6 ms·
The entire healthcare system is broken, not just health insurance companies
- chubs 2y agoI hear impressive things about Singapore’s health system. Maybe USA could trial that system in one state for a while?
- benreesman 2y agoMarkets are inevitable: create an arbitrarily oppressive prison and you will watch some “black” market emerge: markets grow like weeds: it’s just silly to argue that we should have markets or not. But markets are not a-priori useful to the broader society just by being markets! A necessary (but not sufficient) condition for a market to be useful is that it substantially avoids lasting and structural market failures. Market failures are almost as common and ubiquitous as markets! They vary in duration and consequence. The ultimate market failure is to have costs which include a profit margin but little or no competition to get the benefits of a market. Healthcare like other mandatory purchases (you can buy an ambulance ride and six figures of hospital while unconscious!) is especially prone to market failure. The United States especially (though late neoliberal “capitalism” to some degree generally) and HN/SV/EA especially now go so far as to actively endorse induced market failure as the goal. Fuck that. Fuck everyone who is on board with it. This is your goblin brainchild @pg: renounce it. https://youtu.be/3Fx5Q8xGU8k?si=0lnuIjUZNHYjYuxg https://youtu.be/3Fx5Q8xGU8k?si=0lnuIjUZNHYjYuxg
- benreesman 2y agoIf you’re deeply in favor of capitalism as a principle (like I am) then this clique of underendowed aspiring monopolist fascists is your sworn enemy (like it’s mine).
- njtransit 2y agoI always find it funny that doctors never think their huge salaries are part of the problem. Doctors in other countries earn way less than doctors here. That helps keep costs lower.
- romanobro56 2y agoWhat else did every doctor tell you?
- leosanchez 2y agoWon't that be demand / supply issue ?
- jtwaleson 2y agoUltimately yes, but in healthcare, demand is fixed (to a large extent) and supply is tightly controlled as the education takes super long and hospitals only have limited residencies available.
- nradov 2y agoNot really. Demand for healthcare is effectively infinite. Limiting the supply of doctors is one technique that governments use to control overall healthcare system costs. If patients have to wait months for a specialist appointment or elective surgery then that means fewer claims coming in. Generally speaking the supply and demand curves taught in Econ 101 don't apply to healthcare.
- hackeraccount 2y agoSupply and demand curves need not apply here sounds like special pleading. I think we'd get a lot further treating healthcare like every other good/service then saying it's sui generis.
- njtransit 2y agoIt is a supply issue. And supply is artificially limited by the AMA by limiting the number of residencies available.
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- mjevans 2y agoMy personal opinion, is that the biggest mistake was passing the healthcare act congress did in 2009 instead of national single payer Medicare/Medicaid for all. Socialize it all; call in the military doctors to provide care that's missing. Train up more. Break the education cartel and '(evil/dark) company' style hazing of new grads in grueling 12-36 hour deathmarch shifts. Train enough doctors to fulfill society's needs.
- silisili 2y agoI'm a pretty conservative person, and this is the one view I break with hardliners completely with - I agree completely. The funny thing is, most people you talk to on either side of the aisle are for it. The healthcare lobby is so large as to buy politicians to make it seem like a wedge issue, but even a ton of conservatives agree with single payer in principle. I'd wager if you put it to a national vote, it'd break something like 80-20 for.
- chefandy 2y agoI think the core ideas of the ACA with the public option was originally Gingrich, in response to Hillary Clinton’s much more aggressive proposal for single payer, right? And then before the federal ACA, “Romneycare” was implemented in Massachusetts (without a public option, but with preexisting condition protection and not allowing separate high risk pools) by Republican Governor Mitt Romney. I think the discourse ended up polarized because Obama presented it that it seemed really partisan but the person that killed the public option in a Herculean commitment to insurance company profiteering was none other than liberal centrist Senator Joe Lieberman. This is not a partisan issue. There are obviously going to be ideological pockets in the extremes but outside of that, for the most part, the only people that are stepping up to defend the insurance companies are in their goddamned pockets.
- silisili 2y agoYou're right, but there are people on both sides who toe the party line blindly(and stupidly, if I might add). I'll never forget Trump being cornered, and him saying he's not going to let people die in the streets, and his audience booing. He claimed they were all donors and lobbyists taking the audience seats, and despite his typical theatrics, I now believe that to be the truth. Either way, today it is a leftist idea I think, so there will exist some people who oppose it out of spite. I don't know a single person happy with the system today, which is damning. Just look at the reaction from recent events...
- groceryheist 2y agoI fear this post's argument incorrectly assumes that the cap on insurance provides as 20% percent of revenue is the limiting factor on insurance company profits. In fact, it mentions cases where insurance company profits are below the cap! Their interest is not obviously to grow healthcare spending. So I'm not sure to what extent they truly endeavor to deny care so as to increase profit in the long run, and not just smooth a turbulent market.
- exabrial 2y agoI’m sorry but didn’t we fix this in 2008?
- idle_zealot 2y agoAm I right in reading that this guy's message is "this is a systemic problem", but primarily just complaining that spending is too high, and that somehow healthcare spending will collapse society? High healthcare spending that was effective would be great! A healthy population is a productive population, not to mention the moral benefits. The problem is not at all that we spend too much, it's that we toss the money at a loosely regulated market that captures the value rather than using it to deliver excellent results. This is the predictable outcome of any market that can push costs onto externalities or that defeats competition. Some markets are incompatible with competition, and the best you can do in those cases is nationalization with oversight. You can't meaningfully vote with your wallet when you're willing to pay anything for treatment, so at the cost of the optimizing force of markets we fall back to voting with our actual votes for the policy we want. This doesn't guarantee a perfect healthcare system, but it does give better outcomes than what we get by trying to force it into a marketplace.
