7 ms·
The Depths of Wikipedians
- Philpax 2y agoDelightful interview that goes into some of the mentalities involved in Wikipedia editing and the people behind it. Great read!
- bowmessage 2y agoI’ve seen Annie’s live show in Seattle! It was extremely entertaining, highly recommend.
- simonw 2y agoAnnie has a fantastic TikTok account https://www.tiktok.com/@depthsofwikipedia https://www.tiktok.com/@depthsofwikipedia
- spacesanjeet 2y agoThanks for sharing. Wonderful read.
- cxr 2y ago> that's the unfortunate thing about growing and becoming a massive encyclopedia that's more respected than it was in 2004 Is it? Wikipedia was massive and respected in 2014, too, but it wasn't dominated by the problems discussed immediately beforehand—WP:BRD didn't neuter WP:BOLD, and egoists with "standing" didn't have free reign to antagonize newcomers who followed the rules. The problem with Wikipedia and other WMF projects nowadays is the entrenched folks with standing not being subject to rules and being permitted to apply new ones pulled out of thin air, not to mention the insidious circling-of-the-wagons when they're challenged and comrades come to their defense by trying to attack and smear the perceived threat. In a well-ordered and functioning society you can avoid running afoul of the law by following the rules—you can get by without having to pay speeding tickets by simply not speeding. Wikipedia and other WMF projects that have been infected by Wikipedia admins and their toxic mindset are more like a society where impunity might as well be codified—like a cop who says, "It's like this because I say so."
- rvba 2y agoWikimedia foundation could audit the admins who defend each other on a tit or tat basis and attack newbies. My lifetime achievement is getting one those assholes banned. Exactly as you say - rules dont aplly to them. Also using the "standards" to delete everything even when fully cited, while their own articles are slop. Not to mention people who edit good articles just to have more edits. Often for the worse. The worst trend recently is putting 5-10 paragraph quotations in articles. Often by some randoms (self promotion?). Those look like articles written by 5th graders. Wikipedia should be concise!
- kemayo 2y ago> Wikimedia foundation could audit the admins who defend each other on a tit or tat basis and attack newbies. The challenge here is that "the community" really doesn't want the Foundation doing that. The interview mentions the last major flare-up along those lines: FramGate, though it amusingly got mis-transcribed as "Forum Gate". The WMF handed out a 1 year ban from English Wikipedia to an admin called Fram, who this interview describes as "gruff, not friendly, not the most empathetic", for unspecified harassment. There was a great big "community" revolt over it, and the WMF wound up backing down by letting the English Wikipedia arbitration committee undo the ban. The Foundation has a lot of practical power, in that it runs the servers. On a pure technical level, it can do absolutely anything and nobody can stop it. But it worries a lot about driving away the admin structures that keep Wikipedia working. Wikipedia would melt down very quickly under its own weight if the entire admin infrastructure was legitimately pissed off and stopped contributing. (I keep putting "community" in quotes because in wiki parlance it gets used to refer specifically to the set of people who involve themselves in Wikipedia governance, rather than the broader community of people who use and edit Wikipedia. There's a lot of power assigned to a fairly small group of people who invest their time in on-wiki politics. It's kinda like local school boards in that way.)
- simlevesque 2y ago> In a well-ordered and functioning society you can avoid running afoul of the law by following the rules Name me one of those societies that would prove your argument.
- halyconWays 2y ago[flagged]
- rvba 2y agoThey take so much money yet use none to acfually police wikipedia. They dont even bother to search for sock puppets. Or make admin edits anonymous, so admins can be judged
- hk__2 2y ago> They take so much money yet use none to acfually police wikipedia. https://foundation.wikimedia.org/wiki/Policy:Universal_Code_of_Conduct https://foundation.wikimedia.org/wiki/Policy:Universal_Code_...
- metalliqaz 2y agohow does that address what the parent comment said?
- hk__2 2y agoThe Foundation has made lots of efforts in the past years to make this universal code of conduct and it’s (almost?) finally here.
- patmorgan23 2y agoYes, Wikipedia has rules. But how many paid wikimedia employees are involved in the governance/moderation of the platform? How many times have admins and established editors bullied or banned new editors needlessly just so their own work can stay up?
- hk__2 2y ago> But how many paid wikimedia employees are involved in the governance/moderation of the platform? Hopefully none, because each instance should govern/moderate itself.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- seneca 2y agoWikimedia is one of the bigger "fall from grace" stories of the modern internet. I really wonder how long they can continue to have any credibility left. I suppose rose-tinted articles like this help keep it on life support.
