10 ms·
Sexism red/yellow cards at Defcon
- mparlane 14y agoHere was me thinking that the guys attending defcon were more introverts than sleezes.
- mmatants 14y agoIn my experience, the introvert/extrovert trait is orthogonal to whether someone is sleazy.
- boha 14y agoMaybe they _are_ introverts . . . the other 362 days of the year. Part of the magic of Las Vegas is watching people try on new personalities (usually without success). It's sad when it turns into sleaziness.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- derrida 14y agoThe pillow-fight example sounds like straight-out sexism to me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mparlane 14y agoWas he asking guys too ?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- derrida 14y agoWhat do you mean by sexist? Sexism isn't hating women although that would classify (that's a misogynist). It's discriminating on the basis of sex. The idea that women would enjoy having a pillow fight in front of men, because they are women, is the rather naive and ignorant view that qualifies this as sexist in my opinion. I hate dropping "ist" and "isms" around, they tend to sometimes approach ad hominem if used to label a person. But in this case, I am talking about the behaviour.
- gee_totes 14y agoSexism or not, it's making women feel uncomfortable. Maybe these red/yellow cards can help give the poorly socialized some clear social cues. And handing them out is certainly going to be empowering.
- kabuks 14y agoAgreed it's a douche with a hard-on. Doesn't mean it's not sexist. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_objectification http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_objectification
- btilly 14y agoIn your opinion it "just sounds like" a guy interrupting an adult who is in a conversation so that he can try to hit on her. When it was not wanted. In what way does this fail to be sexism? Please explain your point of view in sufficient detail that you can be disabused of your misconceptions of what is and is not going to be offensive to random women. Big hint for you. Unwanted sexual attention creates what is known as a hostile environment. Don't do that.
- ryanwaggoner 14y agoIn your opinion it "just sounds like" a guy interrupting an adult who is in a conversation so that he can try to hit on her. When it was not wanted. This is so ridiculous. "Hitting on" someone is an attempt to find out if the attention is wanted. It can obviously be done in very poor taste, to the point of being abhorrent, but it can also be done respectfully. To say that he was wrong to hit on her because it was unwanted attention is completely circular logic. Serious question: in your version of the ideal world, how does anyone ever begin a romantic relationship?
- btilly 14y agoThis is so ridiculous. "Hitting on" someone is an attempt to find out if the attention is wanted. It can obviously be done in very poor taste, to the point of being abhorrent, but it can also be done respectfully. To say that he was wrong to hit on her because it was unwanted attention is completely circular logic. I did not saying that hitting on women is always wrong. I indicated that walking up, rudely interrupting someone who is talking to someone else, and then presenting weird and likely propositions to her is NOT OK. In your words, this is hitting on a woman "in very poor taste, to the point of being abhorrent." Serious question: in your version of the ideal world, how does anyone ever begin a romantic relationship? Seriously? Here is a strategy for hitting on women in a respectful way. Step 1, do not simply barge in on a conversation, find someone who seems open to conversation and engage politely. Sometimes this is as simple as listening to a conversation for a bit then interjecting. Sometimes you see someone standing there who seems bored. Sometimes you need to sit at a random table and start talking with people around you. Sometimes you're both in line for something and you make a remark to the person behind you. Step 2, engage in neutral conversation. There is a ton of stuff you can talk about. If nothing else you're at a technical conference. You can ask what the other person does, how they are enjoying the conference, etc. Don't forget to use your ears - people like to be listened to. Step 3, assess the possibility of interest. There are a number of socially acceptable ways of doing this. One is to tell an off-color joke. Another is to point out someone else who seems to be headed towards more intimate behavior. Or you could make a mildly flirtatious remark. If a woman is happily interacting with you, and responds to a sexualized twist in the conversation with increased interest, there is a possibility that she could become interested in you. If she is draws away from that direction, that's a sign that she is not interested. But you can go back to step 2, and wind up having had a good conversation. Step 4, if more charged topics have come up and are acceptable, then you can make your pass. Even if you're turned down at that point, she shouldn't be offended. Note that at every step along this way you can break off and have had a mutually pleasant interaction. If you don't think that this is true, you should be talking to someone else. While getting laid might be a welcome surprise, that isn't what you are there for.
