4 ms·

I worked on a side project that generated the AI resume and cover letter. I did a controlled experiment applying for jobs with the generic vs AI customized resu

I worked on a side project that generated the AI resume and cover letter. I did a controlled experiment applying for jobs with the generic vs AI customized resume. The AI customized resume out performed the generic resume by 4x. https://customizedresumes.com/custom-vs-generic-resumes https://customizedresumes.com/custom-vs-generic-resumes

casenmgreen 2y ago
The AI resume - was it a real human resume which was optimized in some way for the role specification, or was it generated from scratch for the role specification?
jdbdnej 2y ago
That's like comparing your "AI customized resume" to shitting on the hiring manager's desk You'll be shocked to find out which performed better!
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y ago
  What's so bad about a "generic" resume? I assume this means one that just honestly describes your experience rather than tailoring it to the job applied for to make it seem you're a better fit than you really are. It's up to the person (hopefully) reading your resume to decide whether you're enough of a potential fit to take to the next step (technical screening call?).
  - jdhdbdbdn 2y ago
    A cover layer is there to show how you fit the role. This cannot be done with a genetic cover layer Telling facts about yourself is done in the CV, not cover layer
    - HarHarVeryFunny 2y ago
      Sure, but the parent was talking about customized resumes, not cover letters. The cover letter of course needs to be customized, else it serves no purpose.
SpicyLemonZest 2y ago
I don't want to hate on your side project, but the AI is clearly hallucinating things to fit the job description. In the ServiceNow result (first I saw with an interview/reject difference), the custom resume claims Jenkins experience, which is in the job listing but nowhere in either the AI base or generic resumes. Same for NinjaTrader and distributed systems + Scala + Github Actions, Upside and data engineering, BigTime and C#.

casenmgreen 2y ago

The AI resume - was it a real human resume which was optimized in some way for the role specification, or was it generated from scratch for the role specification?

jdbdnej 2y ago

That's like comparing your "AI customized resume" to shitting on the hiring manager's desk You'll be shocked to find out which performed better!

HarHarVeryFunny 2y ago
What's so bad about a "generic" resume? I assume this means one that just honestly describes your experience rather than tailoring it to the job applied for to make it seem you're a better fit than you really are. It's up to the person (hopefully) reading your resume to decide whether you're enough of a potential fit to take to the next step (technical screening call?).
- jdhdbdbdn 2y ago
  A cover layer is there to show how you fit the role. This cannot be done with a genetic cover layer Telling facts about yourself is done in the CV, not cover layer
  - HarHarVeryFunny 2y ago
    Sure, but the parent was talking about customized resumes, not cover letters. The cover letter of course needs to be customized, else it serves no purpose.

SpicyLemonZest 2y ago

I don't want to hate on your side project, but the AI is clearly hallucinating things to fit the job description. In the ServiceNow result (first I saw with an interview/reject difference), the custom resume claims Jenkins experience, which is in the job listing but nowhere in either the AI base or generic resumes. Same for NinjaTrader and distributed systems + Scala + Github Actions, Upside and data engineering, BigTime and C#.