3 ms·
Not directly stated (and maybe not even intended) but for me the inconvenient truth is that human society is absolutely powerless against nature at the extreme
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Not directly stated (and maybe not even intended) but for me the inconvenient truth is that human society is absolutely powerless against nature at the extreme ends of the scale. We can do a lot, we can build sea walls, we can reroute rivers, we can cross over or tunnel under almost any obstacle. But ultimately, the planet is capable of bringing more to bear than we can offset, whether it's wind-driven wildfires, floods, large hurricanes, tornados, earthquakes, volcanoes. The best and only thing we can do in those situations is hope we have enough warning to get out of the way or find someplace to hide.
- tlogan 2y agoI believe this assessment is intellectually dishonest. A couple of days before the fires started, I received a major red alert on my phone (I was in Los Angeles just prior to the fires - Recognizing the danger, I decided to leave). I expected to see a large-scale response—fire trucks stationed everywhere, extra firefighters on standby, planes ready to deploy, and vegetation being watered—but none of that appeared to happen. This isn’t about partisanship. One of the core responsibilities of our elected officials is to effectively manage situations like this. Until we address the root causes (like global warming), these events will continue to occur, and we need better preparedness in the meantime.
- SoftTalker 2y agoFire departments do not have the equipment nor the personnel to handle "the entire city is on fire" events. That would require one or two fire trucks with crew for each house in the city. Even if you could do that, you would quickly deplete the available water supply. It's just not possible. Could more have been done to make a fire of this size less likely? Perhaps. But once it starts, and reaches a certain size, with winds as they were and combustible material in its path, all you can do is get out.
- lazide 2y agoEvery city in the state has mutual aid available.
- tlogan 2y ago> Fire departments do not have the equipment > nor the personnel to handle "the entire city is on fire" events. True, but in fire-prone areas—such as those so high-risk that insurers refuse coverage—we might need to consider a different approach. Whether it’s specialized equipment, additional staffing, or other protective measures, some system should be in place specifically for those regions..
- SoftTalker 2y ago> as those so high-risk that insurers refuse coverage Maybe in those areas the policy should be "you're on your own."
- takeda 2y agoThey did prepare though, 3 days before they got units from north California. If nothing would happen they would be attacked for risking safety of BTW: which locations in the whole Los Angeles (you know how big it is? actually there's no guarantee the fire works be in LA) you should get fire trucks stationed? There wasn't any rain registered since April, there were unprecedented (last time we had such big ones was 15 years ago) dry, 100mph winds. This means using air support was also not feasible at the time. We mostly talk about Palisades, but when watching WatchDuty app, fires were constantly popping up in random places. It was a nightmare, and it is frustrating to see politicizing the whole thing or criticizing that fire men did something wrong. Why those people aren't volunteering and helping? There are some things that is impossible to do with what we have. Much more effective would be for example having all building up to the latest fire code, but majority are of course old.
- tlogan 2y ago> If nothing would happen they would be attacked for risking safety of You’ve pinpointed the core issue. Politicians have little incentive to invest in preventive measures because, as voters, we rarely reward that sort of long-term planning. And who’s really at fault? We are. We don’t demand enough accountability for prevention when we cast our votes. If they successfully prevent fires, nobody notices—and no political points are scored.
- takeda 2y agoIt's the same in Software Engineering, lol. If your service just works no one cares. If you instead have a flaky service, but step in to save the day then you become a hero :) Though I agree somewhat that politicians don't have as much incentive, but this is what regulations are for. Someone said that regulations are written in blood, because they are results of "lessons learned". It doesn't help that then those regulations are frequently removed to help businesses and the cycle repeats.
- danaris 2y ago> This isn’t about partisanship. One of the core responsibilities of our elected officials is to effectively manage situations like this. Unfortunately, this seems to be fast becoming a partisan position.
- markus_zhang 2y agoNot necessarily. There are similar cases in other countries where the fire was well controlled. Might not be as similar as I thought, but I'm wondering if professionals can give an honest post mortem at least for this time.
- leptons 2y ago>There are similar cases in other countries where the fire was well controlled. Did they also have unprecedented 100mph wind gusts, and strong winds blowing for days? It's impossible to fly fire mitigation aircraft in those conditions, and the terrain where the fire was spreading the most were rugged mountain areas, mostly not accessible to firefighters.
- throw0101a 2y agoE.g., > “Without helicopters, this kind of a brush fire, we cannot stop it on the ground,” said Margaret Stewart, an LAFD spokeswoman. > Perhaps demonstrating what a difference aircraft can make, a fire that threatened the Hollywood Hills late Wednesday was quickly contained and limited to 43 acres. Calmer winds allowed aircraft to douse flames with water from nearby reservoirs. * https://archive.is/https://www.washingtonpost.com/weather/2025/01/10/la-fires-containment-winds-firefighter-challenges/ https://archive.is/https://www.washingtonpost.com/weather/20...
- SoftTalker 2y agoWater scooped from reservoirs is less effective than you might think. When it is dropped, a good amount of it evaporates before it ever hits the ground. Most effective would be air drops of fire retardant, but neither can be done in high wind conditions.
- throw0101a 2y ago> Water scooped from reservoirs is less effective than you might think. I'm guessing that water scooped from reservoirs is probably more effective than no water at all.