6 ms·
3D-Printed Dune Chess Set
- michaelmcdonald 2y agoI won't discredit how beautiful this set turned out, but by my eyes the pieces are not particularly easy to (quickly) distinguish from one another (i.e. rook vs pawn vs bishop). Gorgeous to look at though!
- kibwen 2y agoUpvoted because as a work of art it's beautiful and as a product of technology it's neat to see that printing with quartz is possible. But it must be said that the distinguishability of the pieces is lacking.
- aziaziazi 2y agoI thought the same in picture but in the article author says he used different texture (one smooth and one rippled) for both parties. I give I’m the benefit of the doubt because fine texture can appear very different in reality than photo. Edit: > For a game of chess to function effectively it’s crucial you clearly differentiate between both opposition pieces, and, the alternate spaces on which those pieces play. In a mono-material set such as this, a binary contrast between rippled and smooth surfaces (reflective of the contrasting states of sand) become the primary signifier of this difference.
- krisoft 2y agoI see the rippling and the smooth pieces, that one is ok. For me what is hard to distinguish are the individual pieces from each other within one colour. The knight from the bishop from the pawn, etc. It is possible to figure them out, but at least for me I can't see it at a glance. I have to think about it and compare them. (whereas with a more traditional set I see it immediately)
- oarsinsync 2y agoI think a standard set optimises for usability over aesthetics. I think this artwork optimises for aesthetics over usability. Both sets are aesthetically pleasing and usable, just to different degrees. I think that’s ok? I’ve seen many chess sets whose primary function was aesthetic rather than to be played. The thing with aesthetics is that it’s highly subjective.
- pdpi 2y agoInsofar as one of the defining characteristics of art is the constraints you impose upon yourself, one of the fundamental constraints of making an art piece out of something functional is that you should either preserve its usability, or break it in a way that makes a statement. This does neither. The concept is great, the board is absolutely beautiful, and, at first glance, the curve is aesthetically pleasing while not getting in the way of reading the board. Texture as the "colour" works great. The figures, though, just look like they ran out of steam, it's like the "horse drawing" meme. They're not evocative of chess pieces, they're not particularly evocative of sand structures either. They're just... there. They're pretty enough, I guess, but in a generic way. When you add to that that the photos have an impossible pawn formation, it kind of screams of "I don't actually care about the subject of my art piece".
- JustBreath 2y agoIt would certainly could serve as a fun challenge for experienced chess players. But I'm let down because my chess partner is a 9 year old who is still learning basic strategies.
- wongarsu 2y agoThe standard set optimizes for mass production. All pieces except the knight can be turned on a lathe, with minor post-processing to cut notches in the rook and bishop. Older chess sets like the Lewis Chessmen from the 1200s look substantially different, having both better aesthetics and usability than the currently popular set. Like having a bishop that is recognizable as a bishop, not a medium-height round thing with a notch in the top. If you don't want to imitate the standard chess set, improving on it isn't that difficult as long as you don't care about mass production from wood. This set somehow manages to be worse
- thousand_nights 2y agoi was gifted a glass set once where black's pieces were matte glass and white's pieces were clear glass, so quite a striking texture difference it was still unplayable and more of a decoration
- bigstrat2003 2y agoI read that but I honestly can't see any difference in the photos they gave. You're right that it might be different in person.
- amelius 2y agoI guess you can get the same effect by just printing with good old PLA, and then dipping it into glue and then into sand.
- SystemOut 2y agoFuzzy skin finish might also get you pretty close along with a wood PLA. They can do both wall and top layer fuzzy skin now.
- stavros 2y agoYou don't need wood PLA, I have a Bambu matte ecru PLA and with fuzzy skin it looks almost exactly like this.
- HWR_14 2y agoThat's a great idea. Do you have any other ideas for finishing the other half of the pieces. Graphite seems too messy, and I'm not sure the different sands will look different enough. I imagine the details that currently (and insufficiently in my opinion) distinguish the colors would be obliterated.
- x_may 2y agoThere’s black sand! Volcanic sand from Iceland is perfectly black and would be a great way to distinguish them
- michaelmior 2y agoYou can also by any color of "sand" you like at your local craft/hobby shop.
