10 ms·
Could the Soviet Union have survived?
- brickfaced 2y agoIt's a shame for the sake of memes that they couldn't hold out long enough for a Unicode flag emoji
- somat 2y agoAs a consolation there is good ol' U262D. I have mine set up as <Multi_key> <c> <c> <c> <p> : "\xe2\x98\xad" #symbol representing proletarian solidarity between agricultural and industrial workers
- brickfaced 2y agoOK but as I'm not a mentally-ill X poster I don't use that one
- Dwedit 2y agoTheir top level domain (.su) has mysteriously survived...
- bdangubic 2y agothought you were joking… i learned something today :)
- neom 2y agoToday I learned: https://www.register.su/ https://www.register.su/ Very interesting page, reminds me of old internet in it's writing style.
- gruez 2y agoTechnically that's not even the official site for the .su tld, it's for a registrar that operates out of the US, but there are many. https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/su.html https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/su.html
- jchook 2y ago> Sorry, all domain sales have been suspended. We no longer register nor transfer already registered domain names to new owners. Dang..
- lazide 2y agoThey also operate out of New York.
- tivert 2y agoGandi appears to still allow registration of them: https://www.gandi.net/en/domain/tld/su https://www.gandi.net/en/domain/tld/su. I didn't actually register one, but they quoted a price of $28.31 for the first year then $63.98/year afterwards.
- WeylandYutani 2y agoThey were clinging to an idiotic economic theory for decades after Xiaoping already told the Chinese to get rich again so no.
- hinkley 2y agoGorbachev thought Chernobyl was the death knell, but if it hadn’t been that it would have been something else.
- Finnucane 2y agoChernobyl hastened the end. Not only was it an enormous ecological and economic disaster, that caused, as the article says, a loss of confidence in the central government, but it was a boost for the Ukrainian independence movement. And without Ukraine, there really is no Soviet Union, no empire. Just Russia and few satellite states.
- hinkley 2y agoWhat I’m saying is that Chernobyl was evidence of rot at the core. Really powerful evidence, but the rot was a fact, not a perception. If not Chernobyl, and I really wish it had been anything else, something else would have gone spectacularly off the rails because while you can hide many truths, incompetence and apathy both tend to reveal the truth of themselves. Corruption can conceal itself because it serves its own purposes. Concealing apathy is a fight against its own motives.
- uncletaco 2y agoThe Soviet Union collapsed less than 5 years after Deng retired in 1989 and his economic model had only begun to bear fruit in the mid 80s. “For decades” is a wildly ignorant thing to say.
- idlewords 2y agoHis name is Deng unless you guys were best buds or something. The Shenzhen Special Economic Zone was established in 1980, less than nine years before the collapse of the Soviet Bloc.
- roenxi 2y agoThere are a lot of ways to break crowds up into 2 groups. One of them is the people who believe reality is more important vs. people who are convinced that The Narrative is more important. Really interesting debate - the narrative people are usually right and they certainly have the numbers but when the reality people have a point it is rather overwhelming. Narratives cannot overcome economics. This article seems to be a narrative person's perspective. Once the Communists gave up control of the media, blam. Game over. The realist argument would probably be that reforming to a justice system with some integrity and adopting some policies to score consecutive years of 10% growth was all they needed to keep treading water. People do make reference to their actual real-world experiences when pushing for change in government. > In fact, in 2006, Gorbachev pinpointed Chernobyl and the resulting media fallout as the real cause of the collapse of the Soviet Union. I just struggle to accept that Gorbachev was being intellectually honest with this one. Is that really where he assigned the blame? The USSR had real economic and legal problems. The US had spent decades showing up just how bad Soviet policies were.
- fakedang 2y agoThe USSR had real problems but something like Chernobyl exposed the out in the open. Had it been a chemical event, the Soviets might have still gotten away with it. But a nuclear event with thousands of eye witnesses and even more people responsible for clean-up? And fallout that spread across the entirety of Europe? We kind of saw a similar process in the beginning of COVID, when China was actively suppressing information internally. But it may not have had the same results because of deeper state centralization and information control, as well as other countries having to bother with the same issue. Yet it still sparked a number of protests across China, due to directly or indirectly being affected by COVID-19.
