12 ms·
Blackmagic Debuts $30K 3D Camera for Capturing Video for Vision Pro
- freedomben 2y agoCool! Though I sincerely hope it's not using some Apple proprietary format that won't work with non-Apple devices.
- strogonoff 2y agoGiven Blackmagic is a brand well-known for using their own proprietary format, for actually selling cameras boasting CinemaDNG support that they after the fact quietly disable in favour of BRAW, they are hardly a good choice for someone who cares about interoperability and open standards.
- tecleandor 2y agoWhat I see from the PR [0] is that it's using a new BRAW version ('The new Blackmagic RAW Immersive file format...)'. So it's as open as BRAW, that is, not much. But at least (I guess/hope...) you should be able to export each "eye" separately in a different format. Converting to the "Apple Vision Pro" format is the last step on the pipeline, after editing. 0: https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/media/release/20241217-01
- formerly_proven 2y agoWasn’t that due to RED patents?
- strogonoff 2y agoCinemaDNG is an open standard. I am using a camera with CinemaDNG support. It came out around the time BM did the bait-and-switch. Another model came out a couple years later, also with CinemaDNG support. It shows that BM is using RED as an excuse to lock people in.
- vanchor3 2y agoRED has a patent on compressed RAW. Apple tried to invalidate it but failed, so anyone who wants to use the concept of compressed RAW has to license it from RED.
- strogonoff 2y agoRaw is not an acronym. CinemaDNG is not a compressed format. It is a directory with DNG files. DNG is an open raw photo format. Both DNG and CinemaDNG predate REDCODE. My camera records 4K 12-bit CinemaDNG with no compression and is in the same price segment. If BM, given options they had (which also include things like “pay RED” or “recall products”), chose to silently remove the support for CinemaDNG in cameras that they sold advertising CinemaDNG support, I doubt blaming RED is anything but a PR tactic.
- tom1337 2y agoUnfortunately the Immersive Video seems to be a proprietary format. Also if I understood correctly you can't even edit this format right now cause DaVinci Resolve is missing an update for that... https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/uk/media/release/20241217-01 https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/uk/media/release/20241217-0...
- diggan 2y agoI've seen people edit 180 videos in Resolve for quite some time. I don't find any details on the various formats it can output, but surely at least one of them will be editable if you have the camera today. The article you linked mentions it uses BRAW which is indeed supported in Resolve today already.
- gardaani 2y agoWhich open format can handle this kind of video? The Cineform video codec can store stereo video, but I don't know if it would be suitable for this.
- fastball 2y agoDoes that matter? If it is a lossless format, you can always convert it to another one after capture.
- TheAceOfHearts 2y agoIs anyone making movies specifically for the Vision Pro? Apple could certainly afford to sponsor a few films to bolster their catalogue. Although for a creative the tiny potential audience makes it seem very unappealing. Then again... Maybe if AVP owners represent an audience that you'd like to target it wouldn't be a bad decision. Everyone that owns one will probably be starved for special content and I'd imagine they'd be willing to buy something specifically made for their niche platform.
- tom1337 2y agoI'd argue that (similarly to 3D captured footage) you can just record both formats in the same time so you can still target the big audience. Wouldn't wonder if we're going to see few Apple TV exclusives which are in "normal" 4K and also offer Immersive View for Vision Pro owners.
- XzAeRosho 2y agoI think the answer it's in the Blackmagic website: >the world’s first advanced cinema camera designed to shoot for Apple Immersive Video I think they are tapping early into an emerging "new" video format.
- klabb3 2y ago3D TV back at it again.
- tlyleung 2y agoApple has commissioned Submerged, the first scripted short film captured in Apple Immersive Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYJcUtVIB_g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYJcUtVIB_g
- threeseed 2y agoApple looks to be getting out of the feature movie business in general and focusing on TV where it is seeing a lot more success. But based on the Vision Pro demo I would expect to see them prioritise non-fiction content e.g. Planet Earth style movies, concerts, athlete profiles etc.
