6 ms·
Longtime Aspen ski executive thinks corporate sustainability is a scam
- ebiester 2y agoSummary: if it doesn't hit the bottom line of the polluter, then there is no reason for them to change their behavior. That's pretty obvious, but the message needs to be hammered in over and over. The bigger issue is that game theory gets in the way - if pollution is taxed here, it will be exported to places where it is not.
- waveBidder 2y agoThe nice thing about being a massive market like the US is that you can impose regulations that producers in other countries need to follow to be able to participate in the market. It does make enforcement harder, but as long as you have the political will its definitely feasible. O/c having the political will is an entirely different thing.
- detourdog 2y agoAnother way to look at is the USA is overdeveloped that we have a duty to make everything as advanced as possible. Which raises the sophistication of other nations.
- kelseyfrog 2y ago> It does make enforcement harder We've overthrown foreign governments for smaller reasons. It's more a question of political will than anything else.
- ebiester 2y agoWe can't even stop slave labor, something the world universally has gone, "this is bad." Hard problems are hard.
- quacksilver 2y agoDon't people just create backdoors? Example: The US has banned lots of Chinese stuff. The stuff now sneaks across the border into southeast Asia, or goes to a final assembly plant there and becomes Vietnamese or Cambodian. There are _supposed to_ be supply chain records and audits in many cases, though reality often doesn't match paperwork...
- llamaimperative 2y agoIn the same way that we shouldn't outlaw murder because sometimes people get away with it anyway
- phil21 2y agoProbably should work on catching a few murderers and figuring out an even moderately effective enforcement mechanism before pretending you can make more stuff illegal. Otherwise people just laugh at you as you further undermine any perceived authority you once had. We have done close to nothing to enforce the current tariffs and such, allowing blatant country of origin laundering to go the whole time with next to zero enforcement action. You can bring a ready to prosecute case to regulators and they do utterly nothing. Adding more to this regime would just be yet more performative nonsense to make some people feel good about themselves. We need far less of that in this world.
- llamaimperative 2y agohttps://www.justice.gov/usao-edtx/pr/importer-agrees-pay-798334-resolve-allegations-underpayment-customs-duties https://www.justice.gov/usao-edtx/pr/importer-agrees-pay-798... https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/ford-motor-company-agrees-pay-365m-settle-customs-civil-penalty-claims-relating https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/ford-motor-company-agrees-pay... https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/us-attorney-announces-228-million-settlement-civil-fraud-lawsuit-against-vitamin https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/us-attorney-announces-2... https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdfl/pr/us-attorney-lapointe-announces-76-million-settlement-civil-false-claims-act-lawsuit https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdfl/pr/us-attorney-lapointe-an... https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/us-attorney-announces-1-million-settlement-civil-fraud-lawsuit-against-trading-company https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/us-attorney-announces-1... Now if you're just arguing the penalties need to be stiffer: sure! But on a cursory search, I don't believe it's fair at all to say we've done "close to nothing" or there's "next to zero enforcement action" or regulators "do utterly nothing" or it's "performative nonsense". What evidence do you have to back up your claims? It seems like perhaps you've actually brought a ready-to-prosecute case forward? Curious to learn!
- debo_ 2y agoFor carbon pricing specifically, border carbon adjustments are being developed as an analogue to duties to blunt the effectiveness of "pollution exports." The EU is the farthest ahead on this. See: - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_Carbon_Border_Adjustment_Mechanism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_Carbon_Border_Adjustment_... - https://citizensclimatelobby.org/blog/policy/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisms-what-are-they-and-why-do-they-matter/ https://citizensclimatelobby.org/blog/policy/carbon-border-a...
- linotype 2y agoThe EU is also doing a great job of cutting emissions by virtue of being in the dumps economically. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cpw2zydnv7lo.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cpw2zydnv7lo.amp
- trimethylpurine 2y agoI wonder if the biggest hindrance to good corporate behavior might be the fiduciary responsibility to the investor that was established with Dodge vs Ford.