- The_Colonel 2y ago> The realist argument would probably be that reforming to a justice system with some integrity and adopting some policies to score consecutive years of 10% growth was all they needed to keep treading water. "all they needed" - as if that's easy to achieve consistently for decades. In the end what killed it was the combination of stagnation and the ability to freely talk about it.
- revskill 2y agoYes if it were putin.
- SteveNuts 2y agoHow so?
- peutetre 2y agoThat would make the answer "no". Putin's Russia will end with Putin because it has the same problem that all autocratic regimes have: succession. After Putin, the oligarchs will scrabble about trying to get the most of what's left. If it gets really bad Russia will descend into civil war. Russia just recently had a mini-civil war with Prigozhin's rebellion. If Russia ends up in civil war then China will invade Siberia under the guise of peace keeping to secure the resources it currently depends on from Russia. China will cut deals with whichever oligarchs win out and part of the deal will be that China takes territory that they see as historically Chinese (such as Outer Manchuria).
- The_Colonel 2y agoThere might be a power struggle, but a civil war? Nope. For that, you'd need (at least two) roughly equally matched adversaries controlling the armed forces. You don't see anything like that and such division doesn't spring up out of nothing. China will also not invade Siberia, it's much easier to control it economically than turning your quasi-ally into a mortal enemy. (besides, nukes)
- peutetre 2y ago> For that, you'd need (at least two) roughly equally matched adversaries controlling the armed forces. Or you have a military weakened and degraded by a pointless war of choice in Ukraine. And you have many armies controlled by oligarchs and warlords looking after their own interests (like Prigozhin). And you have many separatist movements, such has for example a movement for Siberian independence. And you have a power vacuum after the head of a mafia-style state is deposed or dies. After Putin all bets are off. Exactly this is happening in Myanmar right now: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42572620 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42572620
- idlewords 2y agoTo me the shocking thing about the collapse of the Eastern Bloc (both at the time and in hindsight) was that it was nearly bloodless, with events in Yugoslavia and Romania showing what easily might have been the outcome everywhere. Once it became clear that Gorbachev would not send tanks to reinforce fraternal bonds with the various people's republics, the wheels came off rapidly. But it would be hard to overstate the level of surprise in the region, where memories of 1956 (the invasion of Hungary), 1968 (Czechoslovakia), and 1981 (Poland [1]) were very much top of mind. It was simply expected that attempting to break with Moscow would result in a military crackdown. I think subsequent events have proven that Soviet Russia had the capacity to retain at least some of its empire by force, especially if they coupled that with a de facto return to a market economy, the course that worked so well in China. But to his credit Gorbachev decided not to send in troops, and the coup that resulted was too ineptly planned to stick. Gorbachev was a complicated man, certainly no saint, but the decision to let the Soviet empire go merits him a statue or two. [1] The Solidarity movement in Poland in 1981 was suppressed by the Polish army without foreign involvement, but the military junta all but said that the alternative was a Soviet invasion. Whether or not this is true is actively debated in Polish historiography, but was universally believed at the time.
- chii 2y ago> but the decision to let the Soviet empire go merits him a statue or two. not to people like putin, who claim that the dissolution is the greatest mistake in russian empire's history.
- mike_hearn 2y agoNot exactly his position. He's repeated an aphorism that says: "Anyone who doesn't regret the passing of the Soviet Union has no heart. Anyone who wants it restored has no brains" https://aforisimo.ru/30185.html https://aforisimo.ru/30185.html Unwinding a communist system is incredibly difficult and always yields a collapse in living standards, although temporary. Less extreme forms of it are often called "shock therapy" for this reason, but Russia's transition was handled especially badly and was especially extreme as the dissolution of the USSR wasn't a planned event. If you look at opinion polls, a significant fraction of the Russian population does wish for a return to the Soviet system. You will also find some nostalgia in the former DDR. This isn't because they thought it was a perfect or good system, but the memory of the collapse and return to market competition is painful, and of course some of them are naturally left leaning anyway and liked a world where there was no competitive pressures.
