8 ms·
Earth breaches 1.5 °C climate limit for the first time: what does it mean?
- datadeft 2y agoFirst time in what timeframe?
- tikkabhuna 2y agoFrom the first line: > It’s official: Earth’s average temperature climbed to more than 1.5 °C above pre-industrial levels for the first time in 2024
- portaouflop 2y agoLiterally in the subtitle: for one year so far
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoThey mean when was the baseline. The correct answer is: since industrialization and reliable data
- datadeft 2y agoSo in the larger Earth history there could have been a higher increase. We are talking about a super small sample on a huge scale.
- WillAdams 2y agoNo one is debating that the earth in the past was much hotter, and far less hospitable than it is today. The issue here is that modern society was built with certain expectations of certain temperature ranges, and by burning petrochemicals and adding carbon to the atmosphere we have increased the hot house effect of CO2 in the atmosphere beyond the ability of the planet to absorb it, resulting in a net average increase in temperature on a global scale. A layman's understanding of this: - burning fossil fuels adds CO2 and CO to the atmosphere - increased CO2 levels in the atmosphere increases the "greenhouse effect" --- this is easily proven with a science experiment 4th graders can do - the added solar gain increases the temperature of the planet beyond what can be radiated out into space for that portion of the planet rotated out of the sunlight - no one has been able to demonstrate that this additional solar energy is doing anything other than warming the planet --- if it isn't doing so, please explain in plain, simple words where this added energy is going and what it is doing
- jeltz 2y agoThere have been bigger increases but most likely not faster ones though I am not sure how far back we have reliable data for rate of increase. And even if so this rapid rate of increase is still not a good thing. It will require expensive adaptations and lead to extinctions.
- aeonik 2y agoIt's possible there were higher spikes in the past, but I would guess that they were all pretty dramatic events, and yes the earth used to be much hotter in the past. This is obvious if you think about it, all that carbon in the ground had to be in the air before photosynthetic life. And before any life, the Earth was a molten ball of liquid rock. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleoclimatology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleoclimatology
- dghughes 2y agoYes the Earth was molten magma 4.5 billion years but that's not included.
- abenga 2y agoThe only time scale we care about is the duration human beings have been around. You know the planet being fine it's humans we are worried about and all that jazz.
- captainbland 2y agoThe 1.5C (and other similar) thresholds are based on pre-industrial averages. An average of between 1850 and 1900 is generally considered to be the modern pre-industrial baseline. This is then the average of 2024 as compared to that pre-industrial baseline. The significance of this is the rate at which the planet is warming, which is unprecedented as according to historical data. The rate is what concerns environmental scientists as it means that ecosystems etc. do not have the same time to adapt as compared to pre-historical periods of warming.
- lm28469 2y ago> your kitchen is burning, won't you do anything about it ? > so what ? it burned once 40 years ago already
- roelschroeven 2y agoFirst time in a very long time. Most certainly the first time since the first beginnings of civilization; I think also the first time since the existence of humans, or maybe even the existence of life at all, but I'm not 100% sure of that.
- alenrozac 2y agoWe should be investing into living with these changes.
- portaouflop 2y agoWe should begin to acknowledge that there is a non-zero chance for complete societal collapse in the next few decades.
- pcthrowaway 2y agoWe should begin to acknowledge that there may be a near-zero chance of avoiding complete societal collapse in the next few decades.
- master-lincoln 2y agoIn that case, why play along with society or do any research or investments beyond that time frame?
- teamonkey 2y agoBecause society collapsing doesn't mean that everyone will die; research and investments now might be critical for our children and possibly the long-term survival of the human race.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoWhich part of the society, the Trump part, or the Musk part. Oh, they seem to be the same now. It’s so confusing.
- portaouflop 2y agocurrent society collapsing still gives room for survival - look at indigenous peoples in for example Australia - they survived an apocalypse and still are around.
- The_Colonel 2y ago
- _Algernon_ 2y ago2.0°C any% speedrun starting now. Fun times.
- moffkalast 2y ago4°C by 2040, so the numbers match nicely. I know we can do it if we don't put our minds to it.
- deadbabe 2y agoCan always count on Hackernews to start our day off with an existential threat to all humanity that we can no longer do anything about.
