14 ms·
EFF, Reddit, Mozilla, others launch Internet Defense League and Cat Signal
- whichdan 14y agoReally? A giant cat?
- bhousel 14y agoThey could have picked much worse...
- ihsw 14y agoGoatse (for example)?
- ralfn 14y agoIt is not supposed to be a lobbyist. It is supposed to be a poltical movement. Its political marketing aimed at voters. It should target the type of teens on facebook, that you and i may look down upon. As far as im concerned, they dont even go far enough. We need a comic. We need memes. RESCUE MONORAIL CAT FROM THE CLUTCHES OF THE EVIL INTERNET HATE LEAGUE. FIRE UP YOUR MEMES AND BLAST THESE CORRUPT SENIORS OUT OF CONGRESS. That kind of stuff!
- wickedchicken 14y ago> It should target the type of teens on facebook The type of teen who legally can't vote? Sounds effective.
- ralfn 14y agoMany of them can. And they are still easier to convince, that an 80 year old that still uses racial slurs.
- coolnow 14y agoI can't even tell if you're being sarcastic anymore. These "memes" are driving me crazy.
- ralfn 14y agoNot sarcastic. Question: do you need convincing, or are you not the target audience? Im suspecting that most people here, are already being served well by the EFF. Consider this a branch, with a different tone, aimed at the facebook / youtube / 9gag crowd. And its still usefull for us, since we can eaily integrate the "alarm" with our own websites. My memes were an exaggeration, but they were not sarcastic. Lets just hope the people here can be practical enough to accept that maybe the tone of voice isnt for us, it is the most effective way to promote a cause we all already care deeply about.
- petitmiam 14y agoThis reminded me of Anonymous rallying the troops for some LOIC action. I think the Internet Defense League has got it right.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoYeah, I can't take them seriously unless they embed a video; maybe Piano Cat playing a slow, ominous melody, or a call-to-arms. Piano cat plays Prepare for battle soldier Evil is afoot
- dredmorbius 14y agos/call-to-arms/call-to-paws/
- kylek 14y agowould you prefer an elephant or a donkey instead?
- victork2 14y agoWell it embodies the best and the worst of internet movements. While the foundations are good: protecting the web from bad laws, restrictions etc... the execution is really ridiculous. Imagine you're an old style Senator or representative and you see that website with a weird ass looking cat... Do you really think it's going to make them think you're anything but a joke? I find that the words used are equally ridiculous: "League", "XXX signal". It really feels like a little club of geeks trying to have an impact in the world and it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. It could have been a great idea, it's ruined by a poor execution. edit: I have seen a lot of negative reactions and I appreciate people taking the time to answer to me. I won't edit my previous comment but let me add some things: I didn't mean to be insulting but if you want it to be a democratic movement you have to avoid inside jokes at all cost. It's literally filled with Reddit/ geek pop culture references and it won't take off in the general public because a very large portion of the population do not understand or don't like it. It's like saying a meme out loud: you feel ridiculous. For old style senators I am talking about basically any person over 35 that has no idea what reddit/ twitter/ cat facts are and who will find that ridiculous. Yes Senators and representatives are supposed to work for you, but it's like for everything they have to take you seriously. We belong to the Z generation but in order to talk to other generations we have to use common references and avoid cats or internet memes or super hero folklore for what it matters. Serious business in two words.
- humblepie 14y agoI agree with your premise. But I think when it gets momentum and gets picked up by the news media, there will be lots of 'explainers' on TV and the web.
- ralfn 14y agoI think you have democracy backwards. We are not to serve our politicians, they are here to serve us. They dont care what a small group of nerds and tech companies want and think. They care what average people think they want. Symbolism, accessable tone of voice .. Thats extremely relevant. You shouldnt compare it to lobbyist webites. You should compare it those of political movements and politically oriented charities. The memification of the message is brilliant marketing, because its funny, accesible and honest. Rescue the lolcats from the evil clutches of the internet hate league! So load up your meme gun and blast these seniors out of congress.
- zwdr 14y agoI just cant take such initiatives seriously if they have Facebook-Buttons...
- Xavura 14y agoHow else do you propose they get the word out without Facebook/Twitter etc. buttons?