- pinewurst 2y ago(2020)
- Animats 2y agoIt's a tough question. After the fall of the Soviet Union, living conditions in Russia became much worse. The brief period of liberal democracy didn't work out. (Very like the Kerensky period in 1917). Trying to transition to postmodern capitalism did not work out well at all. Then Russia got oligarchs and the Russian mafia, which was basically the old national security state privatized. More recently, Putin crushed the oligarchs and started a war. Arguably. Russia's most successful period since the mid 19th century was under Communism.
- lazide 2y agoWhich considering how terrible living conditions were, is impressively terrible!
- The_Colonel 2y ago> The brief period of liberal democracy didn't work out. (Very like the Kerensky period in 1917). Trying to transition to postmodern capitalism did not work out well at all. Note that this happened to most post-communist countries. 90s were uniformly bad, in the 00s things started to get better. The troubles likely don't have much to do with the liberal democracy as such, but with the transition of the economic system. > Arguably. Russia's most successful period since the mid 19th century was under Communism. The early decades were indeed quite impressive (transformed an agrarian country into an industrial powerhouse), but they did not manage to keep up the momentum, and it's questionable whether it was even possible with the planned economy.
- Animats 2y agoIt's interesting to consider what might have happened if GOSPLAN had enough compute power. GOSPLAN used to have an annual planning cycle and a monthly info update cycle. Walmart has a weekly planning cycle and a daily info update cycle. Amazon probably runs faster than that. It's sort of an article of faith in economics that a centrally planned economy can't work, but there are some rather large centrally planned systems now. Walmart and Amazon are each probably bigger than the USSR's entire consumer economy. On an annual cycle, GOSPLAN could only provide general guidance - add up everybody's steel needs and tell the steel plants. That sort of worked for big stuff, but not for small parts. Factories tended to make too many of their own small parts. (Some US companies used to do that - IBM, Remington Rand, and Teletype all made their own screws.) GOSPLAN never made it to bar codes, either. Today, everything in business is tracked as it moves. GOSPLAN never had that kind of info.
- petesergeant 2y agoJury is still out on if the Russian Federation can survive in one piece for any length of time imho
- karmakurtisaani 2y agoTo be fair, this is true for any country at any point in time until they fall.
- Hilift 2y agoThe west could have kept the Soviet Union alive. The Soviets were poor and an easy adversary to plan for. After witnessing what occurred in the 1991 Gulf War, they realized the writing was on the wall. The Soviet or Russian military would never be able to match what their "main adversary" had just demonstrated, a major ground incursion that took only a few days. 30 years on and over a trillion dollars of military spending, and Russia is still not capable of defeating one country in a three year struggle, and in the process destroyed most of its incompetent force.
- chii 2y ago> Russia is still not capable of defeating one country in a three year struggle the counter-factual is that ukraine survived primarily due to western aid, without which they'd be defeated already and is more likely to have to adapt a gorilla war against russian occupation.
- wat10000 2y agoA Desert Storm equivalent would have won the war before any substantial aid could arrive. The fact that the US could carry out such an operation on the other side of the planet, and Russia can’t even do it on its own border, really casts doubt on this idea of Russia as the world’s second military power.
- jltsiren 2y agoYou must be thinking of the Iraq War (2003), which Putin tried to imitate but failed. The Gulf War (1991) was a slow invasion that started with several weeks of aerial bombardment. A similar operation would have given foreign aid more time to arrive in Ukraine. By the time the coalition started the ground invasion in the Gulf War, Ukraine had already received substantial military aid and won the Battle of Kyiv.
- wat10000 2y agoDesert Storm was about six weeks from start to finish. That’s not enough time for outside aid to make much of a difference.
