7 ms·
Jaguar Land Rover electric car whistleblower sacked
- iambateman 2y agoThanks to the brave person who was willing to speak out in the face of retaliation. People like this are heroic and are essential to keeping unscrupulous bureaucrats in check. Hopefully he gets paid in court.
- klooney 2y agoWell that was wild. An industry wide recruiting blacklist sounds terrible. Key takeaways here are probably "Vinfast doesn't have much in house engineering" and "don't buy one right now".
- buckle8017 2y agoThe key takeaway is that Tata Group doesn't care about safety at all.
- lnsru 2y agoWho cares actually? Nobody. See initial Tesla problem with wheels falling off: https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/us-agency-opens-probe-into-120000-tesla-model-y-vehicles-2023-03-08/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/us-age... Launch fast, ignore obvious things. I see it daily: „just ship products, we finish them when they come for repairs“. Scary new world, nobody is really responsible for this. The workers do not stay long. As well as managers.
- dontlaugh 2y agoTesla and Tata are both famously worse than the rest of the industry, though.
- egeozcan 2y agoI recall a discussion here about the decline in software quality, from many years ago. Someone argued that if we designed hardware the way we design software, we'd be too afraid to go outside. At the time, I thought it was just hyperbole... It's still clearly an exaggeration, but one could argue that reality is gradually moving in that direction.
- stonemetal12 2y ago>gradually moving in that direction Lead paint on children's toys and asbestos in the walls suggest there has never been a culture of making sure it is safe before putting it in production even in the physical world.
- ben_w 2y agoLead pipes, yes. But asbestos in the walls is great for the safety of those living there — the place doesn't burn down so easily. It's the safety of anyone who inhales the dust when the place gets broken down that's endangered by asbestos.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lnsru 2y agoMy director pushes production guys really hard. They sometimes close an eye and ship a bit faulty product. No screws on heatspreader or wrong thermal pad. And here you go, these things do not last long. But in the books revenue was made in that year. Repairs will come later as separate expense.
- ben_w 2y ago> I recall a discussion here about the decline in software quality, from many years ago. Someone argued that if we designed hardware the way we design software, we'd be too afraid to go outside. At the time, I thought it was just hyperbole... That meme goes back at least to the 90s: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/car-balk/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/car-balk/
- smitelli 2y ago> Who cares actually? Nobody. I do. Speaking only for myself, but Tesla has a long long way to go to repair its manufacturing reputation in my eyes.
- sorenjan 2y agoVolvo has their own safety center. https://youtube.com/watch?v=wOJrhNCsPL4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=wOJrhNCsPL4
- constantcrying 2y agoDo you think any medium sized car company doesn't have that?
- borski 2y agoTesla is, by far, the most egregious representative of this. Tata is second. Plenty of companies do care. These two don’t.
- xbar 2y agoTrue. Nor does any other manufacturer of cars nor toys nor paint nor cosmetics nor AI software nor canned foods.... Consumers and victims care about safety. Regulation is the only reason safety exists.
- borski 2y agoLucid and Volvo both care very much about safety. Safety is core to both their brands, and part of what they’ve built them on.
- zie 2y agoVolvo in the past absolutely cared, future Volvo it's still unknown(they have a new owner and their position is unknown last I checked).
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoVolvo is majority-owned by Geely, a car brand that is definitely not known for safety.
- zie 2y agoI meant Volvo’s position under the new ownership. It’s possible Geely enforces Volvo to care as much as they care. It’s also possible they let Volvo be Volvo around safety and have some other way to juice the returns and make them a bunch of money from the purchase. Time will tell.
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoI think Volvo is a good example for why most companies don't care about safety any more than the law and basic PR requires: the market does not reward companies that try to use safety as a selling point. Volvo is the only major car company that consistently manufactures cars that widely exceed legal safety requirements, but have a global market share of less than half a percent. That's probably about the number of people who take safety into consideration as a major factor when making purchasing decisions.