- mjg59 14y ago"I see these women as sexual objects rather than human beings" doesn't sound like sexism to you?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kristofferR 14y agoPeople have sexual attraction to the physical bodies of other people. Women objectify men just as often as men objectify women, maybe not as much in the media yet unfortunately (but that is changing fast). Objectifying people you don't know anything about is not a gender specific trait, it's a human trait.
- nl 14y agoThis isn't really sexism .... Hell, at Defcon 11 there was a photo-op where you could get your picture taken with two "geek girls" lifting their tops. Umm. Wow. Yes, I understand that the party atmosphere makes having females paid to display their bodies seem less sexist. That doesn't excuse the problem, that IS THE PROBLEM!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Aloisius 14y agoWhat I don't understand is why this happens anymore. Surely no one can think it is acceptable in this day and age. I know we're talking about some of the least socially adept group of people, but come on. I don't see how you can even operate in society if you're literally trying to lick other people in public. Disclosure: I went to DEF CON 2 in 1994 when I was a shy 15 year old and there were no women around and apparently, better manners.
- peteretep 14y agoAlcohol
- syassami 14y agoNot really the problem here. See mistermann's comment.
- jasonwatkinspdx 14y agoWe learn norms from our surroundings. If everyone does it, everyone keeps doing it. Also, those of us in the brainy set generally equate our rational inner narrative as the total of our self, underestimating how much of our behavior is driven by habit and unconscious reaction. This makes us very good at explaining away our poor behavior when it's exposed to us.
- btilly 14y agoHere is my theory. A bunch of the people present think that they can hack systems. And have read articles about pickup artists and have come to the theory that what women really want is a guy who has the balls to be up front about what he wants. So being over the top seems to them to be a way to hack human relationships. Maybe there are some women who respond well to that. I don't know. I've never had a reason to try to act like that. But even if a hypothetical minority of women will respond well, the vast majority simply won't. And you'll leave a trail of offended people behind you. So overconfidence combined with stupidly wrong theories about what women will respond to, and a complete lack of respect for feelings hurt lead to over the top jerks. There are not a lot of these. They are probably a very small minority. But even a small portion have a disproportionate impact on the experience that women will have.
- kabuks 14y agoThe recent rash of articles on HN re: sexism leaves me feeling hopeful that our industry is inching closer to being a place were women feel welcome. I would love to see men handing out these cards too.
- derleth 14y ago> I would love to see men handing out these cards too. I would love to see men being able to hand these cards to women without being ridiculed.
- mkaltenecker 14y agoNo, those articles leave me depressed because of all the idiotic sexists that rear their ugly head in the comments. I mean: What. The. Fuck.
- token_female 14y agoI think the same thing, until I read the comments...
- mistermann 14y agoPrediction: The sexism in IT problem will never end. Here's my hypothesis: 1. Women and men are different. We see this played out all around us, all the time, both sides happily make and laugh at jokes about it, and no one has a problem acknowledging this fact during discussion of other topics, but when certain subjects are being discussed, these very same people will assure you, with total sincerity, that there is no difference between men and women. 2. IT is a male dominated field, and it is distinctly different from other "professional" fields. There is something about IT that either appeals especially to males, or males are particularly skilled at. I have no idea why. And, a significant portion of these men have very high technical skills, but relatively undeveloped social skills, which shouldn't be surprising. Other professions require social skills in addition to the skills dedicated to the profession. IT does not. I'm not saying this is righteous, or the ways things should be, but that people continuously seem to be amaaaaaazed that this stuff still happens is getting a bit ridiculous.
