5 ms·
If ChatGPT produces AI-generated code for your app, who does it belong to?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tommek4077 2y agoPlot twist: Nobody who is in charge should care. Leave the no to the naysayers. Ship your app, generate traffic, usage, income. Leave the discussions to other people.
- SavageBeast 2y agoCommenting on this to mark it in my feed for later reference. Well said!
- suryajena 2y agoUnless you are now involved in a lawsuit that asks for a hypothetical 50% of your income for using a tech very similar to their and they speculate its been stolen and not permitted by their license and even if you know you are going to win/or that it doesn't affect you still have to spend money on the lawyers fighting it.
- david-gpu 2y agoDo that at $BigCorp and Legal will eat you alive, if not fired. Long ago I went through the company-approved process to link to SQLite and they had such a long list of caveats and concerns that we just gave up. It gave me a new understanding of how much legal risk a company takes when they use a third-party library, even if it's popular and the license is not copyleft.
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoNothing particularly new, since none of the cases around this have concluded. If I were to guess, I'd say the output of an LLM isn't copyrightable (it's not the creation of a human), unless it's a verbatim copy of some copyrighted training data in which case it belongs to the authors of the work(s) used in training. This creates the most annoying combination of legal problems around using it, so by Murphy's Law it must be correct!
- christkv 2y agoIf i pay a consultant to write code out generally belongs to me. Why would a tool like an llm be any different if you are a paying customer. If you are on the free model shrug….
- xandrius 2y agoIncorrect, it clearly belongs to you if there is an agreement with the transfer of such rights otherwise you are in murky waters. LLMs are not individuals automatically covered by copyright laws, as they are simply tools based off other (often) copyrighted work. This means that the initial copyright infringement is still a valid concern, hence these discussions. If it was a easy and clear cut as just shrugging, the conversation wouldn't be so prevalent.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 2y agoWhat if the contractor used an LLM?
- xandrius 2y agoGenerally, if they never had the rights to something, they cannot transfer them to someone else.
- icedchai 2y agoUnless you have a work-for-hire agreement, it belongs to them. I once explained this to a client (that still owed me money) and he got pretty angry.
- wodenokoto 2y agoIsn’t this article trying to heavily over complicate matters? OpenAI grants you ownership of output. Why do we even need to discuss autherless rights?
- semiquaver 2y ago> OpenAI grants you ownership of output That’s only meaningful if it’s legally established that the ownership of the output was theirs to grant in the first place. There’s no law directly on point and precious few legal decisions in this area, so it’s still very much an open question.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoOwnership of software never made any sense to begin with. We should abandon such a concept as belonging to the dark ages.
- Etheryte 2y agoOn one hand I agree with you, if I can build the same software you can, I should be able to sell it all the same. On the other, if there's no copyright or similar, what stops theft of source code and an identical program with fresh branding?
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> I should be able to sell it all the same No, you should be compensated for your labor. This does not entail a market product.
- Etheryte 2y agoSo only the first company to make a search engine should be able to sell a search engine? I don't see how this stance makes any sense.
- thot_experiment 2y agoI assume op means you should be compensated through a method other than pretending software is scarce and trying to assign value to it through a system that relies on equivocating scarcity with value.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoNo, selling a search engine never made any sense to begin with. Services should be publicly funded and freely accessible. As a bonus we wouldn't have to put up with spam on every site on the internet.
- Etheryte 2y ago
- tibbon 2y agoMy understanding from a talk by an attorney at HOPE 2024 was that AI-generated materials cannot be defended/owned under copyright.
- outofpaper 2y agoYes the copyright office ha already published guidance on the issue but journalists continue to skip over this as a primary source.
- Animats 2y agoThis varies widely by country. The US does not have "database copyright" or "sweat of the brow" copyright. See Feist vs. Rural Telephone, which was about telephone directories. This restriction comes directly from the U.S. Constitution and would require a constitutional amendment to change.[1] The UK and EU are different. The EU allows copyrights on databases. [1] https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S8-C8-3-1/ALDE_00013063/ https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S8-C8-3-...