- ipython 2y agoIt’s all about economics. Just apply the formula: https://youtu.be/SiB8GVMNJkE https://youtu.be/SiB8GVMNJkE (May not be SFW depending on where you work)
- Mashimo 2y agoOr at least blacklisted from that platform they use for recruitment? https://magnitglobal.com/us/en/workforce-management-platform/integrated-platform.html https://magnitglobal.com/us/en/workforce-management-platform... > AI-powered Talent Matching: Leverage AI to identify and match top talent across blue collar and white collar roles from a broad range of sources including contingent workers, freelancers, and project-based workers.
- asplake 2y agoIs that even legal in the UK?
- pjc50 2y agoI wonder how an industry wide blacklist complies with GDPR right to be forgotten. Oh wait, it doesn't, but because it's not a tech company it gets a free pass.
- GJim 2y agoYou are being downvoted because you fail to understand the basic tenants of the GDPR. Choosing to remain ignorant of such important legislation is ridiculous.
- sib 2y ago>> because you fail to understand the basic tenants of the GDPR Hi! In the spirit of improving communication and assuming that you'd like to know: A tenant is someone who rents a property A tenet is a principle or belief that is generally considered to be true
- ben_w 2y agoDisagree, I think it's more about the snark. GDPR may have technically replaced the right to be forgotten with a more limited right of erasure, but unless you care about legal phrasing it's an easy thing to mix up. Also, it does look like a GDPR issue to me — not that I'm a lawyer, so usual caveat applies, all I can do is look at the plain language of GDPR on the Commission website. GDPR regulates "personal data" (information that relates to an identified or identifiable individual), and looking at the "lawful purposes" list in Article 6, people running such a thing would seem to me to need to make some kind of argument about "legitimate interests" or "performance of a contract". It may be that a plain reading of this isn't giving me the correct answer, but I don't see how placing specifically whistleblowers (rather than, say, known embezzlers) on a blacklist would meet the standards: https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection/rules-business-and-organisations/legal-grounds-processing-data/grounds-processing/what-does-grounds-legitimate-interest-mean_en https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection/r...
- baq 2y agoFirst rule of blowing the whistle: never disclose your identity if you can avoid it, even to authorities. There’s no upside to that and authorities are incompetent at preserving anonymity if it’s even legal for them to do so. (Exception: you’re filing a whistleblower report to the SEC, there’s sweet anonymous $$$ for you then.)
- htk 2y agoBut what about the ego? Any virtuous act might be fueled by the expectation of recognition.
- that_guy_iain 2y agoFor some reason this has been downvoted, it seems some people on here think that whistleblowing is never about ego. I wouldn't be surprised if it was a factor most of the time.
- croes 2y agoSo if the name is disclosed it‘s ego and if the source stays anonymous it’s not trustworthy. Got it.
- that_guy_iain 2y agoDidn't say that. Didn't say anything close to that. Not to mention you can be trustworthy and still do something for self-serving purposes.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoMight makes right sycophants without own opinions or values are worthless company wherever you go..
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoThis happened in the other SEC when a football player at an SEC school provided evidence that there were illegal benefits being provided to some of his teammates. The PDF report blacked out his name but was done in such a way that copying and pasting the redacted portion of the report showed his name in clear text.
- r0ckarong 2y agoIs there any society on the planet that isn't fundamentally corrupt at this point? We put whistleblower protection on the books and they punish those who step forward. It's just disgraceful.
- robertlagrant 2y agoAt this point? Do you think corruption is increasing compared to 100 years ago, globally?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mmooss 2y agoWhat are you doing about it? Do you refuse to buy those brands? Vote for leaders who will do something about it? The answer always begins with the people in mirrors, including the one in my mirror too.
- nickdothutton 2y agoUseful interview pattern for candidates: Candidate: Is this a newly created roll? Company: No. Candidate: <breezily> What did the last guy die of? You'd be surprised how few interviewers are able to lie fast enough and convincingly enough.
- lupusreal 2y agoSad to see what's happened to a once great, once British, brand.
