6 ms·
Trapped in the dark for 35 hours – Red Sea dive-boat survivors tell of escapes
- interroboink 2y agoReminds me of this older story, of Harrison Okene, who was trapped in a capsized boat at the bottom of the ocean for 3 days: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/26/i-survived-three-days-in-a-capsized-boat-on-the-ocean-floor-praying-in-my-air-bubble https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/26/i-survi... video of his rescue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=um1ym9u8XaA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=um1ym9u8XaA Randomly, the next year, he rescued his friend when their car goes off a bridge into water. He later became a diver!
- WillPostForFood 2y agoOr a mini Poseidon Adventure
- triyambakam 2y agoThank you for sharing about Okene, what a great story.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoHow could 3 adults, even lying perfectly still, not use up all the oxygen in that air pocket within 35 hours? I thought human beings needed several cubic meters of fresh oxygen (at 1 atm) per hour…
- _hyn3 2y agoNot at 1atm. The air was pressurized.
- nwellinghoff 2y agoHow is that? It was at surface pressure and then rolled over.
- K0balt 2y agoIf the booyancy of the trapped air was a significant factor in the boat not sinking, then the air would have been at pressures over 1atm. Put a barometer in an empty, upside-down cup. Force the upside down cup 1/2 way down into the water, trapping the air inside. The barometer will be at the sea pressure of the bottom of the cup.
- nwellinghoff 2y agoMakes sense if the glass is perfectly vertical, air can’t escape and force is applied from the top. But if you capsize a glass by slightly turning it on its side such that most of it sinks and the air escapes by water displacement you would get some compression on the remaining air but its unclear how much.
- russell_h 2y agoIt doesn’t sound to me like the boat actually sank. In the article it mentioned that they heard the rescue helicopter from within. Wouldn’t that imply that the pressure inside would be one atmosphere? Am I thinking about the physics of this wrong?
- duskwuff 2y agoSound does carry remarkably well through water - but you're right. The ship capsized, but the hull held enough air that it stayed afloat.
- BurningFrog 2y agoIt was floating upside down. There is a picture towards the end of the story.
- shellfishgene 2y agoMostly, the weight of the boat pulling down would compress the air bubble a bit, probably not very much though.
- madaxe_again 2y agoThe pressure of any trapped gas will be equivalent to the depth of the lowest level containing air - so if the bottom of your air bubble is a meter below sea level, your pressure will be 1.1 atm.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoYou got me wondering and I thought maybe there was some kind of gas diffusion where carbon dioxide is absorbed by the ocean water instead of building up in the enclosed space, and finding the most closely related stack exchange question I think I’m satisfied with this answer: probably that four-foot bubble communicated with a larger volume or air under the hull of the boat - and that's the most reasonable explanation of this miraculous survival. When picturing it we might assume the rest of the boat is flooded and this pocket of air is all that remained but that may not be the case. https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/67970/surviving-under-water-in-air-bubble https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/67970/surviving-...
- gunian 2y agoMr Nimbus gave them gills to save them and wiped their memory :)
- sellmesoap 2y agoMr nimbus also controls the police!
- relistan 2y agoThey were in the engine room. The engine would have both air intake and exhaust systems. There was potentially some portion of one or both systems interacting with other air pockets.
- neurostimulant 2y agoYeah, I think the co2 and o2 would diffuse in and out of the water below and eventually equalize, similar with how aquarium co2 indicator works.
- Aerroon 2y agoIt might be enough. Google says a human needs 300-550 liters of oxygen a day. That equals to about 6.8-12.4 cubic meters of air for the 3 of them for 36 hours. The space does seem like it could be large enough to hold that much air, especially if it's compressed a little.
- pcrh 2y agoIn this case, the boat was floating, albeit upside down. So the volume of air trapped must have been sufficient to keep a 44 metre boat afloat; i.e. not a trivial amount.
- rwmj 2y agoIf I remember it right, Mythbusters did the "sinking boat will pull you under" and found it was a myth?
- p_j_w 2y agoMythbusters is not rigorous. You'd be foolish to bet your life on the outcomes of any of their experiments.
