3 ms·
Oh come on Yes, a calorie is a calorie (as long as dietary: macro/micro nutrients needs are supplied), still there may be advantages to the diet, as it is poin
by raverbashing 14y ago
Oh come on
Yes, a calorie is a calorie (as long as dietary: macro/micro nutrients needs are supplied), still there may be advantages to the diet, as it is pointed in the article
"They report that people on the Atkins diet were burning off more calories. Ergo, the diet is a good thing." (it's not necessarily all good especially if you think low-carb diet==eating bacon at will, still)
Also, there may be other advantages, like hunger sensation in different diets.
Dieting is calorie balancing but there are several other aspects that should be considering and dismissing 'low-carb' diets because you're only focusing on the calorie balancing is naive.
- rogerbraun 14y agoHe says that he can explain away the difference in calorie burning as an effect of the measuring method later in the article.
- raverbashing 14y agoOne thing is calorie burning (metabolism) and the other is weight loss (weight measurement), I don't think he would mix up the two naively
- ralfd 14y agoI seriously don't know how you come to that conclusion when the gist of the whole article is that there is no difference between a fat calorie and a carbonhydrate calorie. He says the same amount of calories are burnt. Only the relation to lean body mass (because of less water) is higher. But notice that it is just an educated guess by him, as he criticizes another study.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danmaz74 14y ago"Ergo, the diet is a good thing" is what the proposers of that diet say. On the contrary, Dr. Hirsch says that "when carbohydrate levels are low in a diet and fat content is high, people lose water. That can confuse attempts to measure energy output" ergo, the measurements were mistaken and there is not advantage from a low-carbs diet (as proved from Dr. Hirschs's experiments in a controlled environment).
- raverbashing 14y ago""when carbohydrate levels are low in a diet and fat content is high, people lose water" This is not a bad thing, but it is a thing that has to be compensated. And there is loss of water in all weight loss diets. "the measurements were mistaken and there is not advantage from a low-carbs diet" There is not an advantage from the calorie balancing point but there are several other aspects that are important in diets
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danmaz74 14y agoHe isn't saying that losing water is a bad thing, he says that how you lose it could explain the measured increased levels of calories burned from this new study, even if his own evidence says that you don't lose more weight from a hig fat diet. "There is not an advantage from the calorie balancing point": what he says is that there are no advantages from a weight loss point, as the calories balance IS what creates long-term weight loss (according to him).
- raverbashing 14y ago"what he says is that there are no advantages from a weight loss point" A diet is much more than counting calories. It's about managing to maintain a set amount of food for your objective. Here's an experiment you can do. Replace all your food (lunch/dinner) with chicken fillets (for the daily need of protein), top up calories with sweet potatoes and olive oil for fat needs. See how long you can keep up with this diet. This is a nutritionally sound diet (except for micronutrients), and if you calculate your daily needs you will maintain your weight (or you can adjust for weight loss or gain) But a regular person will probably lose weight because (s)he will get sick of it fast and eat less! The calories matter, but two things can have an equal number of calories and one may make people feel hungry after 1h and the other may make people feel full for the whole day. Guess who's more likely to lose weight?!
- einhverfr 14y ago
- merlincorey 14y agoI eat bacon at will and am steadily losing weight. Paleo, which is similar to Atkins in that you much reduce grains (as well as sugars), plus light exercise is working great for me because I am human.
- raverbashing 14y agoYes But you won't lose weight (meaning fat or muscle) unless there is a caloric deficit. Period What happens is that high-protein diet changes the fullness sensation/hunger, so that's why it shows results and is easier to keep. Of course: less grains == less fiber meaning "you may have a hard time"