3 ms·
> They say they cannot afford to have children in Italy It’s not a birth rate crisis, it’s a suboptimal economic system crisis, where people of reproductive ag
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
> They say they cannot afford to have children in Italy
It’s not a birth rate crisis, it’s a suboptimal economic system crisis, where people of reproductive age do not have the economic opportunity and means to have and support children. The fertility rate is simply a trailing economic sentiment indicator.
We could start slicing off more GDP for human care (healthcare, childcare, elder care, social care, taking care of people broadly speaking), paying people more, enforcing work conditions that are more favorable to fertility and parents, but the folks at the wheel are like “nah” while whining the whole way to the crash site. They don’t want to fix the problem; they want to squeeze to get all the juice without any of the cost.
https://www.aei.org/research-products/working-paper/world-depopulation-prospects-and-implications/ https://www.aei.org/research-products/working-paper/world-de...
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=fertility%20rate&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
(to note, some of the fertility rate decline is because of educated, empowered women having access to contraceptives and thereby reducing desired fertility in the aggregate; this component in total fertility rate decline is unavoidable versus the elastic economic component)
- lotsofpulp 2y agoI don’t think any economic/parental leave/policy changes can bring a nation’s TFR to replacement rate if women are able to stay single and/or cannot be coerced into having more kids than they want (i.e. have physical security and ability to earn income). The simplest way to explain is that too few women will have 3 or more kids to offset the number of women that have 0 or 1 child. Part of it is like that Seinfeld bit about 95% of the population being undate-able. If you have say, 20% of women who don’t pair up because the there is no match available better than them staying single, and another 20% of women who have at most 1 kid, that requires a lot of the remaining women to have 3 or more kids to balance out to 2.1. And I rarely see someone with 3 or more kids, I didn’t even see it much when I was a kid 30 years ago.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCertainly, we could argue that this is solely a result of women empowerment and choice and ignore the folks who say “it’s the economy.” At that point, switch to planned decline if no effort will be made to help those actually interested in reproducing socially and economically. I take issue with the disingenuous and performance art of the messaging, “the purpose of the system is what it does.” Admit defeat and plan for it, it’s not a matter of “if” but simply steepness of downward trajectory.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoThere very well could be an economic component, but the important part is can TFR be raised to above replacement rate, which is what I am seeing zero evidence of based on global data from all different countries with different policies.
- datavirtue 2y agoI'm interested in it. This contrivance of consent (society protecting and empowering women is pure contrived luxury) is a evolutionary dead end. That's why nature never saw fit to program it in. Women need to be desperate for security (financial and physical) or they simply will not have enough children. Anyway. Build the replicators before it all stops. We are a stepping stone to whatever is next. The only answer is to brainwash the hell out of women to focus on child rearing as the top priority. Patriarchal religion springs to mind.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoAren’t the two - empowerment and economy - related? We went from having someone at home to take care of kids, which makes it easier to have them, to having no one at home and double the supply of workers, which of course reduces wages compared to the alternative world.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYes, the two income trap is likely a factor. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Two-Income_Trap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Two-Income_Trap https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-data https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-... > An increasing share of adults under 50 say they're unlikely to have kids — and the major reason is, well, they just don't want them, according to a report from Pew Research Center out Thursday morning. > 64% of young women say they just don't want children, compared to 50% of men. https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-experiences-of-u-s-adults-who-dont-have-children/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-exp... > Majorities in both groups say not having kids has made it easier for them to afford the things they want, have time for hobbies and interests, and save for the future. In the younger group, about six-in-ten also say not having kids has made it easier for them to be successful in their job or career and to have an active social life. (US specific context)
- bamboozled 2y agoIt's also funny to me that the billionaires and soon to be trillionaires are also the most concerned about it :) The pyramid might collapse!
- smcin 2y agoRight. But the graph of 2023(?) data [0] varies hugely by region, from a TFR of 1.65 in Bolzano in the far north, to <= 1.0 in Sardinia and the central regions. That correlates somewhat with GDP but there are clearly other factors. Also this doesn't show internal migration or external immigration (of adults + children) or the effect of cost of housing - is there any compound graph showing all of that? IIRC, the age of mother at (first) childbirth [1] is a useful statistic for understanding causes: in 2023, ranged from 31.9 yrs in the Islands (Sicily + Sardinia) to average 32.5 to 32.9 years in central Italy. [2] "The province defying Italy’s birth dearth: Thirty years of child-friendly policies" describes how Bolzano - South Tyrol's child-friendly policies and $ incentives have given it the highest birthrate of all of Italy since the 1990s. Also, The Lancet [3] last week wrote "The Italian health data system is broken" "A major weakness of the health-care system in Italy is the fragmented health data infrastructure: there is no unified, centralised system for documenting and sharing electronic health records (EHRs), hospital data, and general practitioner records... The root cause is extensive regional autonomy, with 20 regions operating independently and implementing differing policies and technologies, creating regulatory fragmentation and inefficiencies... Such a fragmented system not only fails the Italian population but also imposes a considerable economic burden on the country." Is Meloni's govt changing any of that? [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/18p6ivs/fertility_rate_in_italy_live_births_per_woman/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/18p6ivs/fertility_... [1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/567957/mother-average-age-at-childbirth-in-italy-by-macro-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/567957/mother-average-ag... [2]: https://www.boomcampaign.org/p/the-province-defying-italys-birth https://www.boomcampaign.org/p/the-province-defying-italys-b... [3]: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(24)00375-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7...
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe policies needed are the policies you refer to in the region showing the outlier.
- smcin 2y agoa) Not necessarily: b) Those are provincial policies of South Tyrol, not the Italian government c) South Tyrols started its policies 40 years ago. They also included creating a govt-supported childminder day-care system ('Casa Bimbo'). d) Each province would have to first get political and economic consensus on what is a desirable birthrate for a particular province, or at least agree that pro-child policies should be implemented with taxpayer money (which in general in European politics is taboo for even discussing). e) The policies that would be needed in other provinces/regions would presumably be different and more expensive to Bolzano which has very a low cost of living. e) South Tyrol's provincial govt is led by the South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP), a Christian-democratic political party for the German-speaking minority. Presumably this is considered allowable identitarianism by Italians (or at least South Tyroleans), unlike elsewhere in Italy, or Europe (compare to Hungary or Poland).
- nradov 2y agoSome of those changes sound like good ideas but how do "we" pay people more? Relative to peer countries, Italian workers on average are already over paid and not very productive. Also note that due to recent Russian aggression, the "peace dividend" has been cancelled so Italy and other NATO members are going to have to start spending something like 3% of GDP on defense instead of depending on the USA to protect them.