- oDot 2y agoI research live-action anime[0] and this looks really cool, especially if there's fine-grained control over each sensor and especially if you can change the lenses (in a supported or unsupported manner). Anime has the advantage of being drawn frame-by-frame, thus able to "change" lenses, cameras, etc mid action-packed shots. Using this may allow for shooting two different setups at once, achieving a similar effect. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/@weedonandscott https://www.youtube.com/@weedonandscott
- throwaway48476 2y agoHow many vision pros did they sell and how many people are still using them?
- martin_a 2y agoI thought that product was discontinued completely?!? I think new models were said to take at least until early 2026, not sure I'd invest in this without proper playback devices on the market...
- tatrajim 2y agoNo, it's still rolling out globally, and has a growing group of owners, particularly using AVP for productivity applications after the recent system software update allowing ultrawide screen sharing of mac screens. See /r/visionpro on reddit for developer chatter and the latest developments.
- tatrajim 2y agoPerhaps around 400K sold? Production to date is said to be limited by Sony. The AVP is very much alive, especially with the recent system software update allowing ultrawide viewing of mac screens. See the reddit group /r/visionpro for lively discussion of the latest developments.
- OliverGuy 2y ago8TB for 2hrs of footage is crazy even compared to other high end cinema camera, going to be an interesting work flow for anyone editing this as thats not a a trivial amount of data even by today's standards
- diggan 2y ago> is crazy even compared to other high end cinema camera Is it really? I haven't touched "high end cinema cameras" but if my consumer camera can generate ~1TB/hour and it's a "normal" consumer camera, I'd easily expect 4x that in high end cinema gear for 3D video (multiple videos stitched into one essentially) But again, haven't used any of those or looked it up, so what do I know. It doesn't sound outlandish to me though.
- michaelt 2y ago> if my consumer camera can generate ~1TB/hour and it's a "normal" consumer camera If your consumer camera generates 1TB/hour then you're generating data as fast as a Red Komodo [1] recording at 6K "VFX, Extreme Detail Scenes" Consumer quality? A high-end iphone can record 4K 60FPS video and an hour's footage takes up 24 gigabytes. And you're watching 4K 60fps video on Netflix? Youtube? Maybe 12 gigabytes an hour. [1] https://www.red.com/komodo https://www.red.com/komodo
- diggan 2y agoFair, maybe "prosumer" is more fitting, was thinking of the Pocket Cinema 6K (also from Blackmagic). Not exactly "high end cinema camera" so I still think the data rate doesn't sound out of the world.
- formerly_proven 2y agoRaw 8K video at 60 fps out of something like a Nikon Z8 is around 1.5 TB/hour, 400-500 MB/s. Of course most people wouldn't shoot at 60 fps for historical reasons, and raw video codecs are intra-only so data rate scales linearly with fps. They're just relatively heavily lossily compressed raw images in a box, basically.
- paxys 2y agoWhat filmmaker is going to put in all this effort and spend $30K to shoot videos for a single platform that no one uses? At the very least they need to ditch the proprietary format and support Quest and other headsets.
- echoangle 2y agoDon’t filmmakers rent cameras for a few days/weeks?
- mikae1 2y agoYes.
- germinalphrase 2y agoAlmost always.
- smitelli 2y agoYes, and in some cases you can casually chat up the people at the rental house and find out what other (potentially high profile) productions the equipment was used on.
- mycall 2y agoAre you implying the Vison Pro ecosystem is dead and Apple will abandon it? Sometimes the supporting hardware takes time to manifest itself.
- jl6 2y agoAt the current price point, the AVP is destined to achieve a market position similar to LaserDisc.
- jsheard 2y agoIt's obviously going to get cheaper, but rumor is the second generation will only get the price down to about $2000 which is still well above the "lol nope" threshold for most people. Third times the charm? https://techcrunch.com/2024/10/13/apple-might-release-a-2000-vision-headset-next-year/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/10/13/apple-might-release-a-2000...
- brabel 2y agoIn the late 90's I think, there was a movie where a neural device was created that allowed anyone to "record" their brain activity so that it could be replayed later by anyone with a device for that. But it became like a drug as people got addicted to it and couldn't stop living the virtual experiences of others (this was a long time ago so I hope I remember the story correctly)! Some people wanted to experience murdering someone, or having sex with a famous person... cool stuff :D Anyone knows which movie was that? Anyway, this feels like the beginning of that.