- keiferski 2y agoI think it would have been very unlikely for a number of reasons, but specifically two main ones: - The Soviet Empire never transformed into an assimilative empire and was always something of a post-war occupation state. If you look at other empires that managed to last longer, they almost always had an “absorbing” of the captive areas, adopting some of their cultural ideas, incorporating local elites into the state apparatus, etc. (think of the Romans in Greece, for example.) This didn’t really happen in Soviet member and client states and was more of a top-down promotion of particular individuals and parties. - The existence of Poland. Soviet history really goes back to Russian Empire history, which includes the partitions of Poland and the numerous uprisings for independence during the 19th century. I don’t think it was ever realistic to think Poles would be happy in a Russian empire, and the continual existence of such a large, unhappy client state in the Soviet sphere seems like it was an inevitable weak spot. The Solidarity movement was key in bringing down the USSR, so that is essentially what happened.
- idlewords 2y agoThe Soviet empire was very much assimilative, so successfully that people sometimes overlook it. Its greatest leader was Georgian, while three others were Ukrainian. Parts of it ("Western Ukraine", Kaliningrad) were annexed outright after World War II, while other areas continued a Russification program that started under the tsars. As for Poland, the Solidarity movement was quite effectively suppressed in 1981 and ceased to be an effective political force until the Polish government badly miscalculated and allowed it to reconstitute itself eight years later. The biggest mistake the Soviets made in Poland was in giving a large degree of autonomy to the Catholic Church.
- keiferski 2y agoAll of those areas other than Kaliningrad were assimilated primarily during the Russian Empire, not the Soviet Union. As for Solidarity, I suggest reading about its influence on the Soviet bloc as a whole. Again, even if it didn’t work, it was just another example of a resistance movement in Poland. Another one would have likely occurred a decade or two later.
- jchook 2y agoFrom any realistic humanitarian perspective, the fall of the Soviet Union was a horrific crisis that resulted in untold amounts of human suffering and poverty. Russia spiraled into a terrible mess, celebrated by the West. Perhaps worth noting, shortly after the fall around 1991, Yeltsin hijacked the Russian government and prevented Communists from retaking power. The pattern of events immediately after the fall (and their strong support from the West) raises an eyebrow about how exactly the "collapse" was precipitated. Yeltsin used self-anointed emergency powers to abolish the Constitutional Court and dissolve parliament. When the people protested, he ordered a military attack on parliament, killing hundreds and jailing hundreds of protesters. Yeltsin seized control of all broadcast media, banned opposition publications, and permanently outlawed 15 political parties. He ordered assassinations of his political opponents, parliamentary deputies, and journalists. Yeltsin illegally dissolved the Russian constitution and replaced it with one that gave himself nearly absolute power over policy. By 1996, he was losing badly in his bid for re-election. A communist candidate was far in the lead. During re-election, his administration was bankrolled to the tune of $10B by the IMF and World Bank. Even so, he was still trailing the communist candidate by a long shot. So, he threatened civil war, making it clear he would not relinquish power. About half of the country thought there would be a civil war if the communists won. Ultimately, he rigged the vote count, as reported by ABC news in the US. When he won re-election, Bill Clinton famously lauded the event, saying Russia has "turned its back on tyranny".
- hparadiz 2y agoDon't conflate economic mismanagement with the collapse of an evil empire. For me and my entire family the collapse was a gift that allowed us to finally leave. Staying in character even at the border by stealing what little we had in cash to punish us for leaving. The Soviet Union stole my grandparents and great grandparent's entire life's potential. Forcing them into a life time of servitude to barely scrape by for a shitty Soviet apartment and a shitty car that you needed to wait 10 years to get. It is bafflingly amusing that one would point at any illegality of anything a successor of a Soviet premier does when the reality was that they had absolute power to do whatever they want as is Russian tradition.
