5 ms·
Isn't coffee toxic to humans too?
by amelius 2y ago
Isn't coffee toxic to humans too?
- manmal 2y agoToo much coffee does make some humans toxic.
- osigurdson 2y agoEven humble hydrogen can be dangerous in high enough concentrations. This, and daylight savings time doesn't actually add any hours of sunlight.
- bumby 2y agoMy understanding is the toxic level of caffeine is so high that you’d die of hyponatremia first from the water in coffee before caffeine kills you.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoGenuine question: does that mean when people die after consuming way too much caffeine, it's not because of "caffeine toxicity" per se, but because the effects of the caffeine put too much strain on their body?
- necubi 2y agoNobody is dying from the caffeine in coffee (like 50-100mg per cup). According to the NIH, LD50 of caffeine is 150-200mg/kg (so say 10g for a small person). That's like 100 cups of coffee. Even with espresso that's hard to imagine. It would need to be in powder form or concentrated in something far beyond natural levels of coffee/tea/matcha/etc.
- aphantastic 2y ago1 cup filter coffee can be 170mg or more. And LD50 isn’t really relevant here, even LD1 levels are deadly to hundreds of millions of people. It’s entirely possible for what some might consider a “normal” amount of coffee to be deadly to many. See other comment for espresso calculations. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=etnMr8oUSDo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=etnMr8oUSDo
- bumby 2y ago"It's entirely possible" isn't the way to think about estimating risk because it assumes the risk goal is zero (ie any risk > 0 means the outcome is "possible"). A dose greater than LD50 means "more probable than not" of dying, absent additional information, which is a more appropriate framing. Similarly with caffeine content "can be". All kinds of variables like roasting time affect the dose But the semi-standardized dose for a cup of coffee is about 100mg. Related to your link, they are a much larger cup of coffee for comparison. If you normalize it to the standard coffee size, it comes to 100mg caffeine, so right in line with what would be expected.
- necubi 2y agoLD50 is (an estimate) of the 50th percentile (i.e., 50% chance of dying), but that doesn't mean it's linear. It _certainly_ doesn't mean that 1% of people will die at 2% of that value, which I think is what you're implying. The lowest example of a lethal dose I can find in the literature is 57mg/kg. Caffeine overdoses are so rare that we don't know the true distribution, but it's clearly not the case that millions people will die from a few coffees. Your other comment calculated the lethal dose as *a gallon of espresso*. That's like 125 shots. That is not a remotely normal amount of coffee. It would take multiple people over an hour to make that much espresso for you. --- Edit: I can't reply, but "LD1" isn't a group of people and you can't just claim it's 1% of the population. LD50 doesn't imply anything about the population distribution or how it varies by person. It refers to a particular experimental set up (or estimate from a natural experiment) in which 50% of the subjects died after a certain dosage. For example, the LD50 of falling is ~50ft. Some people will be more susceptible to dying by falling a certain distance than others, but there are many other factors involved and it makes no sense to say someone is in 1% of falling-death-probability. I agree that LD50 doesn't tell you everything you'd want to know, like the lowest possible dose that might kill someone. There might be people who are extremely sensitive to a substance, or situations in which it's particularly dangerous (in combination with other substances or another health condition, for example). For something safe and widely used like caffeine, I'd expect that the vast majority of people would experience roughly similar toxicity (say, within 2x of the median) with a tiny population of outliers; but you can't just assume that there's 1% of the population that's drastically more sensitive.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aphantastic 2y agoLD50 for espresso is roughly 1 gallon per 50kg body mass. I wouldn’t want to, but I could drink 2 gallons of water without significant issue. If we accept that some people will naturally have a lower tolerance (and that espresso isn’t the strongest drink in the world), it’s not hard to see a caffeine overdose itself being fatal. (based on 36ml espresso having 110mg caffeine, LD50 caffeine is 150-200mg/kg)
- Tade0 2y agoI see one problem here: caffeine is soluble in water and a diuretic, meaning anyone attempting suicide by coffee would have a bad time doing it. Healthy kidneys work through around a litre of blood a minute, so my guess is that, ahem, "breaking the seal" would keep caffeine levels in check.