- sparrish 2y agoGlue on silica carbide. It's usually darker colored and has a very aggressive texture (used for grips on pistol handles and skateboards among other things).
- 2y ago
- Vox_Leone 2y agoJust beautiful. We are experimenting with ceramic gelcasting lately[1]. It involves the use of a gel-based slurry, typically made by mixing ceramic powders (such as zirconia, alumina, or silicon carbide) with a liquid binder and a gelling agent in a 3D printed mold. It is a versatile manufacturing method used to create complex ceramic parts. Upon reading the article it occurred to me that the same method could be used to make those kinds of "dune core" pieces, with sand instead of ceramic powders. There must be a sand-binder-gelling solution formulation that can handle the task. [1]https://voxleone.com/2024/03/05/3d-printing-im-making-a-500c-ceramic-hot-end/ https://voxleone.com/2024/03/05/3d-printing-im-making-a-500c...
- johanneskanybal 2y agoI mean we all saw that but the entire text was about that they are very different because they feel different. Doubt you read it.
- knifie_spoonie 2y agoI think the parent commenter did read that and their concern is that tournament chess has a touch-move rule (if you touch a piece you have to move it). This set is certainly a cool art piece, but not particularly functional if a player has trouble distinguishing pieces visually. The queen looks like a slightly larger version of the bishop (or is that the knight?), I could see someone confusing them if they're sitting at different levels.
- jdietrich 2y agoNovelty sets like these are deeply unpleasant for regular chess players, because they interfere with normal pattern recognition. There's a huge difference between being able to tell the pieces apart and being able to read the board at a glance. It's like reading a book in bad handwriting instead of clear type - you can decode it with enough effort, but you can't read fluently or scan the text.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dheera 2y agoMakes the game more interesting. As long as both sides are equally handicapped it’s fine.
- b112 2y agoI'd actually prefer a Dune2000 derived chess set.
- swiftcoder 2y agoGorgeous, but I'd love to see some actual differentiation of form between the various pieces - going to the obvious source of inspiration, sand worms, stillsuits, the rocks of the seitch, and the insect-like forms of the ornithopter all could lend form to the pieces.
- pdpi 2y agoIt's "dune" as in a pile of sand, not "Dune" as in the novel.
- swiftcoder 2y agoYeah, I get that, but the mental association is there already, might as well lean into it
- mpalmer 2y agoWow, I've never seen a critique backed solely by word association. I am guessing the artist made exactly what they wanted to.
- swiftcoder 2y agoThe critique and the suggestion I made are not one and the same. The critique is that the design of the pieces are far too similar for this chess set to be comfortable to play. The suggestion is one possible direction in which one could go to rectify the critique (thus the hyphen, and the mention of possible inspiration).
- daotoad 2y agoIs it? Every usage of the word "dune" is capitalized in both the article and the link. I clicked through because I was hoping to see something related to the book or movies, or even the Jodorowsky project that never materialized.
- defrost 2y ago
- accrual 2y agoIt's a beautiful set, I like how each side was translated to smooth/rippled and the textures are very pleasing to look at - like a miniature playable cast of desert characters. I agree the pieces are a bit difficult to distinguish though, especially the queen and bishops which seem to mostly differ in height but not so much in form.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thorin 2y agoWould be nice to see a Battle Chess [1] version of this! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_Chess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_Chess
- KMnO4 2y agoReminding me that this was a thing was a wonderful holiday gift. Thank you!
- thesuitonym 2y agoThat article has the longest path to Philosophy that I've ever seen.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- d--b 2y agoTo me, this is the worst kind of design. 1. Aesthetics completely annihilates function. I mean good luck figuring the pieces apart. 2. To me it looks like shit. I mean the pieces look ok-ish (I don't really like the curve stuff, I think they could be a lot better, but ok), but the board, oh my god it's hideous. The idea of the curved board is so bad. ugh. It's sad though cause the material is awesome. Come on architects, you can do a lot better than that.
- nottorp 2y ago> 1. Aesthetics completely annihilates function. I mean good luck figuring the pieces apart. It's very modern. Like those web sites that are light grey on darker grey. And the fact that you can't see if a square is white or black when a piece is on it is like they hide interactable elements in web 3.99 or whatever they're at now.
