3 ms·
This article absolutely reeks of ChatGPT to me. For example: >With this in mind, we set out to automate the conversion process and minimize interference with o
by zahlman 2y ago
This article absolutely reeks of ChatGPT to me. For example:
>With this in mind, we set out to automate the conversion process and minimize interference with our developers’ daily work. The result was a tool we call the Kotlinator that we built around J2K. It’s now comprised of six phases:
followed by a list of descriptions of the "phases" which only sort of make sense for the name given to them, and are utterly incoherent as actual phases in a process (and grammatically inconsistent). For example, one of the cited "phases" is... "headless J2K". In other words: they have one piece of software that wraps another, and it - gasp - doesn't use the wrapped software's GUI. Aside from being entirely unremarkable, that's neither a phase in a process nor a component of a tool. It's a fact about the component.
LLMs write like this all the time - and it's clear evidence that they do not, in fact, do anything like reasoning, even if they can sometimes be manipulated into generating a second piece of text that resembles an analysis of the first one. The resulting description is so weird that I question whether the authors actually checked the LLM's output for accuracy.
Any human writer who gives a damn about good writing and has any skill, would not allow "it" to refer to "the conversion process" two sentences back when "a tool called the Kotlinator" has been introduced in the interim (or, if that were the intended referent, would notice that tools are not "comprised of phases"). Such a writer would also not come up with abominations like "the conversion process is now comprised of six phases" where "we now use a six-phase conversion process" would be much clearer. Certainly, a six-point bullet list produced by a competent writer would label them in a grammatically consistent way (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallelism_(grammar) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallelism_(grammar)) - not with an abstract noun describing an action, two participles, two concrete (well, as concrete as software ever is) nouns and a command (who, exactly, is being told to "build" the "error-based fixes" - whatever that means - here?).
I'm starting to feel like Mark Twain.
----
On the other hand, I was cynically expecting some mention of using AI for the actual task, and that doesn't seem to be the case.
(Also, the "reactive" web design is broken. The page overflows horizontally for some range of window widths, without causing a horizontal scrollbar to be added.)
- LegionMammal978 2y agoCalling it a 'phase' doesn't seem that weird to me? For each file, they go through a number of steps to translate it, and one of those steps is to run the J2K tool on it. The next section is just describing how they implemented that step: the J2K tool is normally enmeshed into the rest of the IDE, but they managed to jerry-rig a solution to run the relevant code by itself, without running the rest of the IDE with it every time.
- zahlman 2y agoIt could possibly make sense if the phases were described as e.g. "performing a deep build, preprocessing, running J2K, postprocessing, linting and applying error-based fixes" (i.e., all participles). But then the descriptions should be about how those phases are implemented (i.e., this is the place to mention the work of setting up a headless version of J2K so that it could be run in an automated pipeline) and how they contribute to getting the desired result. The description "The J2K we know and love, but server-friendly!" is utterly useless here, and also practically the archetype of what ChatGPT writes in "promotional material" mode.
- amelius 2y ago> cynically expecting some mention of using AI for the actual task Well, you could combine AI with correctness preserving transformations, so you get the best of both worlds (i.e., correctness AND a translation that keeps the resulting code close to what a human would write).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- spankalee 2y agoWhat's not a "phase" about running J2K?
- Philpax 2y agoYou are tilting at windmills. The article exhibits the kind of English I'd expect from someone sharing a technical development in an acceptably-perfunctory style for a company blog.
- mardifoufs 2y agoIt's as if chatgpt got its style from somewhere... For a hyper sanitized LLM like chatgpt, it's not surprising that it will sound like a sanitized corporate blog (that I still personally liked).