4 ms·
This is a good thing. Let them put those facial scans on a wall of shame. Generating CO2 should be as awkward and uncomfortable as possible. I'm waiting for air
by amelius 2y ago
This is a good thing. Let them put those facial scans on a wall of shame. Generating CO2 should be as awkward and uncomfortable as possible. I'm waiting for airlines to remove all passenger seats.
- frail_figure 2y agoWhy ever leave your basement when you can see the world in VR!?
- Tor3 2y agoPresumably that was sarcastic..
- fipar 2y agoIt will only be awkward and uncomfortable for those who can’t afford business class and not flying in low cost airlines. So basically, it’s the same way it has always been, since we’re in the climate change situation because of rich countries, and I don’t think a lot of us in poor countries care to stop producing CO2, it’s our turn now. “Everything is gonna burn, we’ll all take turns, I’ll get mine too”
- rafaelmn 2y agoI mean if all you care about is greenhouse emissions this still works - leess flying is less flying.
- fipar 2y agoWell, point is that as long as there's enough demand from people who can afford to fly, this won't mean less flying, or at least not significantly less flying, but it will mean even more inequality. I just don't think this is an easy thing to resolve.
- aziaziazi 2y ago> I don’t think a lot of us in poor countries care to stop producing CO2 I’m not sure about the situation everywhere but China gouvernement seems to care more than most other countries, rich or not. They flew a commercial plane with SAF in September. I personally think SAF is a terrible idea but give them credits for willingness.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoCurious: Why is SAF a terrible idea? I don't think we're going to be able to electrify long-distance flights any time soon, and SAF seems like the most sensible solution that's actually available.
- aziaziazi 2y agoSAF production is in direct competition against food production for water and space. They also generate a lot of CO2e because moving stuff long distance and/or via air require a lot of energy. SAF didn’t change anything here. I’m sure the claimed 85% CO2 reduction can be "proved" by analyzing choosen aspect while ignoring others. I really trust the willingness of the executives at work but understand they’re biased to continue A.business B.lifestyle. Most executives are over optimistic of what they’re doing because that’s a good think for their business. I don’t blame.
- fipar 2y agoYou are correct in part but I think not in whole, since I said "a lot of us" and I'm pretty sure people in China would continue driving ICE and flying if it was up to them, the changes are just imposed top-down. I'm glad when an authoritarian regime does something that ends up being good but 1) I still dislike the regime, and 2) I don't think that's something you can rely on. Plus I'm pretty sure (just like everyone else) they're doing this not to avoid climate change but because they have a huge opportunity coming out ahead as providers of cleaner means of transportation (IMHO they already kick ass in EVs and will be the dominant player in this market). But your point stands and has a lot of merit. What remains of my point is that I suspect most people in China wouldn't care about CO2 if up to them, and most of the rest of the poor/undeveloped countries will continue to not care.
- Eumenes 2y agoI'm all for making travel more expensive. Mostly to remove the trashy and rude people from the equation. I don't care about C02 but I do enjoy seeing megalomaniacs like John Kerry and Taylor Swift lecture us plebs on climate/social justice, but fly private jets everywhere.
- amelius 2y agoMore expensive isn't fair because travel would become a rich person's hobby. A better approach would be rationing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing
- fipar 2y agoYou're absolutely right, but the problem is the intersection set of rich people and powerful people is quite large (they're almost, but not quite, the same set) and why would they ration themselves? If air travel rationing would ever be implemented, instead of travel becoming a rich person's hobby (which it already is, for a very loose definition of rich, a definition loose enough that it also counts people with in-house bathrooms with running water and waste disposal systems as rich) it would become a powerful person's hobby. Not that different IMHO. But, just to be clear, I'm totally with you. It's just that I'm terribly pessimistic. What kind of gives me little moments of joy is thinking of what the 3000 version of "Fall of civilizations" podcast will have to say about what is happening now.
- Eumenes 2y agoIts already a rich persons hobby. So rationing would suggest subsidizing travel domestically by the rich, for the less rich, but still globally, very well off. > It is estimated that around 95% of the world’s population has never experienced air travel firsthand. https://www.ncesc.com/has-only-5-of-the-worlds-population-ever-been-on-an-airplane/ https://www.ncesc.com/has-only-5-of-the-worlds-population-ev...
- RamblingCTO 2y agoIt got a magnitude more expensive since covid. Private jets are the problem, not Kate from the UK flying to Tenerife once a year via ryan air.
- hoseja 2y agoModern airliner travel is about as or more co2-efficient as riding a bus.
- unsigner 2y agoI don’t regularly take buses to the other side of Europe to eat some gelato and gawk at cathedrals for a weekend. A lot of people use cheap airlines as cheap entertainment.
- dagw 2y agodon’t regularly take buses to the other side of Europe They used to. When I was growing up, way before budget airlines, buses used to be the way you traveled around Europe for cheap.
- acdha 2y agoDefinitely - and it’s nowhere near the carbon emissions so I think what happened is that they saw someone else’s data (hopefully inadvertently) comparing a mostly full long haul flight (148gm CO2/passenger/kilometer) to a city bus (97g) rather than the long-distance buses you mentioned which are far more efficient since they don’t stop frequently (27g). https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint
- nurbl 2y agoPossible, but taking the bus halfway around the world would also produce a lot of emissions.
- rob74 2y agoIf the airplanes are completely full (which, despite all attempts by Ryanair to scare away their customers, they apparently still are). But this fails to account for "induced demand": if flights would be more expensive or less convenient, people wouldn't fly on weekend trips/holidays, visiting relatives in faraway countries etc. as frequently as they do now.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y ago> Generating CO2 should be as awkward and uncomfortable as possible. Since essentially every activity generates CO2, what you are essentially saying is that life should be made as awkward and uncomfortable as possible. And this certainly feels like the approach many eco-activists are taking, triggering well-deserved backlash. The Green party in Germany, for example, does extremely sensible politics in most areas, but mixes it with performative policies that are more about visibility (through causing inconvenience) than actually meaningful impact. So every time your drink tastes like cardboard as your straw is dissolving, you're reminded to vote for anything else. And "anything else" will most likely not enact the policies that might actually make sense (e.g. stricter carbon taxation).
- acdha 2y ago“Generating” is definitely the wrong term: burning fossil fuels puts sequestered carbon back into the atmosphere so we’d want to distinguish that from recirculating carbon as you would by, say, riding a bicycle where all of the carbon was recirculated. I completely agree with your second point: the low-benefit performative stunts are so foolish that you’d be forgiven for thinking they were the work of undercover saboteurs.
- aziaziazi 2y agoI 100% agree with your second point. > life should be made as awkward and uncomfortable as possible. I have a hard time seeing good faith here but let say you really didn’t got it: What he is saying is that CO2-problematic activities should be made more awkward and unconfortable than those that don’t. A cousin view would be to make substainable options easier and cheaper that others. You know like various incentives measures used everywhere in the economy to serve other goals we set earlier, like keep some domestic agriculture or tax more the cigarettes.