- jasonwatkinspdx 14y agoI believe you are wrong. Your perspective is over simplified. People are unique individuals, and as a group we fit distributions. Certainly there are trends within genders, but we can find examples of any gender at any point along any metric of measurement you like. The point is to stop generalizing and start relating to the real person standing in front of you, no matter what organs or identity they're equipped with. You also have a trivialized view of success in our industry. Social skills matter. Software development is a team process. The reason we're so AAAAAAAAAMAZED this still happens is that once you've some awareness of this, it's baffling that everyone else keeps sticking to these old meaningless generalizations. On the whole we're a smart lot. We should be acting smarter than this.
- kabuks 14y ago> Other professions require social skills in addition to the skills dedicated to the profession. IT does not. I would argue that more software projects fail because of lack of social skills than lack of hard skills. IT absolutely requires social skills.
- 14y ago
- gavanwoolery 14y agoMaybe the title is link bait, but I don't think this is "sexism" by definition. Sexism: "Prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex." A bunch of males were hitting on the author, crassly or awkwardly, but they were not denying the author equal rights. If a female asked a male to show their privates, no one would call it "sexism"; it might be rude, uncalled for, or strange, but not sexism. At a place like DefCon, most of the males are probably not regular bar-hoppers -- they mostly introverted, and probably fail miserably when trying to approach the opposite sex. (Not to knock on anybody, I am introverted/awkward myself.) Long story short, if you step into a bar full of males who normally have few opportunities to make contact with women in a social context...yes, you are stepping into the lion's den. Males are sexual, but not necessarily "sexist" -- don't confuse the two.
- bkrausz 14y ago> Long story short, if you step into a bar full of males who normally have few opportunities to make contact with women in a social context...yes, you are stepping into the lion's den. Males are sexual, but not necessarily "sexist" -- don't confuse the two. On the one hand, I believe you are technically correct (the best kind of correct). On the other, you seem to be implying that this kind of behavior is somehow ok or even justifiable. Explainable, certainly, but it's not justifiable. "Stepping into the lion's den" makes it sound like it's their fault for going to Defcon and not expecting to get grabbed. If this was something as harmless as a lot of men glancing at her, or even the occasional crude date offer, I would agree with you, but being grabbed, asked to show tits, etc. These cross a line that any reasonable person would know not to cross. It's reasonable to minimize potentially promiscuous clothing at an event full of under-socialized individuals. It's not reasonable to have to pass out cards that identify that blatant propositioning is inappropriate.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoI agree - I do not think this type of behavior should be condoned or justified, but I do believe it should be expected. I have seen the same behavior in many bars/clubs. Deep down, every man want two things: food and sex (akin to Freud's "id"). When you have enough drinks in you, your control/moral mechanisms get toned down (your ego and super ego). So, yes, in any bar full of drunk males, any female should expect to get harassed. For clarification, this is expected, but not justifiable or condonable, in my opinion. If you give a knife, fork, and napkin to a starving person, and then feed them a steak, do you think they will act civilized and use proper manners, or pick it up and tear into with their teeth? It is a thin line that separates us from the beasts. ;)
- AYBABTME 14y agoI really don't understand how men, and women, can sometime come to the conclusion that grabbing this gal/dude's ass is a good idea. Like, how does one come up with the mental process of doing this? Is it something like: 1. Homo erectus identified other gender specimen. 2. Homo erectus will walk to specimen and grab specimen ass. 3. Logicaly, Homo erectus is expecting wild sexual intercourse as a result. 4. Homo erectus carry on with brilliant idea. Is it something so deep inside one's primale instinct that they simply can't resist? Is it the rapist sleeping inside one's subconscient?
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoThe thing is that unattractive men observe attractive and/or rich men doing these things and so get an idea that they can do them too. The difference between being arrested or getting laid can be the difference between being John Doe or Bradd Pitt. Can they not resist? Testosterone is one hell of a drug.
