3 ms·
The question has come up several times on the thread so far, and just to add my read to it: the claim that Los Angeles housing prices are inflated seems to rest
by tptacek 2y ago
The question has come up several times on the thread so far, and just to add my read to it: the claim that Los Angeles housing prices are inflated seems to rest in part on the fact that they're about to get a lot more expensive to insure. The annual costs of ownership of a house --- taxes, insurance, and upkeep, probably in that order --- work against the market value of a house. I live in an extremely high-tax inner-ring suburb of Chicago, and the conventional wisdom is that our taxes knock double-digit percentages off our home market value.
Maybe the article is saying the same effect could hit markets around the country more broadly as insurers everywhere jack rates up in response to climate change?
As mismanagement and environmental issues unfold, in the narrative I play in my head to keep myself sane, insurers are kind of heroic. I know they aren't really, but: one thing you can say for them, they're some of the only players in our economy that are required to price externalities. Political bodies and residents can delude themselves about risks indefinitely, but an insurer that ignores them will be insolvent. You could write a state statute capping insurance rates, but, as you've seen, that just forces insurers to leave the market. They don't have a choice. It's kind of wonderful.
- chii 2y ago> are required to price externalities wait until the property owners there start demanding socialized property insurance!
- tptacek 2y agoThey already are, but that's kind of besides my point. I don't doubt that California can throw billions of dollars at subsidizing housing built on parcels so dangerous no insurer can underwrite there. I don't live or die based on whether people can afford to live in Pacific Palisades. But it's somehow sanity-preserving for me to watch insurers exit markets (or drastically increase rates). At least one party to this system has to acknowledge reality, and no organizing or speechifying gets you around it.