- 2y ago
- lkrubner 2y agoThe Soviet Union could have survived if a central political power had survived, but by the late 1970s this was becoming impossible. The collapse of the USSR resembles the collapse of many states that are overtaken by oligarchs, and the oligarchs were gaining power long before the USSR collapsed, though they were called Apparatchiks and had somewhat different roles, and less freedom-of-maneuver than the true oligarchs that emerged in the 1990s. But by the late 1970s the largest industrial powers were consolidating into a single bloc that would be able to defy the Politburo, and so Gorbachev had to worry about a coup the entire time he was in charge, and he was never able to push through the reforms that he knew were needed. I'll post here a long excerpt from the best book on the topic. The Struggle to Save the Soviet Economy: Mikhail Gorvachev and the Collapse of the USSR By Chris Miller ©2016 Page 181-183 The only force that proved strong enough to break the military-industry-agriculture coalition that dominated Soviet politics was the collapse of the Communist Party - which in turn caused the dissolution of the Soviet state. Until mid-1991, the three economic lobbies were bound together by interest, ideology, and inertia. Had Gorbachev been able to divide the coalition partners, playing one interest group against the others, he might have had more success in asserting control over the Communist Party and the Soviet state. But a strategy of divide and rule proved impossible. So long as they dominated the Communist Party, and as long as the party controlled the state, these groups’ shared interests overwhelmed any tactical alliance Gorachev could have conceivably offered. In the years after the collapse of 1991, with the military divided and discredited by the failed coup, and with industry and agriculture writhing under the pain of inflation and depression, Russian president Boris Yeltsin finally managed to split the groups, co-opting much industrial support while slashing farm subsidies and cutting military funding. Even though the Soviet Union by then no longer existed, however, Yeltsin still faced several years of resistance in his attempt to break the lobbies’ stranglehold on the federal budget and on the central bank. Only after Yeltsin shelled parliament in 1993, pushing the country to the brink of civil war, was the military-industry-agriculture coalition finally destroyed. Was the Soviet Union simply unreformable? China’s experience proved that there is nothing inherent in Marxism-Leninism, in autocratic political systems, or in centrally planned economies, that makes a transition to a market economy impossible. In the USSR, to be sure, decades of wasteful investment left the country a burdensome economic inheritance. Yet the most damaging legacy of the command economy was not economic inefficiency, but political sclerosis. The Soviet system proved unreformable not because its economic problems were insurmountable, but because it entrusted vast political power to groups that had every reason to sabotage efforts to resolve the country’s economic dilemmas. In part, this situation was the result of the USSR’s relative wealth. When Deng took power in China, for example, the country’s farmers were on the brink of starvation. No matter what Deng did, the state of China’s countryside could hardly get worse, so China faced no built-in lobby that opposed change. By contrast, the USSR was stuck in a politically induced middle-income trap: many Soviet citizens, especially among the elite, lived decent lives that were threatened by change. Whereas Chinese farmers embraced decollectivization, Soviet farmers - who had benefited from several decades’ worth of farm subsidies - found that Gorbachev’s agriculture policies offered risks as well as rewards. A similar mechanism obstructed change in Soviet manufacturing and service enterprises. Economic efficiency was also restrained by the relative leniency of the Communist Party during the postwar period. Under Stalin, the party had few interest groups because the Soviet dictator enforced his writ through purges and mass killings. Enterprise managers dared not miss production targets, on pain of death. The rapid rotation of cadres, facilitated by Stalin’s purges, reduced the influence of patronage networks. Brezhnev’s policy of “stability of the cadres” ended the use of the firing squad to encourage effective management. That made the Soviet system more humane, but it degraded incentives to work efficiently. Bureaucrats and managers now faced few reasons to act effectively: their firms could not go bankrupt, their salaries did not depend on performance, and they received promotions based on political connections. In China, the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s had shaken up the party and the bureaucracy, cutting back the strength of interest groups and paving the way for Deng Xiaoping’s market reforms. In the Soviet Union, by contrast, the 1960s and 1970s saw patronage network and interest groups solidify. Gorbachev inherited a system in which economic lobby groups played a larger role than ever before. Yet his powers as head of the Communist Party were weaker than any Soviet leader since the Bolsheviks took power in 1917.
- regularization 2y agoWhen Lenin stepped off the train in his return to Russia in April 1917, he was probably the only person in Russia who thought Russia would be run by socialists within a year - the other Bolsheviks certainly didn't. They were working to support Kerensky. Russia's economy was about the size of Brazil's at the time, and he said socialists would go into a holding action in Russia while the real socialist revolution happened to the west. From the perspective of its inception, there was no failure in the Soviet Union, the failure was in the revolution in Germany.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: A Legendary Exposé of the Brutality of the Soviet Union https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42566387 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42566387
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoHow much imaginary food are we hand waving in for this thought process?