- DanBC 14y agoI like the idea of the cards. I couldn't read them. Partly because they're weirdly using text in a jpeg. I'm gently worried about how well they'll be received. Already in this thread there's disagreement. Imagine what that's like when you're surrounded by drunk men. But good luck to them. Clear colour / symbol coding is used sometimes with people who have learning disabilities. For example, when they need to go to a hospital for treatment they can have a sheet with "green square - things I like" and "red circle - Things you must not do" lists. Or cards at meetings to suggest people slow down or take turns in speaking. These ideas are simple, and work really well, and some people are trying to expand them into use for the general population.
- mootothemax 14y agoWhilst there appear to be many reasonable male members of the IT community, one thing holding us back is the number of people who attempt to justify a blatantly wrong situation. Examples include arguing over the definition of sexism, saying stuff like "that's just the difference between men and women," or coming up with hyperbole about how it's not now possible to talk to woman without being labelled a creep. I do wonder how much is because, to badly misquote Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash, of males believing that they're too intelligent to be sexist.
- astrofinch 14y agoAgreed. If anyone politely asks you to stop what you're doing, you should seriously reconsider it, period. Women complaining about behavior they find creepy is just a special case of this general rule.
- rawrly 14y agoWith any large gathering of people you are certain to find a number of outliers with disrespectful social impositions (being racist, sexism or anti-techism.) Defcon is no exception, so it is a grave presumption to place the blame an event itself for the disrespectful actions of a handful of attendees (unless there is a track of "how to seduce women by licking tattoos" at the event.) Furthermore, the fact it is Defcon is held in Las Vegas which only fuels any such flames of inappropriate behaviour with litres of alcohol and tourists who may just be at the casino bar per-chance. This said, I am for these cards. Sometimes people simply need to be told in a direct matter to knock it off. However, please do not cast blame on an entire event for the misguided actions of a few people. I hope this individual has an enjoyable time this year, at the least it appears they plan on returning so whatever misdoings of last year were not enough to dissuade a return visit (even if they plan to now be armed with Defcon funded "creeper cards" it should make the whole experience fare more interesting or enlightening for all involved.)
- swa14 14y agoIt's not that I disagree with the general sentiment, but there's an undertone of self-righteousness there. " I was already thinking about what clothes I would avoid taking to Las Vegas for Defcon. Short skirts, low cut tops, tight dresses, and anything that might be overtly attention-grabbing have been bumped to second priority on that packing list. Why?" Maybe because it's a good idea to dress as part of the business, not part of "the entertainment", if you want to be taken seriously. And no, women should be able to dress in whatever fashion they please without being worried about being assaulted verbally or otherwise, but that doesn't imply the right to be taken seriously. I'm just not sure whether behaviour of that kind is a net-positive in solving the gender-issues during conferences.
- lflux 14y agoDefcon and Blackhat are two different animals. Blackhat is the "business" conference, whereas Defcon is where mohawks and whacky t-shirts are the norm. Dressing as "business" at Defcon will get you accused of being a Fed.
- swa14 14y agoI'm sorry. I meant "the business" as in "the business you're representing", not the "business" as in suits. So in this case dressing in wacky t-shirts and mohawks. Actually, as you put it, wearing a nice business suit might be a good solution for women at defcon. It would buck the trend of dressing whacky forced-casual, making you stand out and garner attention, and, noone is going to grab the ass of a suspected federal agent.
- tsotha 14y agoJesus H. Christ, these wilting flowers are never going to accomplish anything in life.