- baoluofu 2y agoCould be Brainstorm (1983) perhaps? Also, see the last episode of season one of Black Mirror. And "brain dances" in Cyberpunk 2077.
- BrentOzar 2y ago> Anyone knows which movie was that? Strange Days: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_Days_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_Days_(film)
- sho_hn 2y agoWhich, amusingly, required development of a customized camera to film: > The film's SQUID scenes, which offer a point-of-view shot, required multi-faceted cameras and considerable technical preparation.[5] A full year was spent building a specialized camera that could reproduce the effect of looking through someone else's eyes.[5] Bigelow revealed that it was essentially "a stripped-down Arri that weighed much less than the smallest EYMO and yet it would take all the prime lenses. It's an unfairly forgotten film. Much like Blade Runner, it suffers from a clunky plot but has quite smart world building.
- parasubvert 2y agoFilm geeks still talk about Strange Days. It has a cult following.
- brabel 2y ago
- LaSombra 2y agoWebsite announcement, https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagicursacine/ https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagicursacine..., doesn't even mention the Vision Pro and refers to Apple once.
- leshenka 2y agoBut they refer to it in a tweet that is linked from the article https://x.com/Blackmagic_News/status/1868723512455970999 https://x.com/Blackmagic_News/status/1868723512455970999
- hutattedonmyarm 2y agoOn the preorder page they're talking about the "URSA Cine Immersive": https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagicursacine/preorder https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagicursacine... which seems to be more in line what the article talks about
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- capnrefsmmat 2y agoThat's the page for their normal, non-3D, non-VR cinema camera.
- wahnfrieden 2y agoThat's the wrong page, wrong product
- dagmx 2y agoYou’re looking at the wrong product. That’s the Ursa Cine 17k not the Ursa Cine Immersive. This is the page you want https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/media/release/20241217-01 https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/media/release/20241217-01
- consumer451 2y agoThanks for that link. What I find interesting is that there appears to be no way to view the live video on a set of goggles for the camera operator, or the director. At least, it's not mentioned in the link above. Also, it seems like Apple must have contributed to Blackmagic's investment in this product, right? There are ~300k Vision Pros, so maybe Blackmagic will sell a couple hundred of these units? Without Apple's involvement, how could they have justified the investment in hardware and the new version of Resolve?
- ulfw 2y ago[flagged]
- makeitdouble 2y agoIt's just a camera. Nothing stops filmmakers to publish the results for any VR platforms they want.
- pythonaut_16 2y agoThank you for your insightful comment. You’ve clearly thought about this more than the business who decided to make the camera, and your logic is impeccable.
- pythonaut_16 2y agoFor what it's worth my criticism was aimed at the lack of substance in the parent reply rather than the skepticism around the product.
- ulfw 2y agoAnd your two replies have what 'substance'? Get off your high horse
- ada1981 2y agoThe coolest part about AVP is being able to look around in an immersive environment; this seems like it’s only going to give you 3D but not immersive correct? You’ll turn your head and the image will just stay fixed in 3D in front of you?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marxisttemp 2y agoNo, this is for 180VR immersive video. There are already plenty of stereoscopic, non-immersive cameras.
- ada1981 2y agoI’m confused the user experience of 180VR.
- dylan604 2y ago"There is an included 8TB Blackmagic Media Module that is able to store approximately two hours of 8K stereoscopic video recorded in Blackmagic RAW, and Cloud Store is supported for fast media uploads and synchronization." Um, okay, what is supported and what is achievable are two entirely different things. Even with the fattest of pipes, uploading media content to the cloud is only considered fast if you're a turtle or a snail. Even with 12Gbps connection it takes 10-12 minutes to transfer 250GB files.
- VanTheBrand 2y agoCloudstore is actually a on-set NAS product. So it grabs the footage as you are shooting it locally for on-set network playback and syncs to a remote cloud in the background. https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagiccloudstore https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/blackmagiccloudsto...
- alberth 2y agoWhat does this get you, that the ~$2k Canon Dual Fisheye 3D VR Lens not get you? https://www.usa.canon.com/shop/p/rf5-2mm-f2-8-l-dual-fisheye?color=Black&type=New&srsltid=AfmBOoqhpuzmuTx1inM_u6tpd_GnIyg8GyQ_dB8MqrSsJnvcEyl0UGtE https://www.usa.canon.com/shop/p/rf5-2mm-f2-8-l-dual-fisheye...
