6 ms·
Morris Chang and the Origins of TSMC
- wslh 2y agoHe was around 55 years old when he founded TSMC. Regarding the translation from Chinese to English, I think it is a case for community funding. What is the budget required for this?
- alephnerd 2y agoMorris Chang wasn't some rando - he was a Group VP at Texas Instruments (reports to CEO) and COO of General Instruments (a major CMOS manufacturer from the 70s-90s - found in Spellovision). This is the equivalent of Sheryl Sandberg being tasked by a government to found a multi-billion government funded competitor of Facebook.
- rmk 2y agoSheryl Sandberg does not have a technical background. A better analogy would be Eric Schmidt or Adam D'Angelo.
- alephnerd 2y agoEric Schmidt sure, but not D'Angelo, as D'Angelo was never a C-Suite who climbed the ladder but was one of the earliest employees at FB when it was being built. At the C-Suite level - even at a deeply technical company like TSMC - the job is mostly investor relations and arbitrating between various business units internally, so while a technical background is nice to have, the business chops are more critical than technical chops. Look at Hock Tan at Broadcom for example - he started out as a line level EE in the semiconductor space (Malaysia is THE packaging and testing hub for semiconductors), but he is notorious for being extremely dollar driven (I've heard him unironically say "Show me the money" a couple times).
- rmk 2y ago> At the C-Suite level - even at a deeply technical company like TSMC - the job is mostly investor relations and arbitrating between various business units internally, so while a technical background is nice to have, the business chops are more critical than technical chops. I think this is a problem, particularly for the major tech companies that produce tech as the end product. If you are purely a "business leader" then the continued growth and even existence of the company is in jeopardy. Isn't the part of the job you mentioned better done by the COO or CFO?
- osnium123 2y agoGreat question about the budget/funding required. Tyler Cowen’s Emergent Ventures fund has funded it but I don’t know how much time/money is required. https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2024/12/emergent-ventures-39th-cohort.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2024/12/em...
- NonEUCitizen 2y agoYou also need permission from the copyright holder.
- klelatti 2y agoKudos to Brian Potter for getting hold of a copy of Chang’s biography and translating it (with some machine assistance) himself!
- pm90 2y ago> TSMC has a fascinating origin story: it was founded in 1985 by Morris Chang, who, after working in the US for Texas Instruments for more than 20 years, was enticed to go to Taiwan and help develop their high-tech industries as head of Taiwan’s Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI). How much of this was because of Racism? How many people like that, with the right technical, operational knowledge, experience and drive are prevented from transforming their American company because they don’t fit the mold of what Americans consider to be “leaders”.
- alephnerd 2y ago> How much of this was because of Racism From what I heard from peers from that era, not significantly. Taiwan's ITRI gave Morris Chang a blank check to implement his vision, which is something no ambitious person would turn down. Why become yet another rich but nameless CEO (who remembers Bucy at TI) when you can become the next Jack Kilby or William Shockley. China did the same thing for Liang Ming Song (former head of R&D at TSMC) at SMIC and India for Randhir Thakur (former head of foundry services at Intel and Applied Materials) at Tata Electronics. -------- Stop being so combative to OP - he asked a fair question about the bamboo ceiling. Looking at you Chollida1, next_xibalba, and Cumpiler69 (classy name /s)
- ayewo 2y ago> ... he asked a fair question about the bamboo ceiling. Apparently the concept of “bamboo ceiling” (similar to glass ceiling) has its own Wikipedia entry: TIL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo_ceiling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo_ceiling
- next_xibalba 2y agoIt reads to me like it is you who are being combative by calling me out by (screen)name. It was quite reasonable to find the GP comment inexplicable given that 1) the article doesn't make any explicit or implicit mention of racism, 2) Chang rose to group VP at TI after having had his PhD sponsored by the same company [1], and 3) as you say, he was given an astounding offer by Taiwan. In other words, the leap to racism and racial discourse is quite a big one. Whether or not you view my comment as combative, I utterly reject your belief that you have the right to police my content or tone. This isn't Reddit. [1] https://engineering.stanford.edu/news/stanford-engineering-hero-morris-chang-honored-revolutionizing-chip-making https://engineering.stanford.edu/news/stanford-engineering-h...
- mfrommil 2y agoFor those interested in the story, this is a fantastic podcast episode on the history of TSMC. https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/tsmc https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/tsmc
- tyleo 2y agoAcquired never disappoints. For folks reading this comment, there are many episodes which overlap with HN interests.
- asciimike 2y agoHaving recently listened to TSMC as well as Costco, LVMH, and Hermes, there's something available to every member of the HN audience in every episode, no matter how "unrelated" you may think it is. On the other side of the table, as a former sponsor of a season or two: it was the best marketing we (Crusoe) could have done. We had more high quality inbound from our audience than any other channel, by a long shot. They deeply understand their audience and target appropriately. Strongly recommend to anyone trying to reach a decision making audience (customer and investor).
- dcsan 2y agoHow did you measure that? Podcast ads seem almost like old school TV in that a lot of listening is offline, with no call to action or method of measurement. Despite racing and resonating deeply with an audience.
- scarface_74 2y agoYou’re thinking about B2C ads. B2B has long sale cycles where you talk to customer and you can ask them where they heard about you from.