- codehotter 14y agoDoes this happen at non-IT parties where a lot of men gather to get drunk and to try and socialize? I admit I'm not much of a party person, but from what I have seen, the answer is yes. I do not believe this has got anything to do with IT nor with sexism. If you are an attractive woman (relative to the attending male population), you are going to attract attention. That is how men are wired. That is our culture. Men have to approach women, or they don't laid. Pure speculation, but the man who grabbed the woman's ass probably did it because he was in a mischievous mood, and to express his sexuality, and he probably needed to do something like that and get away with it to be happy. In other contexts, the victim might even have smiled at him (or punched him with a smile on her face). That might be what he needed. I grab my girlfriend's ass sometimes and it feels good to be allowed to do that. The problem is probably that these are men that don't get out much, have low social skills, don't have experience with how to express their sexuality in an appropriate way, and things go wrong. And things go wrong in ways that make women very uncomfortable. The problem is probably not that women are not being respected or valued. To me, sexism would be like automatically assuming a woman is not going to be able to perform some task, because she is a woman. Grabbing someone's ass is not sexism, it's inappropriate sexuality. What can we do about it? Teach men how to express their sexuality in a way that works. Teach men that there are places women go to when they want to receive that kind of attention, teach them to recognize the signals, and teach them that IT conferences are not one of those places. The cards are a really good idea just because it makes men aware that they are making her uncomfortable. Believe it or not, most do not realize.
- michaelt 14y ago> The problem is probably not that women are not being respected or valued. What the hell else do you call it when someone grabs your ass? No-one grabs my ass at hacker conferences. You know why? Because I'm a man.
- derleth 14y ago> Men have to approach women, or they don't laid. Hopefully, a reduction of sexism in our society will also change things like this. A longish article on the general subject of how sexism hurts men, too: http://www.alternet.org/reproductivejustice/156194/what_about_the_men_why_our_gender_system_sucks_for_men%2C_too?page=entire http://www.alternet.org/reproductivejustice/156194/what_abou...
- masry 14y agoMore women complaining about how the world isn't tailored to their every want and need, and they get all the sympathy in the world in spite of how plain whiny they're being. On the other end of the spectrum, I invite you to read this article, written by a woman, on how funny male rape is: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2129385/Exhausted-man-flees-night-stand-demands-sex.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2129385/Exhausted-ma... I don't know much about Defcon, but I get the idea that the person that wrote that post isn't organizing it, nor is a prominent figure in the scene. I also gather that the general atmosphere at that is.. fun-ish. If you don't like that kind of fun, have you considered, um, not attending? Or did you just go ahead and demand that everyone at defcon behaved like you want them too, because, obviously, you're at the centre of the universe and everyone at defcon is just there to do what you please? If you go to a gay bar you'll get your ass grabbed, if you go to the sketchy part of town at 2 am you'll get mugged, and if you go to defcon with a shoulder tattoo showing and you're flirting with some guy, you might get the tattoo licked. If you're not into these things, don't go to these places. EDIT: looks like my link's story has been edited to remove the snarky comments first posted by @NatalieEvans85. Good for them
- token_female 14y agoI fucking hate how openly misogynistic HN is. I don't even want to bother sifting through this shit anymore. s/women/black people/g s/attending/going to elite, white-only colleges/g
- masry 14y agoHeh... sure. That's an apt analogy. The "frat party environment I was stepping into" is totally comparable to elite colleges. /s I feel like what was really going on is that there were n young girls at defcon that went to defcon knowing what defcon is like. They were completely fine with it, enjoyed being hit on and maybe got some one on one time the cute hacker across the bar. Then this one entitled lady that thinks is all wrong, and makes cards about how the people that made the conference she wants to go to are creeps.. and guys here read it and think they've gone wrong somewhere.
- 14y ago
- option_greek 14y agoI hope the cards won't end up becoming badges of honor for creeps.
- vishaldpatel 14y agoThe way to reduce this type of sexism and increase understanding is through more interaction, and not less. Yellow and red cards may achieve segregation, but they'll also introduce fear into the mix. A man who receives one of these cards, for whatever reason, will think twice before he talks to a girl at a conference again, just as a girl who has been grabbed once at Defcon thinks twice before ever going to Defcon again. People deal with fear and stress in funny ways. Adding one more layer of fear in a society that is already a little too afraid of the opposite sex will only backfire more in some other way. Men who grab women do so because they're afraid to talk to them. Similarly, every time a guy says "hello" to an overly paranoid girl, she'll think that he wants to get in her pants.