- dagmx 2y agoA lot! Firstly, it’s an actual cine camera so has a lot of cine features for reviewing, output, formats that are recorded etc. Next is the lenses, this has a wider inter pupillary distance so will feel more dimensional and natural. It also has wider coverage. Then there’s the sensors and readout: this can capture 8K per eye, for 90fps. This is required for the Apple immersive format because it partially surrounds you and so you need 8k per eye to make sure you have good resolution coverage for the portion of the video shown on the 4k per eye display. There’s no other commercial product that compares to this.
- alberth 2y agoCan you not get this capability with a RED camera + Canon Fisheye lense? I’m no photographer, but it seems like it’d be tough for someone to justify spending $30K on a single purpose camera - when you could just use an existing high end camera like RED + new lens.
- rowanG077 2y agoIs this a serious question? a RED camera does not have stereovision and has no other way to retain depth information.
- amarshall 2y agoBoth the V-Raptor & Komodo have an RF mount and thus can accept the Canon Dual Fisheye lens. The resolution is a lot lower, and neither sensor is well-matched to the lens’s image circle. The whole point of the Canon Dual Fisheye lens is to record stereoscopic video on a “standard” single sensor camera.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- brink 2y agoThis reminds me. Back in the day, HTC made a 3D enabled phone with a 3D screen and camera. I would love to see that attempted today again with how much progress we've made in terms of screen resolution and camera quality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTC_Evo_3D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTC_Evo_3D
- zitterbewegung 2y agoNot sure why but during the HTC Evo and Nintendo coming out with the 3DS having the screen be 3d (Stereoscopic since you can use it without lenses) didn't take off. The iPhone 15 and 16 pro models can take 3D photos and videos right now https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/spatial-photos-record-videos-apple-vision-pro-iph6e3a6d4fe/ios https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/spatial-photos-record...
- BizarroLand 2y agoThe 3DS was fun but it was gimmicky, and it wasn't great. I would love to have a 3d tv that works without glasses even if it was a limited depth thing (like multiple screens on top of each other to create real depth within a confined space) but I think the technology of the 3DS screen wouldn't scale to larger screens.
- jazzyjackson 2y ago> like multiple screens on top of each other to create real depth within a confined space iirc this is effectively what looking glass displays do [0], or at least the early prototypes I saw, split a projected beam across 16 or so panes of glass. I've only seen the little one in real life but it was pretty enchanting. They go up to 32" and 64", something like 20,000 dollars tho [1] I don't know if they've actually made any sales of the larger formats I was recently googling for whether these displays supported Apple Spatial Video and the answer was yes after some 3rd party conversion and playing media back straight from the iPhone it was recorded on, sounded annoying but feasible [2] [0] https://lookingglassfactory.com/about https://lookingglassfactory.com/about [1] https://www.pcmag.com/news/looking-glass-unveils-second-gen-holographic-displays-at-4k-8k-resolutions https://www.pcmag.com/news/looking-glass-unveils-second-gen-... [2] https://stereoscopy.blog/2024/09/22/how-to-use-the-looking-glass-go-to-display-iphone-15-16-stereoscopic-3-d-and-spatial-photographs-and-videos/ https://stereoscopy.blog/2024/09/22/how-to-use-the-looking-g...
- chakintosh 2y agoNow you can watch MKBHD getting caught speeding in 3D while reviewing this camera
- backspace_ 2y agoCareful, people here might look down on that kind of joke!
- oflannabhra 2y agoI'm guessing there is a lot of negativity towards the Vision Pro here, lots of it deserved. However, the immersive video aspect is the one thing Vision Pro delivers that I think is truly unique and new. I'm not sure that is enough to support a $3500 hardware product, but I encourage anyone to try the demo and utilize the immersive video. It was an otherworldly experience for me, and news like this is very exciting as it will allow more content to be available.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sigmoid10 2y ago"Immersive video" is literally just high-resolution, wide-fov, 3d passthrough videos. As usual, Apple is selling a common feature of e.g. the Quest 3 under a different name and for a much higher price. You can get the same experience without having to shell out several grand.