- spyckie2 2y agoMy wife and I recently applied to receive a breast pump covered by insurance because why not? She is pregnant and while it is not certain she will need it, it’s better to be safe than sorry right? We got the breast pump, some Chinese product that, on Amazon, retails for no more than 50$. Given the quality I was frankly surprised to see that the health insurance had been charged 300$. Not even the iPhone of breast pumps in the market would cost that much. It was vendored to us by some organization that is no doubt making a living from selling cheap Chinese produced breast pumps and charging a 600% markup. This is the exact same thing that is happening to Tylenol, a 50 cent drug that is marked up to 79$ when given at a hospital. To ambulance trips. To routine checkups. To medical exams. To X-rays and to cat scans. Literally everything that is covered by insurance is enjoying exorbitant mark ups. Buyers can’t vote with their wallets because there is no choice. The illusion of choice is barely even there, as difference health insurance coverage covers the same things only at different price points. As a buyer of health insurance you can’t not pay for the 300$ breast pump, or the 79$ Tylenol. There is no choice you can choose to avoid that. And since I bought the $300 dollar breast pump, I contributed to the bloated premiums by causing the expenses for breast pumps to be much higher than it needs to be. So I should apologize to you all. But of course I have no option except to make premiums higher for all of you because I want my wife to have a breast pump. There is no other way to fix any of this nonsense except to socialize healthcare completely.
- monero-xmr 2y agoHere’s a Canadian man who had to wait many hours in the ER, went home instead, died https://www.newsweek.com/adam-burgoyne-death-aneurysm-canada-healthcare-brian-thompson-2000545 https://www.newsweek.com/adam-burgoyne-death-aneurysm-canada... He would have been saved in the US. If health insurers ration care in the US, they are just replacing the role of bureaucrats in socialized medicine countries. You can’t solve the problem of too much demand and too little supply without a free market. Yet everyone keeps trying (and pretending) in the medical care field
- moribvndvs 2y agoUh, health insurers in the US do actually ration care. You can consult the seething masses for the care denied to themselves or loved ones by your free market paragon. Besides, the article isn’t even advocating socialized healthcare.
- mindslight 2y ago> once they made sure I wasn't dying I was thrown out into the waiting room and 6 hours later I said f*ck it and went home. Have you been to an "emergency" room in the US? The ones I'm familiar with have those same kind of waiting times. Our healthcare system basically has both the worst aspects of "government" (extremely bureaucratized, top-down command, and no market dynamics) plus the worst aspects of "private" (profit skimming and no democratic accountability). Personally I think we need to start with reform focused on the provider side - like why the fuck can providers just send you a bevy of bills with fraudulent charges, making it your responsibility to sort out? In any other industry, that would be considered plain fraud. But this doesn't mean I'm going to shout down other people's ideas of where they think reform should start by bringing up failures from other systems as some imagined contrast where our system is at all effective.
- AK42 2y agosort of ... other than the amazing revolutions in medicines, therapies and support that have happened in the last 20 years. The issue is education about preventative care, diet, and exercise to prevent negative health events. Eat less (alot less), Eat healty (alot healthier), Move more (Pick weight up, put it down.. then go walk for a while) PBS is the problem - everyone should know healthcare is first and foremost their problem. Most healthy lifestyle people dont need healthcare. When they do, we (the US) have an amazing system and amazing access to therapies to help them deal with the issues as they arise. AI will help people from diagnosis to outcomes in amazing ways.... ask Claude what to do if youve just been diagnosed with MS. It profound how it will help a patient navigate the next steps.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- taxicabjesus 2y agoAmerican medicine has a tendency to pay for things that are fantastically expensive, but aren’t really what the patient actually needs. I found this blog post about this phenomenon a few years ago: Which Interventions Can Be Paid For: The Explanatory Power of “Prasad’s Law” (hcrenewal.blogspot.com) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21728864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21728864 I had lots of experiences with people who weren’t helped by the money that was spent on their behalf.
- HDThoreaun 2y agoAmerica also spends far far too much on end of life care. Most people dont need months of full time hospice care.
- daft_pink 2y agoI think most people agree that it’s not heroic to assasinate CEO’s. It’s just that if there’s someone responsible for some deaths, the CEO of the largest for profit health insurer that has an awful reputation has taken actions that have resulted in the death of innocent people and we don’t find it disturbing the way that murdering the ceo of walmart might be.
- metalman 2y agothe healthcare (hellcare) system bieng broken is a symptom of a societal disease. Hospitals were designed and built for short term emergency and intensive care, they were run by and only by doctors and nurses who could handle anything, having survived the grueling initiation. And that system worked It was self sustaining and effective.Then came the lawsuits and the ergonomic furniture and critiques of a surgeons "bed side manner" Therein began cancell culture. Now we still need emergency medicine, but also mental health crisis, and drug overdose, and nonmedical elective surgeries, and long term "medical" care for invalids, and palitive care facilities, each with specific physical building design characteristics, and very different decision making and management requirements. Oh and maternity and pediatrics need another way of doing things ,see the Cuban model for maternity and pediatrics done right, they are head and shoulders above anyone else. We should be ashamed of our selves for the nasty mess we have built and just refuse to face.