- wildgift 14y agoA little fear on the part of a man given one of these cards isn't equivalent to the fear of a woman who has been grabbed.
- vishaldpatel 14y agoYou're nitpicking. My stance is that they're both fears and they'll both result in more fear, which is counterproductive to a society that is trying to reduce sexism.
- wildgift 14y agoAn imbalance of power isn't "nitpicking". In this situation, it's not incumbent on the women to educate the men. It's a bar, or a party, not a classroom. The men are being told about the problem, and need to get their act together. Maybe the way to do it is to hold a class on sexism and behavior at defcon.
- vishaldpatel 14y agoNitpicking is when someone loses sight of the big picture when they perceive imperfections in a part of it. You're definitely nitpicking.
- tomc1985 14y agoHow many creepers are going to start collecting these cards? You know, like a creeper leaderboard...
- cfn 14y agoThis is if anything a sad state of affairs. Maybe as a reaction to this, locally, there is a women only developer user group where men can only attend if invited. The other user group has a 50:1 ratio of men vs. women.
- readme 14y agoI tend to believe that women initiate encounters with men with unconscious non-verbal signals. A man who is able to read these signals will have a good success rate in meeting new women. A man who cannot will be pegged as a "creeper". I think it's not only true in real life, but on dating sites as well. Women receive so many messages from men that you are probably just going to get buried in all the noise if you send one. The best approach would be to make a good profile, and wait for them to message you. I'm not saying males initiating contact on these sites won't have any success, but I'd say it's statistically unlikely, comparatively. It is also a strange coincidence that even on a biological level millions of sperm must compete to fertilize one egg. In lieu of absolute scientific proof (which may or may not exist) I'm fairly confident women are the ones who do the choosing, not us. For the best results in approaching women, please consider the following flowcharts: Pre-Approach Flowchart: <eye contact?> --no--> STOP | yes | <did it seem adverse?> --yes--> STOP | no | <is boyfriend present?> --yes--> STOP | no | APPROACH Approach Flowchart: <Did you open by sexually assaulting this woman, such as by unwanted touching?> -------------YES---> GO TO JAIL | <Did you open with a pick-up line?> --YES--> FAIL | <Did you open with a cowardly question such as: do you have the time?> --YES--> FAIL | <Did you confidently introduce yourself or say something very interesting?> --NO--> FAIL | yes | <Was it reciprocated?> --NO--> Nice try anyway | yes | +-- <Are you and her still exchanging mutual -- NO | conversation?> | | | | | YES | | | | NO---<Do you think it is time to end it?> | | +--------------------------+ YES | | | | | <Did you end it?>--NO---[Your odds worsened] | | YES | | | <Did you agree to meet --------+ again or go somewhere else together immediately?>--NO--+ | | WIN ------------YES | | +-------------------------- | <Did you get her number?>--NO-- Maybe you | will see her again. YES | Call soon or she will forget who you are. Don't leave a message the first time. Don't call more than two times in the first week. If very desperate and no luck after two you may try calling once more in a week, but seriously, move on...
- stevewillows 14y agoI think it's great to recognize when someone is inappropriate -- but I can only imagine pervy young boys seeing these as another collectable item from DefCon. My concern is that the cards put a humour or reduced weight to something that is extremely serious.
- camelCase 14y agoThere was an interesting post by a blogger from the MRA/PUA scene. His take is that women can't have it both ways. On the one hand, she invites approaches by dressing in revealing outfits, on the other hand, she complains if the "wrong" guys hits on her. The blog post is here:http://aaronsleazy.blogspot.com/2012/07/note-to-women-if-you-dont-want-to-get.html http://aaronsleazy.blogspot.com/2012/07/note-to-women-if-you... I've also submitted this story to HN, hoping it would yield some interesting comments. [1] [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4243501 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4243501