6 ms·
Yes economic system is highly flawed. Elon Musk owns $400B. Earth will become uninhabitable after 1 billion years from now (when the heat of the Sun becomes to
by amelius 2y ago
Yes economic system is highly flawed.
Elon Musk owns $400B. Earth will become uninhabitable after 1 billion years from now (when the heat of the Sun becomes too large for us).
This means that Musk, if he lived that long, would be able to spend $400 every day until the death of all life on Earth.
This is 15 times the current average daily income worldwide.
If this is not insane, then what is?
- narrator 2y agoYou're looking at the world as a poor person. If you had Elon's brilliance you'd probably quit after you made $5 million dollars or so and definitely after you sold Zip2 back in the 1990s and spent the rest of your life on the beach. The only reason he's still working as hard as he does is not because he wants to spend that on himself. He wants the glory of going to Mars and having a positive impact on humanity and that requires control of the activities of large companies like SpaceX, etc. which requires ownership stakes in those companies that are valued in the billions. One of the reasons that he campaigned so hard for Trump is that Kamala's proposed wealth taxes on unrealized capital gains were going to take his companies from him and he'd have to sell to Vanguard or Blackrock, who would give control of the companies to Boeing-tier mediocrity which would mean that we'd never get to Mars. There have been so many companies where the founders sold out and retired because they had enough money and they got bought by big conglomerates who destroyed those companies with mediocre management and neglect. This is the great thing about Elon, he just keeps building and leveraging all that money to create bigger and bigger companies using his creativity and management ability to achieve his goal of launching an era of space exploration.
- 7thaccount 2y agoWe've already sent probes to Mars. There's no reason to send people other than to show we can. It's extremely uninhabitable...like Antarctica is a paradise in comparison with water, air, and a lack of radiation. We have nowhere near the technology to terraform Mars either. I guess you could dig someone a cave and send them some nuclear batteries and a bunch of prepackaged food, but what's the point? Elon is an oligarch plain and simple. SpaceX is impressive, and I'm a big fan of NASA's research, but let's look past the marketing of him trying to save the human species or whatever. I do think humanity may have to settle another world (or move to a post-biological existence where we can just park our satellite brains around a star for energy), but this is going to take a lot of scientific advancement over many centuries. Elon's plan would make a lot more sense if Mars was an Earth 2.0 and we just needed to move a bunch of people there, but it's not and even if we do find something really close to Earth with JWST, it would take centuries to get there. In short, our best approach is to save the planet we already have and continue funding scientific research.
- kiba 2y agoWe've already sent probes to Mars. There's no reason to send people other than to show we can. It's extremely uninhabitable...like Antarctica is a paradise in comparison with water, air, and a lack of radiation. We have nowhere near the technology to terraform Mars either. I guess you could dig someone a cave and send them some nuclear batteries and a bunch of prepackaged food, but what's the point? People always look at this with hard nosed pragmatism. That's the wrong lens to view Space colonization. It's a vision and a dream.
- someuser2345 2y ago> There's no reason to send people other than to show we can. That is true for lots of other things. What's the point of building the Taj Mahal? What's the point of running a marathon? What's the point of getting the world record for the longest time spent underwater? Just to show that we can. > Elon's plan would make a lot more sense if Mars was an Earth 2.0 and we just needed to move a bunch of people there, but it's not and even if we do find something really close to Earth with JWST, it would take centuries to get there. I agree that we probably won't be able to have a viable Mars colony in our lifetime. However, I do think that the pursuit of that goal will result in lots of useful inventions; just look at what SpaceX has accomplished already.
- jay_kyburz 2y agoMusk aside, I think there is huge value in knowing how to sustain human life indefinitely without the earth. In fact, I think its inevitable that humans will need to leave earth at some point in our future. It may simply be as a result of population and overcrowding, it may be to flee war and persecution. I think there is a small chance we have already made changes to our atmosphere that make life here incompatible with humans. Its possible that within just a few hundred years, humans need to live entirely within climate controlled environments. If I had Musk level money I would be working on this now.
- 7thaccount 2y agoMaking a reusable rocket is not the same thing as a sustainable settlement in a hostile environment. I mean sure ...why not other than it's a huge waste of resources.
- macintux 2y agoThat is a wildly generous interpretation of his behavior and motivations.
- fdschoeneman 2y agoIt's the most likely interpretation toe because it fits the known facts. Ungenerous interpretations don't make sense and don't fit the known facts. Musk isn't hiding his intentions. He's blasting them. He wants to make humans an interplanetary species. He wants his name to be associated with that for millennia. I don't see anything wrong with that and have trouble understanding why people hate him souch for it.
