6 ms·
The Movement to Redirect Billions of Taxpayer Dollars to Private Schools
- rahimnathwani 2y ago"That same year, a coalition of school districts, now numbering more than 200, filed suit against the voucher expansion." In other word, a bunch of government employees used taxpayers' money to find legal action, with the aim of maintaining their local monopolies on the provision of taxpayer-funded education.
- Pulcinella 2y agoGovernment entities use taxpayer money to fund legal action (and pretty much everything else they do) all the time. I am not a lawyer but I believe it is called “administrative law” and is completely normal. To think so otherwise is completely ahistorical and incorrect.
- rahimnathwani 2y ago"Government entities use taxpayer money..." Individual people - government employees - decided to do this. They decided to use taxpayer funds (that were specifically allocated for educating students) to finance legal action aimed at preventing parents from choosing which schools would receive taxpayer funding to educate their children. In other words, government employees spent public education money on litigation designed to keep money flowing into their own pockets, rather than allowing those funds to follow students to whatever educational environment their families determined would best serve them.
- lenerdenator 2y agoThere's an argument to be made that maintaining the integrity of the school district is, in fact, serving the education of the students.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoParents probably care more about the education of their children, than government employees do. I think those parents can be trusted to know what is "serving the education of the students".
- lenerdenator 2y agoAnd plenty of parents don't.
- paleotrope 2y agoWhat are you gonna do about the ones that don't care?
- lenerdenator 2y agoHave a well-funded school system that exists no matter what to give their children at least something.
- Pulcinella 2y agoOf course it’s individual people. The political entity they work for obviously has no will of its own. It is terribly unsurprising to me that people tasked with a job by the government would do what they can to best carry out that job. Are you scandalized when a city and the county it is in sue each other and the transportation department over who has responsibilities for what sections of road and how much money who should get rather than letting the citizens who drive on those roads decide? Where do you draw the line for what money the government decides how to spend and what money individuals should decide how to spend?
- rahimnathwani 2y ago"It is terribly unsurprising to me that people tasked with a job by the government would do what they can to best carry out that job." Right, but the government tasked school district employees with educating kids who enroll in government-run schools. The legislature explicitly created a voucher scheme, and it's unclear why school district employees would think it was their job to prevent this from happening.
- Pulcinella 2y agoDeclining enrollment and pulled funding can destroy the ability of a district to carry out the mission tasked to it by the government. This is not just hypothetical. The rural, conservative school district I used to work for (and may, many like them as pointed out in the article) and the families that rely on them do not like school vouchers, even if they otherwise support everything else that politician does. If too many students unenroll and utilize school vouchers, the whole district could collapse due to lack of funding and screw over all the remaining students. This is compounded by the fact that vouchers often pull out more funding that the government otherwise would provide to the district for that student. This is mentioned in the article as well. e.g. the state pays the district $5k a year per student, but pulls $8k a year for a student that uses a voucher. Also, in a lot of these rural areas there are no other good options anyway besides the school district. It’s either the district, a scammy online charter school, a scammy fly-by-night charter school, or homeschooling.
- lenerdenator 2y agoIt's supposed to be a monopoly. I don't pay property taxes to make some head of OmniCorp Education LLC a multimillionaire. I do it so that the kids in my neighborhood aren't dumber than rocks. Your local school district is the default. If you want to do something else, you're free to. You can educate your child yourself, or pay another educational institution to do it for you. Is that too expensive? Maybe you should talk about that with the person who pays your salary.
- rahimnathwani 2y ago"I don't pay property taxes to make some head of OmniCorp Education LLC a multimillionaire." In my city, school district administrators are multimillionaires. "It's supposed to be a monopoly." Is that a good thing? "Your local school district is the default." Why ought that to be the case? "You can educate your child yourself, or pay another educational institution to do it for you." That's what I do, and the sticker price is less per year than the annual per-student opex of my local school district.
- frumper 2y agoPrivate schools do not play by the same rules. Special education and transportation are a significant cost of public schools that private schools can just ignore.
- lenerdenator 2y ago> Is that a good thing? Is it a bad thing? There are plenty of good public schools in the United States. They typically tend to geographically coincide with places with high average household income and thus lots of funding through property taxes, though that's not the only advantage money gives them. > Why ought that to be the case? Because society benefits when all children have at least some education from the age of five to sixteen, if not longer. There were times throughout history (up until relatively recently, actually - think prior to WWII) where there was lots of competition for your educational dollars. The problem was, if you didn't have educational dollars to spend, your kid got no education. And now that there's more urban than rural population in the US, you can't even just tell junior to help you with farm chores. You'll just have youths doing... well, it's hard to tell, but when kids don't have anywhere they have to be or anything they have to do, it usually turns out poorly for them and their communities. > That's what I do, and the sticker price is less per year than the annual per-student opex of my local school district. I bet it is. The average child who attends a private school typically comes from a household that has more financial resources, and thus, requires less of the social safety net that is often provided through school districts. These schools are also free to tell more "expensive" students (read: neurodivergent and disabled children) to pound sand when it comes to their needs.
- mmooss 2y agoThe title is: Inside the Movement to Redirect Billions of Taxpayer Dollars to Private Religious Schools It's about religious schools, which is a major omission from the title.
- ourmandave 2y agoYeah, the Vouchers Hurt Ohio site says 90% of the schools receiving vouchers are religious.
- bilbo0s 2y agoGotta fund those Christian Madrasas! On a more serious note, you have to wonder why religions are more overt about having the taxpayer foot their bills these days? I mean really, if you want Christian, Muslim or whatever religion schools, fine. No issue from me. But if the government compels me to fund the Madrasas, that's another thing entirely. This is a genuine problem.