- spaintech 2y agoDito on the upvote, esthetics are pleasing and I love the transition of the board. Not sure if that was sand or not… but now in hunting for the files… would make a nice gift for a friend that has it all, rated at 2000+ in chest.
- voidUpdate 2y agoI can feel the texture of that in my spine just looking at the pictures :/ I don't think I'd ever want to touch any of that
- CodeCompost 2y agoMakes me think of Bugles Corn Chips.
- breckenedge 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20241217125401/https://parametric-architecture.com/3d-printed-dune-chess-set-by-rory-noble-turner/ https://web.archive.org/web/20241217125401/https://parametri...
- wklauss 2y agoMore decorative than functional but beautiful nontheless and could be iterated to make it a better chess set. Maybe mixing different types of sand as a finishing coat on the pieces? (vocanic and coral for the pieces and quartz sand for the board)
- cies 2y agoThere is a whole market for chessboards that are not actually useful. I prefer the official sizes/shapes.
- btbuildem 2y agoThe artist definitely captured the atmosphere of the recent movies. Bravo! One thing that immediately jumps out at me about this chessboard is the use of varied ground plane -- how the back rows are high up, whereas the middle of the board is down below. The high ground really evokes a sense of power of the "senior" pieces, and casts the middle rows below as the inevitable battleground. One can imagine pieces mounting an uphill attack in the later stages of the game. Such a simple thing, and so effective!
- eleveriven 2y agoA layer of metaphorical depth
- idunnoman1222 2y agothey could’ve made the board have different texture as well? Well, there’s no STL so no one will ever even be able to use this might as well have left it as a 3-D render
- snapetom 2y agoSure, the article positions it as an art piece, but you're right. The fact that there is no STL puts this in the "ok cool. Next." bucket for the the vast majority of the 3d printing community.
- gorbachev 2y agobtw, on sale at https://www.sandhelden.de/product-page/dune-chess-set https://www.sandhelden.de/product-page/dune-chess-set for 3490 euros.
- 0x38B 2y ago> Amidst this decline of everyday physical sensation; the Dune Chess Set represents an investigation into themes of tactility and intimacy in an attempt to catalyse connection between users, their bodies, and the world around them This is either a human writing overly complex, abstract prose, or an LLM. I’d hoped for interesting text to accompany the admittedly very unique chess set, but this is just overwrought and abstract for no good reason.
- sleepybrett 2y agoI was hoping that someone had created a ruleset and prop reproduction of the 'chess' of the dune universe 'cheops'. The prop from dune 2 is so great but barely seen on screen: https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Cheops?file=Cheops_chess_game_concept_art_%28The_Art_and_Soul_of_Dune_Part_Two%2C_2024%29.png https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Cheops?file=Cheops_chess_game_c... It's got a nice 'go' feel especially with the bowls of pieces, that engraved board is great.. just a great prop. Big ups to the production designers.
- cryptozeus 2y ago[flagged]
- cryptozeus 2y agoPossible gameplay addition in dune chess where certain piece ends up on a certain square and gets eaten by the worm
- ddlutz 2y agoI couldn't find it in the article, maybe I missed it, but does anybody have more information on the printer / material used besides just quartz?
- koinedad 2y agoReally cool design
- Terr_ 2y agoNow I'm wondering about a gameplay twist "Arrakis Chess": Too much movement in a section of the board makes a 2x2 sandworm eat the pieces.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 2y agoWow that's beautiful. Can you download this somewhere? I don't see it.
- engineer_22 2y agoArchitects really know how to run with the purple prose. Edit: cool looking chess set.
- snthpy 2y agoI imagine it might take a bit to get used to the different shapes but I quite like the idea of having different elevation for the ranks. I think that would help learners develop a more intuitive understanding of their importance. Something I'm only acquiring now as I'm teaching my children.
- eleveriven 2y agoAny new chess set with unfamiliar designs takes a bit of adjustment
- eleveriven 2y agoWow, this is a beautiful concept and execution! For me it’s a piece of art that challenges our relationship with materials in a way
- teleforce 2y agoVery nice looking movie theme chess set. This Rook Tower theme pack-away wooden chess board is also wonderfully designed for aesthetic: https://odditymall.com/rook-tower-pack-away-wooden-chess-board https://odditymall.com/rook-tower-pack-away-wooden-chess-boa...