- zwdr 14y agoI'm not against using these buttons, the harmful/annoying thing is that they're used to set tracking cookies. The most simple solution would be to put them on an extra page or only enable them when the user clicks some button. But I'm sure if smart people think about it they find much more solutions. Obviously the designers of this site didnt, and thats what I dont like- being against "bad monopolies" and giving FB more data? Seriously?
- nikcub 14y agouse a browser that blocks third party cookies by default. safari does, opera does and google has an option buried somewhere 9 clicks away in the settings.
- lukejduncan 14y agoI think the poster has a legitimate point. As an end user you can protect yourself, but as an organization that cares about Internet freedom it's a legitimate concern to consider: "Are we enabling tracking through the use of our advocacy, and if so can we avoid that." Although, I wouldn't go so far as to say that I can't take them seriously because they decided to use the buttons.
- nikcub 14y agoI think this organization has bigger issues than facebook buttons on its website
- dotborg 14y ago"bad monopolies".. so which monopolies are good?
- RobAtticus 14y agoMonopolies are not inherently bad. A monopoly on some good or service might be that way because it provides the best product at a fair price and there's no way somebody else could beat them. It's only when a monopoly starts using its position of power to either unfairly gain advantage in a similar market, start screwing over customers that they become "bad," or some other tactic that ruins competition or hurts consumers.
- __alexs 14y ago> Monopolies are not inherently bad. Yes they are. They are bad because they are a massive risk center to their customers. For a small industry this is just kind of annoying, but for a massive one it can have a detrimental effect on the entire economy and not having massive single points of failure in your economy should be (and sometimes is) considered a matter of national security.
- TylerE 14y agoTry convincing someone to build out basic utilities without giving them one. I like to be able to flush my toilet, personally.
- stinkytaco 14y agoWhat about wireless spectrum? Should we just give access to spectrum to everyone who wants it? Your radio, cell phone and wireless Internet would stop working within weeks, I'm sure. Sometime monopoly is not only good, but necessary.
- __alexs 14y agoThat the status quo for RF spectrum is that of government granted monopoly in most of the world is not evidence that this is a necessary way to operate. In fact there have been numerous proposals to change the regulation of important RF ranges into a more typical commons based usage model. e.g. the "whitespace" wireless broadband systems that are still fighting their way through the FCC regulatory quagmire in the US. I'd even argue that the regional monopoly system we currently have actually frequently does have to act in communal ways in the best interests of different providers across regulatory regions. People without billions of dollars on the table just aren't allowed in those conversations.
- dtjohnnymonkey 14y agoIt seems a little strange that they want their users to put hosted JavaScript on their sites. Just doesn't feel like "freedom" to me. Couldn't they control a lot of sites or steal information by changing that script to something malicious?
- radagaisus 14y agoDo you have g+ / tweet / like buttons on your site? Google Analytics? Disqus? jQuery CDN?
- dholowiski 14y agoFor that matter, have you ever run "yum update httpd" without reviewing the source code first?
- nikcub 14y agoThis part makes me uncomfortable: > Our organization and network helped to defeat SOPA/PIPA [..] The Internet Defense League continues this work. But it depends on its members' donations It then goes on to ask for a donation to support staff who 'work behind the scenes'. I think to people who are unfamiliar with what happen around the community action with SOPA and PIPA this section can be interpreted as the Internet Defense League taking credit for the defeat of the bills. It also suggests that without financial contributions from members that this work wouldn't happen and SOPA/PIPA/what-comes-next may just succeed next time, even though this organization wasn't even around during the SOPA debate. There is also no transparency around how this money that is raised will be spent. Who will be hired? What will they do? What will be volunteer roles and what will be hired roles? Weren't SOPA and PIPA defeated by volunteers in ad hoc communities and not paid salarymen working for a quasi online charity? Why is this not structured as a charitable organization? Why is my donation not tax deductible? Who are the people behind this? Where are they based? Why is this so United States centric? Who is backing this financially so far? Where is the about page? Is this a scam? There should be a lot more details on that page before you ask people for money. I would have preferred that donations were directed to the EFF, and that the online organization is done by volunteers - as, you know, it has worked just fine in the past.