- Zanfa 2y ago> Musk isn't hiding his intentions. He's blasting them. He wants to make humans an interplanetary species. What people say about what and why they do things and why they actually do them are rarely correlated.
- fdschoeneman 2y agoOkay. What are his intentions? Since you're a mind reader?
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIt ain't deep. He wants to influence American policty to get more money for whatever personal ideals he has. This isn't mind reading so much as reflecting on his actions from this year alone.
- kiba 2y agoThat is not what people hate Musk for. They hate Musk because he's that unlikable.
- fdschoeneman 2y ago
- scottLobster 2y agoYeah, all his antics in buying/posting on Twitter and his pushing of the Cybertruck, BS androids, "hyperloop" etc are totally part of a grand mission in the service of mankind, and not the acts of an obsessive, socially mal-adjusted narcissist. Gwynne Shotwell is more responsible for SpaceX's operational success than Elon will ever be, she's clearly done a great job of managing up and letting him take the "glory" he so desperately yearns for, but all he really provided was the initial vision and money. Not to understate that contribution, but his supposed "brilliance" is pure marketing. We've seen what happens we he actually gets meaningful operational control of a company (Twitter) and a product (Cybertruck), and it isn't good.
- Spooky23 2y agoROFL. Thanks for taking up the mantle for the poor multibillionaires. The poor guy is homeless, after all. There’s nothing more hilarious than folks devoting time to simp for people like this.
- hilux 2y agoOr maybe he just likes the attention, and he likes "winning," as measured by the size of his wealth. I can think of a prominent politician with the same qualities.
- d3ckard 2y agoExcept he does not. His assets are valued at 400B, provided that he pinky swears not to try to actually sell them, in which case they will be worth much, much less.
- pyrale 2y agoWhy is that? Just because an orderly liquidation would take some time does not mean it would be impossible for him to sell. As a case in point, when he decided to invest in twitter, he was able to use his wealth pretty easily.
- Cpoll 2y agoHe can only share his shares and assets at 400B if the market thinks they're worth 400B, and if there are enough buyers for all 400B. And once he starts selling, the market might re-evaluate the worth of the shares. Isn't Twitter a good counterpoint? I vaguely recall Musk had a hard time liquidating shares to buy it?
- pyrale 2y agoThat is the meaning of what I call orderly liquidation. Sales are usually structured in order not to crash the market. That being said, just because you need to structure a big sale does not mean it can not be done, or that you can not leverage your asset to have cash available at short notice. For instance, a loan with your actions as collateral will let you structure your divestment over years for a very moderate price. Again, what I’m describing is not science fiction, it’s litterally what happened with twitter. Imo it would be a harder challenge to find valuable stuff to buy than to divest orderly. > Isn't Twitter a good counterpoint? I vaguely recall Musk had a hard time liquidating shares to buy it? From what I remember, the issue was more along the lines of him making an offer without thinking it would be accepted, and then be under the gun because he was not prepared. Even then, he eventually found a reasonable financing scheme.
- Ntrails 2y ago
- superluserdo 2y agoYou're mixing up years and days there. It would be about $1 a day, not 400.
- lupusreal 2y agoSomehow people making these sort of hypotheticals about billionaires spending or dispersing their money always make a mistake like this. "Jeff Bezos has 300 billion dollars. There are 300 million people in America, so he could give everybody a million dollars." For fun, calculate how long the billionaires of America could fund America's social programs if they were taxed at 100%. If you ask people this, the off-the-cusp estimates are usually something like a thousand years, a century, some huge number like that...
- hnbad 2y agoSure but those hypotheticals are just poorly thought out ways to visualize the imbalance. Another way to do it would be saying "Jeff Bezos has 300 billion dollars, that is 300 thousand millions. There are 300 million people in America, so $1000 has been taken out of every American's share of the national wealth and reserved exclusively for Jeff Bezos". Repeat that for every billionaire in the US and you should be able to demonstrate quite the imbalance. Of course that assumes you think Earth's and society's (or at least the US's and Americans') resources should exist for all humans (or Americans) and the ideal balance would be based on as little as one needs and as much as one can contribute, i.e. literally how early human communities operated and how human communities still often operate outside economical contexts (e.g. after a natural disaster). You can say that model doesn't scale but I don't see a good argument for why that should be a reason to use a completely different model unless you're literally among the few people it disproportionately benefits (if you ignore how ruinous it usually is to them too at a human and interpersonal level because of how much it alienates them from almost anyone else around them).