- jazzyjackson 2y agothey busted it with a 9 ton boat but now I’m unconvinced because they did demonstrate the effect with a large weight dropping straight down in a pool, so what effect was that?! They were testing Titanic myths and didn’t touch on the fact that Titanic famously dropped like a stone! https://youtu.be/rvU_dkKdZ0U https://youtu.be/rvU_dkKdZ0U
- rurban 2y agoFurniture moving to one side on the top deck sounds most plausible to me.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoWhat kind of furniture is heavy enough to cause that? It'd have to be tons of weight, and anything that isn't chairs and tables would be bolted down.
- rurban 2y agoYou see that the ship was already very top-heavy and unstable. 200-400kg would have been enough, with 1.5m waves and a stupid captain.
- throeurir 2y ago> But Lucianna is critical of the fact the Egyptian navy had to rely on volunteers. "We waited 35 hours. I don't understand how there are no divers on the Egyptian military boats." Why should divers risk their life to save anyone?! The boat was unstable, going inside would be dangerous! Some people are adrenaline junkies, and will volunteer for such thing, but you can not expect professionals to do that!
- pavlov 2y agoIs that how it works when military personnel is called to assist in disaster rescue? “Seems kind of dangerous. I’m a professional, I won’t go there, let’s wait for amateur volunteers to show up.”
- throeurir 2y agoThey did assist. They saved many lives, but waited until it was safe for them! It is not their job to increase number of victims!
- petre 2y agoWhy would the military navy or coast guard risk their lives to save some tourists from a sinking boat, when they could professionally watch from a distance through binoculars? /s Maybe because it's part of their job drscription?
- throeurir 2y agoNo, their primary job is to protect borders!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoIs this sarcasm? I hope it's sarcasm.
- albumen 2y ago
- brian-armstrong 2y ago> Outside the boat, Sarah, Hissora and the others who had jumped off eventually found the two life rafts, which had deployed after the sinking. As they clambered on board, they saw the boat's captain and a number of other crew members were already there. > "There should be some supplies in here," Sarah remembers one of the other guests saying. All the people we spoke to recall a safety briefing mentioning that the life rafts had food and water in them - but they did not, the BBC were told. > "We found a torch, but again it didn't have any batteries. We didn't have any water or any food," Sarah says. "There were flares, but they had already been used." > Sarah also says of the three blankets on board the raft, one had been taken by the captain for himself, leaving one for the rest of the crew and another for the guests. "We ripped it up and huddled together," says Sarah. Absolutely disgraceful behavior from the captain here. This is not a person who should be entrusted with a houseplant, let alone the wellbeing of any number of people on board that vessel.
- jajko 2y agoIf you've ever been to that country, or any similar country, you would notice that real professional competence across whole society is scarce, and most tourism industry is just barely faking it in terms of security and professionalism. Or to put it in different words - don't do extreme sports there, safety net is very thin. Deadly diving accidents are common there too, mostly due to lack of professionalism of instructors, either locals or for some reason russians.
- curiousgal 2y agoGeneralize much? How many duck boat sinkings took the lives of tourists in the US? Were you also so keen to criticise American society as a whole and "similar countries"?
- inglor_cz 2y agoNot the OP, but his generalization about North Africa is spot on. It is one of the few regions that regressed civilizationally since Antiquity. Zero advanced exports, lots of tyranny and dysfunction, natives vote with their feet by the millions, and no one in their sane mind moves there. I don't particularly care about praising the US, a country I have never been to, but if you are trying to put some sort equivalence between Egypt and the US, you are deluding yourself. Quality of institutions in those two places ise mostly incomparable. (The SF homeless situation may be an exception. Yeah, that could be North Africa, only with much more money burned on futile schemes to alleviate the problem.)
- shellfishgene 2y agoAfter several hours trapped in the air pocket, the dive guide, Youssef, wanted to try to swim through the boat, but Lucianna and Christophe persuaded him not to. "Stay with us because they are going to come to get our bodies, so they will find us," Lucianna recalls telling him. An odd decision, I would have thought he was a good diver, so presumeably also a decent free diver, knew the boat well, could alert rescuers to the trapped people, and would not use up oxygen when gone from the bubble.
