9 ms·
The NBA's Problem Is Economics, Not Basketball
- DoesntMatter22 2y agoIt's just boring IMO. Run down the court, Chuck up threes, the game just isn't what it was years ago.
- shockeychap 2y agoProhibiting the use of the hand check also took the teeth out of defense and made it a more offensive game. I think that’s a big part of why Michael and Larry and Magic were so much more exciting to watch even though the team scoring was much lower than today.
- DoesntMatter22 2y agoYup. Big part of it
- glompers 2y agoIn 2019 the NBA's competition committee examined Kirk Goldsberry's proposal [1] to eliminate the shorter-range corner threes. Brad Stevens was on the committee and reportedly said, "You'll never see a slam dunk again" if we do that, because the guys who now have to defend the guys in the corners will go cut off the lanes to the basket. When faced with prospects of two different kinds of boring, Goldsberry points out that the NBA could either make its courts several feet wider to at least diminish the statistical make-percentage advantage of those 3's -- but that this would mess up arena seating arrangements -- or could outright allow teams to draw their own 3-point lines like the local variation in baseball and soccer [2] fields. Basketball requires control of space and pace, but as athleticism has increasingly been optimized, there's just not enough space there to force interesting trade-offs on every play. So it forces less interesting ones. [1] https://www.espn.com/nba/story/_/id/26633540/the-nba-obsessed-3s-let-fix-thing https://www.espn.com/nba/story/_/id/26633540/the-nba-obsesse... [2] https://www.thisisamericansoccer.com/why-are-soccer-fields-different-sizes/ https://www.thisisamericansoccer.com/why-are-soccer-fields-d...
- tiahura 2y agoThanks for the background. Why is shrinking the rim never considered?
- pySSK 2y agoHave there been any proposal to make shots from within the paint 1 point? (Purpose would be to encourage from shooting from outside the paint but from within the 3 point line)
- chongli 2y agoThat would be disastrous! There’s not enough scoring in the paint as it is, due to rule changes. Fans want more scoring in the paint! All the most popular superstars in the past were hyper-athletic guys who consistently got into the paint and made dazzling shots even against stalwart defenders. Outside shooters have always been role players until the arrival of Steph Curry. Now half the league plays like wannabe Curry and fans are getting tired of watching their teams miss dozens of 3 pointers every game.
- itsdrewmiller 2y agoMost dunks are in transition anyway - can’t block the lane if you haven’t made it across half court.
- chongli 2y agobecause the guys who now have to defend the guys in the corners will go cut off the lanes to the basket They do that already. They leave the corner shooter open when the ball is on the other side of the paint in order to clog up the middle. When the offence makes a sequence of passes to find the open guy in the corner then they close out to take away the corner 3.
- Tarsul 2y agoPersonally, I have a different problem: Too many stars are hurt during the playoffs (and the season as well, but not as important). Which means that it's just sad and I have less reason to watch because in the end it mostly comes down to which teams are healthiest the most. (e.g. look at which teams Boston played last playoffs and what happened to the stars of their opponents...) Also, crypto and gambling ads annoy as well.
- mdanger007 2y agoTech companies have the same problems as the NBA. there used to be career stars like Claude Shannon developing cultures of excellence out of teams like IBM, but just like Larry Bird and the Celtics, the free agent market and stars chasing the dollar has diminished the culture and thus the product.
- xhkkffbf 2y agoDidn't Shannon play for Bell Labs? Not IBM?
- PaulHoule 2y agoShannon worked for Bell Labs and then got traded to MIT.
- mdanger007 2y agoGood call!
- chollida1 2y ago> but just like Larry Bird and the Celtics, the free agent market and stars chasing the dollar has diminished the culture and thus the product. Um Larry bird never went the free agent route. He always played for the Celtics who drafted him. He's one person who doesn't fit your narrative.
- mdanger007 2y ago
- iimblack 2y agoBasketball is also the problem, refereeing specifically. Refs are humans and make mistakes but it’s hard to watch and not feel like there’s blatant favoritism to star players or certain teams. There are the L2M reports that detail all the mistakes they make in the end of the game and way too often they’re game altering. Then there’s the inconsistent approach to the rules. They’ll suddenly decide they want to push a rule, call every tiny infraction on it, then 10 games later it’s like the refs collectively forgot the rule exists at all. It all makes for an extremely frustrating experience for the players and the fans.
- jghn 2y ago> there’s blatant favoritism to star players This has always bugged me across all sports. For instance in baseball, while it's gotten a lot better over the years, the inequality of how strike zones were applied was annoying.
- walr000s 2y agoThe Lakers have a statistically impossible +/- in free throws shot. There is favoritism and the league isn't even remotely trying to disguise it...is that really different than any other arena though?
