4 ms·
Adaptation to a Viscous Snowball Earth Ocean as Path to Complex Multicellularity (2021)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 2y agoSuch a mechanism would make complex life even more rare in the universe. Better this solution to the Fermi paradox than that sentient species tend to destroy themselves with technology.
- pfdietz 2y agoWe want the Great Filter to be behind us.
- rbanffy 2y agoI very much love the idea the Great Filter being behind us, but, just in case, we shouldn't ignore the possibility of multiple Great Filters.
- pfdietz 2y agoEvery time a SETI search comes up empty, I am happy.
- rbanffy 2y agoEvery time it comes up empty I think of how many filters we still have to clear.
- pfdietz 2y agoIf we find abundant ET life, it's evidence we're fucked, since at least one filter is in front of us. Only by having little or no ET within cosmological distances would the possibility remain open there's no GF ahead of us.
- wholinator2 2y agoPlease explain because i would intuit the opposite. The less life's we see, the less likely that life survives to/through technological ages that would allow them to talk to us. If we see abundant life the it must be very easy to survive, thus less filters
- pfdietz 2y agoIf life is abundant, there must have been something to prevent it from spreading, now or in the distant past. The fact that we evolved in an apparently empty universe, rather than in one that's been totally colonized, implies something stops this from happening. This thing is called the Great Filter, and it's apparently extremely effective. If the GF is in front of us, in a universe with lots of ETI, our chances of evading it are extremely small. After all, no one else has; why would we be so special? Nick Bostrum has called detection of ETI, or even complex ET life, the worst news mankind would ever receive. It would be a death sentence for our future. https://nickbostrom.com/papers/where-are-they/ https://nickbostrom.com/papers/where-are-they/
- svnt 2y agoYou can have abundant life that is functionally isolated by physics, or said differently, by the degree of technological and societal advancement required to traverse the space between. Great distances and inherent speed limits seem like a decent way to accomplish that.
- pfdietz 2y agoI think it's clear that interstellar travel, while not trivial, should be possible for a civilization just a bit more advanced than our own. The energy or material resources required for interstellar colonization are very small compared to the resources available. It doesn't even require relativistic speeds, although reaching (say) 0.01 c doesn't require outrageous engineering, just a large spacecraft and lots of hydrogen bombs. Now, perhaps it's universally true that civilizations don't advance much beyond where we currently are, or don't persist for sufficiently long for interstellar colonization to be successful. These would also be very depressing outcomes if they are imposed on us by the GF.
- api 2y agoI've always seen a problem with the idea of the great filter: why do we think the filter is one thing or one discrete barrier? Why couldn't there be a very large number of low-probability filters and/or a continuous probability of failure spread across billions of years? Add them all up and the cumulative effect would be the same as a single great filter, but there would not be one single primary hurdle that needs to be cleared. This and the Fermi paradox itself are really just speculations. We have only one data point, which makes it impossible to say anything definitive.
- pfdietz 2y agoThe Great Filter could indeed be an aggregate of subfilters, but this wouldn't change the argument.
- pohl 2y agoWouldn't it potentially make it less rare, if it turns out to be an additional mechanism? (Isn't it possible that there'd be multiple paths?)
- billiam 2y agoI think the rare Earth hypotheses get it backward, it all looks unlikely when you only have one data point. I think that complex life finds a way and it all looks like a six cushion bank shot in retrospect.
- billiam 2y agoThis is more of a hypothesis than a well-rounded and evaluated theory. I could argue that rather than the viscosity of seawater the isolation of hydrothermal vents during the Snowball Earth period was the primary driver of eukaryote evolution and diversity. Isolation makes evolution speed up, and homogeneity slows it down in general. Fascinating to think about it though.
- pdl410 2y agoIsolation = Energy concentration
- pdl410 2y agoThe endosymbiosis that resulted in the harnessing of mitochondrial energy production appears to have only happened once (see work by Nick Lane) and resulted in a ~20 fold increase in available energy to the cell was followed very closely by the Cambrian explosion. We could still all still be bacteria today without it. https://nick-lane.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Lane-J-Theoret-Biol-Margulis-issue.pdf https://nick-lane.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Lane-J-Theo...
- baq 2y agoOnce in a billion years is some very long odds bet. Drake’s equation should include this as a separate factor.
- sandworm101 2y agoIf it happened by chance, then we are alone in the universe. If literally trillions of bacteria all living and dying (ie evolving) with generations measured in hours ... and it still took a billion years to happen, then there is no hope for multicellular life elsewhere. There would have been more bacteria in earth's ancient ocean than there are planets in the visible universe. Hope of ever contacting multicellular aliens is over. OR ... the switch to multicellular life was triggered by some sort of event, an evolved response to an environmental change. In that case then it is reasonable to think that it would happen on other planets too. So I really do hope that it wasn't a matter of pure chance. I want us to meet or at lease hear someone else some day.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoIt seems to me that multicellularity and the corresponding rise of complexity would be very useful adaptations in ANY evolutionary environment. They would give the species more capabilities and help to "game the game" by creating more axis of future variation. How can a unicellular critter compete with all the varied descendant species of a multicellular one? No doubt water temperature/viscocity - environmental factors - did provide an evolutionary pressure for some extant species, but it seems highly speculative to try to write an exact evolutionary history of what factors drove what changes.
- Avshalom 2y ago>>How can a unicellular critter compete with all the varied descendant species of a multicellular one? The prevalence of unicellular life on Earth should tell you that this is a malformed question.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoYes, I suppose, although of course at one time it had been 100%. Maybe only the strongest lineages survived ? What I really meant, rather than multicellularity being invincible, was that it's an obviously beneficial direction, and doesn't seem like it would need any extreme environmental stress to prove beneficial.
- dtgriscom 2y agoMy first thought was "Hah! Water viscosity doesn't change that much with temperature!" But it actually does; it's twice as viscous at 0°C than at 30°C. https://wiki.anton-paar.com/us-en/water/ https://wiki.anton-paar.com/us-en/water/