3 ms·
You don't even need to cheese it when everything is client side, so there's no way for the server to verify you actually killed the required amount of enemies.
by gruez 2y ago
You don't even need to cheese it when everything is client side, so there's no way for the server to verify you actually killed the required amount of enemies.
- make3 2y agoit's a PoC
- cwillu 2y agoWhat part of the concept was proven?
- 93po 2y agoyes - i refuse to use captchas for basically any reason - if a site blocks me with a captcha where i have to label traffic lights or whatever, i close the tab and move on i would probably choose to use doom captcha even if it takes 5 times longer. it is proven that at least people will interact with this if they wouldnt with traditional ones
- yieldcrv 2y agofound the robot jk robots can do this now
- oliwarner 2y agoI think this is unfairly downvoted. Anyone can think of something humans do and just playing DOOM in a browser falls well short of anything new. All the hard stuff is missing. It's half an idea.
- cwillu 2y agoI find the early votes on new comments are biased downwards; I can speculate as to why, but it usually is more than balanced out by later votes.
- dspillett 2y ago> All the hard stuff is missing. It's half an idea. Nah, it's all the idea but half (or less) the implementation. Still counts as a PoC by many definitions. I've been handed less complete proofs to continue ("we fleshed this out in Excel in the client meeting, said we could have it done for real by Tuesday, can we?").
- hombre_fatal 2y agoYou could send inputs to the server, the server simulates them to see if you killed monsters. The concept here is the UX of what it would be like if it were properly hooked up. Just like what you would do with any captcha proposal. You’d want to mock up the UX to evaluate whether it something people can do. Though here’s it’s just for fun.
- Maxatar 2y agoPerhaps this implementation works that way, but in principle if the game is strictly determined based on a random seed and player input, then the server can verify that the player's inputs do in fact result in the correct outcome.
- bcoates 2y agoDoom doesn't even have a (variable) random seed, it's deterministic like an NES game and has built-in record/playback that's just a frame by frame list of player moves.
- DaiPlusPlus 2y agoSo have the client record and send the demo recording. …hang on, this is starting to feel like Elliptic Curve cryptography: it’s trivial to prove a demo file is a “solution” to a random-seeded Doom map, but nontrivial to work-backwards to generate a demo-recording.
- gcr 2y agoThat's how all proof of work tactics work. The heart of Bitcoin is just "Find me a number between 0xf80000 and 0xff0000 whose SHA-1 hash starts with eight zeroes..."
- Salgat 2y agoThis sounds like a trivial thing to take advantage of. Update the game to randomize damage and add a unique seed for each instance played.