3 ms·
Question: my colleague has a Mac with a Timemachine and thinks he is safe for ransomware. Is that, in a practical sense, true?
by amelius 2y ago
Question: my colleague has a Mac with a Timemachine and thinks he is safe for ransomware. Is that, in a practical sense, true?
- jaktet 2y agoI don’t know about timemachine but I have some anecdotal experience with Dropbox and ransomware. Essentially one person’s computer was infected which encrypted all the files for everyone in Dropbox. Because Dropbox had versioning on the files I was able to restore all the files back to the point before they were encrypted after removing and wiping the infected machines. So if timemachine has versioning then maybe then you probably have some options, I’m not sure I’d call this being “safe” from ransomware.
- monai 2y agoAbsolutely not. Time Machine is just a SAMBA share with a nice UI on the client side. If the backup directory gets encrypted, all the versions of your files will also be encrypted.
- amelius 2y agoThere is a different opinion here: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8282686 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8282686 Not sure what to make of it. Is it possible to reach the server side of the Time Machine from the Mac itself? Has such a breach been demonstrated?
- kstrauser 2y agoMy Time Machine server doesn’t run an Apple OS. Someone would have to compromise my laptop and then pivot to separately attack my NAS. A state level actor could probably do that. The people running spray-and-pray ransomware ops almost surely couldn’t, or at least wouldn’t bother.
- amelius 2y agoAfaik, my colleague has a setup with regular Apple hardware and software.
- daghamm 2y agoAccording to Darknet Diaries there are gangs that focus on backup server first, because with backups in place ransomware is not as effective. There are examples of backup software companies being compromised to get to their clients. This is for attacks against bug companies. But maybe it's just a matter of time before "ordinary" ransomware is updated with destroy-backups function.
- amelius 2y agoBut to come back to the original question, is there any evidence against Apple Time Machine being secure?