- dagmx 2y agoYour comment is incorrect in many ways. Based on your comment, I don’t believe you’ve actually tried it? Firstly, it is not passthrough video. Secondly, you cannot currently have the same experience on the quest. You can have lower quality versions of it, but immersive video is 8k per eye at 90fps. There has literally never been cameras available to consumers to capture that till this specific camera. Unless you did professional custom camera rigs. As someone who owns both a Quest and a Vision Pro, and has worked in stereo for a large portion of my career, the two experiences are not remotely comparable when it comes to video today. The quest excels in other areas, but this is one where Meta have very weak coverage on.
- oflannabhra 2y agoYes, I have tried both and AVP is a leap ahead.
- Tepix 2y agoFor reference, here are the per-eye screen resolutions for some VR headsets: - Apple Vision Pro: 3660 x 3200 pixels - Pimax 8K X: 3840 x 2160 - Pimax Crystal Light: 2880 x 2880 - HTC Vive Pro 2: 2448 x 2448 - HP Reverb G2: 2160 x 2160 - Meta Quest 3: 2064 x 2208 - Sony PS VR2: 2000 x 2040 - Pimax Crystal Super 3840 x 3840 (57 ppd, unreleased) The VR180 3D footage gets spread to 180° (horizontal) and inside your HMD you see around 70-90° (again horizontal²) or so at a time. You can see that below 8K per-eye image resolution, you will start noticing a decrease in visual fidelity. -- ² the Pimax has around 159° horizontal FoV.
- crazygringo 2y agoIt gets even more complicated when you consider what geometric format it records in. If it records "naively" where the vertical pixel maps to the angle relative to the horizon, then you get the least amount of detail around the "equator", and you get the most at the "poles" above and below you. Which is not only totally imbalanced, but imbalanced in the worst possible way! Back in 2017 Google introduced a new format that YouTube VR uses: https://blog.google/products/google-ar-vr/bringing-pixels-front-and-center-vr-video/ https://blog.google/products/google-ar-vr/bringing-pixels-fr... It's called an Equi-Angular Cubemap, so each pixel represents the same amount of area in a VR projection. Unfortunately, outside of YouTube it still hasn't really taken off as far as I know, although some VR video players support it. I wonder if Blackmagic records in it? Or more generally, in what shape does the 180° image fall on the rectangular sensor -- and so how does actual resolution vary across the VR projection?
- matsemann 2y agoMy Gopro MAX uses EAC for the 360 videos. But ironically I have to go through the hassle of converting it to equirectangular before uploading to Google Street View..
- quitit 2y agoThis outlines how Apple approaches the immersive video format to put the most pixels on the horizon line: https://blog.mikeswanson.com/apples-mysterious-fisheye-projection/ https://blog.mikeswanson.com/apples-mysterious-fisheye-proje...
- mdswanson 2y agoI've described what kind of video this camera is intended to capture: https://blog.mikeswanson.com/apples-mysterious-fisheye-projection/ https://blog.mikeswanson.com/apples-mysterious-fisheye-proje...
- somethingsome 2y agoHey! Nice writeup, Just something is missing, some MPEG formats can encode this kind of video in OMAF specification. Edit: I'll certainly read the rest of the articles!
- mdswanson 2y agoThanks! Indeed, there are other formats (like OMAF) that describe some of this. In fact, I helped to author one a long while back called OPF.
- dagmx 2y agoI just want to say that your analysis is great. I reference it whenever the discussion comes up about the technicalities of Apples solution.
- mdswanson 2y agoThank you! I really appreciate the feedback.