- bayindirh 2y agoThe nice thing is we had the chance. However the people who had the power decided that monies is more important than a sphere of dirt. It's just too bad that we don't have a replacement for the latter one. Tough luck, maybe next time.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoJust absolutely floors me we have people in this very thread still "being skeptical" about this issue that's probably the second most-studied thing in science, right behind evolution. I'm glad I didn't have kids and I hope I don't live to see the worst effects of climate change. As for the rest of humanity: good fuckin luck y'all, you'll need it.
- hocuspocus 2y agoIt's not so surprising. We (the average tech worker on HN) are part of the problem, not the solution.
- bayindirh 2y agoSome of these people saw the differences and still deny that anything is changing. a: We had more snow in the past. b: Maybe we have less now because everything is warming up? a: Nah, bullshit. It's just a phase, it'll pass. I mean, we know microcliamtes, city/neighborhood heat traps, their effect on local climate, the effects of greenhouse gases in heat retention and how these effects global climate, heat storage in water and earth... For God's sake, people believe when their app says that it'll rain in 15 minutes, but won't believe it that they'll be broiled in 15 years. It's the same calculations basically! ...and despite all this knowledge and we know what we're doing and how we're doing it, many people deny that we did something to the environment and we're here now. oh, boy.
- Alifatisk 2y agoHave we passed the point of no return? I remember reading articles talking about if we ever reach 1.5 degress, there will be irreversible damages.
- alganet 2y agoWe passed the point of no return when scientists warned about it 50 years ago and no one cared.
- Alifatisk 2y agoShould I just stop caring then? I've been trying my best the recent years to minimize my climate footprint.
- moffkalast 2y agoHonestly? Yes. It won't matter either way at this point, even if we reach net zero worldwide we're still more or less screwed since it's a positive feedback loop in terms of albedo (until all the ice is gone anyway) and the oceans have absorbed enough CO2 to keep emitting it for a long while if atmospheric levels drop. Any actual solutions would involve increasing reflectivity though artificial means, i.e. aerosol geoengineering.
- The_Colonel 2y ago> we're still more or less screwed "less screwed" here means "fewer dead people". I think it matters how much screwed are we. BTW this is the exact switcheroo I expect from the climate deniers - first it was "climate change doesn't exist, why should I limit my consumption?", when it's too undeniable they're going to switch in a second to "too late to do anything about it, why should I limit my consumption?"
- moffkalast 2y agoIt certainly matters how screwed we are, but a single person eating less meat and taking the bus more often isn't going to make any impact whatsoever when everyone else maintains business as usual. Laws and tax incentives need to drive it first and foremost, but as usual with these things it's too little, too late. Systemic change is what matters and it's all too common that "personal responsibility" is the talking point of corporations who greenwash their operation through buying cheap fake carbon offsets to relieve themselves of any responsibility while outputting more CO2 than a small nation on a daily basis, making sure to simultaneously blame everyone else as much as possible to divert attention.
- dr_dshiv 2y agoWe know that the continued exponential growth of solar means that fossil fuels won’t be absolutely necessary for the economy in 10-15 years. For instance, if we replaced all the corn-for-ethanol fields with solar, we’d produce something like 15x the total electricity as we do now. But we also know it won’t happen soon enough. We also know that it only costs about 5-10 billion dollars a year to provide global heat balance through solar radiation management (eg by lofting sulfur or calcium carbonate into the upper atmosphere). We have plenty of volcanoes as natural experiments to provide the efficacy of the approach. We also know that there is massive “green” opposition to anything involving geoengineering. But, geoengineering seems to be the only plausible mechanism for preventing global warming at this point. Even stopping all fossil fuels won’t use tomorrow won’t do it — and that won’t be possible for decades — not without riots in the streets.
- lm28469 2y ago> We know that the continued exponential growth of solar means that fossil fuels won’t be absolutely necessary for the economy in 10-15 years. Where did you get that from ? Renewable are stacked on top of fossil, we use as much (more even) fossil fuel than ever before, it never went down: https://ourworldindata.org/energy-mix https://ourworldindata.org/energy-mix Germany is the prime example of this green washing: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/gallery_image/public/paragraphs/images/fig1-installed-net-electricity-generation-capacity-germany-2002-2024.png https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/g...
