4 ms·
What's causing it in the US?
by stavros 2y ago
What's causing it in the US?
- rvnx 2y agoIn Canada potentially Chinese immigrants in Vancouver/Toronto, in the US it's an over-generous monetary policy (through low interest rates, especially during COVID)
- affinepplan 2y agoin Canada, like in the US, it's a lack of supply mostly because of draconian zoning and land-use policies. Chinese immigrants are NOT the primary cause of housing cost inflation, and are likely not even in the top 10 causes.
- OJFord 2y agoI don't know or claim that it's any truer, but I thought the oft-reported reason, for Vancouver/BC especially, was Chinese investment, and explicitly not immigration even, the chief complaint that the growth has been/is expected to be such that they're left unoccupied?
- _whiteCaps_ 2y agoThis is my experience. The two houses that I share a backyard fence with are empty. A caretaker comes by once a month to have a look around one of the houses but otherwise they're unoccupied.
- qball 2y ago>for Vancouver/BC especially The ALR bans any and all significant development in BC. Land is not scarce in BC; land that it's legal to build on is.
- OJFord 2y agoOk - I'm not Canadian, idk what ALR is - I'm just saying what's disagreed with up-thread isn't what, in my experience, is the common claim (whether it's correct or not).
- qball 2y agoThe Agricultural Land Reserve prohibits farmland from being sold for housing development. It's one of the oldest modern NIMBY policies. Most of the land in BC is classified in this way.
- OJFord 2y agoWell that's not obviously bad I don't think? If Canadians want to be mad about pro-farm regulation, they should look to dairy; milk tokens, cheese availability, etc.
- hadlock 2y agoAre you saying prices didn't go up because of Chinese investors, or Chinese immigrants? I haven't heard anyone discussing immigration as a root cause
- ziofill 2y agoOne should also add that (at least in Canada) newer buildings are not built for families but for investors. Who needs all of those 30 square meter studios?
- dowager_dan99 2y agothey've slashed immigration, so I guess we'll find out. BC is also going to tax any sales after less than 2 years of ownership; I'm doubtful this will increase affordability or supply, but it will essentially kill the economic model of renovation & flipping.
- tandr 2y agoI don't think it will kill "reno and flip" market. It will become "reno and rent-to-buy later", or "reno, hold and sell".
- iforgot22 2y agoSeems Canada has a similar money-printing MO as the US. CAD money supply doubled in the past decade.
- bee_rider 2y agoToo much regulation or greedy landlords depending on your political persuasion.
- WalterBright 2y agoThere's never been a time when people were not greedy. The "suddenly, people started being greedy" meme doesn't make much sense.
- bakugo 2y agoPeople have indeed always been greedy, but the greediest are becoming more wealthy and powerful by the day.
- renewiltord 2y agoNah. There was this time when egg farms got greedy and raised the price. Then they became not greedy again and it's fine. Similar situation with software engineers. They got greedy and salaries went up. When they become less greedy, like rights now, things go down a little.
- bee_rider 2y agoThe point of the comment was not to present a full description of either position. It was to point out that everybody here is just going to reflexively provide their partisan answers to this question.
- affinepplan 2y agoNIMBYism making it extremely difficult and expensive to build supply as is needed. in 1946 the US had a population of 141M and built 700k housing units in 2024 the US had a population of 336M and built 90k housing units
- imperfect_light 2y agoWhere are these numbers from? How does 5 million housing units from 2020-2023 (this was published in 2024) translate into "90K housing units" >The United States has added almost 5 million housing units since 2020, most heavily in the South and most of them single-family homes, making a housing shortage look conquerable in much of the nation. https://washingtonstatestandard.com/2024/05/16/housing-boom-in-most-of-the-us-could-ease-shortage-but-cost-is-still-a-problem/#:~:text=The%20housing%20unit%20data%20released,for%20the%20past%20two%20years https://washingtonstatestandard.com/2024/05/16/housing-boom-....