- 4gotunameagain 2y agoI guess the next step here is a video encoder that is natively recording spherical videos ? Any projection is bound to separate areas which could be compressed more efficiently together. A native stereoscopic spherical video encoder could improve compression even more, since side by side views are quite similar in general. Now that's an interesting problem to solve ! (and a very hard one probably)
- somethingsome 2y ago
- PaulHoule 2y agoIt has nothing on this https://www.kandaovr.com/Obsidian-Pro https://www.kandaovr.com/Obsidian-Pro Panoramic photography for VR is on my bucket list although I have a huge list of other projects such as having a reliable camera-to-audience system for stereograms I shoot with another other camera from that company https://www.kandaovr.com/qoocam-ego https://www.kandaovr.com/qoocam-ego Note there are cheap pano cameras too https://www.kandaovr.com/qoocam-3 https://www.kandaovr.com/qoocam-3 though my Uni has a resource center for that kind of thing and I can probably talk my way into borrowing one of the better ones. Stereo panos can be absolutely amazing on a consumer VR headset, I've greatly enjoyed crowd scenes from Paris such as in front of the Louvre and an observation deck on the Eiffel tower. The 3d economy more fundamentally needs some kind of photo-to-3d technology and that is going to take multiple photographs from different angles, a depth camera helps but in one shot it does not give you the pixels that are only visible on the L or the R channel in a stereogram because of obscuration. I've got a friend who makes 3-d models using a $265 million camera https://mastodon.social/@UP8/111915448546172624 https://mastodon.social/@UP8/111915448546172624 one thing we've talked about is where to get the missing pixels that aren't in any of the photographs, it's a tougher problem for him as a scientist than it is for me because he can't make stuff up.
- porphyra 2y ago"Nothing on this" is an interesting way to put it. Two 8,160 x 7,200 large sensors has various pros and cons compared to eight APS-C 24 MP sensors. If you want panoramic field of view, the latter is awesome. If you want high resolution for stereo in a particular direction, you'd want the former.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThe market has shown over and over again that viewers are indifferent to stereo movies. Sure I will watch an awful Star Wars movie on my Quest just because it is in 3d but I am just about the only one. Pano content in VR really is something new. Apple's lack of vision with the Vision Pro is shocking as is the arrogance that somehow a $3k headset will revive interest in something people wouldn`t pay an extra $5 for at the movies. With twice the memory and a desktop grade processor the AVP could trash the Quest 3 at immersive application but Apple is stuck on a backwards and conservative vision of mobile apps floating in the air - totally mundane sci-fi (Washuu had this in Tenchi Muyo) but a $3k headset has to do all, not just what one rich dude thinks is stylish. If you are doing any VR or AR work you realize memory for textures is terribly short and 'more pixels' is the road to nowhere.
- rramon 2y agoI watch a decent amount amount of lower league football (soccer) and one of the main pains there are automated cameras that track the ball and move accordingly, often missing crucial moments due to latency. A setup with a fixed VR camera and a 180 FOV could totally transform the experience, because now with a VR headset I'd be the one tracking the ball with my head movements like in a real stadium. Many smaller local clubs suffer from low attendence due to local factors like people leaving the area, not having time or just bigger clubs playing at the same time. This could be overcome with global audiences and live VR recordings (where you're still able to move your head) and potentially be a nice source of income for many clubs selling virtual stadium tickets.
- ec109685 2y agoThe veo camera does that. Quality isn’t that great but because they buffer and capture a wide angle view of field, they can make it seem like a ball is being tracked by a moving camera.
- top_sigrid 2y agoOr missing crucial moments because they mistake a referee's bald head for the ball: https://www.theverge.com/tldr/2020/11/3/21547392/ai-camera-operator-football-bald-head-soccer-mistakes https://www.theverge.com/tldr/2020/11/3/21547392/ai-camera-o...
- sharpshadow 2y agoTechnically it’s also two cameras in one and would allow for various option if it would be programmable. Like taking video and stills at the same time. Normal fps and slow mo. With attachments one could record two different angles. Macro attachment. Record 8k while streaming HD. But they never offer you a programmable camera system.
- jcarrano 2y agoIf the spacing between the lenses is equal to average human eyes, then that thing is huge!
- kridsdale1 2y agoIn the behind the scenes video for Apple’s “Submerged” film, the camera looks about the size of carry on luggage.
- consumer451 2y agoThis was also posted on one of the best niche subs, r/cinematography. Here is that thread [0], with mostly professional takes. One interesting take-away: > I’ve pre-ordered one. Vision Pro sales will be around 1/2M at the one year mark, and there’s a total of about 3 hours of immersive content available on the headset across every app right now. > That’s a once in a lifetime content opportunity. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/cinematography/comments/1hhvwfv/blackmagic_ursa_cine_immersive_is_available_to/ https://old.reddit.com/r/cinematography/comments/1hhvwfv/bla...