- ben_w 2y agoIf you accept that PV will continue to grow exponentially, the historical trend is ~1000x growth over the last 21 years, or 10x every 7 years. PV is about 10% of global electricity demand and about 1% of all-forms global energy demand today; 7 years (even without wind) and its going to be dominant over electrical generation, 14 and there's enough electricity to electrify everything else we do, too. If you accept that the exponential growth will continue. It's not guaranteed.
- 2y ago
- tempworkac 2y agoI wonder if this means first-world nations will stop consuming, or will they continue to patronize the poorer countries?
- p0w3n3d 2y agoFor sure they will push their citizens to drop their cars and buy brand new which are more ecological, to make the car industry go on. Throwaway things like washing machines that last 2 years are in the agenda too
- Over2Chars 2y agoI don't know what country you live in, but new cars in the U.S. aren't necessarily any more ecological. The SUV has been king and now the CUV ("crossover" UV) which is also a huge beast of a car. Even if we switch from gas to electric, this only shifts the pollution to electric generators, which are... coal/natural gas/nuclear Although renewables are trending up (21% in this random hit, more than I expected) https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-in-the-us.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-... So without solving the electricity generation problem, a shift to full electrics is only a part of the puzzle.
- Over2Chars 2y agoAn "irony" of this, is that China is a major consumer of "clean coal" A random first hit on a search quack for "global coal consumption" on DDG: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/coal-consumption-by-country-terawatt-hours-twh https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/coal-consumption-by-count... note China is dark red. Now, there's a small problem. One reason that China is using so much coal is... to supply all of the exports to other countries! It might be said that your Amazon/etc purchases are shifting the coal usage from your country to China.
- NKosmatos 2y agoWe're going to see many more people becoming Environmental/Climate refugees :-( Our only short to mid term is solar and wind, with a long term solution being nuclear fusion (not fission).
- tempworkac 2y agowhat's wrong with fission?
- NKosmatos 2y agoI’m all in for fission, but it has a really bad reputation, has many opponents, it creates a bit of waste and hasn’t solved our energy problems in the past decades.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoFusion isn't technologically viable. Then it needs to be economically viable. I'm not convinced that fusion will ever be lower cost than fission. And fission will probably never be cheaper than solar and wind and storage, which are categorically cheaper currently on a raw energy basis, and solar wind heavy up to fully drop in price and stabilize. Fission and fusion are peaker and industrial heat application specific. But that implies such a lower level of monetary investment over time that they also won't get the economies of scale to thrive. Even smr size reactors are a big upfront investment, while wind and solar can be scaled and grown organically. I'm hopeful for a lftr style small price competitive fission reactor approach exists, but it's ten years away. Fusion is thirty years from practical use at least. What is apparent is that we will never get political cooperation to solve environmental issues of this scale, outside of mutual agreement to lob nuclear weapons at each other.
- miroljub 2y agoThe climate hype will end inevitably. Only if warming becomes a real problem, people will start looking at (technical) solutions. As long as we can "fight" climate by taxing, subventions, greenwashing, bans, restrictions, everything will be fine for the "people of power". Like "war on terror", child pornography and pandemics, climate change is just another vehicle for global elites to gain more power, influence and wealth.
- baggachipz 2y agoIf you're unwilling to accept the science of this, get off your computer. Don't drive your car, or heat your house this winter. The same scientific processes which led to all of society's advancement are utilized in predicting the consequences of climate change. There is no conspiracy.
- miroljub 2y agoClimate has always been changing. Even before humans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles still holds, and explains quite a bit, though recent research added a few more factors, none of them human related. There's no conspiracy, you just seem to believe more to the "TV approved" science.
- baggachipz 2y agoYou're alleging that there's "TV approved science", in which you're absolutely declaring a conspiracy that the "TV people" are colluding to distort the "facts". I'd ask you to explain this[1], but you're arguing in bad faith to conform to your world view. [1] https://assets.science.nasa.gov/dynamicimage/assets/science/esd/climate/internal_resources/2679/co2-graph-072623.jpg https://assets.science.nasa.gov/dynamicimage/assets/science/... Again, if you're unwilling to accept the findings of the organization responsible for a great many of society's technical advancements, then you're merely trolling.