- badsectoracula 2y agoI already mentioned in another thread (which didn't get much discussion), but the recent EU AI Act takes into account the source material for training by essentially saying that you can train on copyrighted data unless the author opts out. The text from the AI Act is: > General-purpose AI models, in particular large generative AI models, capable of generating text, images, and other content, present unique innovation opportunities but also challenges to artists, authors, and other creators and the way their creative content is created, distributed, used and consumed. The development and training of such models require access to vast amounts of text, images, videos, and other data. Text and data mining techniques may be used extensively in this context for the retrieval and analysis of such content, which may be protected by copyright and related rights. > Any use of copyright protected content requires the authorisation of the rightsholder concerned unless relevant copyright exceptions and limitations apply. > Directive (EU) 2019/790 introduced exceptions and limitations allowing reproductions and extractions of works or other subject matter, for the purpose of text and data mining, under certain conditions. Under these rules, rightsholders may choose to reserve their rights over their works or other subject matter to prevent text and data mining, unless this is done for the purposes of scientific research. Where the rights to opt out has been expressly reserved in an appropriate manner, providers of general-purpose AI models need to obtain an authorisation from rightsholders if they want to carry out text and data mining over such works. (note that the "appropriate manner" is meant to be some machine readable way, AFAIK the way this will happen is still in works - the Act wont become law until 2026 anyway) Under EU copyright law the machine generated output (like code, etc) cannot be copyrighted. Essentially this means that: 1. ChatGPT et al. can can train on copyrighted code, text, etc unless the authors opt out via some (machine readable) way. 2. ChatGPT et al. can then reproduce a bunch of code from whatever it was trained on, that code by itself is not copyrightable (but it can be modified and become part of a copyrighted work - think of it as combining public domain code with some other project). AFAIK the only muddy aspect is what happens when ChatGPT (or really any AI generative algorithm) reproduces already copyrighted works without the knowledge of the user. Again AFAIK this is something that is currently being worked on. There was an AMA on Reddit recently[0] by someone who worked on the act and answered a bunch of questions. IMO it is a great AMA on the topic (at least if you ignore the trolls that ask "why do you want to destroy EU", etc). Also (unrelated to the above AMA) i think both UK and US are likely going towards a similar direction. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/ArtificialInteligence/comments/1fqmcds/i_worked_on_the_eus_artificial_intelligence_act/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ArtificialInteligence/comments/1fqm...
- jjice 2y agoThis felt like a way bigger topic (LLM copyright in general) when ChatGPT first dropped and now no one cares it seems. Are there ongoing cases for this or did something get settled that set a copyright-free precedent that I missed?
- 3836293648 2y agoThere are a bunch of ongoing cases and the US copyright office has made their position clear. We're waiting for American courts and for and European anything to say something
- Wowfunhappy 2y ago> In 2021, the Canadian agency ISED (Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada) recommended three approaches to the question: > 1. Ownership belongs to the person who arranged for the work to be created. > 2. Ownership and copyright are only applicable to works produced by humans, and thus, the resultant code would not be eligible for copyright protection. > 3. A new "authorless" set of rights should be created for AI-generated works. It seems obvious to me that the answer should be #1. An artist who creates works out of random paint splatters (modern art!) didn't purposefully choose the locations of their paint marks. However, they still own the copyright because they arranged for the creation of the work. You would never argue that a piece like this is uncopyrightable.
- Terr_ 2y agoUsing that analogy, you are stochastically sampling from other people's splat mark art, and guiding it towards something that resembles the prior work. I'd like to take a moment to emphasize that whether something is copyrightable and whether it is infringing are actually separate considerations. Both are social constructs the same as which side of the road one drives on, and it makes sense for us to define them in some way that is "fair", whatever that means.
- martin-t 2y agoThey completely forgot a 4th option: it belongs to the people who have copyright on the training data. If I take someone's book, painstakingly replace all words with their synonyms and publish it as mine, I am getting sued. Same if I do some other mechanical transformation meant to obscure the true original work. There's no AI, there's just statistical models of existing work.
- chrismcb 2y agoIf you take a bunch of books. Read then. Then write your own story with hints from each of the books, then who owns the copyright? Yes if you take a single work and replace every word with a synonym, that works be infringement. But that isn't what an ai does
- Havoc 2y agoThis is the wrong question in my mind. The question we need a legal determination on (ideally globally consistent) is more on training data side. Or put differently this is a "Fruit of the poisonous tree" type legal issue. Wondering about the output as the focus is all back to front
- throw310822 2y agoAs far as I know, the code I write for my employer it's his- it would be really funny if ChatGPT had more rights than me to ownership of the product of its work. This is, I believe, a generally accepted principle (even extending beyond what I code during working hours as long as it's connected with the main purpose of my job).
- jasrys 2y agoNo one. At least in the US, copyright requires human authorship.[1] There are several ongoing cases, probably most prominently the Thaler v. Perlmutter case. [2] [1] https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf [2] https://www.copyright.gov/ai/docs/us-brief-for-appellees.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/ai/docs/us-brief-for-appellees.pdf
- Wowfunhappy 2y agoMy understanding of the linked report is it's saying you can't register a work as being "Copyright ChatGPT" or what have you. This is obviously stupid on a bunch of levels—just to begin with, how would "ChatGPT" sue someone for infringement? If it can't, then its copyright is meaningless. The article is about whether the human using ChatGPT can claim copyright.