- naming_the_user 2y agoThat’s also misusing maths though because Amazon is a global company so really you should divide by 8 billion or at least a couple of billion. As a Brit I think I’ve derived significantly more than $1000 in value through Amazon’s existence as compared with the status quo beforehand, and that’s exclusively counting the shopping part and not anything else they do. You can ask the question about whether it would have happened anyway in a communist paradise or whether Bezos gets the correct percentage of the reward but I mean, it actually is a very useful thing. Similarly with Apple and Google and so on. These companies make things that people for the most part choose to use.
- fdschoeneman 2y agoIn answer to your question, it is irrelevant. It doesn't matter how much money musk has, or you have, or bezos has, or the government has. What matters is where that money is invested. If musk was using his money to bang hookers on solid gold yachts, fine, complain about it. But he isn't. He doesn't even own a house. Stop worrying about another man's dollar and start worrying about being a better and less covetous person.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- harimau777 2y agoWasting his money on luxuries would be preferable to destroying Twitter and funding Trump's reelection.
- thomassmith65 2y agoCut to Musk tweeting "no fear, buy the dip!" as he unloads some memecoin.
- SoftTalker 2y agoYacht makers and hookers need customers too.
- fdschoeneman 2y agoI agree with this but not everyone does. My argument here is crafted to those who do not understand why taxation is theft.
- johnnyanmac 2y agowell you're making a horrible argument of it. All you seem to be doing is saying "he's doing good things" and you dismiss any disagreement with "well what do you think he's doing?" with no further discussion. Musk is a great argument that while the government is inefficient, they are still beholden to laws and people. Musk isn't. Tax him to high hell.
- shikon7 2y agoThat's why he works so hard to colonize other planets.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kiba 2y agoI think access to that much capital as assess to strategic resource, not as wealth for individuals. At that level of wealth, it doesn't make sense to think about fancy cars and mansions and living an extravagant and luxurious lifestyle. At that point, you got it made. However, if you're talking about building something meaningful, that's a different matter entirely. That requires far more capitals than what is required to sustain a person indefinitely. There are shows that I would love to revive and reboot, such as Stargate. There are researches I want to do or fund, such as research into 3D printing, or do long term research grants so that people can do meaningful work. The money's not for living. It's for projects. If your personal projects don't require that much money, you can always give it away to fund other people's projects.
- rickydroll 2y agoI agree with you that great wealth can be used to fund meaningful research and development. Unfortunately, as we have seen, great wealth is used to distort society to reinforce their ability to hold onto wealth.
- amelius 2y agoBut the article is about basic research. Do you think that we can cut basic research just so that one rich guy can have projects?
- kiba 2y agoI was commenting on people bemoaning about billionaires being too rich, with the implication that billionaires shouldn't ever need that much money. I don't necessarily agree with the idea of cutting basic research programs and how it's actually structured(short termism, prioritizing novel results over building solid foundation, etc).
- goatlover 2y agoThe (US) economic system isn't economics, anymore than the (US) political system is political science. You're conflating the instance of one particular system with the study of those systems. You're also confusing economists with actual representatives who pass laws. Might as well blame climatologists for climate change.
- efitz 2y agoThis is not true and is a very common misunderstanding of modern wealth. Elon Musk owns hundreds of billions worth of stock. First, the value of those stocks varies from day to day. He can gain or lose billions of dollars in "net worth" on any given business day. Second, he is not free to sell that stock however and whenever he wants; he has to get approval from the boards of his various companies and is limited in the timing and amounts he can sell. Additionally, selling large amounts of stock causes the price to drop, AND dilutes his ownership in, and therefore control of, those companies. I think a lot of people have this stupid idea of Scrooge McDuck swimming in pool of cash, when they think about billionaires. That's not how it works, for most billionaires (I'm not sure about middle eastern oil royalty). In reality, businessman billionaires have most of their wealth in stock, and it is not liquid, and they borrow against the stock (i.e. use the stock as collateral for personal loans) and sell small percentages of it to finance their lifestyles. If you created a company, and it became wildly successful, and it was publicly traded, who should "own" the company? Should you be forced to divest, and therefore cede control to people who had no involvement in the company's initial success? Is that good for founders or for companies? How does it benefit society? Also note that profitability influences stock price, so taking away control from the people who made a company profitable, has a high likelihood of making the company less profitable, which in turn will almost certainly result in each stockholder becoming poorer. Remember that most stockholders aren't Elon Musks, they're John Q. Publics with a 401(k).
- 1832 2y ago> Also note that profitability influences stock price, so taking away control from the people who made a company profitable, has a high likelihood of making the company less profitable, which in turn will almost certainly result in each stockholder becoming poorer. Absolute clown
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]