- scythe 2y agoThe Soviet Union was first headless in 1975. After Brezhnev's stroke, he was no longer fit to govern. The people in the back room — mostly Yuri Andropov, the head of the KGB — ran the country by favor-trading and bumbled their way into Afghanistan. But the mistakes started earlier. The arrest of Khrushchev in 1964 may already have been the point of no return. When you are faking the procedure, at least you retain some possibility of belief in democratic — or at least bureaucratic — principles. But when you just arrest the leader one day, the illusion is broken. Nobody can really believe you anymore. The Five-Year Plan of 1965-70 — the Kosygin reform — was a success by almost all conventional economic measures [1]. Growth improved, innovation occurred, wages went up. But it was reversed. Some people in the party didn't believe that it was Marxist enough. Brezhnev, having come into office how he did, could never have had the courage to demand some kind of pragmatism that could have led the Soviet Union to the transformation that China underwent just a few years later. A nation can't be run like a mob, with everyone looking over their shoulder to see if they're going to be taken outside next. It paralyzes decision-making. So when Brezhnev had a stroke and could barely even perform the superficial functions of leadership, nobody even wanted the job. Surely, if Khrushchev could be ousted from his position for his drunkenness, Brezhnev's incapacity should have been more than sufficient. Andropov, the leader of the KGB, was effectively calling the shots at that point, and when Leonid finally kicked the bucket in 1982, it was indeed Andropov who took over. But isn't it telling that for seven years, Andropov could have easily become the leader of the world's second-largest economy and simply didn't want to? What does that say about his confidence in the system he was running? By the time Gorbachev was in the chair there just wasn't anything left to save. You can't have a vanguard-party government without a functioning vanguard party. The multi-party systems have all proven more resilient because when one of the parties starts to malfunction, it is removed from power and has the opportunity to reinvent itself or be replaced. No single-party state has lasted longer than China's current run, which is also starting to show a few cracks. So far the two-party system in the United States has avoided the notionally unlikely situation that both parties become highly dysfunctional at the same time. But I don't like the news these days. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1965_Soviet_economic_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1965_Soviet_economic_reform
- ranger207 2y agoThe hard part of counterfactuals is that the result of a counterfactual is often an entity that shares only a name in common with the real historical entity. Could the Soviet Union have survived? Sure, maybe, if it didn't look anything like the Soviet Union that actually existed. Could the Chernobyl accident have been avoided? Sure, if the reactor hadn't been designed for better weapons production, if the crew hadn't been pushed to perform an unusually risky procedure, or if the crew had the initiative to avoid the problems they encountered. But the Soviet Union that actually existed was overly militarized and had a culture where obedience was more important than safety, and if it didn't have those traits then it wouldn't have been the Soviet Union that actually existed
- hackandthink 2y agoI see a lot of retrospective know-it-all attitude. There are many alternative scenarios. Gorbachev could have acted more skillfully. "Deng Xiaoping thought Mikhail Gorbachev was an idiot." A more competent new edition of Brezhnev could have prolonged the misery for a few decades.
- freefaler 2y agoNo centrally planned economy can survive in the long term. Resource allocation is so skewed that it kills such systems. No free market pricing means that economic decisions aren't taking into account the costs. Even in USSR with the vast mineral wealth this couldn't save them. Milton Friedman has a good summary on why this happened: https://www.npr.org/2006/11/16/6498016/friedman-on-free-markets-communisms-collapse https://www.npr.org/2006/11/16/6498016/friedman-on-free-mark...
- NoGravitas 2y agoAmazing to have predicted the failure of Wal-Mart in this way.
- freefaler 2y agoWal-Mart is a big org in a relatively free competitive market . This is the big difference between countries and big organizations. USSR didn't compete with other countries outside of the oil and some other resource markets. They imported food (wheat) and now are one of the largest exporters (or they were before the full-scale war).
- tim333 2y agoI think China is proof that it could have survived if it had followed similar policies and allowed private enterprise to run in parallel to the communist system.