- coliveira 2y agoIt is very interesting when capitalists confess that capitalism itself will never solve these issues. It throws away delusional thinking by the uninformed. Any hope of solving environmental issues rests in having a government that is powerful enough compared to the market and willing to work against businesses main financial interests. We're just seeing the example of tech companies, which for years paraded around as earth saviors with pledges of "carbon neutrality", just to discard any such plans when competition for AI supremacy makes them spend as much energy as they possibly can, as quickly as possible, the environment be damned.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoI mean that line of thought has been core to capitalism from the start though. The originators of capitalism argued that it needed strong governments to stop/prevent the negative aspects of capitalism (such as stopping collusion and monopolistic behavior). By it's nature and from the beginning one of capitalism's core requirements is that capitalism cannot function without a framework of rules and enforcement mechanisms that only a strong government can provide.
- coliveira 2y agoIt needs to be a government that is not controlled by companies and billionaires.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoAgreed. All of the original capitalist thinkers specified that very very clearly.
- ebiester 2y agoOkay, so I agree with many leftist critiques of capitalism, but we can also tell that communism also caused environmental destruction, particularly in the soviet block. Mixed economies are not doing that much better - see the Norwegian sovereign fund as but one example. Further, I'd argue that the opposite of a weak state is a totalitarian one, not a socialist one. And I'm arguing that the problem is you need over 200 governments to agree on both it and its enforcement, and that the wealth disparity between countries in and of itself will cause game theory issues for these sorts of agreements to break down, even if each government was enlightened socialist. Capitalism is making it worse, to be sure, but socialism is not a solution here in and of itself.
- bagels 2y agoWhy does Aspen one, a skiing company even bother with "sustainability" at all in the first place? The whole business is predicated on deforestation and people flying airplanes to ski for the weekend.
- brookst 2y agoDo you question all mitigations? Like, why bother going to the gym if you also drink wine?
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoI would compare it to seeing a nutrition team at Frito-Lay. Sure, it's always better to be marginally more healthy, but their primary output is almost surely going to be manufactured excuses for health-conscious people to justify eating potato chips.
- bagels 2y agoNo, I do not question all mitigations. I just think that they could probably have more efficacy by looking in the mirror vs. targeting oil. I am no fan of climate change, used to ski, but also drive an electric car.
- waveBidder 2y agoWell, if there's no snow they have no business model (or more realistically shorter seasons), so they have a pretty strong case for caring.
- bongodongobob 2y agoThat's a wild thing to say from someone who uses electricity. Do you really even care bro?
- LargoLasskhyfv 2y agoHrm. The deforestation in Aspen began with mining. When that wasn't economically viable anymore because of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1893 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1893 , it slowly reinvented itself as a ski-resort. I'd bet there is more deforestation by avalanches in the area. Or forest fires. > ...and people flying airplanes to ski for the weekend. There were railroads there. They could be built back from Glenwood Springs along or in the midst of HWY82, and/or the scenic route along the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tennessee_Pass_(Colorado) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tennessee_Pass_(Colorado) , https://www.american-rails.com/tennessee.html https://www.american-rails.com/tennessee.html , optionally via https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hagerman_Pass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hagerman_Pass , Norrie, Ruedi Reservoir, Basalt. More history & maps: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denver_and_Rio_Grande_Western_Railroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denver_and_Rio_Grande_Western_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Midland_Railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Midland_Railway https://www.drgw.net/ https://www.drgw.net/ https://www.rgsrr.info/ https://www.rgsrr.info/ Choo Choo!
- timewizard 2y ago> “what would you do if you really cared?” Examine why people use fossil fuels and then prioritize development of reasonable and affordable alternatives. > what if I just dumped the trash on the street and hoped and waited for my community to pick it up, or to just suffer from my trash? What if you asked how much fossil fuel is burned transporting people and goods into the Aspen ski resort? Or what the impact of your mostly seasonal labor is? Or why their housing is a 25 minute drive from the resort? > Leave us with what “Terrible Beauty” is The projecting recognition that you are, in fact, one of the largest parts of the problem?