- rbanffy 2y agoI toned down the title to prevent rage engagement on purpose. Didn't work that well - the post got flagged anyway, as it always happens when people forget how to disagree in civil ways. That we on HN can't have a civil discussion on a divisive topic is deeply saddening to me. Se should be better than that.
- mmooss 2y agoI admire the thinking; thanks. > That we on HN can't have a civil discussion on a divisive topic is deeply saddening to me. Se should be better than that. Agreed.
- Pulcinella 2y agoI do not wish for taxpayer dollars to fund private school (religious or otherwise) or homeschooling. One of the things I love most about this country is that America is a civic nation. This country is built on shared civic ideals, values, and vision. This country is not built on a specific racial, ethnic, or religious identity like many, many old-world Eurasian nations.
- nine_zeros 2y ago> One of the things I love most about this country is that America is a civic nation What are you a communist? /s Jokes aside, with the recent election, the country has been sold to capitalists and oligarchs. I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if the school system in some states is fed to vultures to suck money from. You may think it is impossible in America but remember anything has been possible in America, including enslavement and redlining. Selling schools to vultures is not at all outside the realm of possibilities here.
- rbanffy 2y ago> Jokes aside, with the recent election, the country has been sold to capitalists and oligarchs. My question is how long will it take for it to be reversed. I have a deep respect for the ideals upon which the US was founded, but it's getting increasingly hard to respect the ground truth of what the country has become.
- ActionHank 2y agoThat's weird, I could've sworn America was a capitalist oligarchy working to drive down education to produce a cheaper and less educated labour force.
- vinyl7 2y ago> This country is built on shared civic ideals, values, and vision. Sadly I think that died many decades ago and now we're just an economic zone
- econ40432 2y agoHarvard was given public money in 1636. It was a religious school and trained clergy.
- Eumenes 2y agoI'd love to redirect my property/state taxes away from my local failing public school system to the private school I send my kids.
- jameskilton 2y agoThis is the whole problem. That money (and more!) should be going to public schools to fix them. We should all want great public schools everywhere. An educated populace is the only way we as a country can grow and improve.
- Eumenes 2y agoMy local school district pays $17k/year per student ... how much more money do they need?
- tempworkac 2y agois there actually any evidence more money would fix public schools? Urban school districts as far as I know have more money than the suburbs and worse outcomes as reflected in standardized test scores.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoIn my region the city's one massive school district has more money than any single suburban one, obviously. But funding per student is generally higher in the suburbs, and outcomes are better there as well. So I'm sure there are other factors but there is at least some evidence that more money would help.
- the_gastropod 2y agoYes https://learningpolicyinstitute.org/product/how-money-matters-report https://learningpolicyinstitute.org/product/how-money-matter... What you’re describing is exactly the opposite of reality. On average in the US, an urban student receives ~$2,000 less than a suburban student. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-03-27/why-city-kids-get-less-money-for-their-education https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-03-27/why-city-...
- tempworkac 2y agoAre residential tax exemptions also redirecting billions of taxpayer dollars to the "rich", by the same logic?
- pasttense01 2y agoI think there is a lot to be said for public schools to be eliminated, for all schools to be private schools with the government providing vouchers. So you would have some students going to a strong STEM school, others to schools with strong vocational education, etc--instead of students going to an average generic local public school. There is a lot to be said for freedom of choice.
- mschild 2y agoI think thats likely the worst outcome possible. The public school system needs reform not privatization. Privatization of any vital public infrastructure has to my knowledge never led to a better result. Whether is public transport, medical care, or education. You can have a specialized public school system that allows for different life paths, but putting the education in the hands of private entities is going to degrade the education for most students.
- jmclnx 2y agoI agree with this, just look at privatized health care for were private schools will go. It will be a money suck and kids will learn nothing.
- moribvndvs 2y agoWhat actually happens is children from impoverished/troubled families and bad neighborhoods get completely screwed over, exacerbating existing problems and creating new ones by burdening already vulnerable children with more difficult logistics and higher transport and general schooling costs across town. This isn’t even about “better educational outcomes”. That’s all very weak smoke and mirrors for the actual intent: for better off families to pull the ladder up behind them and kick struggling communities clinging to the edge into the abyss while funneling cash to ideological strongholds that desperately need new ways to regrow their dwindling congregations. That’s at best. At worst it’s reinventing classic racist policies.
- unethical_ban 2y agoMaybe.... MAYBE if the private schools were forced to teach the government curriculum. There should not be freedom of choice when it comes to tracking fundamentals of arts and sciences and history. Tell me, what happens when the education privateers decides it isn't profitable to operate in majority black neighborhoods? Rural towns with sparse population?
- vaadu 2y agoYou can't reform a system that is broken by design. The teachers' unions have WAY too much power. More power than parents, which is wrong and corrupts the system. You can see this by comparing money and test scores over the past few decades. More money today and worse results. Kids/parents should have a choice. Just like we have choices on android or iphone and Purdue or Ohio State. Why should it be different with the k-12 education? If some are religious, so what? Parents can send their kids to a non-religious or trade school or a STEM school. Parents should have more choice than bureaucrats.
- nojvek 2y agoIt's not as simple. Schools in my county are extremely selective even though they don't appear on outside. With arduous processes for application and applications only open for one day that only insiders know, or they extend application links to certain people with plausible denial that it's an open application through their arduous links. Public schools on the other hand are straight forward. Once we move towards schools deciding who they want, it separates rich from poor students, white from colored students. I already see it in chartered vs public schools in my county.