6 ms·
IAmA Patent Examiner on reddit
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bitdiffusion 14y agoJust had a browse through and although these particular patent examiners are obviously smart, software is not their area. If you are looking for answers as to how some of the ridiculous patents manage to get through the patent office (including patents for software concepts that engineers are likely to consider "obvious" or for which there is likely "prior art"), you are unlikely to find the answers here.
- chime 14y agoI agree. While he is doing his best to answer the hard questions (instead of avoiding them outright), his answers are not very satisfactory. See this thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/ww982/iama_patent_examiner_i_want_to_answer_questions/c5h0r4x http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/ww982/iama_patent_e... Whenever someone defends software patents, I bring up Amazon's one-click patent. It's so obvious! I use the one-click-checkout feature on Amazon all the time and dearly miss it on every other website out there. Imagine if Pizza Delivery sites or Flower Delivery sites had that feature. People would order things a lot more if they didn't have to go through extra screens to confirm things every single time. The funnel gets smaller as the number of steps rise. And now one company has a patent on short funnels.
- ceol 14y agoI think he did a decent job answering. However, /r/Android is being needlessly confrontational and cynical. For instance, this question from your linked thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/ww982/iama_patent_examiner_i_want_to_answer_questions/c5h21br?context=3 http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/ww982/iama_patent_e... was answered satisfactory. There is a difference between "a plurality of heuristic modules, wherein: each heuristic module corresponds to a respective area of search and employs a different, predetermined heuristic algorithm" and "searching different sources of data wherein you search each with a method that makes sense for its contents" But the replies from random commenters and vote totals would have you believe the opposite.
- doomslice 14y agoI wonder how important the actual wording is vs what appears to be the intent on what the patent covers. To me (and I know I'm simplifying just like the random commenters you speak of), the patent is _intended_ to cover 1. performing heuristic searches on multiple areas (modules) 2. using a different search on each area However, it uses the word "predetermined" when defining the heuristic algorithm to use for each area. If my code randomly picks between two slightly different heuristics (even with a very low probability), would it still be covered under the patent? Also it says "heuristic algorithm" meaning singular algorithm. If I ran 2 algorithms in parallel (even one that always returns no results) and then chose the "better" of the two, would that get around the patent too? Are patents vulnerable to this sort of work-around due to subtle interpretations of wording, or is it really the intent of the patent that matters?
- ceol 14y agoI'm not sure if you remember the whole thing where John Carmack had to change some 3D shader code in Doom 3 because of a patent dispute. The change was adding four lines of code and changing two.[0] So I would say choosing between two similar algorithms, running two algorithms in parallel, or running an additional algorithm that always returned empty would be a valid workaround. [0]: https://twitter.com/id_aa_carmack/status/137189212519792640 https://twitter.com/id_aa_carmack/status/137189212519792640
- jedbrown 14y agoI can think of very few algorithms that don't have sub-algorithms. Isn't any composition of existing algorithms also an algorithm? I can't think of any restriction that algorithm (singular) makes relative to the plural.
- sparkie 14y agoThe method of choosing the best of two algorithms is itself, a heuristic, so I can't see how that would get around it.
- joe_the_user 14y agoHow important is the wording: You can't normally just claim an obvious extension without evidence. We have to provide prior art for every limitation in a claim, and every word must be considered within a claim. It seem every last adjective counts. "In order to jump to an obvious argument, you'd have to prove this device reads on all the limitations minus the unlock image that is slid. Then you'd have to show something else that uses an image to unlock something. Then you'd have to provide rationale why the combination between the two things would have been obvious at the time of the invention, in this case 2005." In other words, obviousness might seem, uh obvious as a defense for most this stuff. But actuality it's categorically dismissed with the "you can't prove it" argument. Plus the "but was it obvious in 2005, with phone!" (lovely to see those so-and-so's trying to wiggle out of that one but essentially coming back to it).
- ry0ohki 14y agoAre you saying Amazon actually enforces that patent? I doubt the Flower Delivery sites are purposely adding clicks to the process because of the Amazon patent.
- chime 14y agoDo you know of even one US-based site with one-click ordering?
- Pent 14y agoValve's Steam games checkout. Does iTunes qualify as well?
- jonknee 14y agoApple pays Amazon for a One-Click license. I imagine Jobs was really in love with the simplicity and just had to have it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click#Apple_Inc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click#Apple_Inc.
