5 ms·
Inconvenient truths about the fires burning in Los Angeles from two fire experts
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Flatcircle 2y agoShockingly little insight or information in that article. A word salad with no new insights.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI think it's funny that the current top 2 comments on this article completely contradict each other. I.e. the top comment is basically dismissing the article, saying that in these types of firestorms that there is essentially nothing you can do - which I strongly disagree with, and which the article points out is demonstrably not true. And now your comment basically says "there is no new insight or information", which I find highly amusing because I see so many comments online, like the top comment, solely blaming the geography or the "wild-urban" interface, so it's clear this is information that people should be aware of: even if fire-prone Southern CA, the problem is not inevitable, and most of the destruction in these latest fires were urban fires, not in wild areas surrounded by trees.
- CurtHagenlocher 2y agoIn an environment where everyone is quick to point their finger at their favorite villain -- whether that's "wokeness" or climate change or whatever -- I'm happy to finally read something which aligns with my biases.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoBlame it on Big Ember ?
- fullshark 2y agoThose damn laws of physics!
- Terr_ 2y agoTLDR: Events like this aren't really a wildfire problem, even if they provided some initial sparks. It's an urban/developed-area problem, and we need to look at those layouts and building materials etc.
- onecommentman 2y ago“Some initial sparks” is a gross under-characterization by the original author. “Almost all of the millions and millions of burning embers as flying ignition sources, one the three necessary elements of the fire triad” is more accurate to my ears. Without the wildfires providing the ignition, those millions of ignition sources for urban fires simply aren’t there, until an urban conflagration starts creating them for themselves. But there is no major urban conflagration without these initial embers from wildfires…except in certain exceptional scenarios (of which the LA fires and most others cited by the author are not one). Firebombing, coordinated arson, industrial accident…. Which is why almost all urban areas in the US without a wildfire risk have had no urban conflagrations in, say, the last 100 years. Seems to me suppressing the fire triad element of sources of ignition by clearing shrubs and trees is much more economical and less disruptive than multidecade urban redevelopment. On a going forward basis, more thought could be given to newer fire-aware building, if it doesn’t take the bureaucratically clogged housing approval process in CA into full blockage. (What’s the chance of that?) This article sounds either like a grift or AI or both.
- defrost 2y agoIt meanders as an article, it does repeatedly return to the core message: This fundamental misunderstanding has likewise led to a misunderstanding of prevention. No longer is it a matter of preventing wildfires but instead preventing points of ignition within communities by employing “home-hardening” strategies — proper landscaping, fire-resistant siding — and enjoining neighbors in collective efforts such as brush clearing. This aligns with the post urban fire recommendations in Canberra, Australia some years back - hardened homes, clean gutters, fewer easily ignited shrubs close to flammable buildings, etc. Wildfires will happen, embers will rain from the sky .. how prepared is your home to be ignition resistant when that happens?
- mitchbob 2y agohttps://archive.ph/2025.01.11-122128/https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2025-01-11/fire-experts-asses-los-angeles-blazes-amid-changing-times https://archive.ph/2025.01.11-122128/https://www.latimes.com...
- SoftTalker 2y ago"... warnings to clear dead vegetation and to wet dry brush within 10 feet of the house with periodic, prolonged sprinklings." I thought watering lawns and plants was banned in much of California, to conserve water?
- ColdTakes 2y agoI lived in California for 26 years. If this is true, nobody listens.
- esafak 2y agoThey do. In my HOA we let the grass go brown to conserve water and, at a domestic level, we rarely took baths (vs showers).
- cdme 2y agoIt's not. There are often limits on watering frequency and more folks are switching to native plants/drought tolerant plants.
- snakeyjake 2y agoLike many things with California, sensible policies that are very effective and will eventually be standard in other states are presented incorrectly for many different (usually financial) reasons in order to turn public opinion against them to delay their spread. Commercial/industrial properties are not permitted to water grass lawns with drinkable water. Commercial/industrial properties are not permitted to use drinkable water to water lawns within 48 hours of 1/4" of rainfall. Commercial/industrial properties are not permitted to use drinkable water to water lawns with so much water that it runs off the lawn into streets or storm drains. https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/conservation/regs/docs/2023/FAQ_SWRCBwaterrestrictions_20230605.pdf https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/conservation/regs/docs/2023/F... Landscaping businesses and landscaping supply retailers launched a campaign several years ago framing the above as "watering lawns and plants is going to be banned in much California". It appears that campaign was partially successful. Commercial/industrial properties can install water recycling systems and use all of the greywater they can get to water their lawns. There are additional local restrictions that depend on the severity of the water supply situation but those are too numerous to list, but at worst none of them prevent weekly watering of plants and lawns adjacent to dwellings.
- bugglebeetle 2y agoThe inconvenient truth is that California’s electrical infrastructure is woefully out of date because of utility company greed and malfeasance. The Democratic Party machine here in the state is too corrupt and asleep at the wheel to do anything about it. See also the management of state’s water resources. Instead of proactively shutting off power during the high wind period, they left it on, and of course the decrepit equipment up in the bone dry mountains exploded and set everything on fire again.
- cdme 2y agoThat's not the fault of the party you're blaming it on. The utilities fail to do so and have (and continue to) face lawsuits and repercussions. If the state were to intervene with their operation further I imagine you'd take issue with that meddling. It's certainly not caused by Delta smelt or a failure to rake leaves in the forest either.
- bugglebeetle 2y agoThe government is already a utility provider, and the absence of LADWP shut offs is the likely cause of the Palisades Fire. Same thing with the Eaton Fire and Southern California Edison. So yes, actually, it is very much the fault of both parties I named.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoFires can get caused by all kinds of things beyond power lines. Its added risk but its only really a risk because the wind, humidity, and fuel load were so ideal. At that point it could be a cigarette butt or freak lightning storm or an arsonist and it would do in the hillside all the same.
- bugglebeetle 2y agoThe recent (across several years) major fires have been caused by utility companies, so while you might live in fear of hypothetical arsonists, freak lightning storms, and cigarette butts, it seems more productive to direct our attention to the actual causes.
- JohnMakin 2y agoI don't really see what is an "inconvenient truth" here, and their "prevention" seems to be basically "we need better fireproofing standards in homes." The thing is, many of the homes in these areas are already fireproofed! I struggle to understand how anyone can think this is entirely preventable when you're dealing with 60+ mph winds and these kind of dry conditions. That, to me, is the inconvenient truth here - that this area may not be habitable long-term to the degree and density in which it is.
- hapless 2y agoFireproofing isnt mandatory, so people dont do it People like lawns and shrubberies, and they hate spending even one dollar extra on roofing when they know a taxpayer-backed insurance policy will cover their substandard construction
- hiatus 2y ago> they hate spending even one dollar extra on roofing when they know a taxpayer-backed insurance policy will cover their substandard construction So people would prefer to lose all of their belongings and be displaced?
- senordevnyc 2y agoYou never think it's going to happen to you...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lq9AJ8yrfs 2y agoYes. They are clearly preferring to save their money on insurance and keep the chance to lose all their belongings and be displaced. That is a fair way to say what happens when people with the option to buy insurance don't. Including people both whose houses burnt down and whose houses didn't burn down. In economics there is a difference between stated preferences and economic or "revealed" preferences. It shows what people say they want and what people do with their money are not always the same thing. Sometimes especially what people say and what people do with their money differ in predictable ways. It can be fun to juxtapose the observed behaviors with what people say. Makes for very compelling and sometimes cynical commentary.
- whimsicalism 2y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42674440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42674440