5 ms·
System76 built the fastest Windows Arm PC
- benatkin 2y agoHalf a gig of RAM would sure be great for ninja builds.
- benatkin 2y agoHalf a terabyte*
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- legulere 2y agoSadly the article lacks comparison in single core performance with Apple chips. Comparison with x86 chips would also be interesting.
- unnah 2y agoBased on the presented multi-core benchmarks, the single-core performance is 40-50% of a single M2 Ultra core: 40% on the HPL Linpack benchmark, and 50% on Cinebench. That is compared to the average M2 Ultra core, counting both the fast "performance" cores and the slow "efficiency" cores. So the M2 performance cores are even faster than that, never mind the M3 or M4. Then again, you cannot buy a 128-core computer from Apple, so it's an apples to oranges comparison.
- jmclnx 2y agoDo not let the title fool you. It also talks about Linux too.
- exabrial 2y agoI cannot wait until they get into Mobile ARM and PopOS with Cosmic is a thing. Apple's quality on the hardware has [finally] returned after the War On Ports was declared over, but the software is still getting jammed with useless BS, parlor tricks, and gizmos that will be forgotten, while ignoring core stability, QOL issues, and further becoming a nanny-state. I'm ready to jump ship.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoAgreed. Our experience developing a low level networking app leads us to believe that MacOS is far buggier than either Windows or Linux.
- diggan 2y ago> MacOS is far buggier than either Windows or Linux. On the UI/UX side of things, definitely a worse experience than even stock Windows or Linux with Gnome, and that's coming from someone who generally likes it but got so tired of recent (at the time) bugs and jankiness that I had to migrate elsewhere. This was probably around 2016 or so, around the time when it seemed like there was no QA department at all at Apple.
- brailsafe 2y ago> On the UI/UX side of things, definitely a worse experience than even stock Windows or Linux There's definitely been a bit of jank and a few poor design decisions made, but to compare it to Windows unfavorably is a bit overblown, considering Windows doesn't seem to have ever deleted code. Version to version on Windows just adds thin veneer over the old one, and leaves me scratching my head; many "They still have THIS!? wtf" moments, like putting carpet over a crack in the foundation
- diggan 2y ago> Version to version on Windows just adds thin veneer over the old one This + keeping the old stuff around is what makes Windows more fitting than macOS in a professional environment. Still, its hard for me to understand using either if you're a developer who favors stability. Just the other week I was unable to poweroff/reboot Windows without it locking down an update on next boot, which pisses me off. Of course, next time I wanted to use Windows, I just needed to check on something quickly, but then this forced update came back to bite me and what should have taken 2 minutes at tops now took 15 minutes.
- 2y ago
- Cshelton 2y agoWe were piloting the new Snapdragon X Elite Surface Laptops to roll them out to our org about 3 months ago. Loved everything about it, but when it came to software... things became messy. The MSFT Office suite was great, as well as any browser of course. Then we had to make sure some older Excel plugins worked for financial users, they didn't. Had to use some workarounds. We tried our front end app Node build pipeline.. we gave up and had to put it in a container to get it to build properly. Tried a few things through the cpu emulator, it was no where near Apple's at their launch of M1. Ultimately, we had to go back to the Intel Surface Laptops. It felt like the ARM laptops were rushed about a year too early...
- officeplant 2y agoThe really sad thing is the complete absence of support for WinARM when shit goes wrong. I've got one of Dell's Qualcomm 8CX Gen2 based inspirons that broke its windows install when it crashed on boot one day. Its been sitting on a shelf for almost 8 months and I periodically take it down to see if shits been fixed for restoring its install. Win11's built in self restore tools attempt to wipe and reinstall windows but ultimately fail and it reverts to the broken state. But this is actually better than 4 months ago when online reinstall function was ENTIRELY broken. It took until a month or so ago for Microsoft to even offer Win11 ARM iso's on their website that weren't virtual machine files. But these images don't work on my inspirion, I'm guessing they don't bake in 8cx Gen2 support. I can get it to boot into the installer but usb is broken entirely and therefore it can't see anything on the installer usb once its booted. Keep in mind WinARM products have been on the market for years at this point. Its insane vs restoring an x86 laptop. Dells tools for building a system restore usb are completely broken. I had to go into their text logs to get the web link and authkey to download the win11 iso. Even after building the boot drive it installs a broken version of win11 that can't successfully update, and has a constantly crashing explorer.exe. I contacted Dell support about this and got strung along for 3 months of back and forth emails before they told me I needed to upgrade to a paid support tier to have a functional laptop again. And then we get to linux where 8cx Gen2 support is a fucking void no one wants to touch because it has a different device tree than Gen1 or Gen3 which seemingly have some manner of linux support. I really hope any IT squad that gets suckered into buying SnapdragonX laptops is ready for a world of pain when something goes wrong.
- rbanffy 2y agoI love the design reminiscent of Silicon Graphics workstations.
- troyvit 2y agoYeah I was reading the article and started fast-forwarding through the description of how the machine was built because I wanted to get to all the Windows/Linux stuff, then was like wait this is System76 man! Their laptops are off the shelf stuff but their desktop hardware is just so classy (I worked for them for a year so I'm a bit biased).
- bluGill 2y agoI'm waiting for their in house laptop they keep saying they are working towards. They say their workstation cases and keyboards are learning steps to creating the laptop, but so far nothing is here
- darknavi 2y ago> Luckily, switching back to Linux solves that issue. Games not only run with 3D acceleration, they run smoothly. > ... Halo 3 ran just as smooth as an Xbox 360 ... A game originally authored for a PowerPC CPU (Xbox 360), ported to x86 (Windows), automatically translated for an ARM chip (Linux). Amazing!
