2 ms·
I don't think anyone disputes that it was a real problem. It just wasn't the problem it was hyped up to be (and no, not because all the bugs were fixed). That'
by IshKebab 2y ago
I don't think anyone disputes that it was a real problem. It just wasn't the problem it was hyped up to be (and no, not because all the bugs were fixed).
That's obviously mainly the fault of the media trying to make the story more exciting, as they always do.
- zamalek 2y agoOne of the critics in the post (Anthony Finkelstein) very much claimed that it wasn't a real problem, it sounds like he might have had an audience too.
- ZiiS 2y agoHad you heard of him prior to this post though?
- richardw 2y ago“On 8 February 1999, while testing Y2K compliance in a computer system monitoring nuclear core rods at Peach Bottom Nuclear Generating Station, Pennsylvania, instead of resetting the time on the external computer meant to simulate the date rollover a technician accidentally changed the time on the operation systems computer. This computer had not yet been upgraded, and the date change caused all the computers at the station to crash. It took approximately seven hours to restore all normal functions, during which time workers had to use obsolete manual equipment to monitor plant operations.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_2000_problem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_2000_problem We do not have a full list of problems that were averted. The only way you can state it was overblown is if you know what would have happened if we hadn’t fixed all the systems. There were definitely countries that didn't do much and had very few issues, but that doesn't prove that e.g. the far more computerised West wouldn't have had. The only rational course was to check every system that the failure of which would cost more than checking it. It was insurance against a problem that had unknown levels of downside until the work was done.
- IshKebab 2y agoYeah exactly. If that's the worst thing you can find that happened then it falls faaar short of what the media were saying.
- richardw 2y agoThat’s not how logic works. You can’t prove something wouldn’t have been impactful because there were few ill effects after the downside has been reduced. The point is the downside was unknowable beforehand, and we don’t have a full list of all the fixes and what would have happened if they weren’t fixed. One nuclear issue having occurred in what should have been a safe and controlled context demonstrates that there could have easily been 100 nuclear issues, all in one night. This is what happened because the system wasn’t patched yet. Extrapolate to banks, payment networks, shipping, defence. Professionals don’t YOLO this shit. Many smart people were around making rational decisions.
- Delphiza 2y agoBy what definition of 'hype'? It was absolutely a significant problem that needed to be 'hyped' in order to get people involved and businesses to spend money. I was involved in the periphery of Y2K, and saw significant budgets being released as a result of the hype. The OPs point is that because those budgets were spent (on the right things, hopefully), the failures did not occur, which means that some hype was necessary.
- IshKebab 2y agoMaybe you don't remember but the news at the time was talking about it as if it was going to be a nuclear apocalypse or something. It's annoyingly hard to search for old newspapers & TV news (does anyone know of a good free site for that?). The first thing I found was this Y2K survival kit: https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1824776914/vintage-y2k-survival-kit-never-opened-if https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1824776914/vintage-y2k-survi... > Futurists predict that riots will sweep through cities all around the world after Y2K knocks out electricity and destroys banking and commerce systems. That's the sort of nonsense that was "promised", and to a large extent, exploited by Y2K consultants. So when people say "it wasn't a problem", they aren't saying "you didn't have to do some IT work to make sure your phone system didn't go down" or whatever. They mean there were no planes falling out of the sky, trains crashing, riots & looting, etc.
- pdejager 2y agoThe year2000(dot)com was the clearing house for much of the non-hypearticles from IT folks. The way back machine has it archived. I’d suggest looking at the copies of the site towards the end of 1999. A good example of such an article was ‘a crock of clocks’ If you wanted to hear my take on y2k 20 years later? Check the podcast: y2k an autobiography Cheers