- hmmmmmmmm11 2y agoFrom the article: "I would say, generally, it's pretty good on US politics — even local politics." Ctrl-F "bias": 0 results Wikipedia is simply not trustworthy on anything remotely political due to the extreme ideological slant of its editors.
- hk__2 2y ago> Wikipedia is simply not trustworthy on anything remotely political due to the extreme ideological slant of its editors. This reminds me of when the BBC reported that they get "complaints from people who feel that [their] reporting of the conflict has been biased against Israel, and complaints from those who feel it has been biased against the Palestinians" [1]. In my experience with the French Wikipedia, it’s the same there, with people from both sides complaining the encyclopedia is biased in favor of the other side. [1]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/israel-gazacoverage https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/israel-gazacoverage
- bawolff 2y agoThe two aren't mutually exclusive. Like they could be biased about certain parts in one direction but the other direction in another. I think we humans have the unfortunate tendency to view things as binary - you are either biased for one side or another. However when we are talking about something like wikipedia with lots of authors or even something like bbc where different articles are written by different people, i think its entirely possible for it to be biased against both sides (and for both sides) in different aspects.
- _carbyau_ 2y agoThat "view things as binary" is a real problem. The world is more detailed, convoluted, fascinating and complex than a binary viewpoint allows.
- WolfeReader 2y agoCan you give an example or two?
- jov2600 2y agoHow do these structured communities balance efficiency with encouraging new contributors, especially those who might find the guidelines intimidating?
- qingcharles 2y agoWikipedia is getting hard. I've been editing on there for over 20 years and I couldn't even get a new article accepted recently, even with a stack of solid citations. God knows how it would be for a new user.
- aspenmayer 2y agoWhat was the article about, out of curiosity?
- qingcharles 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Coronation_roll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Coronation_roll This one went through OK though :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qeqertaq_Avannarleq https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qeqertaq_Avannarleq
- photochemsyn 2y agoThe fundamental problem with Wikipedia is that reading one article edited by a dozen people with different perspectives and opinions is just not as illuminating as reading a dozen articles, each written by one person. That's why all serious researchers need access to the primary literature, original research reports, reviews of collections of reports, all clearly attributed to known sources. If you're working in the field you'll also know about the biases of the lead figures and can take that into account in your reading. Wikipedia is a mess in comparison, it's just for entertainment.
- beezlewax 2y agoExcept wikipedia provides their sources also.. meaning you can go read that material.
- Timwi 2y agoWikipedia only provides a small subset of sources which it arbitrarily deems “reliable” by some arcane definition that flies in the face of what everyday normal people mean by “reliable”. It does the same with “notability”, so most topics don’t even make it into Wikipedia because they are deemed “not notable” when by every reasonable everyday standard they are absolutely notable.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoWikipedia would benefit from allowing fir the narratives that sgape people, articles and the world to be diplayed while fighting for truth. hotly debated issues should show the debate and allow for those with better arguments , not better narratives to win by points.
- Boltgolt 2y agoThis is called the "Talk" page and it's usually an order of magnitude longer than the actual page
- teractiveodular 2y agoI've been editing Wikipedia literally for decades and I'm astonished at the vitriol in these comments. Would any HNers care to share any examples of actual articles that showcase this "extreme ideological slant"? Yes, editing Wikipedia is harder than it needs to be and you better have your Kevlar underwear on before venturing into hot potato topics, but there's a lot more to Wikipedia than that and contributions to more obscure/factual articles are generally more than welcome.
- ClassyJacket 2y agoAnything about gender ideology for one
- Manuel_D 2y agoTwo (well, really one) concrete example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_F._Cantlon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_F._Cantlon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celeste_Kidd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celeste_Kidd The allegations these women made against Jaeger were investigated four separate times, including investigations carried out by 3rd party investigators, and each time were determined to be unfounded. Not only that, the investigations revealed that Kidd and Cantlon had told explicit lies to investigators (e.g. claiming he sexually assaulted other women, but those women explained to investigators that no such assaults occurred, and they never gave any indication to Kidd or Cantlon that that were ever assaulted by Jaeger). Despite this, the wikipedia articles remained entirely credulous of these accusations until only a few months ago. A couple editors suppressed any inclusion of exonerating information.
