3 ms·
The USA is hardly unique in that regard. Other countries have had similar policy issues with major court decisions causing sweeping policy changes. And how coul
by nradov 2y ago
The USA is hardly unique in that regard. Other countries have had similar policy issues with major court decisions causing sweeping policy changes. And how could it be otherwise? When litigants ask the court for a decision, the court has to give an interpretation. Judges can't punt the issue to anyone else, they have to come down on one side or the other.
When a policy issue like abortion ends up in front of the appellate courts it's precisely because the laws are unclear. The legislators did a bad job and wrote vague laws. So the outcome of such cases will always be kind of a toss-up, especially for the most complex cases that make it to the Supreme Court level. Instead of complaining about justices legislating from the bench, voters should insist that Congress write better laws. I understand that sudden changes to established policy can be tremendously disruptive but the anger should be directed at the root cause.
- michaelt 2y ago> And how could it be otherwise? A great many countries use "civil law" where court decisions don't create a binding precedent. Some other "common law" countries - like Canada and the UK - have a parliamentary system with first-past-the-post elections. So they don't get any nonsense like "government shut-downs" because of "deadlock" - and if the legislature wants to change the laws, nothing stops them.
- nradov 2y agoThose differences have only minor impacts on this issue. Civil law courts still have to make decisions about ambiguous or conflicting laws. They follow a different process but the fundamental problem remains. And parliamentary systems do nothing to ensure that laws are clear.
- michaelt 2y ago> Those differences have only minor impacts on this issue. Are you sure? To me it seems fairly obvious that critical legal precedents like Roe vs Wade would not occur in a system that did not have the concept of binding legal precedent ?