- ralfn 14y agoConsidering the list of supporting sites, that are behind this project, claiming to play a crucial part of the defeat of SOPA, would be totally correct. But they dont actually do that. They use "we" in a politically rethoric form, where they try to convince the reader what their position already is. Its like saying "we the american people, need lower taxes to be free". Its a marketing trick.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tommorris 14y agoWell, Wikipedia's shutdown played a pretty significant part in the SOPA/PIPA action... and Wikimedia has decided to not take part in the Internet Defense League. https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Requests_for_comment/Internet_Defense_League https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Requests_for_comment/Interne...
- tokenadult 14y agoAs a multicultural person who has lived in more than one country, as usual when I see initiatives like this, I wonder how well they will work in China, behind the Great Firewall. http://www.greatfirewallofchina.org/ http://www.greatfirewallofchina.org/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-17910953 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-17910953 I posted a Chinese saying attributed to Confucius the last time we discussed an effort to use the Internet to bring about more transparency. 始吾於人也,聽其言而信其行。今吾於人也,聽其言而觀其行。"At first my attitude toward people was to listen to their words and to trust their deeds. Now my attitude toward people is to listen to their words and observe their deeds." I listen to the words "Internet freedom should not be restricted" and I say, as people did during the 1960s civil rights movement, "Right on!" But then I observe deeds and I wonder if anyone has an effectual plan to stop the prior restraint of all print publications in China or the direct party cadre oversight of all broadcast media in China. I can access the Chinese media (and do) just fine, via the World Wide Web, but the common people of China, even the many who now have Internet access, are far from being able to access any available news source from anywhere around the world to the same degree that most Hacker News participants can. All kinds of tough world problems would be easier to solve if the common people of China (and Russia, and a few other countries) had less restricted access to news and information, both about the country they live in and all other countries, and more opportunity to practice political dissent and open discussion of public policy, culminating in voting for national leaders in free and fair elections. If an Internet Cat Signal helps bring that about, I'm all for it. But if the Cat Signal serves mostly as yet another silly publicity tie-in for a Hollywood movie, I have better uses of my time and the server for my personal website than to link into the project. I would really like to see an Internet freedom project that has significant advice and direction from political dissidents experienced with one-party dicatorial regimes, such as the current regime in China. Such a project could help Western Internet freedom activists better understand what issues really matter, and what technical means can overcome determined governmental opposition. See http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/world/july-dec12/dictators_07-16.html http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/world/july-dec12/dictators_07... for examples of research on this important topic. Best wishes to everyone working for more free flow of information to more people all over the world.
- slurgfest 14y ago
- dholowiski 14y agoJust donated - now a member. Will be installing the code on my blog. If you think this is stupid and ridiculous, what exactly are you doing to save the Internet? [edit]I just became an EFF member too.
- lmm 14y ago>If you think this is stupid and ridiculous, what exactly are you doing to save the Internet? I'm holding my rock. It keeps internet-killers away.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sageikosa 14y agoAny idea on how this league will be governed? Does each participant vote on what should become actionable? Will it's governance be by elective representation?
- ybother 14y agoAny idea on what it actually does? How does it detect "danger"? It seems more like an attempt to co-opt internet freedom movements than actually do anything at all.
- ralfn 14y agoTheyll be able to spam, hopefully millions of websites, at once, with the same exact political message. If they use this sparringly ( only for things as big as SOPA ), most site owners wouldnt mind. And the impact, together with all major cities suddenly blasting a cat light, will likely reach the news. At which point, people like the EFF ( which are also part of this initiative ), will likely have serious, well spoken individuals available for interviews and such.
- zmmmmm 14y agoIndeed. I like the idea of this, but without a clear constitution and statement of their mission I can't sign up for it and I certainly won't be injecting their code into my web sites.
- wickedchicken 14y agoHaha yeah! Fuck 'thinking,' I want a cat on the internet to tell me to yell at senators! Absolutely nothing about this feels like mob rule!
- mcguire 14y agoYou're not terribly familiar with the concepts of democracy, right?