- crowcroft 2y agoI would love to know how efficient it is through those ports and translations, vs running smoothly through sheer horsepower (Xbox 360 is nearly two decades old). Impressive nonetheless though!
- kelnos 2y ago> it's a lot faster compiling Arm software native on a monster Arm CPU than even the fastest AMD or Intel CPU with emulation. Running, sure, but compilation speed should be the same, assuming you're using a cross-compiler, which of course you would be. No emulation involved.
- geerlingguy 2y agoEdited the OP to clarify that it's compiling + running test suites, which I believe was the main motivation for this machine's existence (an automotive developer was frustrated with the speed running hundreds of arm64 ECU VMs.
- k_bx 2y agoCross-compiling software which relies on a big bunch of runtime libraries is a major pain in a big project. Have you ever had success with it?
- Aurornis 2y ago> The primary reason someone would buy this thing is for automotive development. Since most cars and infotainment systems run on Arm chips, building software with an Arm workstation makes sense—it's a lot faster compiling Arm software native on a monster Arm CPU than even the fastest AMD or Intel CPU with emulation. I think this is a misunderstanding on Jeff's part, or maybe he was given some bad marketing material. Emulating ARM software is slow, but cross-compiling for ARM is not. Cross-compilers do not rely on emulation to compile. The reason this machine compiles quickly is that it has 128 cores and a high TDP. > Note that you can buy every part of this system—aside from System76's case and support—from a retailer like NewEgg (e.g. the motherboard + CPU combo for $2349) should you wish to build a custom arm64 workstation PC. This link is to a different CPU that is not quite as fast as the one he tested (though still fast) and only has 10Gbe, not 25Gbe. Still a good bargain, but not the same part used in the system.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoCross-compiling can be a pain to set up, though. Sometimes it's easy, sometimes it isn't. I've definitely compiled under emulators in the past just to not have to deal with cross-compilers. I definitely wouldn't spend $7000 to avoid the pain though!
- taeric 2y agoIsn't it typically a flag, nowadays? Even for python, getting an install that works on ARM from X86 is largely `pip install --platform manylinux2014_aarch64 --only-binary=:all:`, if I have it right. I confess it took me longer to find that flag than I'd care to admit. But AWS Lambda using ARM made this something worth finding. And many of the alternatives on how to get the artifacts to deploy did focus on containers for emulation, if I'm remembering correctly.
- jitl 2y agoPython is doing a lot of abstracting for you. In the realm of building C/C++ software using an odd menagerie of system packages and from-source dependencies one might need to figure out the cross-build process of each dependency, and make a prefix for the cross-arch system libraries… it’s doable but the paved path is definitely narrow and there’s lots of thorns when you stray into the jungle. And then you still need to run the tests.
- 999900000999 2y ago>The nice thing about System76 selling this machine is you get their excellent support (you can choose from 1-3 years of support at purchase). This is a huge boon to businesses who elect to run open source software, because they get a fully-supported hardware configuration instead of having to figure out compatibility themselves. This entire thing reads like an advertisement. >Note that you can buy every part of this system—aside from System76's case and support—from a retailer like NewEgg (e.g. the motherboard + CPU combo for $2349) should you wish to build a custom arm64 workstation PC. 7000$ for a computer you can build for around 3500$. You can literally just take their part list and install the OS yourself. I understand companies need to make a profit, but this is nuts. Likewise in the laptop market your almost always better off installing Linux on a Windows laptop vs paying 2x for a System 76 version. Linux can't be simultaneously easy to install and justify on 100% markup.
- 6SixTy 2y agoSystem76 has their own UEFI BIOS and EC firmware, but that doesn't even make it better since you can hypothetically buy a Clevo laptop and mod it to be a brother from another mother.
- 999900000999 2y agoWhat's the ultimate difference for an end user. Just buy a Thinkpad or another laptop that has good support for Linux. I definitely get the argument that your supporting Linux by buying a System 76 computer, but the last time I checked IBM Red Hat isn't exactly a charity.
- 6SixTy 2y agoI know there are a bunch of laptops that have good support for Linux, but I'm talking one more level deep than that. Good support for Coreboot UEFI is hard to come by, and FOSS EC firmware (this makes laptop specific features possible) to my knowledge is unique to System76. Those two components are the unique selling propositions System76 has over your standard Linux-ready laptop. And they aren't quite unique when you realize System76 is commissioning laptops from the likes of Clevo. E: I know I just rehashed by last comment a little bit, but it felt like the point didn't come across properly. I was supporting the mention that the Linux-first USP of S76 wasn't strong enough, and building on top of it.
- UncleOxidant 2y agoThis would be a very nice Linux workstation. Not going to rush right out and get one soon, but something to keep an eye on.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lmaoguy 2y agoKinda like being the fastest double amputee in a foot race at the recovery center.
- nixosbestos 2y agoI sure wish Jeff would learn some Nix or NixOS. Not only does cross-compilation not need to be hard, there is a cached flake that supplies Cosmic for aarch64-linux.
- znpy 2y agoI'd love to be able to get a specced down, "low"-power, version of this to use as a home server: - lower-end cpu (the 32-core version would be just fine for me) - keeping the possibilty having lot of ram around (128gb? 256gb? 512gb?) - low-end gpu or no gpu at all (it would be headless anyway) - keep the ipmi around - maybe some 4 hot-swappable 3.5" drive bays ? I could see myself blowing 2000-3000$ on something like as long as I can keep it working for ten years. Maybe update it a bit over the years. And i'm not joking about the ten-years: I'm still using a 2014-era HP MicroServer Gen8 and it works great. It shows its age, but it does still work great.