2 ms·
I think I'm on safe ground saying printing the names of criminal suspects is a longstanding norm in American print journalism.
by tptacek 2y ago
I think I'm on safe ground saying printing the names of criminal suspects is a longstanding norm in American print journalism.
- chmod775 2y agoIt is. Comparatively it is even very common in most of the Anglosphere, however not for lack of trying by more ethical journalists. If you search for "the juvenile suspect" on google news, you'll get plenty of hits for US newspapers (and occasionally police) applying some consideration. In the west, English speaking countries are the odd ones out: For example in Germany, Poland, Sweden, the Netherlands, Finland, Switzerland, Austria, and France, identifying suspects (not just juvenile ones) is either uncommon or even forbidden by law.
- kasey_junk 2y agoIt’s actually an open discussion in journalism ethics. Many news organizations won’t name juveniles even in jurisdictions where it is allowed. Other guides will be based on the nature of the crime. Most wire services for instance now don’t name suspects for “minor crimes”. Here is the ap announcement on the topic: https://www.ap.org/the-definitive-source/behind-the-news/why-were-no-longer-naming-suspects-in-minor-crime-stories/ https://www.ap.org/the-definitive-source/behind-the-news/why... Note that their argument tends to be around the biasing impact on the persons life. As they are unlikely to follow up on the criminal outcome there won’t be a chance to clear the persons name. In this case I think Krebs is on solid ground as it’s a) not a minor crime b) he can later follow up. But it’s certainly not an area that is black & white.
- tptacek 2y agoRight, sorry, I was (correctly, right?) assuming this wasn't a minor.
- simoncion 2y agoYes, correctly. The article reports that the fellow is 20, and that the reporter talked to the fellow's mother. It seems very unlikely that Krebs fucked up and the fellow is actually 17. (He couldn't be any younger than that because he wouldn't have been able to enlist.)
- kasey_junk 2y agoJust to be clear, the minor crimes announcement I linked to wasn’t about crimes by minors, it was about the seriousness of the crime. I confusingly talked about both. My broader point was that the norm is changing in the us towards not naming suspects. And there are ethics conversations around this in the industry. But I think krebs is on solid footing for this particular case. He’s well within the norm.
- stogot 2y agoYou’re right. They do generally add a “suspected of committing” or “who appeared to attempt” or some other qualifier.