3 ms·
"is a crank" is really far from "has some controversial or heterodox views" I'm not arguing that everything Lustig says is correct, on the contrary, I've gone
by scoofy 2y ago
"is a crank" is really far from "has some controversial or heterodox views"
I'm not arguing that everything Lustig says is correct, on the contrary, I've gone out of my way to criticize him. My point in this conversation is that saying a reputable scientist, at a reputable institution, doing reputable research is somehow a crank... is bananas.
- Dylan16807 2y agoIf he actually said it's the same impact, that is much closer to crank than controversial without a few pieces of really strong evidence. And the counterargument you had for calorie restriction described a situation that is not calorie restriction. I'm not saying he's a crank for sure, but my evaluation of him is riding on whether loeg's description of his claims is accurate, not the evidence you brought, because that evidence really does not support the plausibility of those claims.
- loeg 2y agoWhat do you imagine "crank" means that differs from having some heterodox views? That is the definition of this use. "a person who has strange or unusual ideas and beliefs" https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/crank https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/crank