- dangus 2y agoOr it could be the next 3D video, a gimmick that peaks and fades away quickly among the mass market. If you ask me, the Vision Pro’s sales up to this point justify discontinuation. I think that Apple is only making investments in Vision Pro because they don’t really have another long play for “the next great device form factor,” and because Meta hasn’t thrown in the towel yet Apple presumably refuses to sit back while Meta dominates marketshare for a specific type of app platform. I think that Apple and everyone else is very aware that VR/AR is more likely than not be close to the maximum user base. Meta’s been doing everything it can to make the platform stay within impulse buy territory because they know it’s not really a purchase that potential customers are going to seriously believe that they’ll spend hours and hours every day using like a traditional game console or PC graphics card. Meta has to convince you to buy a device that they must certainly know from their own telemetry that users only interact with for a handful of hours every week. The only reason Apple is sticking with it is that it’s a long term play and they have unlimited money. Or maybe because they refuse to give up until Meta gives up. They can’t let Meta own a computing platform out of pure business ego.
- dannyw 2y agoThere was the Newton, PDAs, and Symbian phones before the iPhone. The technology might need another decade (or two), but I think it’s very shortsighted to think VR/AR is close to its maximum user base.
- 2y ago
- omoikane 2y agoWill this one have a global shutter or a rolling shutter? The tech specs doesn't seem to say either way.
- knifie_spoonie 2y agoDefinitely a rolling shutter. I think no word on the readout speed yet, but I've seen 12ms quoted for the 12K LF sensor.
- kiernan 2y agoWhich formats or types of devices would give you the best ability to attempt to future-proof the capture of (relatively low short-term value) home videos of random family moments?
- sbochins 2y agoSeems like a strange thing to be building around. Lots of money has gotten into VR and it has been around for a while now. It has never gotten out of the geek niche and likely won’t. It’s the only way I play games nowadays and wish it would gain wider traction. But, I’m very pessimistic about normies buying these headsets and watching these VR videos.
- jsiepkes 2y agoMeanwhile I still can't even buy the Vision Pro itself in the Netherlands. Sure, I could get one from Germany. However I did that with a Google Pixel 6 Pro and that turned out to be hell when I needed to claim warranty on it. Which required an address in Germany. So I'm not really inclined to go down that road again.
- deadbabe 2y agoMaybe this is a dumb question but why can’t you just record video with two iPhones evenly spaced with some kind of jig and synchronized the video output to get something usable for a 3D video?
- ppp999 2y agoApparently you only need one iPhone : https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/spatial-photos-record-videos-apple-vision-pro-iph6e3a6d4fe/ios https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/spatial-photos-record... But of course the quality is probably a lot lower than with this camera
- kazinator 2y agoThe lenses are too close together for serious 3D. Like say you want to stereoscopically shoot a cityscape from a highrise building. A couple of inches of separation won't do anything; you need the cameras a few feet apart. What's the point of integrating two cameras into one unit, when you can just capture with two cameras. It's a software problem.
- Tepix 2y agoYou eyes provide decent 3d, don't they?
- kazinator 2y agoYes, over small scales and distances. Say you want a stereogram that shows you Manhattan or the Grand Canyon as if it were a model laid out on a table before you. A human-like stereoscopic shot of those places will not produce the depth. (Maybe something can be computed, but that's a separate discussion.)
- empiricus 2y agoJust use 2 normal cameras with 1 meter separation. There are some videos on deovr/quest with this kind stereo effect; for example clouds filmed from a airplane, they look like toy 3d clouds.
- kazinator 2y agoI've taken stereograms of clouds from an airplane. This is done just by taking consecutive shots out of the same window from the same angle, as the airplane flies. So you have probably hundreds of meters of separation. At 900 km/h, if you take two shots one second apart, that's 250 meters. Of course the resulting stereogram is perceived as a wonderful miniature. To make a 3D film this way, just take a regular video, and then split it into offsets. Well over a decade ago, someone in Japan turned some old videos of the Candies idol group (1970s) into 3D this way, e.g.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqBL08JOM0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqBL08JOM0I Needless to say, the original footage was not shot with two cameras; it's just a time offset in the same video stream. Due to the motion of the performers or camera, you get faked out stereoscopy. To find more of these, search: youtube キャンデイーズ 3D