4 ms·
If Facebook hired an office assistant and decided that it improved employee morale to also throw marshmallows at said office assistant as they walked down the h
by joe_the_user 14y ago
If Facebook hired an office assistant and decided that it improved employee morale to also throw marshmallows at said office assistant as they walked down the hall, well that's what that office assistant was hired for. If they complain, get another one. "End of story".
If you want to be a real office assistant, go someplace else.
[yes, I am being sarcastic, I believe it is illustrative in this case]
Edit: Also Thomas, are you saying that employees have a right to be rude to personel of their company's helpdesk?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 14y agoI think this is a ridiculous apples-oranges comparison. The sole purpose of a yoga instructor at Facebook is to improve employee morale. Facebook is entirely justified in looking to optimize yoga instructors for employee happiness. This particular yoga intructor was apparently not a good fit.
- joe_the_user 14y agoI've corrected my reference to your name in the post above. It seems like you are saying that if I was a Facebook employee and you were a yoga instructor there, I would be under no obligation to do so since you would be there solely for my entertainment - (I mean "morale")? Edit: Also, you may find it hard to believe but Yoga instructor is actually a job that most instructors take seriously and pursue with the aim of teaching people yoga rather than simply improving morale. Most yoga instructors probably have gone through more training than an average office assistant. Still, for all I know the job was advertised with the description "yoga-instructor, not serious, only for the morale".
- tptacek 14y agoPlease resist the urge to drive the conversation into absurd places, like throwing marshmallows at office workers or yoga instructors. Facebook is not a giant yoga instruction business. The yoga instructors are there specifically to make employees happier. Not more efficient. Not more compliant with regulations. Not more accountably. Certainly not "better at yoga". Happier. That is the job of a contracting yoga instructor who teaches at companies like Facebook. You're not engaging with that point; you're just throwing marshmallows at it. If the entire story here is that Facebook turns out to be a bad place to run a yoga class, I'm left wondering: who gives a shit? And so to your last edit: I'm sure this is a very important controversy in yoga circles. But back in the real world, we still find ourself talking about a company that bought free yoga lessons for its employees, and then got punished in the press for not doing it the right way.
- kamaal 14y ago>>The yoga instructors are there specifically to make employees happier What makes the employees happy? Fake Yoga? This is clearly a case of somebody totally uninterested in yoga, but wants to learn it because of a hype kind of a person getting into a Yoga class. I understand you are trying to convey Facebook itself wants to sell fake yoga to its employees, so that they can get the feeling of a perk. Which is actually just a ritual the company wants to do and get over with. But if I were to be a guy in that yoga class I would raise my voice against insult to yoga and also the teacher in general, because sooner or later nothing serious will ever happen in such a company. If I ever go to a music class or whatever class. I go there because I genuinely want to learn something. I don't like uninterested people joining and spreading nuisance to other serious participants who are serious about learning things.
- btilly 14y agoI don't know that. I'd need to hear from other people in the class before making a judgement on it. If the student was making the class worse for other students, then despite that student being unhappy about the teacher the teacher's actions were actually good for morale. (Were I a student in the class, that is how I'd have felt. YMMV.) By contrast if this was one in a long line of incidents where the teacher was ticking off students, then the firing was appropriate. But the squeaky wheel gets the grease. The rude student complained and had enough weight to get the instructor fired. I'll probably never have enough information to have an opinion on whether Facebook made the right decision.
- tptacek 14y agoI think that if I was in HR at Facebook, I'd be thinking "I'm doing HR for a multibillion dollar company in a fierce battle for talent with some of the most savvy companies in the world. I do not have the bandwidth to adjudicate yoga disputes. Hey, company I contract out to for yoga classes: just send someone different next time so I can get on with my real job." Ultimately I don't care about the specifics of this story, except that it seems like a really good parable for teaching the difference between how businesses and insiders perceive value. Substitute "PHP developer" for "yoga instructor" and you could forklift this whole thread into the "Ask HN: How can I become a consultant" posting from earlier today. "Start by not being like this yoga instructor." (I don't think the yoga structure is a bad person; I just think she had the wrong job.)