2 ms·
> there are good arguments that free trade is not always a good thing Arguments are one thing, results are another. Free markets always result in more prosperi
by WalterBright 2y ago
> there are good arguments that free trade is not always a good thing
Arguments are one thing, results are another. Free markets always result in more prosperity, from top to bottom. Free trade is just one aspect of a free market.
- vouaobrasil 2y ago> Arguments are one thing, results are another. Free markets always result in more prosperity, from top to bottom. Free trade is just one aspect of a free market. More prosperity but often at a cost to local environments and commons that are not priced into the market. And prosperity itself, measured purely in terms of economic gains, is not always a good thing either.
- WalterBright 2y ago> And prosperity itself, measured purely in terms of economic gains, is not always a good thing either. I don't know anyone who prefers to be less prosperous.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoProsperous can be measured in different ways. For example, right now, I am "less prosperous" by an economic measurement, but much more prosperous in terms of free time. And I'm much happier being "less prosperous" by the economic definition.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago> Free trade is just one aspect of a free market. This is wildly misleading. Free trade in the 21st century generally refers to trade across national boundaries. Nations represent markets that are not subject to the same basic conditions as each other. Moreover, free trade (the international kind) almost always seems to involve a lack of restriction on the movement of goods, capital and profit, but rarely allows labor the same benefit. The 21st century version of "free trade" is about expanding the scope and scale of capital markets and the movement of goods and profits across national (and thus market-jurisdictional and -conditional) boundaries. It has almost nothing to with the "old" notion of free trade within a given market.
- WalterBright 2y agoDo you know that the Constitution set up a "free trade zone" among the states? And it works great, too! > It has almost nothing to with the "old" notion of free trade within a given market. The Law of Supply and Demand has never changed, and never will.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoThe constitution also sets up free movement of labor among states. It works great too! "The Law of Supply and Demand" was unknown to the Romans or various middle Eastern empires (just two examples), whose economies worked in entirely different ways from those that followed the mercantilist period in Europe, and became canonized by Smith et al.
- WalterBright 2y ago> "The Law of Supply and Demand" was unknown to the Romans So was the law of gravity, but gravity still ruled their lives. > whose economies worked in entirely different ways The Law of Supply and Demand applies to all economic systems.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago> So was the law of gravity, but gravity still ruled their lives. I expected a better response from you. > The Law of Supply and Demand applies to all economic systems. False. Well, false for some well known versions of whatever "the law of supply and demand" is. There are all kinds of reasons why the retail cost of goods are not an inverse linear function of their supply; ditto for the retail cost of labor. Why do you feel this need to reduce complex systems to vapid platitudes?
- deepnotderp 2y agoNonsense. “Free trade” here refers to inter-country globalized trade across borders, not free markets within a confine. There’s a much stronger case to be made that industrial policy has resulted in prosperity for Asia, ironically the opposite of free trade :)
- WalterBright 2y agoWhy do you think the Constitution instituted a free trade zone among the states?