3 ms·
Wealth inequality causes social disorder. All those other non American cities exist in places with more robust social safety nets and have fewer billionaires/le
by nati0628 2y ago
Wealth inequality causes social disorder. All those other non American cities exist in places with more robust social safety nets and have fewer billionaires/less overt corporate control of the government. This is a fundamental truth of human society.
- anonym29 2y agoI grew up poor and that didn't magically compel me to initiate acts of violence or disrespect the property rights of other people. It gave me the motivation to work my ass off to get myself to where I am today. Individuals making a conscious and deliberate choice to commit violence or property crime is the cause of social disorder. Nobody's a robot without free will.
- bpodgursky 2y agoHave you ever been to a large East Asian city? You should look into the income inequality in those cities — and the amount SF spends on social safety nets — and you may be surprised.
- kerkeslager 2y agoHow much money does SF spend on giving the homeless homes? Not shelters, homes. How much money does SF spend on making sure people can get medical care without going into debt? When I went to the SF General emergency room after after a bike accident, I walked out with a just under $2500 bill, which would have been financially crippling for someone of less financial means. SF spends a massive amount of money on social safety nets that don't fundamentally address problems, because they don't have the political will to implement cheaper solutions that actually solve the fundamental problems. Put another way, SF spends a lot of money on feel-good programs, and very little on actual social safety nets.
- bpodgursky 2y ago> When I went to the SF General emergency room after after a bike accident I walked out with a just under $2500 bill, which would have been financially crippling for someone of less financial means. It would not cripple anyone. They would simply not pay, and nothing would happen. That's just what happens to 95% of medical bills not paid by insurance.
- kerkeslager 2y ago...which is why many treatments require pre-approval. Imagine thinking "just don't pay!" was a solution to the healthcare crisis.
- bpodgursky 2y agoNowhere did I say it was. But we cannot solve problems unless everyone is aligned on basic facts about the system we have now.
- kerkeslager 2y ago> Nowhere did I say it was. I don't know what your intention was for what you said, but if your intention wasn't to insinuate that this solves the problem, you failed in your intention. > But we cannot solve problems unless everyone is aligned on basic facts about the system we have now. Disagree. Bringing up random irrelevant stuff overcomplicates already complex discussion. You're downplaying the problem, even if you don't intend to. This a tactic to paralyze the conversation, not further it. Whether this is your tactic or whether you're just repeating what others have said, I don't know, but if it's the latter, you should be more cognizant of the effects of what you repeat. The fact that you can get away with simply not paying some medical debt is not a useful addition to this conversation. A society with a functioning safety net does not saddle people with medical debt, regardless of whether there is any way for that debt to be collected. Notably, you're just passing off the problem to healthcare providers who now don't get paid in the "solution" you're talking about.
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoTrying to pin this on "wealth inequality" is misdirection. Amazon having a large market cap and Jeff Bezos owning a significant fraction of the shares isn't really what caused any of this. The real issue is poverty, and in turn cost of living. People can't afford housing, become desperate, crime increases. But trying to fix this with "safety nets" is basically "let them eat cake" unless you have a way to fund it, and trying to fund it while the prices are still so high means the government can't afford it either, whereas if you were to adopt policies that lowered housing prices then that would be the solution in itself. But now you need to make that happen in San Francisco.
- Aloisius 2y agoCriminality is a social contagion. Wealth inequality, frankly, has little to do with it.
- af3d 2y agoBlame it on bad culture. Good people know that orderly conduct is necessary to maintain a healthy and vibrant community. Just take a look at the Nordic countries where this used to be the absolute norm across the board. Now even there you see quite a bit of social turmoil. Many who have migrated to these countries over the years simply do not share the same values and the effects are sadly self-evident. People do not feel nearly as safe as they once did. It may not be as bad as the average American city, mind you, but there has nonetheless been a real change in the "atmosphere". (Which isn't to say "all migrants are bad". Unvetted immigration is the issue I am referring to here.) Point is, wealth-inequality has nothing to do with it.