- debo_ 2y ago"Largest parts of the problem" seems like hyperbole.
- dataflow 2y ago> One of the ideas that came to us, it wasn't our idea, was that a private corporation nor even a public corporation had sued a fossil fuel company for hiding science and preventing society from taking action on climate. I never understood the point of suing oil companies. (Edit: I mean insofar as "fixing the climate" goes. If the goal is something else, ignore my comment.) So let's say they don't even show up to court, and just lose by default, and the companies get destroyed. OK, congratulations... now what? Consumers aren't going to go "oh my gosh I'm such a fool... if Exxon hadn't fooled me about global warming I would've gone grocery shopping with my carriage horse." They're still going to drive everywhere like they were yesterday, they're going to want bottom-of-the-barrel (pardon the pun) oil prices, and they're going to vote for the leaders that give them that. Whether they're in denial or actively outraged at everyone else for unsustainable living, it's not like most people have enough disposable income, free time, or a bright outlook on the future to invest in more costly methods of living. People want low oil prices, that's our way of life. The oil companies are there because of consumer demand. How does suing them greedy oil companies address that?
- ch4s3 2y agoI think people incorrectly assume that if it had been 100% clear in 1980 that we were on a course to dramatically change the global climate that we could or would have made key technological advances earlier. I personally doubt this and think that there were a lot of unknowns. There has been plenty of investment and research into batteries and photovoltaics for decades and they both needed advances in other areas to get to where they are today. A lot of what makes PV so useful now relies on technology developed for microchips. If somehow we had managed to figure out climate models before we stopped building nuclear plants, then maybe we could have ended up on a different trajectory but it just seems so unlikely.
- dataflow 2y agoI'd be maybe willing to buy this if we were still in the '80s, but this is 40 years later. I'm not sure what the point of suing them now is, at least as far as actually attacking climate change goes. For justice-serving purposes, OK, sue them out of existence. But how is that going to fix the climate?
- xyst 2y agoInstead of “suing ExxonMobil” (what a joke, basically just blank checks to lawyers), why don’t these billionaire assholes invest in green energy to compete in areas where O&G / coal is dominant - Great Appalachia, Permian Basin, and other areas. Give people in these areas higher paying jobs, retrain them as necessary, promote highly safe working environments (compared to dangerous oil fields). Then over time the sentiment regarding climate change shifts - politicians taking the cut from O&G will get replaced, laws can change, policies can be placed to push progressive initiatives.
- airstrike 2y agoPeople generally invest where returns are attractive. If it doesn't make financial sense to invest in those regions, then private investors aren't going to do it. One common argument against green energy projects is that they only have attractive returns when they come with sizeable subsidies attached, which really just means taxpayers are footing the bill. I appreciate those same taxpayers are also footing the climate bill, but people tend to care more about the dollars in their pocket today than some future risk which may or may not affect them directly.
- worik 2y ago> One common argument against green energy projects is that they only have attractive returns when they come with sizeable subsidies attached, which really just means taxpayers are footing the bill. That argument has been out of date for at least five years.
- alephnerd 2y ago> invest in green energy to compete in areas where O&G / coal is dominant - Great Appalachia, Permian Basin, and other areas You ain't building a solar array or a mega windmill farm in Appalachia - it is a significant upfront cost and very challenging. > Give people in these areas higher paying jobs, retrain them as necessary, promote highly safe working environments Easier said than done. One of the great things about renewable energy sources like Solar Arrays and Wind Turbines is that there isn't that much labor needed. The manufacturing is largely automated and maintenance doesn't need hundreds of people - maybe a dozen well paid Technicians at most. More critically, these are very technical power systems and the technicians managing these arrays often have a College Education in Electrical or Mechanical Engineering and a decent amount of professional experience. The regions disproportionately affected by your proposal are those with some of the weakest human capital in the US (Appalachia, Permian Basin, the Gulf coast, rural Alaska). ---------- Green Technology adoption is critical to ensure we can remain on Earth sustainably, but handwaving fears about job sustainability is a disservice, and plays a major roll in the arising backlash to green technology.
