
- staticelf 2y agoYes, that is what I am saying.
- exe34 2y agoWhy do you think everybody else seems to be confusing it for that then?
- staticelf 2y agoBecause they are not confusing it. They believe in the opposite political opinion and want to smear their believed opponents whenever possible.
- zfg 2y agoNeo-nazis say otherwise: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/elon-musk-salute-reaction-right-wing-extremists-1235241866/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/elon-mus... Hitler says otherwise: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tlenyBWs4w&t=88s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tlenyBWs4w&t=88s Says it twice: https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1i68puj/have_we_learned_nothing/ https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1i68puj/have_we_l... In what way was Musk not doing a fascist salute?
- staticelf 2y agoIn what way was Musk not doing a roman salute or just throwing his heart out to the masses?
- anonymous344 2y ago[flagged]
- zwnow 2y agoIt was a naz! salut. Dont belittle his actions, he is a grown man and should be held accountable for the way he presents himself.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoHow do you accurately determine when raising your arm is a Nazi salute and when not? If I raise my arm to hail a cab, what's stopping someone form accusing me of trying to hail Hitler? To me, it's the context that determines that. From my PoV it looked like he was greeting/thanking the crowd. Plenty of other celebrities and athletes do the exact same gesture towards crowds all the time. People are too quick to see nazism everywhere when they condition themselves for that. However, I also do see how it can be interpreted as a Nazi salute in this case.
- thrance 2y agoMusk has a long history of anti-semitism [1], and has showed support to the AFD in Germany, a political party directly linked to neonazis. He knows some neonazi-adjacent guys usually attend Trump rallies, and this "nazi-ish salute" might be a dog whistle to catter to them. Or it could not be, and he'll certainly deny it was. We'll never know for sure, that's how a dog whistle works. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Views_of_Elon_Musk#Race_and_white_nationalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Views_of_Elon_Musk#Race_and_...
- sincerecook 2y agoPutting aside the histrionics that Nazis are everywhere and about to kill everyone, does anyone have a good theory on why Elon would do this? Like is he just regressing to a 13 year old troll now? From the last few weeks you'd think he just went full clown. He's a 50 something year old man with 10 or 12 kids who apparently doesn't do much of anything besides troll people on Twitter, what's going on with this man?
- scoofy 2y agoI noted in a comment above that this type of behavior, "Lol, nothing matters" is exactly the kind of behavior described by Sartre in Anti-Semite and Jew about the behavior of actual brownshirts and blackshirts that this salute is meant to directly reference: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Semite_and_Jew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Semite_and_Jew It isn't that this type of behavior is designed to get something, it's that the type of mindset, one that has decided not to care anymore, to reject nuance and embrace a kind of good-guy/bad-guy explanation of complex problem in the world, ultimately leading to bad faith engagement... well all that leads to this type of behavior. The idea is that this type of action isn't trying to achieve anything, it's the result of a worldview.
- swat535 2y agoI'm surprised to see these types of reactionary / rage-bait comments bubble up in HN threads recently. I personally find that they don't add much value to discussion. Perhaps it's a sign of the community growing with outsiders not being familiar with HN guidelines [0], or that Dang is stretched too thin to constantly moderate everything. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- scoofy 2y agoI mean, I really don't know how to react to this type of situation, personally. I do think that the CEO of a firm doing a fascist salute, multiple times, on live television is actually relevant to the business interests of the company, and the political interest of the nations in which it operates. Do I think it's worth talking about in this context? I honestly don't know. I get your point. I also understand that it was the type of "Lol, nothing matters" flamebait, meant to ruffle feathers intentionally, but it's relevant that this is exactly that ethos pointed to in Sartre's Anti-Semite and Jew about the actual brownshirts and blackshirts this salute is meant to directly reference: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Semite_and_Jew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Semite_and_Jew No, I would agree with you that the salute isn't directly relevant to the pledge in the article, but it's certainly directly relevant to whether or not the pledge is being made in good-faith. This is why I think it's relevant, even if it's exhausting. We just live in exhausting times.