- AntiRush 14y agoOn Steam, you click add to cart (which takes you to a checkout page), and then you have to check an "I agree..." box before hitting the actual purchase button. I don't think this qualifies as one-click.
- danmaz74 14y agoThe problems, according to them (and I have no reason not to believe them), is that right now the burden of proof of the obviousness of a patent application is on the patent office, not the other way around. And that this obviousness can only be proved by either citing an older patent or a certain type of publication, or a combination of those, not what the examiner "just knows" - or what it looks obvious to him/her or any other technically skilled practitioner, as the basic law says. According to them this "presumption of patentability" (as I would call it) was a policy change that happened not very long ago, as before the policy was to reject as many patents as possible. I would also make a wild guess: That this change was lobbied for by the IP law firms, because they are the only ones which really benefit from it.
- robomartin 14y agoIf I read them correctly the whole business of deciding if something is obvious is seriously broken in that it seems to be limited to combining claims from existing patents. This, of course, isn't even close to what "obvious" means to those "skilled in the art". I, like many others, have run across so many patents that should not have been issued at all. This isn't limited to software. There are examples across disciplines, like the guy who got a patent for running wires inside clothing to connect devices or the company that got several patents on using pulse-width-modulation to control the intensity of LEDs to mix colors or most software patents. In hardware I have seen lots of patents that cover the exact same thing. I have seen patents for things that don't work. And, patents for things that I knew had been available or done prior to the filing date. I call these "implementation" patents rather than true inventions. The term refers to the fact that a modern skilled engineer or team of engineers would be more than capable of coming up with that or a myriad of other implementations when given a problem to be solved. That's what engineering is all about. Many engineers across time and distance are able to solve similar problems and end-up with similar solutions. This is what we are trained to do. This is also the part of the human and other animals: the use of our brains to solve problems. It seems that the patent system ought to be reformed in such a way that the rules recognize who we are, what we are taught, what we do, what we are capable of and, in general, the fact of knowledge acceleration. Today it should be exceedingly hard to receive a patent on just about anything. Patents should be reserved for true invention and not implementation. Today's environment is such that there's so much distributed knowledge across so many disciplines that most "inventions" that are patented are really cases of someone choosing a solution to a problem (not inventing one) and then hiring an attorney to try and monopolize it. Case in point: The Apple "slide to unlock" patent. Someone chose that solution from available knowledge. No sane person would suggest that this qualifies as an invention by any possible imaginative stretch. This was a UI decision that the lawyers at Apple got a patent for. They got a patent for, effectively, the analog of a mechanical slide switch made to look nice, nothing less. Not an invention, but they have a patent to say otherwise. I am not against patents. I am against the granting of patents for non-inventions. Today the granting of a patent should almost be so rare as to make national news. Just a few per year. In fact, they should be rarer and rarer with time, to the point that those granted the few patents that should make it through the system per year would be invited to the White House to receive a Presidential Innovation award or some such thing. It only stands to reason that, as technology advances, there will be less and less true inventions per year. Part of the problem was alluded to on the reddit thread: the USPTO makes money and Washington takes it away. Fix that and you might just fix the system. Maybe the patent review process should be open to anyone. Yes, your competitors, anywhere in the world, get to examine and weigh-in. If an invention passes such a test it is probably deserving of a monopoly for twenty years. This also means that someone will really think hard before spilling all the beans in front of the entire world. Only a true invention, where other engineers go "This guy deserves a patent for this!" should be granted patents. And rightly so.
- gcb 14y ago"the uspo accepts everything. False" "examiners get paid by parents" am i the only one that find those 2 points right on his summary counter intuitive?
- jedbrown 14y agoOne of my biggest complaints about the current state of patents is that it reverses the process of innovation. I have not heard of anyone reading existing patents to get new ideas for software. Instead, we invariably invent first, usually oblivious to the existence, or not, of relevant patents. Then we search (or are informed) that our new product falls within the scope of an existing patent and decide whether to license it or iteratively re-invent to find a solution that does not infringe. Consider the various compositions of linked lists that are patented (http://www.google.com/patents/US7028023 http://www.google.com/patents/US7028023), any of which would be casually "re-invented" by any competent developer. The USPTO should give the world more credit for "obviousness". I propose that the closure of established concepts under the algebra of established compositional operations shall be considered "obvious", in which case we can all go about applying those compositional operations without worrying about stumbling over patented combinations.