- itsdrewmiller 2y agoStatistically impossible is wild hyperbole. No two teams have the same players and many have drastically different strategies.
- walr000s 2y agoWild hyperbole? https://x.com/AndrewDBailey/status/1772275077280858370 https://x.com/AndrewDBailey/status/1772275077280858370 Being +1017 in FTA differential when the next closest is +358 isn't explained by whatever crap you're selling
- itsdrewmiller 2y ago
- PaulHoule 2y agoI played pickup basketball a lot as a youth and the people who were better than me were better at fouling and getting away with it. I think that's every bit as much true of the pro game which has been dogged with refereeing scandals. It is better than professional wrestling but for many reasons I don't completely believe it such as: the "star" player grandstanding to the point where you think the other side isn't really making them work, the suppression of the full court press, etc. (Not like my dad and I didn't love the epic rivalry the Celtics had with the Lakers in the late 1980s) On the other hand I love going to men's or women's basketball games at my Uni where you can usually buy a general admission ticket and sit in the front row.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>the people who were better than me were better at fouling and getting away with it. It ain't cheating if you ain't caught. Honesty is losing in the game of life.
- shockeychap 2y agoWhile I don’t disagree about the grandstanding and theatrics ruining the NBA, I take issue with those who complain that better players are just getting away with fouls and cheating. Basketball, despite the rules around fouls and illegal contact, is a very physical and tough game. Being tough enough to work through some of the contact (both legal and illegal) is very important to being a high level player. I think it’s reductive and petty to effectively say that they’re just better because they hit more and harder. Even Michael Jordan had to work hard at toughening up to get past Detroit in the late 80s and early 90s.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThat's a great point. There is a lot of spiciness in soccer where you see a player on your team get a red card and then your team works extra hard down a man for 60 minutes for a draw and then find out the other team has a player who specializes in giving out red cards.
- ajennings 2y ago
- elorant 2y agoEuroleague seems way more interesting these days
- jussy 2y ago+1 the basketball products outside of the NBA, I find more enjoyable and fun to watch but I'm also outside of USA. I often find that players from outside the US and Canada in the NBA more enjoyable to watch also. More casual observers of basketball in my family prefer the NBA. The article would of benefitted from comparing the FIBA products, Euroleague and NBA. A lot of comments in this post are different under FIBA rules like longer 3pt lines, no defensive 3 seconds, less timeouts etc. However none make more money or have a viewership more than the NBA. The flow of the game is crucial but has economic tradeoffs. If the NBA wants a slice of the global pie then i think it may need to adjust some of the rules that benefit the economics in the short term.
- shockeychap 2y agoI can't read this because of the paywall. ("Free registration" is just paying with my email and information.)
- jmclnx 2y agoI could not get into it either. But I tend to agree with the various favoritism comments. But with a twist and it applies to all US Pro Sports. I believe in the US, due to TV revenue, the Professional Orgs want playoffs to occur between Nationwide popular teams to maximize TV revenue. So they they want to avoid having 2 teams in the finals that will not generate nationwide ratings. I have not watched any pro sports for decades. But going back, in basketball the 2 teams that generated huge ratings and buzz a long time ago were LA and Boston. I do not know what the "magic" teams combinations are now, but I am would not be surprised if the refs subtilely try to get the "popular" team to win.
- c22 2y agoI love whining about paywalls as much as the next guy, but I copied the URL into the "saved snapshots" search at archive.is and got this pretty quickly: https://archive.is/VgwLx https://archive.is/VgwLx
- m10i 2y agoThe NBA’s problem is a combination of many things, including basketball. Here’s a sample: - The ref’s dictate the outcomes of the games more than the players themselves do. I’m of the opinion that when there’s a significant mismatch between two teams (let’s say one team’s stars are injured, or the other team is just simply vastly superior on offense or defense), the ref’s take it upon themselves (perhaps on the league’s orders) to help “even the playing field”, which means calling fouls on one side that they won’t call on the other side, confusing and bewildering everyone including both team’s coaches, the players, the commentators, and the fans watching. This keeps the gambling system better engaged, since predictable one-sided blowouts don’t make for lots of gambling revenue. - Most of the big name stars are constantly injured, which doesn’t help sell seats/get people to tune in. - Personality is prohibited. This highly sanitized product is pretty lame to watch. If a player just delivers a nasty dunk and then even so much as looks at the guy they just dunked on, that’s a foul. Players can’t even trash talk each other without the ref’s making it a huge deal and giving them both fouls. That is part of the essence of highly competitive basketball. Imagine giving Michael Jordan or 75% of the players in his era endless fouls simply for the most basic taunting. It would quickly become an unwatchable product that embarrasses all participants, and the players would retreat into their personality shells. People want to see shit talking, they want to see passion, they want to see anger/comedy. It’s exciting. It goes viral. This is not rocket science, NBA. - region-restricted games are hilarious (awful) - it’s overpriced - outside of Inside the NBA with Shaq, Kenny, Chuck, and Ernie, the other show hosts are pretty devoid of personality, and they very rarely have something interesting to say, so there’s no point in watching them. - I don’t know much about the AAU circuit, but I have heard many folks say that it hasn’t been good for the league. Am curious to learn more there
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoOne thing I don't see people talking about is the viewing experience. I love esports, specifically DOTA 2. An average game might be between 35-45 minutes, but a long game might run 80 minutes. In that time, not a single commercial. No time outs. Nothing. 80 minutes of straight entertainment. And going down this road you can include streaming in general. The modern sports watching experience, basketball and other sports included, is completely unwatchable once you get used to actual constant excitement. I'm never watching these sports again because I don't care to watch an ad every 3 minutes.