- worik 2y ago> Is love a better motivator than fear? Oh yes. (Us on) the left need to learn the lessons. Fear and hate are the weapons of the right and billionaire robber barons We must practice the Politics of Love and Hope. It is hard to do when your heart is full of fear and hate, which is a reasonable place for a heart right now. But it is no use in saving the world. Sounds trite, but it is true: Love will save the world. Nothing else comes close
- airstrike 2y agoLove has nothing to do with it. It's about human nature and our monkey brains being wired for greed and for protecting loved ones we know closely over humanity at large.
- briandear 2y ago“It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages”
- worik 2y agoI was speaking to the Left So quoting Adam Smith out of context is not really relevant That said, there is no "butcher, the brewer, or the baker" now, it is Butcher Corp, Brewer Corp, and Baking Corp.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoSadly we didn't evolve our mammalian ancestor/monkey brains in a world surrounded by love. It evolved to process a world filled with danger. I think the average monkey brain will key on danger signals over love every time. I think that is the reason why historical 'see the world with love' figures withdrew from the world rather than engage with it. I think concepts of politics of love and hope are vastly different between cultures/socio economic classes as well, where as monkey brain fear/hate are an easier, more universal sell.
- 2y ago
- maeil 2y agoThis man's heart is clearly in the right place, so maybe this isn't fair. Nevertheless: > The book is trying to get at this question of the gap between what people say they care about and what they do in response to a threat to all of it. If you ask the average American, “What do you love? What do you care about?” They'd say, “My family, my partner, my children, the natural world that I visit and recreate in– those things are important to me, my community.” And then you say “Climate change is a threat to all of those things. An existential threat. What are you doing about it?” And the reality on the ground from the last election is people barely even vote. And when they take action, those actions tend to be token recycling, and they don't take the next step of saying “what would really matter?” So the takeaway from the book is that the beauty of the world, our families, the stories we tell about ourselves, these are so precious that they're worth protecting. I'm hoping that that love and that caring will propel people to do really meaningful work on climate change. You know, I think a different book needs to be written. The focus is always on the people who aren't doing much. I see it on HN all the time; hundreds of comments like "We aren't willing to make real sacrifices", "Everyone has a price", "No one truly cares", and so on. On the contrary, I never see positive highlighting of the who is actually making sacrifices to do things that have an impact. Those get handwaved away in the above quotes, as if they don't exist. They need to be put up on a pestedal, we need to highlight them and talk about how awesome they are. I've never seen any book do that. Tell people that you too can be one of them. Even when there's reporting on them, it's all very flat, matter of fact. It's super harmful to wave them away, to not mention their existance, because in people's minds 1. it reinforces the idea that there's no choice 2. it makes people inadvertently feel good about themselves because oh well, we're all like that. Spreading this exact sentiment is also such a well known strategy that bad actors have been using on a variety of topics for decades. > I mean, if a company is publicly traded, it has to turn a profit for shareholders. Real shame on CPR for implicitly supporting the myth of fiduciary duty, which too is incredibly harmful for the exact same reasons but for corporations - providing a cover as if there's no other option. As long as a company isn't intentionally, actively being run into the ground, there is absolutely zero risk of getting in trouble for not upholding fiduciary duty. It does not happen, it's a convenient myth to excuse companies offloading their negative externalities onto society in chase of shortterm greed. This is a real factor on this exact topic and it's really unfortunate this implication is being reinforced in such an article. Yes, they're not technically saying it, but it very much has that effect.