- relistan 2y agoPresumably they had no idea if the boat was on the bottom of the sea or not, and at what depth.
- shellfishgene 2y agoStill, rationally thinking, which is presuming a lot in the situation, I can't find any real advantage to the two tourists of having the dive guide not try.
- MaKey 2y agoMaybe they were just worried about his wellbeing.
- shellfishgene 2y agoThere reason she gave was "Stay with us because they are going to come to get our bodies" so I think they were beyond worrying about anyone's wellbeing :( What a nightmare.
- MaKey 2y agoI read it as "They are going to come to get our bodies so there is a chance we'll make it out of here alive if we just wait".
- Ekaros 2y agoWhy didn't these divers free dive out? Should have been pretty easy?
- jajko 2y agoClearly it wasn't, having diving certificate doesn't make you magically an Aquaman.
- relistan 2y agoAlso, presumably they did not know if the boat was on the bottom of the sea or not, and at what depth.
- Filligree 2y agoFreediving inside an enclosed space is known as “angling for a Darwin Award”. Doing it in a shipwreck is one of the most dangerous things you can possibly do. You won’t have the normal cues of up and down, won’t have any sort of decent lighting, and all the while your body wants to panic due to CO2. Then, they’d been breathing compressed air. If they reached the surface they’d get the bends, and depending on depth that could kill them or cause serious damage.
- shellfishgene 2y agoMost SCUBA divers don't train freediving, next time at the pool see how far you can dive on one breath. Then imagine being panicked, in the dark, in a ship you don't know that well, in the machine room you've never been in before, where now everything is upside down and at an angle, filled with water and all kinds of stuff floating around.
- Filligree 2y agoDo I have to? It’s going to give me nightmares. Yeah, if he’d tried swimming out there’d have been one less survivor.
- saberience 2y agoSo I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that you're not a diver or free-diver. I've done a lot of diving and a little bit of free-diving. I would never, not a million years, try and free-dive out of a boat, especially a large and unfamiliar boat that had sunk. It's almost certain death to try and do so. 1) No Breath: First of all, the average person can roughly hold their breath a minute or lets be generous and say one and a half minutes. Well, that's in perfect comfortable conditions in a nice warm, safe, room. Now you're in cold water, you're in shock because your boat sank, and you're in the dark, you're likely highly anxious or panicking, you can now hold your breath 30-45 seconds if doing no work at all. If you're actively swimming for your life you probably last for 20-30 seconds IF THAT. 2) Getting Lost: Dive boats can be quite large, full of random objects, and if you've been diving on a boat for a few days only, there is little chance you are going to be able to navigate through the boat in the dark in good conditions, now imagine the boat is filled with water, completely dark and upside down. You are panicked and disoriented, if you somehow manage to find an exit it's almost entirely down to dumb luck. 3) Depth (and potential DCS). You have no idea what depth the boat has sunk to. So let's say it's at 50m, it takes a long time to surface from 50m and if it's already taken you 1 minute to get out of the boat, you're fucked again. Not to mention any DCS you may suffer if you've been breathing compressed air down at 50m for very long! Maybe there are some combination of factors which would make this a good idea, like, very small boat with very obvious exits, warm water in the tropics, shallow water and its daytime so there is light to see by, and you're also a champion free-diver and regularly do 7-9 minute breath holds. Sure in these cases you might just swim out. But if you're a normal person trying to swim out of a boat in the dark, upside-down, in unknown depths, cold water, random detritus floating everywhere, just stay put!
- Havoc 2y agoKinda wild that the Egyptian gov just put out a made up cause with zero evidence instead of saying cause unknown currently
- shellfishgene 2y agoSee this unrelated story from a few weeks back... https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/masks-smoke-and-mirrors-the-untold-story-of-egyptair-flight-804-42c788fcac2d https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/masks-smoke-and-mirrors-...