3 ms·
It is about the laws. Fair use is a very restrictive use for copyrighted images - you can only use the if you transform them significantly in some way, reduce t
by chris_wot 14y ago
It is about the laws. Fair use is a very restrictive use for copyrighted images - you can only use the if you transform them significantly in some way, reduce the image quality so that you don't reduce the value for the original owner, or use the in a not for profit medium as fair use tends to be more friendly to this sort of thing.
None of these things are really viable for Wikipedia. Fair use is a necessary evil, but when they can replaced with a free image then that is what is done!
- Dylan16807 14y agoThe problem is when images are replaced with nothing or with far inferior images. I agree that free should be prioritized when the two images are in the same ballpark of quality.
- chris_wot 14y agoIt is indeed a problem, however the project has as one of it's five pillars that it is free content that anyone can access, use, modify or distribute. This means that if the image is restricted in such a way that others can't modify or distribute it, then it can't be used. Fair use is a legal doctrine that limits the rights of copyright holders, but it is very narrow. Essentially, to be "fair use", the usage must consider the purpose of the work, the nature of the work, the amount used and the effect using the work has on the market for the work. In essence, while fair use allows for free distribution, it also severely limits it. Fair use is thus controversial on Wikipedia, and while allowed is severely frowned upon.
- Dylan16807 14y agoMost images in an encyclopedia don't need modification. Fair use takes care of access and distribution pretty well.
- chris_wot 14y agoAs I stated before, one of the primary tenets of Wikipedia is that it is "free content that anyone can access, use, modify or distribute." If you can't modify something that is part of the project, then this is defying the essential raison de être of the project. Fair use allows it, but it's so problematic that many would just like to get rid of it. I'm not one of those people, but it should only be used judiciously.
- majormajor 14y agoAnd in the US, fair use is an affirmative defense, with the burden of proof on the defendent. It can't keep you from getting sued in the same way a completely free image would.