- ChadNauseam 2y agoIt's kind of interesting that the page for Cantlon mentions that she is Time person of the year for being one of the Silence Breakers, but as far as I can tell, the actual article has 0 information about the circumstances that lead to her being given that award until almost the bottom of the article, under the heading "Academic service".
- 2y ago
- casenmgreen 2y ago> that's the unfortunate thing about growing and becoming a massive encyclopedia that's more respected than it was in 2004 In the very few areas where I am well read or even an expert, the Wiki articles I read horrify me. I consider them wholly misleading and improper. As such, I do not read Wiki articles on anything subjective (history, people, etc) because such articles of this type I am in a position to judge, I judge very poorly indeed, so I have reason to think all articles of these types are no good, at all. For some classes of articles, such as math or computer science concepts, I find all Wiki articles utterly hopeless - the explanations only make sense to someone who already understands. I'm conscious also of the massive propaganda efforts being exerted by various entities on various pages, such as, for example, the Ukraine War, or the Russian Government. This leaves the balance, articles on simple, fairly non-subjective and uncontrovertial subjects, and they seem okay. It's not great, and when I really do need to know about something, I consult an actual, curated, non-mass-edited encyclopedia. Also, many years ago, I used to edit/contribute, but that stopped, because it became increasingly difficult and unpleasant due to other editors, and in any event, anything you added sooner or later would be removed or edited away, one way or another. Oh and then have the Foundation, doing it's voodoo-idiocy in the background, such as the amazing new editor which no one wants or likes.
- lblume 2y agoCould you give concrete examples of obviously misleading articles? Maybe depends on perspective, but I would consider most articles I found to be at the very least to be acceptable. My new tab page is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random, so I engage with the content a lot. I also think that with CS and similar articles, it boils down to the learning type of the person in question. I can personally grasp new concepts very well through articles just because of the linked structure, that if I don't yet know something, I can just click on it and create a connection.
- suddenlybananas 2y agoA lot of the theoretical linguistics articles are quite bad: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Determiner_phrase#Arguments_for_NP_over_DP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Determiner_phrase#Arguments_fo... is full of bizarre arguments that don't make sense in the tradition that postulated the DP hypothesis. Not only that, but the trees are written in a really bizarre way for a topic in generative grammar.
- aucisson_masque 2y ago› Wikipedia is unique in that it still feels very web 1.0 in its design and aesthetics That's what I like about Wikipedia, it may not be always 100% accurate but it's quick, isn't filled with ads and it gets things right most often. It's either that or looking at seo optimized website for dozens of minutes. I don't donate nearly enough considering the time it made me save.
- hoseja 2y ago>from my vantage point it seems like people are less tolerant of the old school, laddish internet type trolling. And that is exciting too. >It's mostly just like — hey, can we cool it? Can we cool it with the German hymns?
- devops99 2y ago[flagged]
- tivert 2y ago> ...one shared quality of every single person I've met who has stuck around Wikipedia for a long time is ... they put a low value on their own time. ... Who are they? ... I think common professions are software and computer engineering. Especially with the meme equating Wikipedia with "knowledge," it's worth highlighting that Wikipedia invariably reflects the biases of the people who write it, and they're weird people with weird personality traits. > All of which leads to my larger question, which is — is the writing and editing process working? > AR: I mean, the answer is no. There are people who just kind of wait for their opponent to get carpal tunnel — and that's not productive for anyone. I would call those sorts of debates tendentious. You're not trying to find consensus.... > AR: If you're putting anything out into the world, please do not cite Wikipedia! Do not do that. I don't trust it. Ever. That's why you check all the sources. Ideally, every single thing, every single piece of information besides, like, “the sky is blue”-type stuff should be tied to a source. I would say, just cite those because people interpret things weirdly sometimes, and you never know. Wikipedia is a great outlet for propaganda, even if it's mostly pushed by opinionated people who "put a low value on their own time." And it's naive to thing it's this fair adversarial thing where all the sides fight and the truth pops out. There's a meta-game where one side (usually the one that's more in tune with the Wikipedia's general baises) uses the rules to get the other side excluded or otherwise boxed out. > Back in the day, there were five — call them guidelines, decrees, commandments — sent down from on high from the less good co-founder, Larry Sanger. And the last one was: “Ignore all rules.” And ha! That's still there. "The less good co-founder"? Why the swipe?
- crusty 2y agoWith this much interest, maybe I should start taking donations for the R.F. Kennedy and Justin Peters Encyclopedia of Upstairs Medicine and Uppity Females. Looks like a cash machine. There's still no accounting for...