- zimbatm 14y agoWhy make the tracking code so complicated ? Couldn't it be simply written like this ? : <script async src="//members.internetdefenseleague.org/include/?variant=banner"> Also the url is the referrer no ?
- rwhitman 14y agoThe async property doesn't work in IE
- shmerl 14y agoDid they avoid using bats for copyright reasons?-) Cat doesn't cut it as much as bat I guess.
- juan_juarez 14y agoIt's the internet. We like cats. Cute cat pictures make the internet work.
- tomp 14y agoToo bad this seems very US centric...
- iuguy 14y agoIf you're in the UK you could do a lot worse than join the ORG[1]. Maybe non-US resident HN'ers can co-opt this thread to post their own local feline alert movements. [1] - http://www.openrightsgroup.org/ http://www.openrightsgroup.org/
- petitmiam 14y agoIt's a shame non-US residents would have to set up something locally. I had hoped for a truly global 'Internet Defense League', which then could have smaller branches for country/region specific issues.
- dholowiski 14y agoAs is the core infrastructure of the internet...
- vipervpn 14y agoNEWS FLASH: Being bitter, apathetic and contrarian does not make you sound smart. This is undeniably an awesome idea. Stop searching for flaws and help.
- mcguire 14y agoBut, but, I am bitter, apathetic, and contrarian!
- rufugee 14y agoOddly, signing up wouldn't work for me in chrome...only Firefox worked. When I submitted the form in chrome, is just reloaded the page.
- warmfuzzykitten 14y agoWorked for me in chrome.
- mherdeg 14y agoOh man, oh man, oh man, I miss putting little blue ribbons on all my Web pages' footers!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ribbon_Online_Free_Speech_Campaign http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ribbon_Online_Free_Speech_...
- SleekoNiko 14y agoAt the risk of being productive, what is the benefit of using this "service" over posting my own message on my website? (Honest question)
- mtgx 14y agoFrom Techdirt: "Earlier this year, I wrote about the Hacking Society gathering, put on by Union Square Ventures. During that discussion, Clay Shirky brought up the idea of an "Internet Volunteer Fire Department" and Tiffiniy Cheng, from Fight for the Future, explained the IDL and how they were already working on it. You can watch that discussion to get a sense of the thinking behind this effort:" http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=XDTD9laPQWo http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=X...
- lee337 14y agohttp://i.imgur.com/K5Y88.png http://i.imgur.com/K5Y88.png
- tatsuke95 14y agoI can't believe there is so much negativity. I'm usually the guy who has something negative to say about everything, and end up in these threads where other people ask, "why so negative?" But this? This political action is literally what killed SOPA; that's not me talking, that's straight from Dodd's mouth. Now they've developed an easy call-to-action for future, similar bills? It's genius. Politicians thrive on the historical forgetfulness of the public. It was a matter of weeks before another bill similar to SOPA was in the works. The politicians will adjust their strategy and count on less political action the "next-time-around". I hope this can prevent it. Who cares if it's about cats and comics? That's the theme of a generation and internet culture. And (combined with their high unemployment and lower expectations of future standard of living) this generation is going to be a political force. Bank on it.
- losethos 14y agoJews are atheist since holocaust--hate God. God says... 15177 offerings. 29:12 And on the fifteenth day of the seventh month ye shall have an holy convocation; ye shall do no servile work, and ye shall keep a feast unto the LORD seven days: 29:13 And ye shall offer a burnt offering, a sacrifice made by fire, of a sweet savour unto the LORD; thirteen young bullocks, two rams, and fourteen lambs of the first year; they shall be without blemish: 29:14 And their meat offering shall be of flour mingled with oil, three tenth deals unto every bullock of the thirteen bullocks, two tenth deals to each ram of the two rams, 29:15 And a several tenth deal to each lamb of the fourteen lambs: 29:16 And one kid of the goats for a sin offering; beside the continual burnt offering, his meat offering, and his drink offering.
- tommorris 14y agoCripes, they've still got that shitty name. Anyone from the United Kingdom will immediately associate the name with the English Defence League, a violent far-right Islamophobic street protest movement. As branding ideas go, having a name that has that connotation is a really dumb choice.