- sccomps 2y ago> once British All of its senior executive leadership is still British https://www.jaguarlandrover.com/leadership https://www.jaguarlandrover.com/leadership
- dagw 2y agoAll of its senior executive leadership is still British Obviously not true. One of them is German.
- JaDogg 2y agoBoth speak Germanic languages, close enough?
- taffronaut 2y agoAs British as the British Royal Family then https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Windsor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Windsor
- ginko 2y agoEven better then.
- sib 2y agoJaguar was historically known for terrible quality control, right? When I was young, the joke was that you had to own two; one to use while the other was in the shop...
- y-c-o-m-b 2y agoYeah "once great" is definitely a huge exaggeration. They're terribly unreliable. In the 90s we had one Jag in the neighborhood I lived in and it never moved lol. Everyone knew they were junk even back then. How it usually went (not sure about now, but certainly 10 years ago): Dodge < Jaguar/Landrover < Germans cars < American cars < Japanese cars
- nabla9 2y ago> posting concerns on Reddit He started commenting after NHTSA was already on the case. He was commenting the investigation where VinFast was cooperating. It would be better to report to media, regulators or, relevant hedge fund who could start shorting.
- ge0 2y agoThe weird thing for me here is why it is relevant that it's an electric car, at the end of the day the failure was with the engineering of the suspension, nothing to do with the way that it is powered. This could have happened with any vehicle, this article seems to be click baiting on the fact that the model was an EV.
- thfuran 2y agoElectric vehicles are very heavy, which means a lot of mechanical stress for the suspension. And any rate, if a particular EV model was what's affected, why not specify that?
- bloggie 2y agoI'm not sure about that, my electric vehicle weighs about a ton less than a Mustang.
- qup 2y agoIs it a skateboard? Mustangs aren't even 2 tons. An ~1800-lb limit, to be a ton less than a mustang, doesn't give you much room to make a full-size vehicle. A prius is over 3,000 lbs.
- mikestew 2y agoEven if it is a skateboard, it is still heavier than a non-electric skateboard. As GP said, electric vehicles are very heavy. My electric bike weighs considerably more than non-electric bikes, our electric scooters weigh more than kick scooters, and parent is being contrarian for the sake of being contrarian.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoQuibble: Electric vehicle weight is compared to the ICE alternatives. You’re comparing electric vehicles to things without motors at all
- potato3732842 2y agoReading the reddit thread it reeks of fresh out of school MEs making the wrong assumptions and implicit value judgments when weighing tradeoffs because it's what they're familiar with and school does a really great job indoctrinating them to pursue performance on first order metrics (e.g. weight) the detriment of secondary or "not even mentioned but implied" metrics (failure mode, serviceability, tooling costs, etc) and a lack of senior people like the whistleblower to call them on it. While I sympathize with the complaints about budget and time that kind of further reinforces my point. In the face of those constraints experienced engineers would have designed something conservative with room for improvement. It's new engineers who more frequently tend to over-optimize design something right up to within an inch of its life when faced with tight constraints.
- cogman10 2y agoFrom the article > He soon became concerned VinFast was cutting corners with safety, keeping costs down by employing a small team of inexperienced engineers. > His concerns grew when he heard three of his predecessors had quit after short spells on the project. This to me sounds like the boss issued a task that was impossible to do safely and fired anyone who splashed reality into the mix.
- potato3732842 2y agoA lot of stuff that is perfectly possible to do "safely" is only possible if your head is full of a decade of experience and familiarity with the real world successful solutions to similar problems. People with that knowledge and in an environment were other corners are being cut tend to produce designs that have room for minor revision by other parties as well as corner cutting (i.e. the testing guys pencil whip it) while still actually working well in reality, though perhaps leaving some performance in key areas on the table. If you are fresh out of school and your head is full of ancient knowledge that is in the textbooks and lessons and tidbits of "the new hotness" and you are too reliant on simulation, testing, and other process that is done for process sake in school you are likely to design something that leaves less potential performance in measured areas (weight, cost, etc) but has lot of teething issues on secondary or unmeasured criteria (i.e. the tool and die guys will hate you, your item will wear rapidly in a case that while not average, represents a large number of users, etc) Look at Juicero. It hit the key points, it juiced things, but it was wildly expensive and a bear to manufacture and operating costs were comical because there were no adults in the room to tell the noobs that their weighting of the tradeoffs both expressed and implied wasn't quit right. Here the same sort of inexperienced people were told to produce a suspension befitting a sexy new EV but also to make it cheap. Well they did that, but they also made something that's coming apart at the seams from day 1 and doesn't age gracefully at all and in cases of extreme use results in spectacular failures. You see this sort of pattern in all sorts of technical fields.