- HenryBemis 2y agoI've spent years as an auditor. The thing I always tried to figure out was the "root cause". The root cause for global warming is not that company XYZ doesn't plant trees, so "let's <find some solution> to offset the <insert problem>", but find the root cause, and stop/limit/correct/<verb> that cause. Now this is literally a hydra. Consumerism? Yes! Plastics and the lies of oil industry that 'plastic(s) is/are recyclable? Yes! Politics? Yes! Greed? Yes! Big bubble global economy that nobody wants it to bust/rightsize? Yes! Musk has said many things about many topics. One that I admired one thing he said some years back was (along the lines of..) "for humans going to inhabit Mars it is better that they make up their own laws, and I (he) hopes they will do a better job than what we did on earth". I don't feel/believe that Earth will ever be repaired/become pristine while it has humans on it. Perhaps we will wipe ourselves out and 1000 years later, once all signs of civilization will be consumed by floods, earthquakes, nature, the planet will be pristine. It's just a Arrow Paradox (Zeno's paradoxes). I fear an Idiocracy/Wall-e kinda future. This cartoon comes to mind: https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995 https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995
- airstrike 2y agoPeople create value for shareholders because doing so creates value for themselves and their households. Humans brains are wired to hog resources at the expense of others. We generally share with our neighbor to the extent that helps us have more in the future. You can't weasel your way out of human nature. Also thinking we can write better laws if we start from scratch is typical hubris from someone who's never really studied Law. Just another variant of the most common SV syndrome.
- mandmandam 2y ago> thinking we can write better laws if we start from scratch is typical hubris from someone who's never really studied Law It is. However, looking at the US legal system as someone who isn't profiting from it, it's difficult to justify its existence.
- k8sToGo 2y agoEarth cannot be pristine. In fact global warming isn't bad (or good) for earth. It's bad for humans. And what you describe as pristine is a state that is from the perspective of humanity. What I mean is earth doesn't "care" in what state it is in. It will just simply continue in whatever state it will be in. With or without humans.
- MACHINEWAVE 2y ago[dead]
- MACHINEWAVE 2y ago[dead]
- brikym 2y agoHe has a lot of good points but I can't help but find irony in companies like Aspen and Patagonia being part of the problem. How many people travel to a tourist destination without flying or driving a car? How many of Patagonia's rain jackets are covered in forever chemicals like PFAS? The world will have to be drastically different to solve these problems. A carbon tax is the way to do it since offsets are often plainly fraudulent. We have a long way to go. Cars should be as efficient as possible if not replaced by rail. Food packaging ought to be reusable and standardized like shipping containers or milk bottles way back in the day. People would have to give up on their manicured chemical water intensive artificially green lawns and how embarrassing that would be. All appliances, devices and vehicles should be repairable. The way to drive this would be a prepaid tax to account for the costs of the pollution. It would have to be a high enough tax that people get angry about their standard of living changing so it won't happen under democratic politics in such an individualistic society. Everyone has to have their over sized car to signal wealth to their neighbour. But at least if there were regulations we would all be in it together and find more efficient ways to peacock to our neighbours.
- llamaimperative 2y agohttps://www.patagonia.com/our-footprint/pfas.html https://www.patagonia.com/our-footprint/pfas.html
- mandmandam 2y ago> How many people travel to a tourist destination without flying or driving a car? That point was acknowledged in the second paragraph of the article. "His career led him to a tough lesson about his field: it’s a failure that perpetuates the very systems driving global warming". > How many of Patagonia's rain jackets are covered in forever chemicals like PFAS? From this year on, none of them (as linked in the policy above).
- theelous3 2y agoAs of a few months ago, patagonia don't use pfas. https://eu.patagonia.com/ie/en/our-footprint/pfas.html https://eu.patagonia.com/ie/en/our-footprint/pfas.html
- 2y ago
- emodendroket 2y agoSure, but in light of recent events I am not going to be too quick to say shallow lip service to a cause is that bad compared to actively running away from it, which I would not be surprised to be the next move whenever people feel like they've done enough on the ending diversity front.
- hackernewds 2y agoProvides zero evidence around how corporate sustainability is a scam.
- cratermoon 2y agoSee for example The i-frame and the s-frame: How focusing on individual-level solutions has led behavioral public policy astray https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences/article/abs/iframe-and-the-sframe-how-focusing-on-individuallevel-solutions-has-led-behavioral-public-policy-astray/A799C9C57F388A712BE5A8D34D5229A1 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioral-and-brain...