- LeafItAlone 2y agoParent used a single month’s count for the whole year
- WalterBright 2y ago1946 was a special case. It was the start of the baby boom, kicked off by the victorious soldiers returning home and wanting to get on with life.
- MattGaiser 2y agoYour 90K number is a monthly number, not annual and only for single family units. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/HOUST1F https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/HOUST1F
- iforgot22 2y agoIt's also a delta being put alongside the absolute US population
- 2y ago
- Passport4-Lurk 2y agoIt’s always supply. It’s fair to criticize foreign ownership/hedge funds purchasing homes, but the overwhelming reason is that we are not building enough.
- stavros 2y agoSure, but it's one thing to not be building enough for people to live in, and another thing to not be building enough for people to keep empty flats as speculation vehicles.
- golergka 2y agoWhen too many flats are used as speculation vehicles, the bubble pops and the problem solves itself.
- epicureanideal 2y agoExcept at that point the wealthy homeowners will ask for bailouts.
- gruez 2y agoHow many % of flats are empty? At least in the US the hottest housing markets usually have the lowest vacancy rates. This makes sense, because the opportunity costs for leaving a property empty is higher, so owners are more tempted to rent them out.
- jedberg 2y agoThe vacancy rates are deceiving though. If you have a place that is owned by someone and they are paying taxes on it, and it's not listed as a rental, it's not considered vacant. In big cities there are definitely homes that are empty and not listed being used as a store of wealth. In fact just within view of my own home are two houses like that. Both owned by foreign families who wanted a safer place to keep their wealth than their own country (China and India respectively).
- thfuran 2y agoDecades of public support for treating housing as an investment shaping zoning and other related policies, the relative profitability of constructing budget vs luxury housing, and more recently, inflationary monetary policy,
- qball 2y agoNew development was made illegal in the places people want to live. It's that simple. Now, you may agree with the given reasons for making that development illegal (and/or very expensive), or you may not, but that is the undeniable end result of those policies. We made that bed, now we lay in it; we could theoretically un-make that bed overnight, but there's serious money (and political power) riding on making sure this problem never goes away.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoA housing bust in 2008 washed a lot of capital and talent out of the house construction industry, and the current boom is hard to supply with construction capacity even when there is land to build on. And also, even if the land exists, there is already a SFH on it that needs to be torn down, so we are densifying at a slower rate than we need to. Couple that with an even increasing focus of good job opportunities into a few hot metros, the whole US housing market becomes one hot mess.
- epicureanideal 2y agoThere are robotic construction companies like FBR, and plenty of open stretches of land along highway 101, 680, 880, etc.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoThere is a lot of cheap housing in the south and Midwest as well, but it isn’t very relevant since people are picky about where they want to live.
- dataviz1000 2y agoI wonder if it has something to do with advance economies growing at 1%-2% a year while the least developed countries are growing at 4% - 5%? This would cause the demand for building materials to skyrocket as billions of people can enter the market to purchase lumber, steel, and energy who 10 years ago couldn't.
- iforgot22 2y agoSame reason gold increases in $ value just by existing or people passively invest in S&P500. New money is created and it has to settle somewhere. There's plenty of cheap land or land that barely moves in value, but the desirable spots in cities are limited, so that's a natural place to invest.
- epicureanideal 2y agoLimited yes, but limited by regulation more than anything else. Within a 30 minute drive of SF there are hundreds of square miles to develop on. Pick a dozen at random and build residential skyscrapers. Problem solved.
- iforgot22 2y agoThat's pretty much what they're doing. But the apartment that probably requires driving 30 minutes (or 1.5hr train) to work is worth a lot less than something in SF. Edit: SF itself does have strict zoning. But even if everyone there wanted max density, so they tore everything down and built skyscrapers instead (ignoring the soil problem there), it's a fixed supply of land.
- epicureanideal 2y agoYeah I’m seeing some of the development but it’s mostly 5 story rather than 50, and very small total area compared to what would be possible. The apartments are still quite expensive even an hour’s train ride away.