- asciimike 2y agoTwo things: 1. I believe they require that you have an acquired specific landing page (e.g. crusoe.ai/acquired), which we saw directly as conversions through to our waitlist. The volume was lower than other channels, but the signal was much, much higher. 2. To @scarface_74's comment, "you talk to customer and you can ask them where they heard about you from" is mostly why I made the claim. In particular, when fundraising, basically everyone I talked to said, "I heard about you on Acquired, really interesting business model that I hadn't considered, let's talk more about it." Sponsorship isn't cheap (I would go so far as to call it expensive), but relative to spending an equivalent amount on search or display ads/billboards on 101/etc., I think it was the right choice at the time. My only analogy for this is what I call "cruise missile marketing" where you're investing a lot of time/money in building something that is very specifically targeted at high value buyers. It works really well for large, infrequent transactions (raising capital, selling GPU clusters, etc.) and less well for commodity SaaS or B2C products where volume >> everything.
- battle-racket 2y ago> Eventually Chang is approached by a manager who tells him that he could eventually rise to the position of Vice President of R&D, but to do so he would need to get a phD, and that TI will pay for Chang to get one ... Chang applies and is accepted into Stanford’s electrical engineering graduate program. He again works hard and graduates in 3 years 3 years for a EE PhD is extremely impressive.
- wslh 2y agoI think the world unique TSMC 3nm technology is even more impressive though.
- creer 2y ago> 3 years for a EE PhD is extremely impressive. Sure, but to this day, it depends on the school. At some universities that's right out, at Stanford that's common (after a Master or two). That wasn't the case for Chang but I feel that for some foreign students, it's due to them simply not recognizing that they could actually take their time and enjoy life and the out of this world campus and region. Some students feel pressure, of funding, of potential missed opportunity, of legal status, of acting on a bet that's WAY out of their home professional path, etc. Meanwhile some US students with no major funding problem often feel that there is all the time in the world, if only the university would let them. For that matter, I bet Chang felt pressure to not be away from this career track at Texas Instrument for too long. He was doing this PhD as a requirement for a specific promotion.
- markus_zhang 2y agoMany people do enjoy hard work over simple pleasures. It is very prominent in Asians I think.
- 486sx33 2y agoThat’s pretty racist. What does race have to do with personal preference?
- barkingcat 2y agoIt's kind of ridiculous that the actual title of the book isn't mentioned. I believe it is 張忠謀自傳全集(上下冊) (for both parts) https://www.books.com.tw/products/0011005571?sloc=main https://www.books.com.tw/products/0011005571?sloc=main
- creer 2y ago> Chang’s immense success with TSMC looks obvious only in hindsight; nobody at the time [...] saw it that way. That's fair but we can also recognize the pattern! We are now familiar with this one. Chang had noticed the need for fabs as a service to all. And he further noticed that it was at the intersection of others' needs: Taiwan looking for local industry, Philips looking for a local boost, established chips and design companies struggling to find the fab space they were ready to pay for, his ITRI mandate. There are no sure thing but we can see the good call and well done to put all the players together - that was plenty as grounds for a new business with good chances.
- hinkley 2y agoThe other pattern we see is the manufacturing ladder, which has played out in Taiwan, Hong Kong, Japan, South Korea and now is underway in mainland China. You can make a factory to make low end products. People copy you. Some employees bubble to the top, and can start making moderately decent products or quit to start on their own ideas. Eventually the low end stops being a good investment of money or people and it fizzles out in favor of luxury and specialty goods. LG used to make the bottom shelf VCRs that you would find at Best Buy. The VCRs were branded Goldstar, the company Lucky Goldstar. When they went up market they rebranded to distance themselves from their bargain product lines. Now they have fridges that cost more than high end computers.
- lmz 2y agoThe fridges seem to have the reliability of a high end computer too: https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/consumer/fridge-failures-federal-lawsuit-cites-lg-refrigerator-issue/3552575/ https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/consumer/fridge-failures-...
- kridsdale1 2y agoAn LG Signature (the absolute top end) dishwasher caused $20,000 of damage to my kitchen two months ago. Now have Meile. LG sill makes the best Televisions, though.
- ngneer 2y agoThere is no shortage of material on the topic, but I would recommend "Chip War" by Chris Miller as a complementary read.
- LAC-Tech 2y agoVery cool read. One thing stuck out to me: In 1973 Taiwan founded the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI) to help develop its industrial and technological capabilities. Taiwan’s industrial policy playbook was largely based on what had worked in Japan and Korea, and ITRI was based on similar institutes that had been founded in those two countries. As a frequent visitor to Taiwan I note that they've tried to do the same thing several times since then, in other technical fields, and have yet to replicate the success they had with semi conductors. They to be fair they're only 23.6 million people so to be technical world leader "only" in semiconductors is already a huge achievement.
- HardikVala 2y agoAn interesting coincidence is that the first fabless semiconductor company, Chips and Technologies, was also founded in 1985, by Dado Banatao and Gordon Campbell. They didn't partner with TSMC but contracted with companies like Hitachi that had excess fab capacity to manufacture their semiconductors. Wild. They eventually sold the company to Intel, which obviously didn't appreciate the insight of de-verticalization in the semiconductor supply chain.