- AtlasBarfed 2y ago[flagged]
- Uw5ssYPc 2y ago[flagged]
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoYou are the main character.
- neom 2y ago10 years ago I said to a group of friends that I thought in about 10 years time air travel would be a very very highly regulated thing, with international limits placed on how many miles an airline is allowed to fly a passenger (I even thought a secondary market for airline miles would emerge) - I figured by 2025 we'd have nuclear back on track and large scale nation state projects to implement a rapid shift to solar/wind/nuclear funded by a global $xxxT fund. How unprophetic of me.
- dsign 2y agoI have lived in two countries. In one, the effects of global warming are devastating: droughts, wildfires, epidemics, starvation, and a sense of hopelessness brought about by intense heat and no air conditioner. In my second country, things don't look so dire...longer summers? yes, they will be able to put up with that here, though they may not be able to stand those pesky climate refugees :-( . I think that best remedy we have now to global warming is to build resilient societies, to increase democratic participation, to educate people, to alleviate inequality, to not rely on gas from Russia, to fight waste, and to ... well, keep a discerning eye on the future and on things in general.
- barbs 2y agoWhich countries were they, specifically?
- totallynothoney 2y agoWouldn't you like to know? :^)
- jmclnx 2y agoThe real question is not "what does it mean", but "what will be done ?". The answer is nothing and at this point without a massive change of life style, it is probably too late. 50 years ago, Pres. Carter wanted to get Climate Change on the radar, but Reagan stopped that and doubled down on Fossil Fuels. We are probably 50 years from massive coastal flooding, time to start working on mitigations for the flooding. But of course nothing will be done with that until it is too late. Look at insurance companies, they know what will happen and that is reflected in them pulling out of some parts of the country. 50 years from now, insurance will probably cost 25% to maybe 50% of the house value per year. Similar to Auto Insurance in high risk urban environments.
- bryanlarsen 2y ago> it is probably too late. It is definitely too late to avoid breaching 1.5 degrees. It is probably too late to avoid breaching 2.5 degrees. It is not too late to avoid breaching 4 degrees, or 6 or 8. We cannot give up.
- mmh0000 2y agoCan't give up if you never try! [insert head pointing meme here]
- bryanlarsen 2y agoWe've literally spent trillions of dollars already to combat and mitigate change. We spend $500B annually just on solar panels. Add in the amounts we've spend on wind turbines, EV's, methane capture, etc, and we're spending over $1T per year combatting climate change. It's not enough, but this meme that we're not trying is silly.
- Yizahi 2y agoGraph of CO2 level in the atmosphere doesn't show even a tiny sign of those efforts. Sure, they are all good and commendable, but here we get zero points for the effort. If we reduce emissions a lot, really reduce them across he globe, this will simply mean that we will slow heating speed, not the target temperature. Like turning oven regulator from 3 to 2.5 - oven will still reach maximum temperature. CO2 level is the regulator.
- normalaccess 2y agoWhere are the measurements being taken? Cities are heat islands and really skew the data.
- polotics 2y agothey are being taken with full knowledge of this effect as well as many others. climate scientists are not idiots they are also not conspiring, come on
- gmuslera 2y ago(Positive) feedback loops are dangerous, even if we stop doing anything that moves things forward, feedback loops can get us to hell on Earth (quite literally) all by themselves if we reach the right conditions. And that is why is dangerous to surpass that limit. Even if we define that today conditions are safe or that we can still move things a bit forward without too much harm, feedback loops won't stop because we want them to do and make us cross the cliff. It is not something binary, of course, we were getting already loss of albedo and permafrost thawing and so on before reaching that landmark, but things can speed up badly eventually out of the safe zone.
- taneq 2y ago"If we don't act soon then it will be too late!!!"
- betaby 2y agoctrl+f 'overpopulation' - nothing. Elephant in the room continued to be ignored. World population doubled in ~50 yeas while simultaneously consumes more.
- sebazzz 2y agoThat is because we have an economy reliant on growth. That has to come somewhere, either us - or worker immigration and having a baby factory elsewhere in the world.