- apitman 2y agoHow do esports make money, and how much money do they make compared to the NBA?
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoA lot less! Sponsorships. Merch. Tournament wins. The best of the best might make millions a year but it falls off very quickly.
- pySSK 2y agoFully agreed. Soccer is like your esports example too – 45 minutes uninterrupted, followed by 15 minutes of some ads + analysis, following by another 45 minutes uninterrupted. I find it hard to keep attention if I try to watch NBA or NFL because of all the interruptions.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoThe article's thesis does not ring true. The hypothesis of the author has been true for many years in several soccer leagues. The most famous example being Spain's La Liga, which has been dominated by 2 superteams in the last 2 decades. Meanwhile, attendance and viewership during this period has dragged noticeably, and in fact, there's constant expert opinion advocating to end the superteam "experiment".
- walr000s 2y agoThe narrative that "the world wants to be dominated" is a popular one in mainstream media today. Is there actually any substance to the narrative? Not in this article. Like most written in this vein, there isn't even an attempt at quantifying support for the story.
- BJones12 2y agohttps://archive.is/VgwLx https://archive.is/VgwLx
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- itsdrewmiller 2y agoThis article is so bad - the thesis is that competitive parity is the main problem with the NBA, yet it actually calls out that the NFL is doing fine. The NFL has the most parity and a true salary cap. Why does Bloomberg even publish this.
- addicted 2y agoIt’s a Tyler Cowen article. The guy has always led with his conclusion before even looking at the evidence, since a long time, right through his Marginal Revolution blog years.
- tiahura 2y agoseason length - how are a 7’ guy’s knees supposed too go at even 85% effort for that many games? unlikeable players - Moses Malone wasn’t nice, but without getting into culture war, it’s different know. athleticism has beaten the rules. Shrink the rim 2” and force the game back into the paint. (And while you’re at it, make soccer goals bigger.)
- lawgimenez 2y agoPlayers are just shooting to much 3s. It’s boring to watch, every game it’s like a shooutout with barely no defense.
- pronouncedjerry 2y agoyet the team valuations are higher than ever. this article is baseless.
- chongli 2y agoThe NBA’s problem is the 3-pointer. Teams shoot more threes than they ever have before [1] because it’s a winning strategy (more points per attempt). At the same time, the league-wide 3pt% (percentage of 3-pointers made) has remained extremely stable around 35-36% [2] for the past few decades. This means the league as a whole has not found a way to consistently defend against the three. So why is this bad? It’s really boring basketball! Watching teams shoot and miss a bit less than 2/3 of their shots with very little the other team’s defence can do about it is not fun to watch! All of the athleticism and skill of the most famous stars in the NBA’s past has focused on basketball skills: dribbling, crossovers, driving the ball to the basket, making layups and dunks, changing hands mid shot to avoid a block, making turn around jumpers and hook shots, floaters. The one exception to that is Steph Curry who is best known as a shooter but who is frankly a pretty boring player to watch. [1] https://shottracker.com/articles/the-3-point-revolution https://shottracker.com/articles/the-3-point-revolution [2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915101/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915101/
- bdangubic 2y agoSteph Curry and analytics have ruined the NBA. Not Steph’s fault, he is just an insane shooter but today’s game is now based on 3’s. analytics have helped explain to teams that 3-pointer is not a little more that 2-pointer, it is 50% (FIFTY) more. For NBA’s survival 3-pt line needs to be moved at least 6 feet back if not more. Can’t have fucking centers chucking 3’s at 45% clip. The best of the best need to shoot less than 30% from 3’s in order for NBA to change to a more interesting game again. And of course season needs to be cut to no more than 60 games