3 ms·
Okay, I hadn't really picked up on the implications of well-ordering there. Though the (im)possibility of well-ordering all reals doesn't really matter here.
by Dylan16807 2y ago
Okay, I hadn't really picked up on the implications of well-ordering there.
Though the (im)possibility of well-ordering all reals doesn't really matter here. Computable reals can by sorted by their programs, and definable reals can be sorted by their definitions. So if you have a "concrete definition of definable reals", then the system you use gives you ways to well-order them. And if you want to "refer to the first real that’s undefinable in that system", you can make a new system2 that encapsulates the old system1.
That might prove we can't have a universal system for defining things, which would be disappointing but workable.
Or maybe it's just that "the first real that's undefinable in system1" is not concrete, so we can reject it as a description of a number, and then the consequences are much smaller.