- _fat_santa 2y agoAs a car guy I heard about the whole VinFast saga a few months ago. It was kinda shocking because just about every car Youtuber that got a chance to review the VinFast shat all over it. Apparently after a while they pulled all review cars and eventually let more reviewers access them after they sorted them out. But IIRC even after that, reviewers of the "sorted" cards noted that their were still issues and they all seemed to be getting the same set of "sorted" cards which indicates the ones on the lot were probably still dogshit.
- khaki54 2y agoJaguar and Land [Range] Rover are notorious for their electrical problems. I wouldn't trust an ICE vehicle from them let alone an EV. I doubt that even with new ownership or investment (or whatever is going on here) they can overcome the culture of unreliability and poor quality that has been built over a century.
- kittikitti 2y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/VinFastCommunity/comments/1d3be8z/i_designed_major_sections_of_vinfast_ask_me/ https://www.reddit.com/r/VinFastCommunity/comments/1d3be8z/i... Self-identifying yourself on Reddit and then posting classified company information in a childish tone would definitely get you blacklisted. If you read the post, it's clear that he didn't care about fixing the problems, he just wanted to dunk on the company for Reddit updoots.
- cmcconomy 2y agohow you feel about this depends if you're a means or an ends guy
- secondcoming 2y agoDoes the fact that he blew the whistle infer that he cared about the problems? What would you have done if you realised that something you're working on was a death-trap, and managed ignored your concerns?
- KerrAvon 2y ago*imply
- constantcrying 2y agoA) Inform your Boss B) Inform the Boss of your Boss C) Inform the certifying authorities D) Inform the Media If none of these are willing to listen, it isn't your fault. But posting years after the fact on Reddit is negligence.
- sangnoir 2y agoReddit is the Media.
- constantcrying 2y agoSure, buddy.
- darth_avocado 2y agoSmall nit: they call it Jaguar Land Rover electric car, but everything seems to be about Vinfast a completely different company?
- AlotOfReading 2y agoVinfast is acting as a Tier 1 for Jaguar, designing parts of the front chassis. This guy was on one of the engineering teams.
- maronato 2y agoIt’s the opposite. Vinfast hired JLR to design their cars. This guy works for JLR and blew the whistle on Vinfast’s leadership not caring about the safety of VF6 and VF7.
- maronato 2y agoThe headline is clickbaity for sure. Vinfast hired JLR to design some aspects of their cars and the guy was one of the engineers assigned to it. On Reddit, he praises JLR engineering standards and says the problem was Vinfast’s leadership ignoring engineering concerns, always picking the cheapest materials, and skipping safety tests. The title makes it seem like JLR’s cars are the ones being whistleblown, which isn’t true.
- dominicrose 2y agoTrying to make cheap non-electrical vehicles makes sense, because it's mainstream and has been for a long time. A cheap brand would make a car like the ones we had 5 years ago, which are safe. A kind of random number, but you get the idea. I've always viewed EVs as a luxury. While it's interesting to experiment with cheap EV designs, the short or midterm goal shouldn't be production. There's a reason Tesla sells its cars even though they are expensive. They're supposed to be expensive since they are basically high-scale experiment.
- sloucher 2y agoNice self-own by Tata. Guy blows whistle while working at their obscure VinFast brand, but they sack him once he's moved to work for Jaguar - so all the headlines are about JLR rather than VinFast...