- folmar 2y ago1 gallon = 7.6 l, and anectada from Wikipedia (referenced to https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-drinking-too-much-water-can-kill/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-...) says 6 l in 3 hours killed a man. Half-life of caffeine is approximately 5 h, so quite similar.
- bumby 2y ago1 gal is about half that (3.8 liters)
- wging 2y agoCaffeine doesn't only come in coffee. Caffeine pills and powders make overdoses much easier. For example: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8824417/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8824417/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- daedrdev 2y agoMost things are toxic at high enough doses, for example too much oxygen in the air is poisionous
- amelius 2y agoYes, but I get the impression that a lot of people have a limit on the number of cups they can drink per day (usually below 5), after which they get various symptoms.
- DebtDeflation 2y agoAt a high enough dose, sure. But study after study over the last decade has shown coffee to have a positive effect on everything from diabetes to Alzheimers.
- markasoftware 2y agofrom a brief look, it seems most of the benefits are attributed to antioxidants / other chemicals in the coffee, not caffeine.
- DebtDeflation 2y agoI'm not a medical professional, but my understanding is that at least for the anti Alzheimer effect, it is due to the caffeine, specifically the effect it has on dilating capillaries in the brain.
- NavinF 2y agoDoes that work with other stimulants? Pretty much all the stronger ones dialate capillaries with fewer side effects than caffeine
- khendron 2y agoNot for me. Coffee, anything caffeinated actually, makes me sick like I have the flu. The older I get, the more sensitive I become. I can't even eat chocolate anymore because of the caffeine content.
- panabee 2y agoThis is a good question and encapsulates the challenges of food and drug regulation. Yes and no. At certain concentrations, many safe compounds become dangerous in humans. Even at tiny doses, foods like peanuts may be safe for the vast majority yet lethal for a minority. Given how devilishly heterogeneous the human race is, the ideal solution provides safety testing at the individual level, not the population level [0]. But this is years away until computational and biological breakthroughs arrive. [0] Population level is a misnomer. FDA trial sizes below. Phase 1: 20 to 100 people Phase 2: up to several hundred people Phase 3: 300 to 3,000 people https://www.fda.gov/patients/drug-development-process/step-3-clinical-research https://www.fda.gov/patients/drug-development-process/step-3...
- EA-3167 2y agoKeep in mind that very commonly accepted safe substances such as carrots or water also become lethal at high enough doses, for all humans. It's often stated, and it can be tiring to hear, but the dose really does make the poison.
- pas 2y agoAnd context matters. Folks with this or that kidney problems can die from basically nothing while the median bloke doesn't even notice that their piss is a tad darker.
- EA-3167 2y agoThat's an excellent point, and of course individuals can have pretty stark differences in metabolism, with the alcohol flush reaction being a great and highly visible example.
- stefantalpalaru 2y ago[dead]
- 6SixTy 2y agoDose makes the poison
- ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dose_makes_the_poison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dose_makes_the_poison
- chrisweekly 2y agoToxicity is in the dose. Even good old H2O can be lethal in sufficient quantity.
- krispyfi 2y agohttps://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/panera-to-pull-highly-caffeinated-charged-lemonade-from-menu-after-wrongful-death-lawsuits/ar-BB1m3uYT https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/panera-to-pull-hig... Panera used to sell a drink that contained close to the FDA maximum recommended daily quantity of caffeine, and also allowed free refills. Several people died, and sales were halted after some wrongful death lawsuits. This isn't to say that caffeine is dangerous. Danger isn't an intrinsic property of a substance but rather an emergent property of the context in which it is used. (This is why the schedules of the Controlled Substance Act are inherently stupid.)